Creepshow Returns: 6 Things to Know About Shudder’s Horror Reboot

The Stephen King–George A. Romero ’80s classic is back as an anthology series helmed by The Walking Dead boss Greg Nicotero. Rotten Tomatoes visited the show's Atlanta set.

by | September 26, 2019 | Comments

With the success of series like The Terror, The Haunting of Hill House, and American Horror Story, television has never been a better medium for creators interested in telling spooky stories on a regular basis. The latest entry into the genre is Creepshow, a TV anthology version of the Stephen King/George A. Romero horror film that debuts today on genre-focused streaming service Shudder.

Spearheaded by The Walking Dead boss Greg Nicotero, the series pays tribute to its roots by telling frightening stories of many ilks (gory, suspenseful, silly, unsettling). The first episode features the installments “Gray Matter,” based on the King story of the same name about an alcoholic whose booze of choice might affect him in more nefarious ways, and “The House of the Head,” about a girl who discovers a killer severed head in her dollhouse.

Earlier this year, Rotten Tomatoes visited the series’ Atlanta set, where we walked through blood-soaked sets, saw creatures being made, and saw a werewolf decapitate a Nazi. Here are six things we learned about the show while we were there.

1. It’s in good hands with superfan Greg Nicotero

Greg Nicotero at arrivals for Opening Night Of Universal Studios' HALLOWEEN HORROR NIGHTS, Universal Studios Hollywood, Universal City, CA September 12, 2019. Photo By: Priscilla Grant/Everett Collection
(Photo by Priscilla Grant/Everett Collection)

The Walking Dead boss is a lifelong horror fan who got his start working on special effects makeup with Romero and Creepshow’s effects mastermind Tom Savini on Romero’s Day of the Dead.

With this Creepshow reboot, “I want to embrace the spirit of the original movie,” Nicotero said from his windowless office in an Atlanta production facility. “I’m not rebooting anything. It’s not like, ‘Oh we’re going to upgrade it and retell it.’ It’s really like you’re picking up another issue of Creepshow, and these are the stories.”

The stories include works from King, one from King’s son, Joe Hill, plus more adaptations of existing stories and a few original tales. Nicotero was so dedicated to the project that he began working on it during The Walking Dead, taking just a week off before flying back to Atlanta to begin pre-production on Creepshow.

2. The series was filmed in an uber-short time frame

Creepshow (Shudder)
(Photo by Shudder)

Each of the six episodes contains two stories, and each story has just three and a half days to film.

“You can’t stop filming for 12 hours. You can’t eat, you can’t go to the bathroom, and you’ve just got to keep filming and go crazy,” Nicotero said in a short break while filming the final two installments.

On one stage, special effects experts prepared a dummy for its impending decapitation — the fake blood spurting everywhere meant they had just one take (or risk spending hours cleaning up the blood only to set it all up again. On the other, the production team used a forklift to place a massive monster they created on the set of the story they’d begin filming the next day.

Originally, Nicotero wanted to film even more stories, but with a packed production schedule spanning from the beginning of January through the end of March, it wasn’t enough time to fully realize that many tales.

“I was pretty greedy at first. I was like, ‘We should do three stories per episode, and each story should be like 17 minutes,’ and then we got into production and I was like, ‘What the f— was I thinking? We should do two,’” he admitted.

3. For practical effects, Nicotero brought in the experts.

Creepshow (Shudder)
(Photo by Shudder)

Special effects guru Savini worked closely with Romero on many of his films, including the original Creepshow. So it was only natural Nicotero would hire him to helm a story of his own (Joe Hill’s “By the Silver Water of Lake Champlain”).

“It’s 98 percent practical effects — all the creature work, all the makeup, the werewolves, the puppets,” Nicotero said.

Evidence of that mandate is strewn about the production spaces that once held Gabrielle Union’s BET drama Being Mary Jane — cardboard boxes loaded with fake animal carcasses are piled next to busts of various creatures. (And sets from stories filmed weeks prior sit abandoned, covered in fake blood and gore — evidence of the sheer speed of production.)

“We’re shooting so fast that when one of them is done, the guys just throw it on the floor in the room and grab the next one and run to set. So when you walk by our lock-up, everything is just thrown everywhere. There’s no time to even pick anything up,” Nicotero said. “The skin crawlers, the big bloody monster, they’re all on the ground. We finish shooting and it was soaked in blood and they just dropped it and it’s still sitting there, because you don’t even have five minutes to wipe the blood off. We’re moving that fast.”

