Alex Garland on Devs, Free Will, and Science Fiction Television

The Ex Machina director gives us a tour of his twisty new FX on Hulu series, starring Sonoya Mizuno and Nick Offerman.

by | March 4, 2020 | Comments

When Devs debuts as part of FX on Hulu, it will introduce viewers to a bevy of science concepts like quantum computing and the deterministic model of the universe. It will also introduce a Silicon Valley where trade secrets are protected with ruthless efficiency. The program is the product of writer-director Alex Garland, who spent the last several years mapping out the limited series.

As the director of Certified Fresh films Ex Machina, which he also wrote, and Annihilation — to say nothing of his screenplays for films like Sunshine — Garland has emerged as one of the major voices of 21st century science fiction film (and now television). And even though our world increasingly resembles the one theorized by the major science fiction films of the 20th century, Garland told Rotten Tomatoes the role of science fiction is “exactly” the same in the hyper-connected world of 2020 as it was 40 years ago and even earlier.

DEVS - Pictured: Alex Garland. CR: Miya Mizuno/FX

(Photo by Miya Mizuno/FX)

“It’s a very good, and actually quite comfortable, way of holding a mirror up to something which is contemporary. Because if you hold a mirror up exactly to the thing that is contemporary, people find themselves reacting to the argument that’s being made [as] they would if they were to find someone having argued about contemporary politics,” he said.

Where more direct critiques of current issues may bristle against a viewer or reader’s established views, science fiction still offers a “gentler way into that argument” whether it is The Time Machine’s critique of Victorian values, Star Trek’s use of aliens to discuss race relations or the way Devs looks at the billionaire class.

But do not expect the show to be a screed against tech giants who often seem to have more money than empathy. Instead, viewers will quickly find Forest (Nick Offerman) a disarming, human presence as he introduces Sergei (Karl Glusman) to the secretive Devs team within the show’s fictional tech company, Amaya. In fact, Garland said Offerman’s own natural warmth was key to making Forest work.

“He also has something else which is something soulful, I think. You could even in some ways describe it as melancholic,” he added.

Although, he said, that sense of melancholy was something Offerman found within Forest: “It felt like a perfect, natural fit. Nick is a kind man, and that kindness comes through in the character.”

Granted, as viewers will quickly see, Forest’s warmth is tinged with a willingness to protect the secret of Devs at any cost.

“And so, if you create a character who’s been extremely morally problematic and then you have a kind, and warm, and empathetic person carry that role, you get a sort of weird and interesting dissonance,” he said.

That dissonance will certainly form one of the questions viewers of Devs will be asking by the end of its first hour.

Another question to be asked: Is the universe deterministic? In that theory of existence, every action is prescribed, and a person’s choices are only an illusion. It is the model Forest himself espouses even as Sergei offers a multiversal answer — which allows for free will — to a problem his team addresses early in the series. Both concepts have been the playthings of science fiction for decades, but Devs makes them the purview of a tech company mindset that many will find quite familiar thanks to the ascent of Google and Apple. And though the ideas may become more approachable within the context of the series, Garland thinks most people react to the concepts in the same way.

“[They] actually find it, firstly, preposterous, and, secondly, unsettling. They don’t like the idea of multiple universes, because it stops them having primacy. What the Many-Worlds Theory really does, it says that each of the universes that exist — if they do exist — essentially has equal status to all of the other ones. So, there isn’t a main universe and then a bunch of branches, there’s just a very large number of coexisting universes. And people tend not to like theories that make them too small, I suppose.”

It is a reaction which speaks to one of the central conflicts in Devs: what Garland called “our intuitive sense in conflict with the data.”

“Quite aside from Many-Worlds, the data makes it very clear the universe is absolutely massive; close to unimaginably huge. And that’s now beyond any real doubt, because it could be proven in various sorts of ways,” he said. “And that is in conflict with people’s own experience of the world, where they are much more at the center of the universe and occupying quite a big space within the universe. You know, then [there’s] their family, their friends, their job, and, in a way, the more they lose proximity with these bonds, the smaller they feel.”

