Critics Consensus

Black Mass Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Scorch Trials lacks stong characters, and You're the Worst is Certified Fresh.

by | September 16, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a notorious mobster (Black Mass, starring Johnny Depp and Benedict Cumberbatch), teenage adventurers (Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials, starring Dylan O’Brien and Kaya Scodelario), and a desperate criminal (Captive, starring David Oyelowo and Kate Mara). What do the critics have to say?

Black Mass (2015) 73%

Black Mass isn’t the first feature film about brutal gangster-turned-slippery fugitive Whitey Bulger — he’s the subject of a critically-acclaimed documentary and the loose inspiration for Jack Nicholson’s character in The Departed. Critics say Black Mass explores well-trodden crime movie territory as well, but the film is elevated by Johnny Depp’s mesmerizing lead performance — and excellent work from a solid supporting cast. The movie follows Bulger’s rise from petty hood to violent mob boss; Whitey’s rise in Boston’s demimonde is assisted by FBI agent John Connolly (Joel Edgerton), who enlists him as a confidential informant, and his politician brother Billy (Benedict Cumberbatch), who uses his office  to protect him. The pundits say Black Mass often feels familiar, but it’s still a well-crafted film that finds Depp giving his best performance in years.

Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials (2015) 48%

As dystopian sci-fi adventure films based on young adult novels go, The Maze Runner was pretty solid, if decidedly a cut below The Hunger Games series. Unfortunately, critics say its sequel, The Scorch Trials, is mostly a run-of-the-mill action yarn with a few decent set pieces and little-to-no character development. This time out, our heroes, led by Thomas (Dylan O’Brien), have left the maze behind; instead, they must navigate harsh landscapes and avoid not just the evil WCKD but also hoards of zombies. The pundits say Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials is briskly paced and occasionally exciting, but its overabundance of  plotting makes for limited emotional involvement.

Captive (2015) 27%

Based on an astonishing true story, Captive recounts the tale of an escaped criminal (David Oyelowo) who takes a hostage (Kate Mara) and eventually surrenders after she encourages him to read the Christian self-help book The Purpose-Driven Life. Critics say Captive is enlivened by its excellent leads, but it never quite generates a necessary sense of tension.

What’s Hot on TV

You're the Worst: Season 2 (2015) 97%

Expertly balancing character growth against edgy humorYou’re the Worst elevates the show’s excellent writing and talented cast to a new level.

Project Greenlight: Season 4 (2015) 88%

Project Greenlight makes a welcome return, retaining many of the qualities that helped make it a reality TV favorite.

The Bastard Executioner: Season 1 (2015) 46%

Kurt Sutter’s The Bastard Executioner doesn’t want for dark thrills, but it unfortunately has more enthusiasm for brutality and gore than necessary narrative focus.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Peace Officer (2015) , a documentary about the increase in military weapons and tactics among police officers, is at 100 percent.
  • Sicario (2015) , starring Emily Blunt and Benicio Del Toro in a thriller about a straight-arrow FBI agent whose mission to bring down a drug cartel kingpin is compromised by her allies’ opaque motives, is at 91 percent.
  • The New Girlfriend (2014) , a psychological dramedy about a man whose gender fluidity comes to light after the death of his wife, is at 82 percent.
  • Prophet's Prey (2015) , a documentary about the abuses of power by the leader of a breakaway Mormon sect, is at 80 percent.
  • () , starring Chow Yun-Fat in a musical satire of the modern workplace, is at 80 percent.
  • Pawn Sacrifice (2014) , starring Tobey Maguire and Peter Sarsgaard in a fictional retelling of the famous showdown between chess masters Bobby Fischer and Boris Spassky, is at 76 percent.
  • Everest (2015) , starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Jason Clarke in an adventure film based on the true story of a group of climbers who were trapped in a blizzard while ascending the world’s tallest mountain, is at 71 percent.
  • Being Canadian (2015) , a documentary about the quirks and characteristics that define our neighbors to the North, is at 60 percent.
  • The Man Who Saved the World (2014) , a documentary about the Soviet Army colonel whose calm under pressure likely averted a nuclear war, is at 60 percent.
  • Some Kind of Hate (2015) , a horror film about a bullied teen who is protected by a vengeful ghost, is at 50 percent.
  • The Cut (2014) , a drama about a man who goes searching for his missing daughters after fighting in World War I, is at 40 percent.
  • Cooties (2014) , starring Elijah Wood and Rainn Wilson in a horror comedy about a group of teachers who fight to survive a plague of grade-school zombies, is at 37 percent.
  • Hellions (2015) , a horror film about a pregnant teenager bedeviled by malevolent trick-or-treaters, is at 31 percent.

