How A Nightmare on Elm Street Made Us Root for the Bad Guy

On its 35th anniversary, we look back at the seminal horror film that changed the game by establishing its villain as more than just a somber, silent entity.

by | November 16, 2019 | Comments

New Line Cinema
(Photo by New Line Cinema)

During the casting for A Nightmare on Elm Street, director Wes Craven thought he needed a “big man.” After all, it was going to be a horror movie about an evil, dream-haunting psychopath who slaughters kids with a glove fitted with knives. In his mind, Craven was following the precedent set by Tobe Hooper in 1974 and John Carpenter in 1978 – The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and Halloween both featured hulking, unstoppable man-monsters. Craven even interviewed Kane Hodder – the man who would wear the hockey mask once Jason Voorhees took center stage in the Friday the 13th series – for the part.

But a skinny, young actor named Robert Englund thought that most child abusers were weasels and creeps, not hulks. So he offered a different take on the lecherous Freddy Krueger, and not only would Nightmare take off because of it, but horror movies themselves would be changed forever.

Released 35 years ago this week, A Nightmare on Elm Street took the concept of the bad guy as the marquee character – the one people not only came to see, but to actively cheer on – to whole new levels. The faceless, voiceless, mask-obscured killing machines that preceded Nightmare had to make way for a mugging, self-referential, hammy villain-hero.

The Diva Who Shunned the Mask

In the end credits of Halloween, the character of Michael Myers isn’t even listed by name. He’s called “The Shape.” This is significant because Michael isn’t meant to “be” anyone. The whole point is that he just is, a silent menace in the periphery as the movie focuses on the guilt-ridden Dr. Loomis (Donald Pleasence) and high school good girl Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis). With his slow movement, white, expressionless face, and complete silence, Michael is a terrifying blank slate.

A few years later, Friday the 13th would completely obscure its main villain until the very end – revealing at last that the murders were committed by a revenge-obsessed woman scarred by the apparent death of her son, Jason, many years before. When Jason himself took the spotlight in the next few installments, he, too, was a silent, expressionless entity who at first wears a nondescript bag over his head before he even gets his signature goalie mask (in Part III).

And yet, by 1986’s Friday the 13th Part 6: Jason Lives, we saw the movie literally opening with a tongue-in-cheek James Bond parody:

What happened? Freddy happened.

A Nightmare on Elm Street had the same bland, suburban setting as Halloween and a similar gang of horny teens as the Friday films, but there was a key difference. Freddy wasn’t just scary, he was darkly witty. He was creative. He was, well, a thousand times more interesting than anyone he killed.

Sure, people went to horror movies for the killer or the monster – this had been true since the 1950s. You went to see The Blob because you wanted to see the blob. But this was different. Audiences liked Freddy. He was the star, not just the threat, and things only got hammier as the franchise went along. It was because, rather than going with yet another “big man” monster, Craven and Englund delivered a performance. Freddy was a theatrical diva.

Would any other slasher work so well in a Fresh Prince video?

The other competitors had no choice but to follow suit. Although somewhat hamstrung by their lack of personality, Jason and Michael still went through increasingly bizarre and laughable incarnations in an effort to keep up with Freddy. This is why we eventually got cyborg space-Jason and Busta Rhymes electrocuting Michael Myers in the crotch after he shouts, “Trick or treat, motherf—er!”

Post-Nightmare, movie slashers had to be more than just killers. They needed to be in the spotlight, not the shadows. One-liners, theatricality, and insane death scenarios all became requirements. We’d never have IT’s Pennywise or Scream’s Ghostface without Freddy.

So to celebrate the mugging, one-liner-spewing dream-weaver on his 35th anniversary, let’s run down his greatest hits.

The Five Best Freddy Kills

1) A Nightmare on Elm Street: “Watch this.”

Freddy’s first outing really sets the tone, and this scene has it all. Rather than simply stalking and killing Tina (Amanda Wyss), he toys with her, throwing out one-liners and a few party tricks as he leads her to an overly elaborate demise. Freddy is playing to the crowd.

2) Nightmare On Elm Street 4: The Dream Master: “Wanna suck face?”

Freddy kills an asthmatic girl by dropping this one-liner before literally sucking the air out of her lungs and leaving her a deflated corpse.

3) Freddy’s Dead: The Final Nightmare: “Let’s trip out.”

Freddy’s satirical take on the “This is your brain…” PSAs from the ’80s and ’90s – complete with a cameo from former Freddy victim Johnny Depp – and an extended Super Mario Bros.-inspired kill is all the proof you need that he was a frustrated comedian.

4) A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child: “Bon Appétit!”

Dressing up as a chef and strapping a girl with an eating disorder into a high chair for the sole purpose of force-feeding her to death in front of her overbearing mother? Can you imagine Leatherface putting in this kind of multi-layered effort?

5) A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors: “Welcome to prime time, b—h!”

A scene that begins with former talk show host Dick Cavett turning into Freddy before killing Zsa Zsa Gabor can’t possibly get any more insane, can it? Oh, yes. Freddy literally pops out of the TV and pulls Jennifer (Penelope Sudrow) face-first into the set with his mechanical TV arms. With an applause-baiting one-liner, of course.