Nevertheless, Garland noted conversations moving from the possibility of a mulitverse where free will exists to a deterministic view where there is no choice elicits an equally strong emotional response.

“If I have a conversation with people about free will, nobody likes the idea that they don’t have it. And it is completely in contradiction with our own sense — ‘But I absolutely, definitely have free will. I can feel it now,’ [they say], which is… again, it’s what people feel, but it may not be supported by the data.”

That view, as espoused by Forest, leads Devs’ main character, Lily Chan (Sonoya Mizuno), onto her collision course with the warm and melancholy Amaya CEO. And while discussing Lilly’s actions would lead to a level of spoilers we definitely cannot reveal in this or any other reality, it did lead to another question the show presents: Do ethics exist in a deterministic universe?

“I don’t personally think it takes ethics and morality out of the conversation, I just think it means you react differently to the state of affairs,” Garland said.

DEVS -- Pictured: Nick Offerman as Forest. CR: Miya Mizuno/FX

(Photo by Miya Mizuno/FX)

To illustrate morality in a deterministic universe, he used a 15-year-old boy mugging someone at knife point as an example. In a universe with free will, the boy’s punishment (provided he is caught) proceeds from the notion he is in absolute control of his choices.

“If you take deterministic view, you might say, ‘Well, hang on a minute. Because this kid is a crystal meth addict, and both his parents were crystal meth addicts, and he was addicted by the time he was 12, and he was trapped in a world that had given him a very distorted sense of ethics, and, as well as that, a sense of desperation, and no home, that led ultimately to the mugging.’ Under those circumstances, punishing the kid makes much less sense. Rehabilitating a kid makes much more sense.”

“What we do then is make sure that [the kid doesn’t] do it again,” Garland suggested. “So, that doesn’t remove the ethics, because you still don’t want the kid to mug anybody. It’s just more that you’re not punishing him for something that wasn’t his own decision.”

Of course, Garland was quick to point out that while his example leads to a morality with more empathy and compassion, it also suggests atrocities are also unavoidable in a deterministic universe. “I don’t think anybody wants to let Adolf Hitler off the hook in the way that you might let a 15-year-old off the hook,” he quipped.

Nonetheless, the morality of what Forest calls “tram lines” will no doubt feature in discussions of Devs when its full shape is revealed with the show’s finale six weeks from now.

Part of that shape, though, is the modernist, mid-20th-century-style Amaya campus, shot partially at UC Santa Cruz and the University of Manchester. The style branches out of the campus and into the way much of the series is shot. To Garland, that style is a great container for science fiction stories because of its “utilitarian” essence.

“By looking at the [modernist] structure, you understand something about why it was built and how it was built. It’s less concerned with the kind of a flamboyance that you might get in a Victorian or Edwardian period church, which is trying to proclaim something about itself, and is not exactly utilitarian. Or for that matter, elaborate science fiction citadels with gleaming spires or whatever it happens to be.” Instead, the modernist feel has “this sort of blunt quality that I like, it’s sort of arresting.”

While Devs represents Garland’s first television work, he said he would consider telling other science fiction stories in the film format.

“I personally cannot imagine how I would tell this particular story within two hours,” he said. “The things I wanted to do — or was hoping to do with the characters — and with the narrative, would have just felt incredibly crudely crunched together if it was two hours.”

DEVS -- Pictured: Sonoya Mizuno as Lily. CR: Miya Mizuno/FX

(Photo by Miya Mizuno/FX)

But, he added, “there are other spaces” film offers even if there is the implicit expectation of action.

“I think films often have to be a bit more ‘sugar rushing.’ Film is so much… I mean, it doesn’t have to be, but it tends to lean towards urgency and economy, and I guess that then leads people towards action sequences,” he explained.

