News

Hear Us Out: The End of the Skywalker Saga Is The Best Thing For Star Wars' Future

The only way Star Wars will stay interesting is if we head far, far away from the Skywalker family.

by | December 19, 2019 | Comments

Hear Us Out is a semi-regular column in which guest contributors and editors venture forth a take that’s sure to get fans talking. 

We’re mere seconds away from The Rise Of Skywalker. And sure, we’re excited – but also, if you love Star Wars and want it to continue, you might also feel that the end of the Skywalker Saga can’t come soon enough.

That may seem counterintuitive, but hear us out. The franchise is in urgent need of renewal if it is to continue in the long term. 

While The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi were box office smashes, they were also divisive among adults and didn’t have the mythical quality that turns children into lifelong fans. Kids understand goodies vs. baddies – but the more nuanced modern characters don’t easily lend themselves to games of Goodies versus Baddies so much as Superpowered Person With Opaque Past versus Ambiguous Villain With Veiled Agenda. Fascinating for many, but a little over-the-head for the younger Jedis out there.

We’ve had nine films exploring a single Midi-Chlorian–stuffed bloodline, and often it’s been like racing along a highway past crowded, colorful side streets without being able to jump out and explore. Bounty hunters! Exotic beasts! New cultures and species! Spaceship makers! Gambling dens! Criminal syndicates! Can’t we go sightseeing a bit? 

Well, now with the Saga done, we have the opportunity to do just that. And let’s be frank… 


1. At his Best, Luke Skywalker Was The Audience, Not A Character

Star Wars A New Hope

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

He was our surrogate, the eyes through which we were introduced to that galaxy far, far away – at least, until he became the Jedi master upon whom the fate of the universe depended. 

And the more he fulfilled his destiny the less engaging he became as an avatar for the viewer, which was a problem for the now-non-canon Expanded Universe, which too often followed plots that were endless reimaginings of Luke The Super-Wizard Defeats Yet Another Imperial Superweapon.

However, that same Expanded Universe also held the possible solution to Skywalker fatigue, which was to explore the universe rather than find new challenges for the core heroes to overcome. 

Whether in the “Tales From…” short story collections that fleshed out the lives of background characters from the movies, or the Rogue Squadron novels and comics that followed relatively minor film characters building a new elite fighting force, or the Knights of the Old Republic games, which explored the early Jedi and Sith millennia before the Empire, all of them told fresh stories in different genres and showed just how magnificently versatile Star Wars can be. 

That aside…


2. The Sequels Have Been Emotionally Exhausting

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Who doesn’t want a happy ending to conclude a long, challenging hero’s journey?

We had decades during which we assumed our heroes lived happily ever after following Return of the Jedi’s Ewok dance party, and it’s been undercut now that we know relationship breakdowns, parental failure, political turmoil, isolation, Rathtars, and green breastmilk are just around the corner. The Rebels saved the whole galaxy, for crying out loud; is it too much to hope they earned a bit of peace in the process?  

Similarly, it’d be nice to feel that Rey, Poe, Finn and/or whoever is left standing get a chance to enjoy their lives without we fans growing anxious that they’re going to be immediately plunged into some desperate new struggle for freedom before they can even grab a shower. And speaking of not getting downtime…


3. There’s No One Left To Bring Back 

Star Wars - The Force Awakens

(Photo by ©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures/Lucasfilm Ltd./Courtesy Everett Collection)

We’ve been assured that Leia will still get a narratively satisfying send-off following Carrie Fisher’s shocking, untimely, heartbreaking death, but with her gone, Luke and Han already knocked off, and the trailer to The Rise Of Skywalker suggesting that Threepio is headed for brain wipe, the bench from the original trilogy is getting awfully thin. 

Sure, we’re getting return visits from the Emperor and Lando Calrissian (and Wedge Antilles, if there’s any justice in the universe). But when even Admiral Ackbar gets killed offscreen, Star Wars needs to look forward rather than back.


4. Films Aren’t The Only Mainstream Option Anymore

Solo and Rogue One were ambitious attempts to shove new ideas into the classic format, and for all their charms, they still felt like they were forcing a longer story into the confines of a two-hour runtime. In 1977, that was the only way to do it. In 2019, that’s not remotely the case.

