How Does "The Departed" Rank Among Oscar's Best?

by | February 26, 2007 | Comments

So Martin Scorsese finally has his long-overdue, much-deserved Oscar. But where does "The Departed" stack up in the annals of Academy history?

Pretty well, actually. "The Departed" is the 30th best-reviewed Best Picture of all time, placing it in between "The Lost Weekend" and "Lord of the Rings: Return of the King."


"I just won an Oscar! Drinks are on me!"

Though few doubt Scorsese‘s preeminence in the pantheon of filmmakers, until now, he’s been the Susan Lucci of directors: oft-nominated, but never victorious. "Taxi Driver" (100 percent) lost to "Rocky" (93 percent); "Raging Bull" (100 percent) was beaten by "Ordinary People" (88 percent); "GoodFellas" (98 percent) fell to "Dances with Wolves" (77 percent); "Gangs of New York" (77 percent) was defeated by "Chicago" (86 percent); and "The Aviator" (89 percent) lost to "Million Dollar Baby" (92 percent).

In addition, Scorsese was a five-time also ran for the Best Director statuette: for "Raging Bull," he lost to "Ordinary People"’s Robert Redford; Barry Levinson ("Rain Man") topped him for his work on "The Last Temptation of Christ"; Kevin Costner ("Dances with Wolves") beat him for "GoodFellas"; Roman Polanski ("The Pianist") won over his work on "Gangs"; and Clint Eastwood took home the statue for "Million Dollar Baby," trumping "The Aviator."


"I’m gonna clear off my shelf to make room for that Oscar."

Scorsese didn’t have any better luck in the Best Adapted Screenplay category; he was nominated twice but didn’t win, for "GoodFellas" (with Nicholas Pileggi) and for "The Age of Innocence" (with Jay Cocks).

Click here to see the complete Best of the Best Pictures list!