Tag Cloud

YA Infographic hidden camera scorecard Classic Film doctor who Turner Classic Movies laika Spike Pixar SXSW 2022 Spring TV Valentine's Day Cartoon Network Neflix Lifetime Christmas movies singing competition TV Land international Nat Geo latino Universal golden globe awards critics RT21 Thanksgiving japan dceu critic resources technology Syfy Discovery Channel FX on Hulu twilight X-Men Mary Tyler Moore PaleyFest Fall TV witnail streamig Amazon Prime Comedy Sundance Now The CW Mindy Kaling canceled TV shows adventure breaking bad dramedy new star wars movies crime thriller basketball criterion werewolf Quiz emmy awards Academy Awards sag awards NBA OWN green book First Look live action Pop TV rom-coms Kids & Family Extras nfl Epix italian Disney Channel serial killer marvel cinematic universe superhero CNN rotten Best Actress travel TBS Star Trek Chilling Adventures of Sabrina space South by Southwest Film Festival godzilla Women's History Month Starz Prime Video The Arrangement movie screenings DC Comics YouTube popular dc Winners Tokyo Olympics FXX young adult Mary Poppins Returns composers universal monsters TCA 2017 WarnerMedia disaster zombie mockumentary Paramount Network Amazon Studios comic books sitcom crime drama Horror video on demand Marvel Television Travel Channel PlayStation Britbox teaser comiccon gangster indiana jones black comedy Nickelodeon zombies free movies Film diversity suspense debate classics Best and Worst Tubi NYCC Sci-Fi hist royal family The Academy FX ViacomCBS streaming New York Comic Con films Hulu 99% social media dragons IMDb TV richard e. Grant slasher Disney+ Disney Plus mcc Fox Searchlight Song of Ice and Fire cinemax Marvel Fantasy war San Diego Comic-Con game of thrones robots CMT strong female leads Alien science fiction japanese kong Opinion dark historical drama TCA indie 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Podcast comic book movies book Character Guide Box Office ABC christmas movies spain Spectrum Originals TV movies golden globes justice league Avengers obi wan 2021 wonder woman Tarantino Calendar Teen Warner Bros. ratings Walt Disney Pictures festival a nightmare on elm street Year in Review Awards renewed TV shows Pacific Islander movies anthology Photos BAFTA YouTube Red Netflix Toys Video Games GoT SundanceTV Best Director Endgame all-time NBC reviews Heroines hispanic heritage month medical drama die hard 1990s superman joker parents reboot Interview fresh 94th Oscars quibi Martial Arts saw Hallmark TCA Winter 2020 stop motion Pet Sematary BET Awards transformers Awards Tour batman Cannes ghosts aliens scene in color Summer MGM Lifetime directors ABC Signature Chernobyl BBC telelvision MCU LGBT south america live event Paramount worst rt labs critics edition TV screen actors guild Action know your critic The Witch tv talk casting History cops Comedy Central Musicals Christmas halloween tv Drama Pirates jamie lee curtis Pop Rocky HBO Go comic Holidays rt labs blaxploitation Freeform cancelled TV series king arthur Television Academy football sequel dogs trophy Animation cancelled television 90s ABC Family PBS mob remakes Lionsgate Rock 2015 TCM summer TV book adaptation Oscars halloween archives razzies El Rey stoner docuseries TCA Awards MTV The Purge versus target psycho Mary poppins Esquire Superheroe SXSW Columbia Pictures Dark Horse Comics 71st Emmy Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards Tags: Comedy revenge name the review jurassic park Biopics spy thriller chucky summer TV preview 24 frames Peacock 93rd Oscars Black History Month A&E CBS vs. documentary Disney streaming service Amazon E! Showtime The Walking Dead IFC Premiere Dates children's TV cancelled TV shows heist movie comedies Ovation Trivia game show streaming movies Comic Book Super Bowl Certified Fresh spanish Crackle political drama Trophy Talk fast and furious feel good worst movies cults TruTV what to watch nature TV One obituary GIFs ESPN award winner Ellie Kemper elevated horror USA Network new zealand Apple TV Plus Cosplay australia Funimation zero dark thirty spider-verse Sundance TV CBS All Access true crime HBO television Disney binge animated AMC Plus cartoon APB cancelled black Arrowverse child's play independent Holiday HFPA dreamworks pirates of the caribbean scary movies posters mutant Paramount Plus cats Food Network vampires Sneak Peek Disney Plus Elton John monster movies sports CW Seed Red Carpet The Walt Disney Company DGA Crunchyroll Reality Image Comics hollywood Turner canceled discovery nbcuniversal police drama Creative Arts Emmys SDCC Baby Yoda DirecTV psychological thriller slashers Rom-Com Grammys Nominations Tomatazos Lucasfilm legend Set visit Rocketman Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel Studios thriller Trailer Oscar BBC America mission: impossible 007 Sony Pictures American Society of Cinematographers Shudder comic book movie Broadway MSNBC based on movie 45 LGBTQ FOX Election festivals french See It Skip It VOD Western GLAAD romantic comedy aapi Shondaland Exclusive Video Musical sopranos Film Festival politics natural history First Reviews harry potter supernatural lord of the rings adenture franchise rt archives Music miniseries Country blockbusters Fargo comics Ghostbusters Superheroes Emmys National Geographic Apple DC streaming service spider-man Pride Month 72 Emmy Awards news AMC Black Mirror Instagram Live action-comedy 2019 docudrama OneApp Sundance boxoffice 2016 foreign biography Logo Star Wars YouTube Premium Schedule facebook new york USA period drama sequels crime VICE venice HBO Max Mystery concert finale Legendary romance Wes Anderson talk show biopic satire Best Actor Acorn TV unscripted asian-american prank Winter TV adaptation TV renewals Best Picture Brie Larson Amazon Prime Video ITV kaiju art house 73rd Emmy Awards Hear Us Out Netflix Christmas movies ID dexter Television Critics Association Writers Guild of America Watching Series VH1 olympics Family Hollywood Foreign Press Association Universal Pictures hispanic toy story BBC One theme song Fox News spinoff crossover Marathons Apple TV+ Binge Guide 20th Century Fox kids Bravo WGN Polls and Games Emmy Nominations series 2020 Comic-Con@Home 2021 TNT TLC Reality Competition Comics on TV high school leaderboard Vudu documentaries Captain marvel marvel comics E3 BET stand-up comedy DC Universe Masterpiece President A24 toronto trailers genre women Stephen King king kong TIFF Adult Swim video boxing 4/20 Tumblr rotten movies we love cooking spanish language anime RT History Countdown Anna Paquin james bond Mudbound deadpool blockbuster 2017 21st Century Fox Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt best cars IFC Films summer preview 2018 scary