While Star Wars video games have been, to be generous, a bit hit-and-miss over recent years, it’s reassuring that Respawn’s recent Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order has shown that having time and breathing space can be a satisfying experience, a creative triumph, and also sell through the roof (since it’s currently on track to be the fourth-biggest physical release of the year). 

And for all the technical advances since, now-non-canon games like The Force Unleashed, the Dark Forces series, and the aforementioned Knights Of The Old Republic proved that letting us discover how this galaxy works at our own pace makes for an immersive, engaging experience sometimes superior to the headlong rush through settings, characters, and plot points to which the movie format is increasingly forced to adhere.

But most of all…


5. TV Can Be A Better Way To Tell These Stories 

The Mandalorian character poster (Disney+)

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Which brings us to The Mandalorian or, as the world knows it, Baby Yoda And His Boba Pett.

There had been TV outings for Star Wars before – Rebels, The Clone Wars, Forces of Destiny… um, Droids – but for viewers hesitant about animation, the offerings were limited to two made-for-TV Ewok movies and the legendarily awful Star Wars Holiday Special. So it’s no small deal that we just got a TV show that is not only great and Certified Fresh, but is the same Western-set-in-space that we fell in love with back in 1977. 

The world of The Mandalorian feels dusty, itchy, and uncomfortable, just like the Tatooine of A New Hope, and follows through on the promise we got with our first view of the Mos Eisley Cantina: this is a dynamic universe in which every scumbag and villain has a story. 

And we know that this is just the beginning for Disney+, with the Rogue One backstory explored in the upcoming Cassian Andor series and the recently confirmed Obi-Wan series starring the prequels’ MVP, Ewan McGregor. 

Will they be as successful without the meme-worthy cuteness of The Child, though? Difficult to see. Always in motion is the future. 


Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker is in theaters December 20. The Mandalorian is streaming on Disney+. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

