Iron Man and Cap' Voted Fans’ Favorite Avengers, While Guardians 3 Is Most Anticipated New MCU Flick

Our mega MCU survey reveals your favorite MCU movies, villains, sidekicks, credits scenes, and which Infinity War death hit hardest.

by | April 22, 2019 | Comments

In the lead up to Avengers: Endgame, we invited fans to take part in a mammoth survey to find out your favorite movies, characters, and moments from the Marvel Cinematic Universe – so far! Hundreds of Rotten Tomatoes fans took part, weighing in on their favorite Avengers, their favorite villains, their most heartbreaking Infinity War deaths, and which post-Endgame movie they’re most excited to see. (Because it may be the “endgame” this week, but the MCU will go on). We dug deep into the data to spot some fun trends, seeing if there were divides along gender lines (ladies love M’Baku, who’d have thunk it!?) and generations (our Millennial/Non-Millennial split told us a bunch). Check out the results and major findings below, and let us know your own answers in the comments section.

Captain America and Iron Man Tie for Favorite Avenger With 53%, While Ladies Love Thor

Captain America: Civil War

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

In one of our survey’s most unsurprising results, the two Avengers whose relationship underpins the entire MCU came out on top when we asked Who Is Your Favorite Avenger? Some 53% of fans cast votes for Tony Stark and Steve Rogers; Thor came in a close third with 50% of respondents naming him one of their favorites.

Cap’ was the clear overall favorite when it came to younger fans: 64% of Millennials named him one of their favorites (compared with 55% for Iron Man). Female fans were slightly less into Steve, though, with 44% of female respondents saying he was a favorite, compared with 59% of males. For the ladies, it was all about the God of Thunder: Thor got the highest percentage of female votes, with 55% of female respondents designating the Asgardian one of their most beloved heroes.

Spidey was surprisingly divisive, both between the sexes and among generations. While 46% of male fans called Peter Parker one of their favorite Avengers, just 29% of female fans did the same. Not surprisingly, the youngest Avenger has some serious Millennial appeal, getting 44% of Millennials to name him a fave, compared with 36% of Non-Millennials.

The top nine favorites in our survey were all characters who have had standalone MCU films (Hulk, whose standalone film did not star Mark Ruffalo, came in last amongst those). The bottom eight have not had their own films, although one is on the way for Black Widow (ranked 10th), and Scarlet Witch, Vision, Bucky Barnes, and Falcon will all appear in limited series on Disney+.

Here are the full results from the question, Who Is Your Favorite Avenger? (Note, people could vote for multiple characters.)

  1. Iron Man – 53%
  2. Captain America –  53%
  3. Thor – 50%
  4. Spider-Man – 39%
  5. Doctor Strange – 30%
  6. Black Panther – 29%
  7. Ant-Man – 29%
  8. Captain Marvel – 25%
  9. Hulk – 23%
  10. Black Widow – 18%
  11. Hawkeye – 13%
  12. Scarlet Witch – 13%
  13. Vision – 10%
  14. Bucky Barnes – 9%
  15. Falcon – 7%
  16. Quicksilver – 6%
  17. War Machine – 6%

Peter Parker’s Infinity War Death Broke Your Hearts More Than Any Other

Peter Parker Endgame Poster

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

Yes, we know he’s not dead dead, but that didn’t make the heartbreak any easier. When asked which character’s Infinity War death was the saddest, some 61% of respondents ticked the box marked Peter Parker. Gamora came in second with 36% of respondents including her in their selections, and Groot came in third with 35%. Peter Quill did surprisingly poorly, with only 17% of respondents admitting they were torn up about his death – perhaps they still haven’t forgiven him for letting his emotions get the better of him.

Here are the top five saddest Infinity War deaths, according to the fans. (Note, people could vote for multiple characters.)

  1. Peter Parker – 61%
  2. Gamora – 36%
  3. Groot – 35%
  4. Loki – 23%
  5. Vision – 21%

Groot is – by far! – the Most Beloved MCU Sidekick, But fans have not forgotten Peggy Carter

(Photo by Peter Parker Endgame Poster)

Groot took out this category in a landslide, with 66% of respondents selecting him as one of their favorite supporting characters or sidekicks; Agent Coulson (Clark Gregg) came in second with 39%. Black Panther’s Shuri (Letitia Wright) was not far behind with 37%, followed by Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson) at 36%, and Valkyrie (Tessa Thompson) at 31%. We were happy to see folks have not forgotten Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell), seventh with 25%.