For Devs, he needed television’s acceptance of people “talking in rooms” to fully realize characters like Lilly, Forest, and Kenton (Zach Grenier), Amaya’s dedicated chief of security, to his satisfaction. At the same time he agreed “there are so many great science fiction films” and an idea more suited to film could appear at any moment. “It would certainly depend on the narrative,” he added.

As for Devs narrative, Garland said he hoped to “give a very fair account of the world” within a science fiction context “by trying to be fair about the idea to do with physics that it contains, and also the way we interact with each other.” The series, in his mind, is really full of partnerships and “the sort of good people who love each other to one extent or another, as colleagues, or friends, or partners, or parents.”

“Its intention is not to be removed, its attempt is to be connected, and I hope that’s ultimately how it comes across,” he added.

For this writer, Devs definitely connected in no small part because of the weird synchronicity of sharing a last name with Forest’s company.

“It must be kind of weird to see that suddenly you’re the head of the corporation that does quantum computing,” Garland quipped when he noted the connection.

As it happens, the name was chosen because the girl who plays its enigmatic face is also named Amaya: Amaya Mizuno-Andre. Often Japanese in origin, the name also appears to enter the Romance languages from the Basque Country — though opinions do differ — where it translates from Euskera into English as “the beginning of the end” or simply “the end.”

“Oh my God, that is hilarious!” Garland said upon hearing about the Basque origin. “That was completely unintentional.”

Devs launches on Thursday, March 5 on FX on Hulu.

