Debating the Merits of The Reader

Oscar-worthy or revisionist whitewashing?

by | February 13, 2009 | Comments

When you read the list of Best Picture nominations for this year’s Academy Awards and saw The Reader nestled in between Slumdog Millionare and Milk, were you surprised? Well, you’re in good company — and for some, the response goes further than mere surprise: There’s a small backlash movement brewing among writers who believe The Reader makes some questionable (to say the least) statements about the Holocaust, and this week, Slate’s Ron Rosenbaum and the Huffington Post’s Rod Lurie used their columns to make a case against the film.

In a piece titled “Don’t Give an Oscar to The Reader,” Rosenbaum leads off by calling The Reader “the worst Holocaust film ever made,” and goes on from there to build a detailed three-page argument against giving it the highest honor the film industry has to offer — and pauses to scrutinize what he deems similar offenses in Valkyrie. Read the whole article by following the link below.

Offering a similar opinion, Rod Lurie wrote a column titled “The Holocaust Revisionism of Hollywood,” which he leads off by saying The Reader “gives ammunition to Holocaust negationists,” goes on to reference Ron Rosenbaum’s article, and from there proceeds to offer a point-by-point dismantling of the film’s presentation of World War II history. It isn’t as long as Rosenbaum’s article, but it reaches the same conclusion — The Reader doesn’t deserve a Best Picture nomination.

Of course, you could find (or make) an argument against pretty much any nomination — but in this case, the film in question has stirred up feelings that run deeper than simple dislike for a film. Check out both articles, and see what you think: Should The Reader have gone down as one of 2008’s best movies?

Source: Slate (Ron Rosenbaum article)
Source: The Huffington Post (Rod Lurie article)

Tag Cloud

Sundance TV sitcom CBS VICE green book AMC crossover NBC Amazon cancelled television screenings Marvel Ghostbusters finale Tubi stand-up comedy Drama Biopics X-Men Comedy Western anthology true crime comiccon Pet Sematary Pixar quibi Syfy Heroines Rocketman Universal hispanic New York Comic Con Esquire Nickelodeon SXSW DC Comics FOX series Warner Bros. Shondaland USA Network 21st Century Fox Amazon Studios free movies Mystery Fox News Academy Awards joker spy thriller Netflix Christmas movies 2015 Masterpiece 2017 Ovation Trailer Red Carpet Sundance BBC America Certified Fresh documentary south america nature Film Festival Year in Review anime DC Universe SundanceTV Peacock crime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime drama political drama First Look Holidays justice league spinoff BET jamie lee curtis Fantasy ITV DirecTV MCU historical drama The Walking Dead Musical Premiere Dates Comics on TV biography San Diego Comic-Con Acorn TV Cosplay FX Tumblr dramedy HBO Max ESPN The Purge Tomatazos Amazon Prime science fiction Avengers Lifetime 24 frames canceled Binge Guide Turner Classic Movies Awards Star Trek Fall TV 2018 Country Brie Larson Music IFC TBS 007 dogs Disney Black Mirror A&E Winter TV screen actors guild National Geographic zero dark thirty Martial Arts Adult Swim Super Bowl Television Academy game show YouTube Premium Classic Film Watching Series streaming Box Office Discovery Channel Animation Quiz Interview blaxploitation Cartoon Network ratings E3 Sundance Now psycho 45 zombie spanish language Mary poppins festivals cops Freeform Superheroes Hallmark Disney Channel Marvel Television ghosts The Witch Thanksgiving El Rey cooking Columbia Pictures discovery Song of Ice and Fire Nat Geo toy story disaster 2016 MTV Endgame canceled TV shows Trivia Video Games Extras Anna Paquin composers President politics renewed TV shows Apple TV Plus breaking bad kids cancelled Disney+ Disney Plus Apple mockumentary PaleyFest slashers richard e. Grant Captain marvel Sneak Peek Sony Pictures cats talk show Awards Tour Reality Competition based on movie Vudu doctor who television ABC children's TV Tarantino TLC A24 71st Emmy Awards Cannes Emmy Nominations TV psychological thriller Britbox supernatural travel cartoon RT21 cults Stephen King casting History Star Wars Logo Chernobyl movie Hallmark Christmas movies reboot Marvel Studios Spike Pride Month cinemax DGA Apple TV+ YouTube Red rotten movies we love Opinion Set visit diversity RT History latino IFC Films 2019 YA PBS space Photos Mary Tyler Moore Crackle game of thrones adventure crime thriller TruTV cars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt GIFs Bravo First Reviews Walt Disney Pictures SDCC Amazon Prime Video FXX Holiday CMT Calendar Spring TV Lucasfilm TCM WarnerMedia versus Rom-Com Best and Worst Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers TV renewals unscripted Musicals Pop foreign transformers movies social media E! Schedule CNN LGBTQ WGN Creative Arts Emmys dc Comic Book Oscars spider-man BBC HBO Nominations NYCC dragons Dark Horse Comics golden globes sag awards YouTube MSNBC Starz Pirates zombies Food Network Baby Yoda spain tv talk APB Countdown Infographic Mudbound Family Netflix blockbuster thriller Superheroe directors TCA 2017 Disney streaming service Hulu Elton John cancelled TV series Paramount Network Disney Plus OWN batman what to watch Turner facebook Mindy Kaling halloween LGBT TCA Winter 2020 20th Century Fox Valentine's Day Epix Summer technology Rock sequel Spectrum Originals Toys elevated horror Paramount serial killer ABC Family theme song hist period drama Marathons DC streaming service Podcast war GLAAD teaser CW Seed Ellie Kemper singing competition Showtime VH1 award winner Crunchyroll CBS All Access Winners GoT mutant name the review police drama Women's History Month Comedy Central Reality The CW strong female leads Mary Poppins Returns comics 2020 TIFF Lifetime Christmas movies animated revenge Action miniseries OneApp See It Skip It Horror sports video indie docudrama Film Polls and Games Kids & Family romantic comedy dceu Teen Election TCA book binge cancelled TV shows adaptation Arrowverse comic Rocky harry potter aliens Lionsgate romance TNT independent medical drama Grammys The Arrangement USA natural history Shudder Christmas Character Guide robots boxoffice Writers Guild of America christmas movies Sci-Fi werewolf Emmys witnail vampires TV Land