feel good talk show political drama Mary Tyler Moore romantic comedy quibi ratings 21st Century Fox South by Southwest Film Festival based on movie X-Men anime movie godzilla TV American Society of Cinematographers kong Holidays Election critics VICE Alien OWN IFC high school international boxoffice game of thrones comic books Star Wars 4/20 trailers RT History USA Network Freeform Character Guide boxing comic Classic Film telelvision fast and furious IFC Films Valentine's Day Nat Geo SDCC See It Skip It witnail popular australia ITV space Stephen King rom-coms indiana jones toronto Mindy Kaling composers Comic-Con@Home 2021 Vudu psychological thriller SXSW canceled TV shows WGN BET Awards movies Universal comedies crossover mutant Comics on TV Sundance TV disaster rt labs critics edition Turner Music Food Network live event 72 Emmy Awards docudrama award winner The CW National Geographic Fox News Tarantino cooking cancelled TV series 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards medical drama Epix pirates of the caribbean Spike Nominations Spectrum Originals Prime Video Endgame SXSW 2022 Best Actor teaser SundanceTV adventure FXX Writers Guild of America GoT cancelled blockbusters Year in Review Captain marvel technology Fox Searchlight psycho Pirates ghosts 2015 DGA OneApp TCM spain unscripted canceled TV renewals Tags: Comedy USA Disney Channel Fargo suspense summer preview Marvel Action Amazon Prime Video Shudder new zealand Martial Arts Hallmark The Purge TCA Awards thriller rotten History best Image Comics king arthur Best Picture football legend facebook cults Winter TV japan Lionsgate Baby Yoda Rocketman criterion Marathons women Teen Sony CMT YA news crime drama genre twilight hollywood nature ABC Signature Sony Pictures TV One The Arrangement Instagram Live elevated horror A24 deadpool YouTube Premium Mary poppins Ovation halloween renewed TV shows Reality Watching Series Apple TV Plus Legendary President RT21 new york 90s Walt Disney Pictures Rock DC Comics CBS cats dark CW Seed sports GIFs stand-up comedy cancelled television free movies MTV natural history Paramount Plus Family Emmy Nominations TCA Comic Book Lucasfilm italian PlayStation Cannes Pride Month royal family nfl festival basketball Britbox BBC 99% Film Festival Quiz nbcuniversal TCA Winter 2020 travel reviews a nightmare on elm street slasher Best Actress rt archives social media revenge miniseries Nickelodeon Travel Channel Podcast 2018 Best Director Wes Anderson razzies Heroines obituary independent politics blaxploitation 2020 Horror TNT Marvel Studios BBC One Extras marvel comics marvel cinematic universe E! FX Country indie Christmas Polls and Games vs. Toys Women's History Month 1990s WarnerMedia PBS DirecTV scary movies 20th Century Fox adenture Brie Larson The Academy Emmys art house Chernobyl stoner finale Awards Tour NBA golden globes joker Pixar Animation tv talk Film toy story television mission: impossible leaderboard Disney harry potter all-time versus sitcom The Witch french BBC America aapi Warner Bros. period drama laika diversity HBO Max Fall TV directors Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt NYCC jurassic park Grammys Anna Paquin what to watch Avengers worst Western book adaptation Amazon Studios debate broadcast BET Ghostbusters The Walking Dead binge Universal Pictures casting Star Trek Logo festivals CNN TCA 2017 dragons Kids & Family FX on Hulu Best and Worst king kong Binge Guide rotten movies we love screenings rt labs slashers comic book movie Pop TV 2016 Ellie Kemper TBS TV movies fresh summer TV preview Summer franchise zombie DC streaming service Sundance mob Fantasy Cosplay young adult live action Comedy Central cars foreign dramedy LGBTQ Superheroes robots Esquire Dark Horse Comics posters Turner Classic Movies 2019 Funimation scene in color Tokyo Olympics kids worst movies Syfy halloween tv AMC Plus Comedy doctor who heist movie ID TruTV Adult Swim concert justice league Pop Crunchyroll die hard hidden camera Bravo Black History Month Rocky Hallmark Christmas movies Tubi japanese zero dark thirty vampires Mudbound Pacific Islander transformers summer TV olympics Premiere Dates Box Office hispanic heritage month universal monsters scary game show spanish language singing competition cancelled TV shows Neflix Countdown Pet Sematary christmas movies HFPA docuseries spinoff Musical james bond Academy Awards stop motion Arrowverse Reality Competition IMDb TV GLAAD 94th Oscars Winners supernatural Holiday comiccon target FOX BAFTA asian-american aliens Red Carpet dogs Paramount Pictures Showtime blockbuster serial killer hist TV Land APB 79th Golden Globes Awards TIFF NBC VOD Biopics YouTube Red children's TV obi wan south america richard e. Grant VH1 know your critic YouTube monster movies breaking bad Creative Arts Emmys kaiju Disney Plus cartoon streaming 93rd Oscars Photos lord of the rings dc 2021 Disney+ Disney Plus Super Bowl animated ABC Family Television Critics Association spider-man action-comedy biography San Diego Comic-Con hispanic Calendar CBS All Access comic book movies Mary Poppins Returns New York Comic Con Trailer Spring TV dceu critic resources Superheroe strong female leads 45 satire Sneak Peek Discovery Channel Hollywood Foreign Press Association Masterpiece ViacomCBS child's play venice romance Crackle Apple TV+ Song of Ice and Fire ABC discovery sequels Trivia new star wars movies jamie lee curtis sag awards Black Mirror Amazon biopic zombies Broadway E3 streaming movies films classics science fiction The Walt Disney Company First Look sopranos historical drama book cinemax First Reviews Rom-Com dreamworks El Rey dexter golden globe awards Shondaland Marvel Television Tumblr AMC Set visit Tomatazos Hulu black Infographic remakes archives Trophy Talk Television Academy werewolf prank black comedy Exclusive Video documentary Thanksgiving reboot Peacock Netflix Christmas movies saw Oscar Focus Features screen actors guild spy thriller video on demand TLC wonder woman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina chucky HBO war trophy mcc crime thriller Starz DC Universe 71st Emmy Awards spanish superman latino mockumentary PaleyFest 007 name the review parents HBO Go adaptation Lifetime comics Schedule Drama MGM Cartoon Network Paramount Awards Video Games Musicals Certified Fresh spider-verse anthology emmy awards Hear Us Out Elton John ESPN Sundance Now true crime video series Interview Acorn TV scorecard theme song gangster sequel Lifetime Christmas movies Oscars MCU Apple 73rd Emmy Awards Mystery Star Wars Celebration cops batman Amazon Prime police drama Netflix Disney streaming service Columbia Pictures MSNBC green book 24 frames crime LGBT 2017 A&E documentaries superhero Paramount Network interviews Sci-Fi Opinion streamig