Critics Consensus

Black Mass Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Scorch Trials lacks stong characters, and You're the Worst is Certified Fresh.

by | September 16, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a notorious mobster (Black Mass, starring Johnny Depp and Benedict Cumberbatch), teenage adventurers (Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials, starring Dylan O’Brien and Kaya Scodelario), and a desperate criminal (Captive, starring David Oyelowo and Kate Mara). What do the critics have to say?


Black Mass (2015) 73%

Black Mass isn’t the first feature film about brutal gangster-turned-slippery fugitive Whitey Bulger — he’s the subject of a critically-acclaimed documentary and the loose inspiration for Jack Nicholson’s character in The Departed. Critics say Black Mass explores well-trodden crime movie territory as well, but the film is elevated by Johnny Depp’s mesmerizing lead performance — and excellent work from a solid supporting cast. The movie follows Bulger’s rise from petty hood to violent mob boss; Whitey’s rise in Boston’s demimonde is assisted by FBI agent John Connolly (Joel Edgerton), who enlists him as a confidential informant, and his politician brother Billy (Benedict Cumberbatch), who uses his office  to protect him. The pundits say Black Mass often feels familiar, but it’s still a well-crafted film that finds Depp giving his best performance in years.


Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials (2015) 47%

As dystopian sci-fi adventure films based on young adult novels go, The Maze Runner was pretty solid, if decidedly a cut below The Hunger Games series. Unfortunately, critics say its sequel, The Scorch Trials, is mostly a run-of-the-mill action yarn with a few decent set pieces and little-to-no character development. This time out, our heroes, led by Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), have left the maze behind; instead, they must navigate harsh landscapes and avoid not just the evil WCKD but also hoards of zombies. The pundits say Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials is briskly paced and occasionally exciting, but its overabundance of  plotting makes for limited emotional involvement.


Captive (2015) 27%

Based on an astonishing true story, Captive recounts the tale of an escaped criminal (David Oyelowo) who takes a hostage (Kate Mara) and eventually surrenders after she encourages him to read the Christian self-help book The Purpose-Driven Life. Critics say Captive is enlivened by its excellent leads, but it never quite generates a necessary sense of tension.


What’s Hot on TV

You're the Worst: Season 2 (2015) 97%

Expertly balancing character growth against edgy humorYou’re the Worst elevates the show’s excellent writing and talented cast to a new level.


Project Greenlight: Season 4 (2015) 88%

Project Greenlight makes a welcome return, retaining many of the qualities that helped make it a reality TV favorite.


The Bastard Executioner: Season 1 (2015) 46%

Kurt Sutter’s The Bastard Executioner doesn’t want for dark thrills, but it unfortunately has more enthusiasm for brutality and gore than necessary narrative focus.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Peace Officer (2015) , a documentary about the increase in military weapons and tactics among police officers, is at 100 percent.
  • Sicario (2015) , starring Emily Blunt and Benicio Del Toro in a thriller about a straight-arrow FBI agent whose mission to bring down a drug cartel kingpin is compromised by her allies’ opaque motives, is at 91 percent.
  • The New Girlfriend (2015) , a psychological dramedy about a man whose gender fluidity comes to light after the death of his wife, is at 82 percent.
  • Prophet's Prey (2015) , a documentary about the abuses of power by the leader of a breakaway Mormon sect, is at 80 percent.
  • () , starring Chow Yun-Fat in a musical satire of the modern workplace, is at 80 percent.
  • Pawn Sacrifice (2015) , starring Tobey Maguire and Peter Sarsgaard in a fictional retelling of the famous showdown between chess masters Bobby Fischer and Boris Spassky, is at 76 percent.
  • Everest (2015) , starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Jason Clarke in an adventure film based on the true story of a group of climbers who were trapped in a blizzard while ascending the world’s tallest mountain, is at 71 percent.
  • Being Canadian (2015) , a documentary about the quirks and characteristics that define our neighbors to the North, is at 60 percent.
  • The Man Who Saved the World (2015) , a documentary about the Soviet Army colonel whose calm under pressure likely averted a nuclear war, is at 60 percent.
  • Some Kind of Hate (2015) , a horror film about a bullied teen who is protected by a vengeful ghost, is at 50 percent.
  • The Cut (2015) , a drama about a man who goes searching for his missing daughters after fighting in World War I, is at 40 percent.
  • Cooties (2015) , starring Elijah Wood and Rainn Wilson in a horror comedy about a group of teachers who fight to survive a plague of grade-school zombies, is at 37 percent.
  • Hellions (2015) , a horror film about a pregnant teenager bedeviled by malevolent trick-or-treaters, is at 31 percent.
  • Tenshi Ippikiookami

    Lots of options, even if some of them are only in limited. Autumn is here :D! I’m quite curious about Sicario and Pawn Sacrifice. Too bad the Maze Runner sequel seems to be a little bit of a letdown.

  • Gary the Dairy Fairy

    Black Mass is worth seeing for Depp’s performance alone. The movie as a whole is good, but not quite the masterpiece I was hoping it would be.

