Castle Rock Season 2 First Reviews: Lizzy Caplan Kills in Iconic Role

Just in time for Halloween, a gory tale in the spirit of Stephen King that features one of the author's most beloved characters, Annie Wilkes.

by | October 22, 2019 | Comments

Castle Rock presented a cornucopia of Stephen King Easter eggs to fans when the first season premiered to Hulu in October 2018. The Shawshank Redemption, Needful Things, and Stand By Me were just a few of the author’s iconic works that were mined for the series — from co-creators Sam Shaw and Dustin Thomason, and executive producers J.J. Abrams and King himself.

Season 1 of the series (which is Certified Fresh at 87% on the Tomatometer with 76 reviews) followed the story of Henry Deaver (Andre Holland) who returned to his childhood home of Castle Rock, Maine after a mysterious young man (Bill Skarsgård) was found living in a cage underground, beneath Shawshank Prison. This odd discovery sparked a domino effect of terrible events throughout the town, establishing the inherent evil of the fictional town while providing a fun collection of genre nods for newbies and die-hard fans alike.

The goal here was to establish the King universe for the small-screen, adhering to the author’s extensive library of work — from short stories and novellas like The Body and The Sun Dog to his more in-depth novels like The Stand and The Shining — for inspiration. New characters and narratives breathed new life into the familiar genre goodies sprinkled throughout its initial run.

With season 2, though, it seems that Castle Rock has narrowed its focus on the master of horror’s work. This time around, the scope of the series will expand outside of the town’s borders to the Somali community of Jerusalem’s Lot — the small town featured in the vampire-themed Salem’s Lot. Tim Robbins, Paul Sparks, Barkhad Abdi, and Yusra Warsama are new to the cast this season, helping to expand this new storyline.

Most notable, though, is the character of Annie Wilkes (Lizzy Caplan) — a role which won Kathy Bates the Oscar in 1991 — leading the new season. How did the young nurse become the kidnapping psychopath, who terrorizes author Paul Sheldon (James Caan) in the Rob Reiner film adaptation Misery? These new episodes allegedly will set out to answer that question.

Here’s what critics are saying about season 2 of Hulu’s Castle Rock:

Castle Rock keyart season 2 (Hulu)
(Photo by Hulu)


Caplan is excellent as the psychologically deteriorating Annie Wilkes. She’s obviously heavily influenced by Bates, but she gives a fiercely committed performance of her own. —Liam Mathews, TV Guide

Caplan, who is in the unenviable position of following Kathy Bates’ Oscar-winning turn in the 1990 film Misery, does a remarkable job portraying Castle Rock’s reimagined Annie. —Kristen Baldwin, EW


Tim Robbins returns to the geographic proximity of THE SHAWSHANK REDEMPTION but plays a man haunted by his past and trying to make amends. Barkhad Abdi gets his meatiest acting role since CAPTAIN PHILLIPS and nails it. Even Elsie Fisher shows her work in EIGHTH GRADE was no fluke as she plays the tormented daughter of Annie Wilkes. —Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Emporium

Sam Shaw and Dustin Thomason are intent on putting their best foot forward from the moment go. That means making use of Caplan and Fisher, but also Tim Robbins as Pop Merrill, Paul Sparks (Boardwalk Empire) as Ace Merrill, and Barkhad Abi (Captain Philips), as a criminal family threatening to tear itself apart over the construction of a new Somali mall in Castle Rock. —Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Emporium

Abdi and Warsama are both standouts in a Somali storyline that starts off intriguing and timely only to sputter a bit by the season’s halfway point. —Dan Fienberg, The Hollywood Reporter


Season 2 fares a bit better. The show is still far too obsessed with trying to ape producer J.J. Abrams’ infamous “mystery box” formula, where only tiny bits of info are doled out in frustrating fashion. But the story is stronger overall, as is the cast of characters. —Chris Evangelista, SlashFilm

The effectiveness of not just the characters but the story itself is so strong and compelling that we don’t need any other references to King and his memorable characters throughout the rest of the season, with those possible nods likely only heightening the rivetting story that we already get to witness take place. —Patrick Cavanaugh,

Despite all its high drama, season two feels a little more conventional in its narrative, and that’ll likely make for a more satisfying story arc, especially with all the horror-fantasy elements to come. —Cheryl Eddy, IO9

Much like Season 1, this is a Stephen King mixtape, but the tunes are much better this time around. —Mike Fugere, CBR

Castle Rock season 2 premieres on Wednesday, October 23 on Hulu.