There were plenty of generational splits when it came to favorite sidekicks, with Valkyrie creating one of the biggest: Millennials are all about the booze-swilling rebel, with 41% naming her one of their favorite supporting characters, but just 25% of Non-Millennials felt the same. Millennials similarly showed love for Korg (Taika Waititi), Bucky, and JARVIS, while Non-Millennials were left relatively cold by them.

One of the bigger gender divides was over M’Baku (Winston Duke), with 27% of female respondents naming him a fave compared with 18% of males.

Here are the top 10 favorite sidekicks/supporting characters. (Note, people could vote for multiple characters.)

  1. Groot – 60%
  2. Agent Coulson – 39%
  3. Shuri – 37%
  4. Nick Fury – 36%
  5. Valkyrie – 31%
  6. Bucky Barnes – 26%
  7. Peggy Carter – 25%
  8. Okoye – 24%
  9. Korg – 24%
  10. Wong – 21%


Thor: Ragnarok

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Sure, we could get into the whole “but is he really a villain?” debate, given his trajectory in the films, but we’re not going to. For a number of Phase 1 movies, Loki (Tom Hiddleston) was a villain – pure and simple. And you guys love him when he’s at his most devious. The god of mischief received the most votes for favorite villain, at 63%, followed by Thanos (Josh Brolin) at 48%. Hela (Cate Blanchett) was number three at 30%.

Black Panther’s Erik Killmonger (Michael B. Jordan) was the highest-ranked human villain on the list, coming in at number four, just ahead of the Winter Soldier, with 29%. But Killmonger was generationally divisive, with 41% of Millennials naming him one of their favorites (he actually ranked third for Millennials, above Hela), but just 21% of Non-Millennials doing the same.

Interestingly, critic favorite Helmut Zemo (Daniel Brühl), who sowed the seeds of the Avengers’ internal breakdown in Civil War, came in near the bottom of our villain list, with only 4% of fans naming him one of their favorites. In terms of major MCU villains, only Iron Man 3’s Aldrich Killian (Guy Pearce) came in lower, with just 3%.

Here are fans’ top 10 favorite villains. (Note, people could vote for multiple characters.)

  1. Loki – 63%
  2. Thanos – 48%
  3. Hela – 30%
  4. Erik Killmonger – 29%
  5. The Winter Soldier – 23%
  6. The Vulture – 20%
  7. Red Skull – 18%
  8. Ronan the Accuser – 16%
  9. Ultron – 17%
  10. Ego – 13%

For Standalone MCU Movies, Set It in Space and Make It Quippy

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Fans’ top 10 favorite standalone MCU movies contain some of the MCUs’ Freshest offerings on the Tomatometer – though the Freshest movie, Black Panther (97%), is fans’ fourth favorite. Number one for fans is Guardians of the Galaxy, which 51% of respondents named as one of their favorites, followed by the similarly funny and space-set Thor: Ragnarok. Just one Phase 1 origin movie features in the top 10: Iron Man came in at number three, with 40% of respondents saying it was among their faves. Only two franchises are represented twice in the top 10: Captain America, with The Winter Soldier and Civil War both among fans’ favorites, and Guardians, with Vol. 1 and 2 both in the top 10.

Fans’ least favorite standalone movie? No shocks here: The Incredible Hulk, which is also tied for the MCU’s lowest Tomatometer score with Thor: The Dark World at 67%. Incidentally, that latter film is fans’ second least favorite MCU movie.

Here are the fans’ top 10 standalone MCU movies. (Note, people could vote for multiple movies.)

  1. Guardians of the Galaxy – 51%
  2. Thor: Ragnarok – 42%
  3. Iron Man – 40%
  4. Black Panther – 36%
  5. Captain America: The Winter Soldier – 31%
  6. Captain America: Civil War – 30%
  7. Spider-Man: Homecoming – 28%
  8. Ant-Man – 23%
  9. Doctor Strange – 21%
  10. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – 21%

Baby Groot Dancing is Your Favorite Post-Credits Scene

Baby Groot

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

Groot’s cuteness reigns supreme again, with 55% of fans saying that baby Groot in the Guardians post-credits sequence is their favorite of the after-movie stingers. His closest competition is one of the MCU’s most recent: The Captain Marvel credit sequence in which Carol shows up to meet the rest of the Avengers.

