News

Eternals First Reviews: Marvel's Most Unconventional Film Yet

Critics say director Chloé Zhao applies her unique sensibilities to the Marvel formula to deliver an epic story with big implications for the MCU going forward, even if it doesn't reach the top tier of the franchise.

by | October 25, 2021 | Comments

Could Eternals actually be one of the lesser installments of the Marvel Cinematic Universe? It’s surely one of the most unique and ambitious of the franchise, helmed by recent Oscar-winning director Chloé Zhao (Nomadland), and it features as diverse a cast of characters as can be, as well as arguably a more epic scope than even the last two Avengers movies.

Yet the first reviews for Eternals put its Tomatometer score in the bottom four of the 26 MCU features, alongside Iron Man 2, Thor: The Dark World, and The Incredible Hulk. That’s still on the fresh side, but the takes are generally more mixed than usual. Perhaps this will change later as more reviews come through, but it’s indeed a surprising twist for now.

Here’s what critics are saying about Eternals:


How does it compare to other MCU movies?

“Ranks among the better entries of the MCU… In terms of raw ambition and scope, Eternals belongs in the same camp as Black Panther.” – Brandon Zachary, CBR

“This critic finds it easily landing in her top 10 MCU films, and perhaps even in the top 5.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“Among the more interesting and original entries in the ever-expanding canon.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“More conceptually interesting than most MCU entries.” – Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

“It refreshingly bucks convention by not following the studio’s typical story and aesthetic formulas.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Eternals is by far Marvel’s bleakest film.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

“As much as it pains me to say it, Zhao presents one of the weakest MCU offerings yet.” – Linda Marric, The Jewish Chronicle


Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

Will Marvel fans still love it?

“There’s no doubt that Marvel devotees will once again lap it up and might even forgive the rather shambolic nature of this offering.” – Linda Marric, The Jewish Chronicle

“It’s still very much a Marvel movie.” – Molly Freeman, Screen Rant

“It doesn’t have to be perfect to be good, and it doesn’t necessarily need to shy away from the stuff people like about the MCU to be unique.” – Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

“This is still business as usual for Marvel — a continuation, rather than a great leap.” – John Nugent, Empire Magazine

“That Eternals feigns at such freedom only makes it harder to stomach when it falls back on the same old song.” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire


What about fans of Zhao’s films?

“It’s the work of a singular director… the likes of which has never been seen in Marvel before.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

Eternals does bend the ubiquitous fantasy genre to some degree to fit the director’s customary vein of humanistic intimacy measured against an expansive natural-world canvas.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“In many ways, this looks and feels nothing like any Chloé Zhao film we’ve seen before… Anyone anticipating the first ‘arthouse Marvel’ should temper their expectations.’” – John Nugent, Empire Magazine

“This truly isn’t the film any of us were expecting from this hugely accomplished filmmaker.’” – Linda Marric, The Jewish Chronicle

“It’s clear that Zhao, in signing up for this project, made a decision to put her highly expressive and idiosyncratic style on the shelf, and to embrace the straight-up expository conventionality of Marvel filmmaking. That’s something of a disappointment.’” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“Effectively illustrates why even the most independent-minded of filmmakers are powerless to evolve an apex predator franchise that doesn’t have any Darwinian impetus to adapt.’” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire


Richard Madden and Chloe Zhao on the set of Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

Is it actually the best of both worlds?

Eternals is not exactly the arthouse fare we’ve seen before from Zhao but it isn’t a typical superhero tentpole either. When it finds the sweet spot between both is when it works the best.” – Don Kaye, Den of Geek

“Both a Marvel superhero epic, as massively conceived as they come, and unquestionably Zhao’s version of one, as attentive to beauty and intimacy as it is to the expected fate-of-all-life concerns.” – Robert Abele, The Wrap

“Her fingerprints are all over every frame and yet her distinct, grounded, character-driven style doesn’t clash with what’s expected from the genre, only magnifies the greatness lying in its underpinnings.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“At times, it does find issues with knowing how to balance the aspects an audience has come to expect with an MCU film and Zhao’s instincts.” – Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

“What makes Eternals feel special is that, for once, the director genuinely cares as much about the character within that spectacle, as the spectacle itself.” – Robert Abele, The Wrap


Will it remind us of any other movies?

