Debating the Merits of The Reader

Oscar-worthy or revisionist whitewashing?

by | February 13, 2009 | Comments

When you read the list of Best Picture nominations for this year’s Academy Awards and saw The Reader nestled in between Slumdog Millionare and Milk, were you surprised? Well, you’re in good company — and for some, the response goes further than mere surprise: There’s a small backlash movement brewing among writers who believe The Reader makes some questionable (to say the least) statements about the Holocaust, and this week, Slate’s Ron Rosenbaum and the Huffington Post’s Rod Lurie used their columns to make a case against the film.

In a piece titled “Don’t Give an Oscar to The Reader,” Rosenbaum leads off by calling The Reader “the worst Holocaust film ever made,” and goes on from there to build a detailed three-page argument against giving it the highest honor the film industry has to offer — and pauses to scrutinize what he deems similar offenses in Valkyrie. Read the whole article by following the link below.

Offering a similar opinion, Rod Lurie wrote a column titled “The Holocaust Revisionism of Hollywood,” which he leads off by saying The Reader “gives ammunition to Holocaust negationists,” goes on to reference Ron Rosenbaum’s article, and from there proceeds to offer a point-by-point dismantling of the film’s presentation of World War II history. It isn’t as long as Rosenbaum’s article, but it reaches the same conclusion — The Reader doesn’t deserve a Best Picture nomination.

Of course, you could find (or make) an argument against pretty much any nomination — but in this case, the film in question has stirred up feelings that run deeper than simple dislike for a film. Check out both articles, and see what you think: Should The Reader have gone down as one of 2008’s best movies?

Source: Slate (Ron Rosenbaum article)
Source: The Huffington Post (Rod Lurie article)

Tag Cloud

MTV Oscars 45 TV Land CBS CNN singing competition GIFs USA travel Thanksgiving BBC Winter TV cinemax First Look police drama Warner Bros. Mindy Kaling Netflix FX vampires Red Carpet Premiere Dates DC Universe ABC Emmys Marvel crime thriller Bravo Paramount Lifetime Trivia political drama Interview NBC FXX Reality Competition TCM Dark Horse Comics cooking Teen GLAAD Pop Awards serial killer Mary Tyler Moore Mystery Certified Fresh Podcast WGN Rocky Martial Arts Lionsgate crime drama Tumblr Valentine's Day Election Grammys VICE Biopics Summer President sports A&E diversity binge CMT Disney Musicals Star Trek CBS All Access Photos TNT Hulu period drama Video Games Ghostbusters social media Crackle DirecTV ITV E! Adult Swim 2016 IFC Holidays dramedy war LGBTQ Horror Infographic Super Bowl romance BBC America Winners OWN based on movie thriller Trailer Action APB Writers Guild of America X-Men BET Fantasy TruTV TIFF Country supernatural Logo Opinion comiccon Amazon cats aliens Comedy Central Fox News GoT biography FOX Food Network talk show what to watch YA History American Society of Cinematographers Pirates ESPN adventure Cosplay TCA 2017 Drama The CW The Arrangement historical drama Reality crime Nat Geo PaleyFest Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt politics RT History composers 2015 SDCC Fall TV VH1 TCA Schedule Comic Book Sci-Fi Box Office Year in Review Masterpiece psycho Freeform Toys Tomatazos ABC Family SundanceTV Sundance Musical 007 El Rey E3 Kids & Family MSNBC discovery TLC sitcom Marathons 24 frames technology AMC Superheroes Countdown Universal TBS Starz DC Comics Ellie Kemper Rom-Com Showtime Sneak Peek Best and Worst Animation zombie Esquire Syfy Set visit Extras Watching Series TV science fiction Character Guide Rock harry potter Comedy Nominations HBO Nickelodeon Music PBS cops Spring TV boxoffice Polls and Games NYCC Calendar 2017 docudrama Star Wars Disney Channel transformers Cartoon Network