Here is the rest of the top five favorite post-credits scenes. (Note, people could vote for multiple scenes.)

  1. Baby Groot dances (Guardians of the Galaxy) – 55%
  2. Captain Marvel meets the Avengers (Captain Marvel) – 39%
  3. Nick Fury pages Captain Marvel (Avengers: Infinity War) – 35%
  4. Star-Lord tells teen Groot to clean his room (Guardians of the Galaxy: Vol. 2) – 28%
  5. Nick Fury meets Tony Stark (Iron Man) – 28%

Fans Can’t Wait to See Guardians Vol. 3 (And Other Familiar Properties)

Marvel Studios

(Photo by @ Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, @ Marvel Studios)

Familiarity was key for fans when we asked what post-Endgame movie they were most looking forward to. Three sequels topped the list, with one familiar character’s first solo flick coming in close behind, and less-familiar properties rounding out the bottom of the list. Of course, The Eternals and Shang-Chi are at a massive disadvantage here, given that we have not had time to fall in love with those characters (they’re still being cast!). Given the talent involved behind the camera on those projects (acclaimed indie director Chloe Zhao is helming The Eternals and Short Term 12 filmmaker Destin Daniel Cretton is directing Shang-Chi), we have no doubt folks will be much more excited as we get nearer to their release dates.

Here are fans top six most anticipated post-Endgame movies. (Note, we included movies that are in production/active development, and people could vote for multiple movies.)

  1. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 – 63%
  2. Black Panther 2 – 48%
  3. Spider-Man: Far from Home – 48%
  4. Black Widow – 40%
  5. The Eternals – 14%
  6. Shang-Chi – 11%

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Thumbnail image courtesy Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, Marvel Studios