“Marvel has made a Dune-sized, Dune-length, and almost Dune-portentous superhero movie.” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

“[It] has a purposefulness and gravitas that feels strikingly akin in places to Denis Villeneuve’s recent Dune.” – Neil Smith, Total Film

Eternals plays like an extravagant blockbuster riff on The Tree of Life.” – Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times


Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

How is the script?

“The writing team of Chloé Zhao, Patrick Burleigh, Ryan Firpo, Kaz Firpo weave these stories together through masterful uses of vignettes that tie together the past and the present.” – Josephine L., Geeks of Color

“Seven thousand years is a lot to cover in just over two and a half hours, but Eternals pulls it off perfectly.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“What keeps Eternals from elevating to the top tier of the franchise is that its massive scope can sometimes play against the story.” – Brandon Zachary, CBR

Eternals tried to do too much… Sadly, there were too many cooks in the kitchen.” – Kirsten Acuna, Insider


Is there any levity?

“Yes, there is fun; plenty of stunts, jokes, combat, visuals, twists and, for the romantics, more than one love story, and not all of them straight, thank god.” – Robert Abele, The Wrap

Eternals has humor in spades thanks to both Kingo and Sprite. While much of the comedy is fun and entertaining like most Marvel movies, there are other times when a joke undercuts an important emotional moment.” – Molly Freeman, Screen Rant

“When the screenplay — by Zhao, Patrick Burleigh, Ryan Firpo, and Kaz Firpo — does try to wink at the rest of the MCU with jokey asides, the dialogue is jarringly out of place.” – Esther Zuckerman, Thrillist


Eternals

(Photo by Sophie Mutevelian/©Marvel Studios)

How does the movie look?

“Zhao’s work with cinematographer Ben Davis makes it a sight to behold.” – Brandon Zachary, CBR

“Ben Davis’ cinematography earns top marks. His eye for naturalism shines a spotlight on the characters’ humanity, providing an interesting, beguiling sense of wonder and joy witnessing extraordinary beings and creatures placed in ordinary locations.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“The cinematography here is a amazing…It is absolutely gorgeous to watch. Nearly every scene is breathtaking — and when the action is brought into it — WOW!” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“Ben Davis’ sweeping naturalistic cinematography… gives a less synthetic look than the average MCU joint.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“Compared to the diarrheal computer goop of the Endgame finale, this might as well be Dogme 95.” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

“Breathtaking but otherwise time-consuming nature shots can start to feel like a bit of a chore.” – Amelia Emberwing, IGN Movies


What about the visual effects?

“Some of the bigger special effects are so monumental they circle past realism and all the way back around until they achieve a sense of awe that’s been sorely absent from the MCU.” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

“The special effects team killed it… The style and aesthetic are so ethereal, futuristic, and cosmic all at the same time that I was in awe every time I saw it on screen.” – Josephine L., Geeks of Color

“The Eternals’ ability to generate gold geometrical force fields and weaponry delivers some cool effects work, at times suggesting the intricate beauty of art nouveau draftsmanship with hints of M.C. Escher.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter


Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

And the action?

“The clashes are efficiently choreographed but somewhat rote, even if it’s a thrill to see relative elders like Jolie and Lee busting serious moves.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“The action of Eternals is, for the most part, grounded in reality largely because Zhao films the fight scenes in daylight and on location… This makes the movie feel more immersive and the action more thrilling as a result.” – Molly Freeman, Screen Rant

“Arguably the least adrenaline-pumping Marvel escapade to date.” – Damon Smith, PA Media

“What action we get is mostly the same ‘superpowered heroes shoot effects out of their hands or throw punches to defeat CGI-created monsters.’” – Scott Mendelson, Forbes


Is the diversity of the ensemble appreciated?

“It’s to the credit of Zhao and her appealing ensemble that this mix actually feels organic to the story and not merely like woke pandering.” – David Rooney, Hollywood Reporter

“The movie presents [it] with a no-big-deal effrontery that makes them a winning prototype of a more dynamically inclusive superhero world.” – Owen Gleiberman, Variety

“I truly believe everyone will find someone that they resonate with on screen.” – Josephine L., Geeks of Color

“Touted as Marvel’s first deaf superhero, Lauren Ridloff is underutilized and feels like a mere check of the diversity box.” – Kirsten Acuna, Insider


Kumail Nanjiani, Gemma Chan, and Lia McHugh in Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

Who stands out?