Tag Cloud

biography VICE action-comedy FX on Hulu theme song Trophy Talk halloween scary movies Film Festival remakes Nominations aliens tv talk jurassic park DC Comics Western Rocketman Mystery hidden camera slasher The CW Super Bowl documentaries Fargo Character Guide Tarantino LGBTQ 2017 cinemax based on movie IFC Acorn TV SXSW Fox News cults USA dc Lifetime LGBT comic books a nightmare on elm street Broadway indiana jones Marvel Television golden globe awards superhero canceled TV shows ABC binge Box Office crime films Television Academy Awards Chernobyl miniseries kong Sci-Fi dceu suspense rt labs superman Funimation TCA Winter 2020 Certified Fresh award winner olympics Holiday Arrowverse mcc A&E james bond Heroines travel 2019 technology independent comiccon mob TV renewals unscripted PBS singing competition The Arrangement APB Instagram Live San Diego Comic-Con australia elevated horror Exclusive Video fast and furious japan robots heist movie zombie batman cops DC streaming service National Geographic Wes Anderson docuseries Biopics Horror Hear Us Out Sundance Now CW Seed new star wars movies facebook TV Land 20th Century Fox Teen 2015 spy thriller mission: impossible festivals anthology Sundance dark kaiju Logo 99% Marvel Studios free movies Fox Searchlight Comedy Central PlayStation Tokyo Olympics live event joker Mary Poppins Returns classics feel good DC Universe Marathons Sundance TV critic resources dramedy harry potter children's TV adaptation Endgame Grammys The Purge Mary poppins 2020 TV movies trophy mockumentary CNN Sneak Peek Brie Larson Musical Baby Yoda video Bravo Reality DGA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comic Book royal family FX TCA Awards nfl hollywood hispanic Pop marvel comics Superheroe Food Network foreign spinoff Amazon Prime movie Winners The Walt Disney Company Spike IMDb TV die hard Apple TV+ TNT Britbox NBC WarnerMedia all-time Music TV christmas movies The Walking Dead movies Cartoon Network Rocky Paramount Plus serial killer telelvision GoT high school Tubi Ovation television Universal Pictures medical drama Legendary Dark Horse Comics 2018 Elton John stop motion diversity Paramount Network Apple TV Plus young adult Columbia Pictures anime Fantasy 007 aapi Creative Arts Emmys streaming movies Crackle TruTV Quiz teaser The Academy ghosts sag awards sequel 2016 rt archives ABC Family prank Podcast Star Wars Musicals Mindy Kaling scary BET police drama finale Pet Sematary AMC Plus Comic-Con@Home 2021 E3 90s book MTV new zealand Starz indie spider-verse archives international VH1 Warner Bros. twilight Disney+ Disney Plus FOX spanish language comics FXX PaleyFest Watching Series spider-man SundanceTV reboot Spectrum Originals sopranos Pixar VOD comic war venice GIFs Set visit worst Disney black Premiere Dates Best and Worst Holidays Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TIFF jamie lee curtis Vudu Martial Arts revenge festival Sony Pictures Trivia Country Star Trek Family Awards Tour crime drama 71st Emmy Awards YA Action Netflix Christmas movies Academy Awards Mary Tyler Moore strong female leads zero dark thirty sports psychological thriller IFC Films marvel cinematic universe vampires casting screen actors guild Interview french Classic Film Avengers legend werewolf popular 1990s composers historical drama Toys Tumblr stoner Hallmark 72 Emmy Awards politics Rock period drama what to watch Television Critics Association Crunchyroll genre romance docudrama American Society of Cinematographers cancelled worst movies universal monsters 21st Century Fox nature ViacomCBS Spring TV pirates of the caribbean laika RT History Masterpiece Ellie Kemper Stephen King Alien blockbusters Emmy Nominations 24 frames DirecTV BBC America Paramount screenings blockbuster CMT President OneApp Black History Month TLC social media Anna Paquin cartoon satire name the review south america black comedy monster movies saw Fall TV Travel Channel debate deadpool OWN Rom-Com trailers king kong Walt Disney Pictures Amazon Nat Geo rt labs critics edition Mudbound YouTube Premium art house YouTube Cosplay TBS gangster supernatural rotten movies we love ID japanese A24 SDCC game of thrones Reality Competition psycho dexter BBC Lionsgate cancelled TV shows hispanic heritage month Polls and Games green book HBO Go cats Amazon Studios MCU breaking bad dragons Oscars HBO First Reviews 93rd Oscars Disney Channel halloween tv live action Emmys TV One Peacock book adaptation See It Skip It TCM space Summer Ghostbusters fresh versus Thanksgiving news criterion Captain marvel ABC Signature biopic Black Mirror Universal wonder woman concert ITV Hulu 73rd Emmy Awards target Shudder HBO Max Cannes mutant justice league toronto History YouTube Red vs. stand-up comedy Nickelodeon cars Discovery Channel richard e. Grant Election canceled Binge Guide adenture spain spanish documentary football Film Winter TV series italian dogs Syfy Drama NBA new york comedies asian-american true crime CBS adventure renewed TV shows cancelled TV series BBC One Opinion chucky obituary best lord of the rings Countdown TCA 2017 king arthur Amazon Prime Video emmy awards critics X-Men razzies Calendar Trailer CBS All Access crossover MSNBC Christmas hist Animation El Rey directors zombies Kids & Family BAFTA AMC Tomatazos video on demand boxing Turner Classic Movies streaming Song of Ice and Fire WGN scene in color BET Awards Year in Review Apple Showtime Esquire posters Adult Swim Lifetime Christmas movies Image Comics Infographic dreamworks Netflix scorecard Women's History Month toy story leaderboard 45 Pacific Islander reviews GLAAD RT21 Neflix witnail Disney Plus Comics on TV Hallmark Christmas movies parents women discovery Extras slashers TCA sitcom blaxploitation Epix E! sequels cooking Schedule romantic comedy comic book movie child's play The Witch game show political drama godzilla talk show Writers Guild of America Freeform Pirates Disney streaming service Shondaland Marvel NYCC thriller nbcuniversal First Look disaster comic book movies franchise Turner Valentine's Day boxoffice golden globes natural history Pop TV cancelled television animated Video Games Lucasfilm latino ESPN New York Comic Con Photos Pride Month 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Comedy quibi Red Carpet basketball rotten 2021 4/20 doctor who crime thriller kids ratings USA Network science fiction know your critic rom-coms Superheroes transformers