4. He hired big names to star.

Tricia Helfer in Creepshow (Shudder)
(Photo by Shudder)

How did the little horror series for a streaming service wind up with genre heavyweights like Tricia Helfer, Adrienne Barbeau, Jeffrey Combs, and Bruce Davidson, plus other stars including Giancarlo Esposito, David Arquette, Kid Cudi, and Big Boi (yeah, Outkast’s Big Boi)?

“I literally texted every single actor I’ve ever worked with to find out what they were up to and I was like, ‘Come on, let’s play, it’ll be fun,’” Nicotero said. One thing he could promise his pals: It’s quick. You come in, you shoot a couple of days, and you leave. So in that regard it’s been fun, but it’s also been insanely hard.”

5. The scary stories include adaptations and originals.

Creepshow (Shudder)
(Photo by Shudder)

Adaptations include Stephen King’s “Gray Matter” (which kicks off the series), Joe Hill’s “By the Silver Water of Lake Champlain,” Joe R. Lansdale’s “The Companion,” Josh Malerman’s “The House of the Head,” Christopher Buehlman’s “The Man in the Suitcase,” Bruce Jones’ “All Hallows Eve,” and John Skipp and Dori Miller’s “Times Is Tough in Musky Holler.”

The original stories include “Lydia Layne’s Better Half” by John Harrison and Nicotero, “Skincrawlers” by Paul Dini and Stephen Langford, “Night of the Paw” by John Esposito, and “Bad Wolf Down” by Rob Schrab.

Again, Nicotero hit up his friends to obtain the season’s best-known story: “I actually wrote Stephen King and said, ‘Can’t be Creepshow without a Stephen King story. What do you think?’ And he’s like, ‘I have just the story!’ Within 20 minutes, Stephen had two different stories that he had proposed,” Nicotero said, and once production began, it was clear “Gray Matter” was the right choice. “It was just cool that he said, ‘Yeah man, sure.’”

6. It honors its roots.

CREEPSHOW, Stephen King, 1982, (c) Warner Brothers/courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Warner Brothers/courtesy Everett Collection)

While filmmaking techniques have advanced in the more than 35 years since the original, which was originally designed to pay tribute to mid-century horror comics, this Creepshow retains much of its look. That means intros and outros that use the familiar comic book motif.

“Because of the comic book vibe with all the panels, I think Creepshow is a different experience. We are really embracing the split-screens and going through the panels. So it’s got that flair and flavor to it, which is great,” Nicotero said.

And the crew — from prop makers to set decorators — are also reverent horror fans, and have filled the series with plenty of Easter Eggs. Gray Matter has “probably 30” nods to King’s work. An ash tray from the original film owned by one of Nicotero’s friends appears in every episode.

“I want people to look and then they’ll watch it a couple more times,” he said of “Gray Matter.” “There’s a lot of little things. Comic books, the voodoo doll – I forget half of them because we’ve been shooting for seven weeks. I’ll probably go back and go, ‘Oh s—, I forgot about that one!’ But it’s been fun because even the art department guys come and go, ‘Look, we made this!’ and I’m like ‘That’s great, I didn’t think about that!’ Even ‘The House of the Head,’ … it’s a really great psychological thriller about a little girl who comes home and her dollhouse is haunted. She goes to the store and she’s like, ‘I need help,’ and she goes to the store and gets a cop and puts the cop toy in and then the cop gets killed and she goes and gets an Indian. We did a little Chief Woodenhead from Creepshow 2 as the Indian. All that nerdy s— where we’re doing it and I’m like, ‘No one’s ever going to notice this,’ and on set, half the crew is like, ‘Is that Chief Woodenhead?!’ I’m like, ‘How the f— do you guys know that? This is great.’ So there’s a lot of that kind of stuff, and it’s been fun.”

New episodes of Creepshow debut Wednesdays at 9 p.m. ET/6 p.m. PT on Shudder’s TV live-stream and On Demand.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

