Detective Pikachu Is Officially the Best-Reviewed Video-Game Movie of All Time

Critics choose Pika Pika to break the video-game curse.

by | May 13, 2019 | Comments

(Photo by Warner Bros. /courtesy Everett Collection)

Sega. Capcom. Ubisoft. Blizzard. Konami. Many have vied for the throne in the battle of the first Fresh video-game movie adaptation, and all have failed. Until now. Fittingly, it is Nintendo and its Pokémon: Detective Pikachu film that wears the crown, breaking the video-game curse. It’s fitting not just because of the ubiquity of Nintendo in pop culture for decades, but because it was their legendary 1993’s bob-omb Super Mario Bros. that kicked off the adaptation cycle in the first place.

Before we dive further into the achievement, be aware we only considered U.S. theatrical releases when ranking video-game movies. Second, the movie needed to have at least 20 reviews for consideration, the same minimum we used for our list of 41 video game movies ranked by Tomatometer. Why 20 reviews? That’s the number required to get one of our sparkling Critics Consensus summaries, and also implies that the movie generated enough interest to be reviewed by a varied swath of critics. The previous Pokémon movie, The Power of Us (in theaters for a little over a week in America, courtesy of distribution by Fathom Events), actually got a 60%…but only from 5 reviews, not enough to consider it beyond a niche novelty.

With a Tomatometer percentage hovering in the low-60s, the crown sits precariously on Pikachu’s fluffy lil’ skull. Detective is a movie that will continue to see reviews added for months, perhaps even years to come, and enough unfavorable reviews could handily plunge it beneath 60% and into zone Rotten. But for now, Detective Pikachu‘s bright visuals, gallery of lovingly and faithfully rendered Pokemon, and fast-paced kid-friendly narrative (not to mention the coup of casting Ryan Reynolds as lead voice) are good enough with critics. After 26 years and well over 30 Rotten movies – not even the Konami Code could’ve saved Hollywood – it’s been a long time coming.

But other video game movies have come close, especially in recent years. Rampage and Tomb Raider, both just above 52%, had been battling back and forth for the top spot since their releases last year. Meanwhile, 2016 had previously looked like it was going to be the year, with Warcraft by Duncan Jones (Moon, Source Code) and Assassin’s Creed (starring Michael Fassbender, by his Macbeth director Justin Kurzel), though neither landed above 30%.

See the full list of Tomatometer-ranked video game movies here. Detective Pikachu is currently playing in theaters now.

Adjusted Score: 80.403%
Critics Consensus: Pokémon Detective Pikachu may not take its wonderfully bizarre premise as far as it could have, but this offbeat adaptation should catch most -- if not all -- of the franchise's fans.
Synopsis: The story begins when ace detective Harry Goodman goes mysteriously missing, prompting his 21-year-old son Tim to find out what... [More]
Directed By: Rob Letterman

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Song of Ice and Fire historical drama X-Men Reality crime E! A&E Photos 2018 disaster PBS APB biography Biopics Oscars Elton John Syfy Drama BBC DC Universe FOX TIFF Extras TCM Tarantino Thanksgiving YouTube Red adventure Grammys Mystery Watching Series 2019 Nominations VH1 Comedy Central DC streaming service binge History TV Land true crime Polls and Games miniseries Character Guide Calendar harry potter Superheroe ratings 21st Century Fox El Rey Paramount FX GIFs cinemax Columbia Pictures docudrama Summer DC Comics Video Games TruTV Valentine's Day Women's History Month CBS All Access Ellie Kemper Heroines Holidays Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Horror Amazon Sneak Peek crime drama science fiction BET Comics on TV justice league Marvel Lionsgate period drama DirecTV Writers Guild of America TNT Mudbound aliens Mary Poppins Returns dceu award winner American Society of Cinematographers First Look jamie lee curtis crossover President BBC America Star Trek Film Festival romance blaxploitation sitcom toy story See It Skip It Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Bravo serial killer FXX Pop sports SundanceTV Awards San Diego Comic-Con Best and Worst cults based on movie streaming Winners Fantasy dragons Freeform talk show IFC Nat Geo war Lifetime 45 Opinion NYCC PaleyFest thriller DGA political drama discovery Awards Tour Black Mirror adaptation Emmys nature Rock dramedy Super Bowl casting Christmas Lucasfilm AMC Netflix Pixar Premiere Dates Election Winter TV anime WarnerMedia Chernobyl CW Seed Reality Competition Trophy Talk natural history Superheroes RT History Certified Fresh Rocky MTV Cosplay Spectrum Originals boxoffice Showtime medical drama dc CNN Quiz VICE spinoff USA Network YA YouTube Premium The Arrangement Ovation social media travel mutant television Starz Rocketman politics Trailer comiccon CBS Warner Bros. Anna Paquin MSNBC Comedy CMT The CW Tomatazos Martial Arts animated Pet Sematary Toys Universal Trivia WGN Red Carpet mockumentary MCU Sundance Schedule singing competition Animation NBC zombies 2015 space Captain marvel Epix transformers Walt Disney Pictures police drama Musicals psychological thriller comic Nickelodeon TBS Country Logo Marathons Western Vudu vampires Adult Swim Spring TV unscripted witnail Teen New York Comic Con SDCC Musical TCA 007 Mary Tyler Moore Pride Month HBO Max ITV Cannes LGBTQ Hulu TV Shondaland what to watch Infographic Podcast Creative Arts Emmys Crackle cops The Witch 2016 cats technology spider-man Disney Channel GLAAD richard e. Grant Mindy Kaling golden globes Box Office Mary poppins game show SXSW 20th Century Fox spy thriller Fox News hist anthology Shudder Countdown psycho ABC Family National Geographic robots teaser Pirates green book Dark Horse Comics Interview HBO OWN festivals Music sequel E3 Kids & Family LGBT RT21 ABC Star Wars Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Sony Pictures cooking TLC ESPN facebook Sundance Now 2017 Fall TV finale GoT 24 frames Comic Book zero dark thirty Britbox supernatural Paramount Network zombie Spike theme song USA Stephen King doctor who Acorn TV Food Network crime thriller Ghostbusters Apple Brie Larson Masterpiece Sci-Fi elevated horror strong female leads Action Set visit TCA 2017 diversity composers Emmy Nominations Year in Review Esquire Tumblr Rom-Com IFC Films