Adjusted Score: 91.074%
Critics Consensus: Driven by an unsettlingly compelling Lizzy Caplan, Castle Rock's second chapter opens the borders of its titular town without losing any of its creeping atmosphere.
Synopsis: In season two of Castle Rock, a feud between warring clans comes to a boil when budding psychopath Annie Wilkes,... [More]

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

DC Comics true crime Superheroe stand-up comedy Infographic FXX Lionsgate X-Men revenge Fall TV Britbox Podcast Logo rotten movies we love doctor who Discovery Channel zero dark thirty Spike blockbuster justice league Comics on TV documentaries ratings news cats Bravo biography Polls and Games harry potter Black History Month Interview Captain marvel Musical historical drama MCU emmy awards facebook thriller Emmys IFC Films Ghostbusters twilight The Arrangement Spectrum Originals dceu die hard NYCC OWN Hallmark ABC Family parents mission: impossible Sundance TV DirecTV Apple TV+ Marvel Studios renewed TV shows 24 frames Stephen King canceled President Film name the review El Rey Rocketman dramedy binge LGBTQ Showtime HBO Cannes sitcom children's TV 2020 crime drama transformers animated composers Epix E3 green book adventure book television Sony Pictures Disney Plus docudrama dragons New York Comic Con Drama Crunchyroll adaptation films Netflix Christmas movies Cosplay Chernobyl hispanic Esquire Dark Horse Comics cars HBO Go Grammys ITV werewolf Television Academy Lifetime Christmas movies Disney+ Disney Plus Masterpiece Biopics a nightmare on elm street asian-american Sundance Now sequel fast and furious mockumentary superhero series criterion tv talk VOD Amazon Prime Video Rocky Red Carpet TruTV Opinion Tumblr Set visit crime screenings First Look blaxploitation Starz psychological thriller chucky romantic comedy Turner Classic Movies TV renewals stoner TCA 2019 DGA BET Awards franchise OneApp Summer elevated horror TV Land Christmas Warner Bros. spinoff Best and Worst spider-man batman 2018 Extras boxoffice cancelled teaser comiccon dc Character Guide Pixar discovery BBC concert Star Wars History HBO Max Disney natural history psycho Ellie Kemper Election politics Apple TV Plus golden globes Pop Marathons video Heroines DC Universe based on movie Pirates Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FOX The Witch Fox News Emmy Nominations RT21 72 Emmy Awards Rock miniseries indiana jones casting SundanceTV Mary Tyler Moore Song of Ice and Fire Teen 2016 The Walking Dead Mary Poppins Returns Academy Awards Peacock Valentine's Day Nickelodeon Family Pop TV PlayStation GLAAD movies game of thrones witnail Tomatazos A24 Tarantino YouTube Women's History Month richard e. Grant game show Box Office TCM Trailer Funimation Video Games Countdown Anna Paquin ghosts RT History TCA Winter 2020 halloween hist stop motion CW Seed Awards cops disaster Paramount south america SDCC all-time Comedy Central Year in Review Endgame IFC anthology Food Network Holidays First Reviews Holiday comics movie Photos Toys indie Animation CNN CBS All Access what to watch Schedule Hulu Thanksgiving MSNBC independent spanish language Nominations streaming travel Star Trek romance PaleyFest scary movies Netflix TV Marvel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Super Bowl TBS versus WGN theme song Amazon Prime spy thriller Crackle Spring TV Kids & Family war Lucasfilm child's play San Diego Comic-Con Sundance USA Network serial killer Trophy Talk FX on Hulu FX award winner crime thriller diversity Mystery supernatural American Society of Cinematographers cooking Brie Larson Columbia Pictures kids Binge Guide documentary quibi Travel Channel Shudder E! comedies canceled TV shows toy story Avengers The Purge Horror Martial Arts slashers YouTube Red YouTube Premium Television Critics Association breaking bad Adult Swim spain CBS The CW science fiction Comedy Creative Arts Emmys free movies aliens social media Arrowverse Classic Film Oscars comic SXSW A&E GIFs joker YA Turner Disney streaming service best 007 45 Rom-Com Superheroes USA Elton John Cartoon Network Universal Hallmark Christmas movies zombie Certified Fresh BAFTA worst talk show mutant christmas movies reviews Calendar ABC Paramount Network Amazon Studios reboot Nat Geo zombies directors singing competition Reality screen actors guild Mary poppins DC streaming service Pet Sematary Freeform classics 20th Century Fox Black Mirror TCA 2017 satire AMC LGBT Western Mindy Kaling Premiere Dates finale Acorn TV VICE police drama 21st Century Fox Reality Competition NBC MTV dark Watching Series Fantasy Comic Book BBC One sequels medical drama ESPN Disney Channel sag awards 4/20 cancelled TV shows robots Amazon obituary nature Music Lifetime TNT Syfy Writers Guild of America cults vampires Musicals BBC America Ovation CMT Mudbound TIFF rotten TLC Tubi Walt Disney Pictures Action strong female leads festivals Apple cartoon APB Trivia sports laika Winners Vudu Country 71st Emmy Awards Shondaland cinemax GoT latino space Marvel Television PBS crossover Quiz jamie lee curtis VH1 critics Winter TV National Geographic Sneak Peek Sci-Fi anime Hear Us Out See It Skip It WarnerMedia 2015 video on demand universal monsters 2017 unscripted political drama Baby Yoda foreign Awards Tour cancelled television period drama cancelled TV series BET TCA Awards technology Pride Month dogs Film Festival nbcuniversal hollywood