discovery Nickelodeon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pop TV Acorn TV Tubi Bravo Hulu Writers Guild of America Baby Yoda based on movie streaming BBC psychological thriller YouTube Pixar stoner Mary Tyler Moore Masterpiece anime RT21 Disney+ Disney Plus San Diego Comic-Con dramedy composers Crackle TruTV Ghostbusters HBO Go Trivia critics National Geographic Television Academy ghosts quibi Hallmark Song of Ice and Fire cancelled television The Purge Kids & Family cancelled Character Guide miniseries Rocketman Reality Competition Ovation name the review indie hist Fantasy 2018 game of thrones Ellie Kemper Hear Us Out 2017 nature CBS All Access blockbuster Hallmark Christmas movies Disney Plus politics game show CMT VICE comic ratings The Walking Dead History sitcom Red Carpet disaster 2016 Interview Quiz franchise jamie lee curtis sports Sundance Now festivals Countdown witnail American Society of Cinematographers dceu zombie Toys Amazon Awards medical drama parents war die hard Pet Sematary Horror mockumentary dc supernatural sequel TCM CW Seed Captain marvel A24 documentaries Lucasfilm Television Critics Association facebook APB television Mystery Martial Arts Endgame Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving LGBTQ Turner Opinion See It Skip It Sci-Fi TBS Super Bowl Spike Marvel Television Lifetime TV renewals Mary poppins Shondaland kids Netflix Christmas movies BAFTA christmas movies Western Crunchyroll doctor who vampires A&E TV Land independent OWN SundanceTV TCA USA Network batman Academy Awards Oscars cinemax video on demand romantic comedy Winter TV psycho talk show Tumblr dark Spectrum Originals comics BET Awards 71st Emmy Awards 24 frames Superheroes Funimation cults Walt Disney Pictures Mudbound Marvel Arrowverse Emmy Nominations AMC boxoffice TLC Warner Bros. 20th Century Fox Podcast sag awards Certified Fresh Comedy IFC Films chucky Box Office Superheroe Black Mirror cats Biopics FOX DC Universe natural history free movies ABC Family screen actors guild award winner theme song Paramount New York Comic Con Elton John harry potter spider-man technology strong female leads revenge ITV Logo Holidays Mary Poppins Returns all-time Awards Tour werewolf Women's History Month GoT animated twilight The CW Set visit joker Disney streaming service Star Trek Freeform adventure The Arrangement travel First Reviews BBC One Photos comedies YouTube Premium indiana jones Pop robots richard e. Grant BET Fox News TNT dogs BBC America science fiction Sony Pictures Spring TV what to watch MCU TIFF children's TV spain zombies stand-up comedy cancelled TV series diversity rotten movies we love scary movies spy thriller Britbox Holiday singing competition VH1 Universal Christmas Rock Nat Geo IFC child's play SDCC Infographic Classic Film PlayStation cars Teen elevated horror Sundance Anna Paquin movie Shudder VOD crime drama Extras El Rey political drama south america binge DGA ESPN Netflix PBS Country YA versus best Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Turner Classic Movies 2020 NBC romance LGBT cops universal monsters 2015 PaleyFest spanish language HBO crime thriller Grammys Apple TV+ 007 21st Century Fox FXX 4/20 Emmys breaking bad canceled TV shows Adult Swim Vudu Family aliens Cosplay Mindy Kaling FX on Hulu Calendar Creative Arts Emmys Reality Discovery Channel Pirates Comic Book Disney Channel book Showtime period drama GLAAD Schedule asian-american NYCC toy story Disney ABC YouTube Red Paramount Network spinoff transformers reboot 2019 Year in Review Music Tarantino casting Video Games social media Marvel Studios comiccon blaxploitation Polls and Games Summer cooking true crime Black History Month Comedy Central series canceled President satire Sneak Peek Rocky CNN reviews Trophy Talk mutant TV Cannes historical drama Musicals slashers Apple Columbia Pictures movies Cartoon Network screenings finale Star Wars golden globes CBS justice league MSNBC Rom-Com video a nightmare on elm street Syfy cancelled TV shows directors Sundance TV foreign films Nominations WGN 45 renewed TV shows Esquire crime anthology Chernobyl unscripted Apple TV Plus police drama halloween Amazon Prime Video Trailer HBO Max Peacock Brie Larson Comics on TV news Dark Horse Comics Action RT History teaser FX Film Festival USA Animation serial killer Pride Month The Witch Fall TV Musical Valentine's Day DC streaming service Starz docudrama Tomatazos Marathons hispanic X-Men Amazon Prime green book Binge Guide E3 OneApp mission: impossible crossover Heroines DC Comics Drama documentary Best and Worst MTV Epix zero dark thirty SXSW thriller WarnerMedia criterion biography Watching Series TCA 2017 E! DirecTV GIFs Election space adaptation Film Avengers Food Network First Look TCA Winter 2020 Stephen King Amazon Studios Winners Travel Channel concert TCA Awards latino cartoon Premiere Dates tv talk Lionsgate dragons