“It’s [Don] Lee’s grasp of nuanced facets that genuinely wows, combining humor, heart and physical acumen, making him the picture’s MVP.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“Best is Nanjiani, who takes his usual comic persona in a dramatic direction as he wrestles with a painful existential conflict and blasts energy bolts from his hands.” – Don Kaye, Den of Geek

“The definite standouts are Kumail Nanjiani’s Kingo… his ‘valet’ Karun, played by Harish Patel… and Angelina Jolie’s Thena, effortlessly regal and classically aloof.” – John Nugent, Empire Magazine


Does it have a villain problem?

“Watching super-powered immortals go at it with powerful monsters or even each other only provides so much in terms of stakes.” – Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

“The Big Bad being battled isn’t a traditional villain… [This] blunts the audience’s collective cathartic release, as they may yearn to see invincible heroes overcoming an uncontrollable evil mastermind.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction


Eternals

(Photo by ©Marvel Studios)

Will we want to watch it multiple times?

“There is a lot going on here, so seeing this movie more than once is something that is highly recommended.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“On the whole there isn’t much here in a way of plot to make anyone want to sit through this more than once.” – Linda Marric, The Jewish Chronicle


Will it make us hopeful for the future of the MCU?

“I can only hope we see more MCU entries daring to ask existential questions about existence that don’t have easy answers.” – Aaron Neuwirth, We Live Entertainment

“Bodes well for a franchise that looks eminently capable of developing in more than one direction.” – Neil Smith, Total Film

“If this is what the future of Marvel looks like, sign me up!” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky


Eternals is in theaters on November 5, 2021.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Avengers CW Seed comic book movie San Diego Comic-Con Trophy Talk Paramount Plus Film summer TV Schedule toronto Pirates elevated horror deadpool IFC Films cancelled werewolf dceu zero dark thirty obituary Endgame The Academy genre Rom-Com suspense Creative Arts Emmys Chernobyl Disney TV renewals TruTV Nominations black science fiction Apple TV Plus Legendary action-comedy Syfy Mary poppins Women's History Month films Apple TV+ sag awards VOD Instagram Live kids streaming movies Pride Month Best Actress GoT new star wars movies football Winter TV canceled TV shows royal family Awards Tour cancelled television adaptation TBS crime Exclusive Video worst remakes anime Writers Guild of America HBO Max scene in color series Adult Swim 2019 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt composers Wes Anderson latino cinemax space sequel Fargo godzilla trailers HBO parents Shondaland children's TV YA 007 Best Director E3 psychological thriller spanish Horror rom-coms Alien Elton John adventure toy story Certified Fresh Amazon Prime Video Fantasy Mary Tyler Moore HBO Go El Rey Columbia Pictures boxoffice Walt Disney Pictures japan high school scary movies RT21 Photos Black History Month Emmys 94th Oscars ViacomCBS Nickelodeon GIFs Marvel Studios BET Awards 20th Century Fox Teen History 2015 spider-man obi wan fresh Amazon Studios Red Carpet MTV cancelled TV shows stop motion television child's play Summer universal monsters concert ghosts Oscars medical drama Action monster movies Sundance Now IFC live event 4/20 movies nature fast and furious PBS legend Captain marvel OneApp 24 frames mission: impossible quibi Bravo Box Office pirates of the caribbean WGN CBS All Access nbcuniversal Disney Channel canceled vampires Infographic Ovation halloween foreign cartoon See It Skip It docudrama CMT vs. Sony Pictures twilight romance New York Comic Con transformers boxing Sundance Rock spain aapi teaser mob Stephen King true crime AMC YouTube Esquire singing competition what to watch discovery target war USA Marvel Showtime Extras olympics unscripted die hard PaleyFest ESPN Discovery Channel Food Network Reality MSNBC Black Mirror popular GLAAD versus Cosplay 90s The Purge Disney streaming service international news American Society of Cinematographers ABC Signature diversity king arthur 79th Golden Globes Awards Neflix Drama Pop TV period drama MCU Podcast Comic Book basketball Comic-Con@Home 2021 new york hispanic heritage month First Reviews slasher Martial Arts a nightmare on elm street President best Paramount Network sopranos Lionsgate rt labs critics edition ratings DC Universe The Witch art house Superheroe Mystery The Walt Disney Company spanish language doctor who Emmy Nominations Academy Awards Comedy Central blaxploitation Vudu Disney Plus james bond hidden camera superman dexter A24 crime thriller Amazon historical drama Calendar rotten movies we love ABC Biopics Netflix Thanksgiving Cartoon Network Crunchyroll classics festivals Spectrum Originals TV One Logo Brie Larson Travel Channel TCA Awards Cannes Rocky french Lifetime 93rd Oscars Acorn TV talk show political drama TIFF TV Land SXSW 2022 theme song scene in color laika critic resources 1990s disaster Tags: Comedy X-Men Quiz ABC Family mcc First Look Grammys debate cults comic book movies cops worst movies Comedy Fox News slashers ID documentary Shudder DC Comics PlayStation black comedy crossover archives supernatural HFPA Crackle heist movie Watching Series blockbuster strong female leads book witnail all-time comics rt archives Best Actor Best Picture joker CNN stand-up comedy FX on Hulu spider-verse spinoff Hollywood Foreign Press Association animated Valentine's Day documentaries streaming directors Binge Guide Pet Sematary marvel comics Star Trek Hear Us Out saw TV Ghostbusters adenture italian anthology Broadway Marathons golden globes christmas movies jurassic park AMC Plus TCA Winter 2020 sequels Holiday TCA 2017 BBC young adult Prime Video hispanic reviews TNT Mindy Kaling TLC cats harry potter IMDb TV Character Guide telelvision ITV Sneak Peek justice league Paramount Pictures Song of Ice and Fire Star Wars Celebration 99% renewed TV shows serial killer Lucasfilm revenge Mudbound FXX Oscar Universal docuseries jamie lee curtis police drama biography breaking bad Hallmark 2021 72 Emmy Awards asian-american Winners Best and Worst Funimation Star Wars Premiere Dates Christmas Music Musicals casting Country comedies posters LGBTQ Set visit Holidays franchise screenings facebook Apple Reality Competition Heroines Lifetime Christmas movies 2017 cooking aliens gangster DGA MGM Pixar mutant king kong Starz award winner Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YouTube Red RT History new zealand summer TV preview BET Tarantino independent marvel cinematic universe SXSW satire finale stoner Marvel Television summer preview crime drama rotten Television Critics Association tv talk video on demand Geeked Week DirecTV Tubi The Arrangement Freeform USA Network lord of the rings Family Ellie Kemper Anna Paquin zombie natural history E! TCM kaiju The CW YouTube Premium Spring TV festival broadcast miniseries National Geographic wonder woman 2018 dark Epix thriller Toys game show dramedy hist south america psycho DC streaming service streamig Classic Film NYCC BBC America LGBT SundanceTV hollywood mockumentary scorecard CBS richard e. Grant Tomatazos Comics on TV scary prank video 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards free movies game of thrones Video Games Sony trophy blockbusters A&E cancelled TV series Animation venice golden globe awards BBC One South by Southwest Film Festival 71st Emmy Awards 2020 comic books Pop NBA emmy awards based on movie Pacific Islander rt labs dragons binge NBC Britbox Opinion biopic romantic comedy screen actors guild Fall TV Disney+ Disney Plus know your critic Paramount Trailer Film Festival name the review batman Election Mary Poppins Returns 21st Century Fox comic sitcom reboot Polls and Games nfl TCA Fox Searchlight Peacock Netflix Christmas movies target scene in color FOX APB scene in color film series FX TV movies Television Academy Turner Kids & Family Superheroes Hulu dreamworks zombies robots SDCC Sci-Fi Native japanese dc live action chucky Hallmark Christmas movies feel good comiccon Countdown halloween tv interviews Indigenous women Image Comics politics razzies Amazon Prime Turner Classic Movies Dark Horse Comics Sundance TV WarnerMedia Musical Warner Bros. OWN Year in Review Tumblr BAFTA 2016 criterion Universal Pictures technology VICE superhero indie Masterpiece Rocketman leaderboard Baby Yoda Super Bowl indiana jones spy thriller Awards social media book adaptation cars The Walking Dead kong travel Arrowverse 73rd Emmy Awards green book australia VH1 Nat Geo sports Trivia Focus Features movie Tokyo Olympics 45 dogs Interview critics Western series Spike