Tag Cloud

olympics MSNBC series romantic comedy TV renewals TCA YouTube Red slasher Wes Anderson ESPN DC streaming service dc free movies halloween tv cars halloween Writers Guild of America cinemax Black Mirror Apple TV Plus movies OneApp action-comedy Superheroes crossover LGBTQ scene in color concert Fall TV reviews cats new zealand RT21 heist movie WGN spider-man casting Drama 4/20 Dark Horse Comics BBC America aapi kong WarnerMedia black The Walking Dead marvel comics Amazon Studios BET crime thriller richard e. Grant technology Schedule teaser rotten movies we love Horror dramedy telelvision 73rd Emmy Awards anthology FXX Disney Election joker dexter spanish TCA Awards Summer ABC Signature international AMC ABC TLC young adult Netflix comiccon singing competition unscripted cancelled TV shows game show Lionsgate 71st Emmy Awards golden globes 20th Century Fox DC Comics Legendary Nominations remakes Set visit Toys godzilla NBC HBO Go Country prank disaster Comic Book TV One Tubi adenture hispanic kids high school Hallmark Christmas movies documentaries NYCC Character Guide Comics on TV Martial Arts Holidays Amazon Prime Video Awards japanese docuseries Exclusive Video NBA hollywood zombies indiana jones Travel Channel festival obituary Interview Logo ViacomCBS Disney Plus Lifetime Disney Channel space Polls and Games 2017 japan X-Men canceled Animation 2018 Women's History Month 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards films Turner twilight mcc The Witch Best and Worst Fox Searchlight Anna Paquin christmas movies james bond TV golden globe awards Quiz ghosts Shudder wonder woman travel children's TV Countdown hist Tomatazos RT History CMT Trivia HBO live action doctor who TCM Family CBS All Access universal monsters werewolf historical drama Musical satire Mystery feel good DGA TCA 2017 Amazon Lucasfilm politics criterion Teen TruTV gangster Rocky American Society of Cinematographers New York Comic Con San Diego Comic-Con 1990s franchise versus streaming movies Emmy Nominations award winner serial killer Broadway President psychological thriller Music lord of the rings CW Seed asian-american TNT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina laika basketball nfl facebook worst comic books Endgame Cosplay boxoffice french Photos Pixar Disney+ Disney Plus Spike streaming Arrowverse cartoon Comic-Con@Home 2021 First Reviews Creative Arts Emmys book Reality critic resources Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt football comedies anime Action Crunchyroll comic superhero Film Festival Premiere Dates south america Vudu talk show cops Trailer stoner mockumentary Universal Comedy king arthur El Rey Holiday Walt Disney Pictures target Apple TV+ kaiju Tokyo Olympics trailers BAFTA based on movie GoT Pet Sematary superman Box Office natural history Image Comics cooking indie IFC Films IFC YA Stephen King Certified Fresh See It Skip It Academy Awards Paramount Plus Opinion book adaptation Red Carpet blaxploitation canceled TV shows critics witnail OWN 21st Century Fox worst movies stand-up comedy cults National Geographic fresh Pacific Islander Spring TV Sundance revenge Rocketman BBC One chucky Showtime TBS spanish language new york Nickelodeon Video Games 2021 Pirates new star wars movies movie Classic Film Netflix Christmas movies VH1 rt labs Grammys dragons blockbusters social media Western parents Mindy Kaling Cannes Film PBS The CW nbcuniversal SundanceTV Star Trek Valentine's Day YouTube Premium TCA Winter 2020 Song of Ice and Fire cancelled television Extras slashers legend 24 frames robots Superheroe Television Critics Association sag awards Nat Geo aliens animated ratings E3 political drama Oscars australia Freeform debate video popular MCU scary movies APB Warner Bros. Britbox Fox News strong female leads TV Land Thanksgiving 007 police drama A&E television king kong Hulu GLAAD emmy awards zombie justice league adventure Columbia Pictures 99% Cartoon Network TIFF Heroines ABC Family comic book movies TV movies VOD Emmys Fantasy biography finale transformers medical drama USA die hard blockbuster Marathons Paramount pirates of the caribbean 2016 period drama Star Wars tv talk PaleyFest 2015 Peacock DirecTV independent renewed TV shows MTV Chernobyl harry potter BBC Mudbound mission: impossible Lifetime Christmas movies Captain marvel Paramount Network composers Elton John screen actors guild miniseries know your critic elevated horror Watching Series Christmas dceu spinoff stop motion sequels Marvel Calendar rt archives hispanic heritage month sports 90s romance Winter TV dogs GIFs sequel Binge Guide ITV suspense Mary Tyler Moore toy story 2020 FX Sundance Now The Purge Rock italian what to watch Tumblr Comedy Central SDCC all-time FOX ID Television Academy Bravo psycho 45 Marvel Television Hallmark news adaptation reboot vampires zero dark thirty BET Awards HBO Max YouTube Alien batman CBS A24 archives documentary Syfy diversity Crackle supernatural Tarantino fast and furious crime drama Pride Month Sci-Fi dark rt labs critics edition cancelled TV series Awards Tour Avengers spain theme song Ghostbusters Baby Yoda a nightmare on elm street Disney streaming service discovery Funimation latino Sneak Peek Podcast Adult Swim saw toronto Black History Month 93rd Oscars Spectrum Originals Food Network classics 2019 thriller Marvel Studios Discovery Channel SXSW Epix Trophy Talk Biopics DC Universe Mary Poppins Returns E! breaking bad festivals Masterpiece Apple Pop TV directors quibi comic book movie Mary poppins rom-coms Starz Kids & Family cancelled nature Infographic razzies Shondaland game of thrones Sundance TV crime Year in Review monster movies Hear Us Out binge Pop science fiction true crime Musicals The Walt Disney Company Acorn TV Brie Larson History posters video on demand marvel cinematic universe jurassic park name the review The Arrangement 72 Emmy Awards war docudrama venice Ellie Kemper Winners PlayStation foreign biopic comics VICE USA Network First Look Rom-Com FX on Hulu screenings scorecard green book women deadpool LGBT sitcom royal family child's play mutant Turner Classic Movies spy thriller The Academy Super Bowl Reality Competition Esquire Ovation Sony Pictures hidden camera CNN best Amazon Prime boxing rotten jamie lee curtis