Tag Cloud

binge Sony Pictures criterion El Rey based on movie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DC Comics Anna Paquin Food Network scene in color Shondaland USA Marvel Television E! comedies Comic-Con@Home 2021 nbcuniversal IFC Films HBO Max sports crime Music Fantasy Television Critics Association japan docuseries streaming movies Freeform australia SXSW crime thriller 24 frames zombie indie Comic Book Mary Poppins Returns space 73rd Emmy Awards jurassic park aapi GLAAD APB Ovation war Animation hispanic heritage month New York Comic Con USA Network BAFTA Dark Horse Comics Showtime breaking bad crime drama The Witch History robots twilight Rocketman japanese American Society of Cinematographers First Look prank toy story Acorn TV period drama rt labs ViacomCBS animated trailers dogs ratings indiana jones hist Trivia black know your critic Women's History Month halloween tv comic book movie WGN The Walking Dead Hear Us Out video Superheroes Alien casting Musical richard e. Grant dragons rt labs critics edition Esquire hispanic cults romance cops serial killer a nightmare on elm street new star wars movies Mary poppins cancelled TV series popular boxing festival Amazon Rom-Com Character Guide doctor who diversity Reality Competition Wes Anderson Premiere Dates Cosplay TBS fresh Exclusive Video Comics on TV TV Tumblr basketball San Diego Comic-Con Marvel Studios 99% Western 2020 rotten stop motion PlayStation Lifetime harry potter women batman Television Academy live action Epix Walt Disney Pictures teaser NYCC VOD Hallmark Christmas movies E3 cars stand-up comedy medical drama 2015 2018 Ellie Kemper Bravo blaxploitation Emmy Nominations Discovery Channel foreign blockbusters kids sag awards mockumentary spain legend TLC Holidays 2019 Pet Sematary laika FXX nfl Podcast video on demand Trophy Talk Creative Arts Emmys HBO Go nature comics posters joker Infographic emmy awards SDCC kaiju natural history Certified Fresh Schedule Biopics sitcom jamie lee curtis award winner Paramount Plus lord of the rings Teen Peacock Election TCM superman Funimation latino Cannes rotten movies we love MSNBC wonder woman feel good mutant Horror dark transformers dceu 20th Century Fox Lifetime Christmas movies Quiz saw Black History Month royal family 45 Academy Awards renewed TV shows halloween PaleyFest Countdown south america franchise monster movies godzilla Grammys psychological thriller stoner Heroines Tubi Image Comics Legendary dexter miniseries DC Universe chucky Fox Searchlight YouTube Masterpiece FX on Hulu Stephen King The Arrangement james bond HBO Pop TV screen actors guild Sundance Best and Worst singing competition Netflix Cartoon Network TruTV 2016 french sequels 007 cinemax italian ABC Signature LGBT international A24 Broadway RT History archives critics canceled TV shows Nominations book adaptation DC streaming service Disney Channel TCA Winter 2020 worst Thanksgiving WarnerMedia anthology elevated horror Britbox First Reviews Hulu christmas movies TCA new zealand biography remakes book OneApp vampires adaptation series Pride Month TV movies movies TIFF slashers Disney Plus heist movie zero dark thirty zombies ABC movie independent Mindy Kaling Nickelodeon Calendar Starz Reality 4/20 reviews Film Festival CNN Opinion supernatural Binge Guide Tarantino Amazon Prime Nat Geo king kong golden globes TV Land deadpool BET theme song Chernobyl high school OWN scary movies television President golden globe awards aliens Mystery Lucasfilm See It Skip It PBS Captain marvel Family Superheroe Toys TCA 2017 Comedy telelvision DGA Watching Series Country anime The Purge cartoon BBC America spider-man National Geographic facebook ITV free movies Apple TV+ finale canceled Holiday NBC Paramount CMT comic book movies comiccon 21st Century Fox Columbia Pictures witnail spy thriller romantic comedy Year in Review Travel Channel rt archives Hallmark Spectrum Originals Vudu Spring TV TV One BBC Ghostbusters Polls and Games biopic Apple TV Plus VH1 target Rock FOX adventure GoT Crackle cooking The CW A&E Trailer RT21 Turner Classic Movies NBA game of thrones Disney streaming service 2021 boxoffice hidden camera Warner Bros. CBS historical drama ESPN debate Baby Yoda Arrowverse comic scorecard reboot unscripted Song of Ice and Fire Pixar Pop Valentine's Day ABC Family marvel cinematic universe SundanceTV Disney Sundance TV The Academy thriller universal monsters Comedy Central concert cancelled television versus CBS All Access Logo slasher obituary hollywood Marvel parents Writers Guild of America screenings Fall TV talk show festivals 72 Emmy Awards venice disaster Star Wars Lionsgate Box Office composers Elton John what to watch VICE Sneak Peek revenge Amazon Studios Summer Tomatazos Tokyo Olympics razzies CW Seed sequel new york documentary werewolf classics ID Oscars strong female leads critic resources olympics YouTube Red Red Carpet name the review Pirates justice league fast and furious Amazon Prime Video mcc dramedy Mudbound Marathons die hard Star Trek Apple Winter TV Super Bowl Kids & Family worst movies Awards Tour best asian-american films marvel comics TCA Awards 71st Emmy Awards politics Action quibi Netflix Christmas movies LGBTQ 90s Syfy TNT spanish YouTube Premium Winners TV renewals suspense dc Extras gangster Musicals news Spike green book X-Men spanish language kong Paramount Network AMC cancelled satire Avengers Martial Arts Black Mirror Adult Swim Mary Tyler Moore action-comedy documentaries Sundance Now 2017 travel BBC One science fiction rom-coms BET Awards Turner true crime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina child's play Christmas comic books Awards game show Set visit Interview Brie Larson 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards discovery children's TV spinoff Shudder GIFs blockbuster Universal Film Rocky The Walt Disney Company ghosts adenture king arthur MCU superhero MTV football Emmys Crunchyroll social media IFC cancelled TV shows mission: impossible DirecTV Drama 93rd Oscars Sci-Fi Photos technology Video Games docudrama 1990s Endgame Classic Film tv talk all-time Pacific Islander YA directors crossover political drama police drama pirates of the caribbean Fox News psycho streaming toronto Disney+ Disney Plus cats young adult FX