A Nightmare on Elm Street went into wide release on November 16, 1984.

Adjusted Score: 97.948%
Critics Consensus: Wes Craven's intelligent premise, combined with the horrifying visual appearance of Freddy Krueger, still causes nightmares to this day.
Synopsis: A group of teenagers are terrorized by "Freddy Krueger", an evil being from another world who gets to his victims... [More]
Directed By: Wes Craven

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Syfy Shondaland Paramount RT History Bravo Star Wars joker Teen Warner Bros. Podcast romance LGBTQ theme song Musical festivals cooking natural history Holiday Mary Poppins Returns Britbox technology Fantasy justice league crossover aliens Fox News Adult Swim Fall TV canceled TV shows USA richard e. Grant transformers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Toys Kids & Family psycho adventure canceled Writers Guild of America DC Comics Mudbound Photos Sony Pictures comiccon screenings facebook television harry potter social media Mary poppins diversity DGA El Rey YouTube Red Showtime doctor who Music cartoon Film Festival sequel SDCC Superheroes MCU Infographic RT21 Winter TV APB dceu quibi Vudu IFC Polls and Games First Look Turner Classic Movies Ovation TruTV hist 2018 adaptation Rock X-Men Hallmark Christmas movies Comedy Central strong female leads Quiz FXX comics Election series cancelled TV series PaleyFest Film Tumblr dc Country werewolf Hallmark zero dark thirty MTV Marvel Creative Arts Emmys Grammys Masterpiece golden globes period drama Sundance The Walking Dead 2020 Apple TV+ Walt Disney Pictures Hulu indie WGN Trivia cancelled TV shows Captain marvel DC Universe renewed TV shows based on movie Columbia Pictures Esquire American Society of Cinematographers spider-man book San Diego Comic-Con Sneak Peek Ghostbusters 2015 YouTube Premium Holidays Superheroe Binge Guide Family First Reviews witnail versus Emmy Nominations ghosts 2019 politics batman CNN casting independent ABC Family Dark Horse Comics ABC free movies Heroines Anna Paquin dramedy Comedy Amazon Prime Video Rocky streaming Opinion spanish language Lifetime 71st Emmy Awards singing competition CMT New York Comic Con Acorn TV cults spy thriller Sundance Now Arrowverse crime thriller Avengers Horror Spring TV war Oscars ESPN VICE hispanic Chernobyl travel Star Trek what to watch Shudder kids Paramount Network slashers Disney Calendar Western Interview latino TCM boxoffice YA Rocketman Emmys finale Apple Disney Channel Set visit Marvel Studios sports political drama SXSW cancelled Red Carpet 2016 elevated horror A&E cars Black Mirror Cosplay true crime dragons tv talk Comic Book Lifetime Christmas movies Women's History Month animated Drama medical drama Sci-Fi cancelled television anthology jamie lee curtis Logo discovery cinemax Amazon Prime CBS All Access historical drama History Pixar Apple TV Plus romantic comedy Valentine's Day Character Guide robots disaster Extras Song of Ice and Fire rotten movies we love 2017 Lucasfilm Mary Tyler Moore OWN HBO Max christmas movies unscripted foreign Pop mockumentary Stephen King Comics on TV spain Crunchyroll movies Schedule A24 toy story Nat Geo breaking bad E! TV game show Pet Sematary Best and Worst Freeform Endgame TBS thriller Trophy Talk Super Bowl binge President Marvel Television See It Skip It CW Seed TV Land name the review miniseries 24 frames crime drama children's TV Winners Summer halloween revenge crime anime spinoff BBC BBC America Box Office GIFs Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Food Network serial killer video IFC Films Reality The Arrangement Biopics YouTube talk show VH1 Premiere Dates blockbuster Starz Christmas Television Academy 21st Century Fox ITV Mindy Kaling Spike The CW TCA 2017 award winner SundanceTV Year in Review BET screen actors guild Elton John 20th Century Fox NYCC Marathons police drama sitcom vampires green book Musicals Tarantino stand-up comedy Crackle Cannes HBO Disney Plus mutant Peacock Mystery DirecTV 45 composers GLAAD Awards Tour CBS WarnerMedia MSNBC Nominations TV renewals Classic Film AMC Netflix Nickelodeon Turner 007 cats biography TCA comic Brie Larson FOX blaxploitation zombie Awards Disney+ Disney Plus The Witch TLC National Geographic psychological thriller space Martial Arts E3 Ellie Kemper TIFF Universal Spectrum Originals Amazon Video Games FX cops Netflix Christmas movies Trailer sag awards Lionsgate Rom-Com teaser DC streaming service The Purge Watching Series supernatural Tomatazos NBC Animation south america USA Network Reality Competition Disney streaming service Action science fiction Cartoon Network docudrama Certified Fresh PBS Pride Month GoT Pirates LGBT Epix zombies game of thrones nature Countdown ratings Thanksgiving TNT