Debating the Merits of The Reader

Oscar-worthy or revisionist whitewashing?

by | February 13, 2009 | Comments

When you read the list of Best Picture nominations for this year’s Academy Awards and saw The Reader nestled in between Slumdog Millionare and Milk, were you surprised? Well, you’re in good company — and for some, the response goes further than mere surprise: There’s a small backlash movement brewing among writers who believe The Reader makes some questionable (to say the least) statements about the Holocaust, and this week, Slate’s Ron Rosenbaum and the Huffington Post’s Rod Lurie used their columns to make a case against the film.

In a piece titled “Don’t Give an Oscar to The Reader,” Rosenbaum leads off by calling The Reader “the worst Holocaust film ever made,” and goes on from there to build a detailed three-page argument against giving it the highest honor the film industry has to offer — and pauses to scrutinize what he deems similar offenses in Valkyrie. Read the whole article by following the link below.

Offering a similar opinion, Rod Lurie wrote a column titled “The Holocaust Revisionism of Hollywood,” which he leads off by saying The Reader “gives ammunition to Holocaust negationists,” goes on to reference Ron Rosenbaum’s article, and from there proceeds to offer a point-by-point dismantling of the film’s presentation of World War II history. It isn’t as long as Rosenbaum’s article, but it reaches the same conclusion — The Reader doesn’t deserve a Best Picture nomination.

Of course, you could find (or make) an argument against pretty much any nomination — but in this case, the film in question has stirred up feelings that run deeper than simple dislike for a film. Check out both articles, and see what you think: Should The Reader have gone down as one of 2008’s best movies?

Source: Slate (Ron Rosenbaum article)
Source: The Huffington Post (Rod Lurie article)

Tag Cloud

Nickelodeon Certified Fresh MSNBC Sony Pictures Schedule comiccon FX YouTube Premium Sundance VICE aliens Writers Guild of America FXX streaming GIFs BBC America Paramount Comedy Central Nominations President binge Shondaland Character Guide Britbox Lionsgate 45 war Disney Channel Pixar 24 frames GLAAD NYCC Summer Fall TV Lucasfilm Marathons Warner Bros. CBS social media technology docudrama Food Network Sneak Peek Winners Set visit 2017 doctor who Valentine's Day CMT ITV adventure dramedy science fiction IFC VH1 robots Cartoon Network TCA 2017 Rom-Com transformers period drama Watching Series X-Men Photos Acorn TV Super Bowl OWN San Diego Comic-Con Grammys TBS Premiere Dates Ovation Horror Polls and Games CW Seed Calendar Logo crime drama discovery Crackle Paramount Network zombie medical drama cinemax E3 The Arrangement PBS Sundance Now Reality Competition Walt Disney Pictures Kids & Family Ellie Kemper composers sitcom SXSW hist zombies First Look DirecTV Mindy Kaling YA what to watch Holidays Podcast Red Carpet singing competition Reality ABC Family harry potter historical drama golden globes Superheroes YouTube Red crossover Drama NBC Nat Geo Adult Swim 21st Century Fox biography Star Trek Best and Worst AMC TCM Creative Arts Emmys Universal unscripted Pop Showtime Year in Review IFC Films cooking 20th Century Fox psycho CNN TV Thanksgiving SDCC Sci-Fi Box Office Rock El Rey Cosplay Teen Music Esquire cats WGN Musical Columbia Pictures Masterpiece TV Land ABC mutant Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Emmys Extras Action crime thriller National Geographic Christmas E! Election Biopics MTV justice league PaleyFest sports boxoffice based on movie Tumblr diversity Ghostbusters Syfy FOX Starz Infographic Opinion Rocky romance Amazon Country Winter TV vampires DC Universe Comic Book History finale ESPN American Society of Cinematographers TIFF Western Trailer TLC dc APB Video Games cults Marvel See It Skip It Musicals A&E Netflix DC streaming service Song of Ice and Fire GoT thriller Fantasy Mary Tyler Moore ratings supernatural Countdown crime Star Wars 2015 DC Comics Disney Dark Horse Comics Apple Awards SundanceTV Pirates Tomatazos Freeform Martial Arts blaxploitation Fox News travel spy thriller TruTV Spike Mystery The CW BET Bravo USA serial killer Hulu RT History Interview politics Toys festivals cops dceu LGBTQ 2016 Lifetime Spring TV USA Network TNT 007 police drama talk show BBC Animation TCA Oscars Superheroe CBS All Access Trivia Comedy HBO political drama