Tag Cloud

name the review BBC America teaser nature war MCU halloween stoner 2018 2019 miniseries Year in Review Sundance Now cars romantic comedy animated Ellie Kemper Alien TV Land game of thrones comic books Mary Poppins Returns docudrama joker robots spider-man Writers Guild of America best Paramount Comic Book E! Interview Holiday streaming Schedule Pixar IFC Films dogs crime Rom-Com Discovery Channel classics VICE ESPN Marvel Studios Emmy Nominations foreign Amazon Studios comics disaster Toys Tubi versus New York Comic Con Awards what to watch green book NBC 2020 aliens diversity critics 45 composers Stephen King OneApp fresh psychological thriller Comedy Central Quiz Esquire justice league Extras venice Tarantino Mystery Starz news cooking Women's History Month PlayStation Nat Geo CMT San Diego Comic-Con spinoff Chilling Adventures of Sabrina reviews toy story cults The Walking Dead Spring TV travel 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV shows Grammys scary movies Warner Bros. universal monsters Amazon stop motion E3 transformers werewolf cancelled television HBO Columbia Pictures Crunchyroll remakes australia American Society of Cinematographers finale Infographic Syfy Premiere Dates sequel Dark Horse Comics Apple TV+ crime drama GoT GLAAD Comedy Countdown Hallmark Christmas movies Winter TV natural history BET Awards First Reviews zombies TV renewals Turner Classic Movies Podcast revenge historical drama Reality Competition Polls and Games dceu police drama twilight Cannes cartoon festival Vudu child's play Star Trek Britbox RT History BBC Peacock kids tv talk FX on Hulu technology Disney streaming service fast and furious Sundance The Purge Photos a nightmare on elm street television cats SDCC Academy Awards Nominations Western X-Men CNN reboot Red Carpet Lifetime Christmas movies archives Amazon Prime Video screenings Sci-Fi blockbuster Hulu independent medical drama Freeform psycho BBC One chucky slashers Thanksgiving Ovation Chernobyl game show rotten movies we love binge A24 HBO Max video 4/20 true crime nbcuniversal Television Critics Association documentary politics TCA nfl Netflix Christmas movies video on demand YouTube Premium TLC unscripted Mudbound sag awards LGBT supernatural TCA 2017 blaxploitation Song of Ice and Fire Funimation Winners PaleyFest hollywood Pop movie TBS sequels Set visit laika Pride Month Trophy Talk Masterpiece based on movie vampires Lionsgate Star Wars TIFF spanish El Rey cancelled die hard YouTube WarnerMedia Heroines Sundance TV Anna Paquin zero dark thirty Musical anime FXX award winner TCA Winter 2020 Watching Series spain Binge Guide Animation james bond SXSW Pop TV ratings Fall TV Certified Fresh Classic Film Valentine's Day USA book Black History Month Walt Disney Pictures Comics on TV History criterion spanish language ITV Universal sports Film boxoffice cinemax RT21 24 frames Rock harry potter dragons CBS All Access directors OWN 2015 FOX Superheroes discovery mission: impossible Disney Channel Mary poppins documentaries rt archives Apple hispanic Baby Yoda superhero doctor who Logo GIFs Sneak Peek halloween tv south america canceled TV shows adaptation films Musicals NYCC FX dark TCM concert The Arrangement Biopics MTV ID Hear Us Out festivals free movies Showtime 99% parents Tomatazos crime thriller DirecTV BAFTA Election asian-american biography cancelled TV series Ghostbusters Action period drama Trivia anthology The Academy Shudder quibi Marvel strong female leads A&E Awards Tour Paramount Network Food Network golden globes Captain marvel rotten WGN comedies HBO Go comiccon latino sitcom romance canceled SundanceTV series dramedy Kids & Family talk show children's TV Bravo japanese LGBTQ DGA elevated horror ghosts spy thriller thriller Pet Sematary Black Mirror Travel Channel President BET Fox News all-time Country CW Seed Television Academy Hallmark 2016 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TNT Fantasy Spectrum Originals Netflix breaking bad MSNBC National Geographic franchise Cosplay The CW adventure space Marathons screen actors guild Adult Swim mutant serial killer Christmas Best and Worst Disney Lifetime Super Bowl facebook toronto The Witch YouTube Red Rocky Fox Searchlight italian Trailer zombie 2017 Music CBS YA theme song dc Rocketman Lucasfilm political drama First Look TruTV Character Guide 71st Emmy Awards ABC Mary Tyler Moore Elton John Sony Pictures DC Universe batman APB Martial Arts 20th Century Fox worst movies movies VOD social media Spike renewed TV shows Family scorecard PBS Acorn TV Teen black Horror USA Network Nickelodeon Turner Disney Plus Holidays Endgame Arrowverse Marvel Television mockumentary Disney+ Disney Plus hist 21st Century Fox Amazon Prime richard e. Grant indiana jones cops Tumblr witnail boxing VH1 christmas movies stand-up comedy crossover Superheroe Avengers indie Crackle Creative Arts Emmys Cartoon Network emmy awards AMC 007 Apple TV Plus Box Office See It Skip It ABC Family Reality IFC Brie Larson Epix Summer comic jamie lee curtis singing competition Calendar Film Festival deadpool science fiction TV Emmys Pirates Mindy Kaling Oscars worst DC streaming service Drama casting satire obituary DC Comics Video Games football Shondaland TCA Awards french Opinion