Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Taken Is A Near Miss

Plus, The Uninvited is so-so, and New in Town is unwelcome.

by | January 29, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a kidnapping plot (Taken, starring Liam Neeson and Famke Janssen); haunted teens (The Uninvited, starring Emily Browning and Elizabeth Banks); and cold comfort (New in Town, starring Renee Zellweger and Harry Connick Jr.). What do the critics have to say?



Taken is an action flick that’s both efficient and absurd, critics say, and so it’s often entertaining — but only up to a point. The film stars Liam Neeson as a retired CIA agent who learns his daughter has been abducted in Paris; upon receiving a frantic phone call from her, he tracks her down — and finds himself on the trail of a massive criminal enterprise. The pundits say Taken is a sprightly piece of work, and Neeson is compelling in the lead role, but the film is weighted down by contrivances and leaps in logic.


The Uninvited

Another Asian horror remake getting released in January? While the critics say The Uninvited may not live up to the standard set by its source material (2003’s A Tale of Two Sisters), it’s a reasonably involving thriller– though not an entirely successful one. Emily Browning plays a young woman with a history of mental problems who, upon meeting her father’s new fiancée (Elizabeth Banks), is immediately suspicious; creepy goings-on ensue. The pundits say The Uninvited is moody and well acted, but it also contains plenty of haunted house conventions and telegraphed plot twists.


New in Town

It may be cold in Minnesota this time of year, but that’s nothing compared to the chilly reception the critics have given New in Town. In this fish-out-of-water romantic comedy, Renee Zellweger stars as a hotshot executive who’s sent to the Land of 10,000 Lakes to oversee layoffs at one of her company’s factories; there, she falls for the local union rep (Harry Connick Jr.) and learns about the strange customs of small-town Americans. The pundits say New in Town‘s timely premise and winning leads are no match for the film’s weather-beaten, clichéd script, which tries way too hard to be uplifting.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Medicine for Melancholy, a stylish, nuanced tale of two Bay Area hipsters in love, is at 94 percent.
  • The Filipino import Serbis, a documentary that examines at the root causes of the long-running gang war, is at 90 percent.
  • Shadows, about a young man who survives a car crash only to be confronted by ghostly visions, is at 57 percent.
  • Blessed Is the Match: The Life and Death of Hannah Senesh, a documentary about the famed poet and resistance fighter who attempted to free imprisoned Jews in World War II, is at 50 percent.
  • The Toe Tactic, a live action/animated hybrid about a young woman dealing with the death of her father, is at 43 percent.

Finally, props to AnthonyDidge, who came the closest to guessing Underworld: Rise of the Lycans‘ 34 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

CMT 73rd Emmy Awards The Walking Dead Image Comics hist TV One Thanksgiving Marvel Studios satire popular Music Disney laika a nightmare on elm street thriller strong female leads mission: impossible Peacock 99% documentaries aliens cancelled TV shows doctor who crossover Neflix Apple TV Plus spider-verse Cartoon Network archives deadpool Bravo Super Bowl E3 renewed TV shows live action Grammys Heroines Family Sundance TV Animation boxing child's play Box Office Turner cancelled television Shondaland Awards President FX on Hulu fast and furious rt archives Hear Us Out ViacomCBS scorecard gangster Focus Features Ellie Kemper lord of the rings Kids & Family RT21 Alien social media TV Land parents die hard jurassic park period drama HBO new star wars movies zombies Food Network Sundance Now docuseries Paramount Plus Toys First Look The Purge Academy Awards richard e. Grant Writers Guild of America CW Seed DC Comics Superheroe Masterpiece Stephen King fresh Dark Horse Comics olympics 90s Star Wars teaser target 2015 Columbia Pictures new york Election Martial Arts dogs Christmas The Academy comics TCA screenings boxoffice sequel breaking bad Winter TV hollywood A&E miniseries Video Games critic resources golden globe awards WGN cars Binge Guide japanese video on demand Acorn TV directors documentary The Witch PBS razzies Universal Pictures new zealand spanish language hidden camera Best and Worst Fall TV Mary poppins Holidays 71st Emmy Awards Pacific Islander Rock revenge Set visit DGA Spike BBC America 79th Golden Globes Awards Paramount Network Netflix Turner Classic Movies 45 South by Southwest Film Festival 94th Oscars sag awards Trophy Talk Amazon Best Actor TNT LGBTQ Red Carpet medical drama TLC Hallmark Christmas movies Vudu finale Prime Video A24 Calendar Biopics zero dark thirty Premiere Dates black children's TV Avengers streaming OWN Certified Fresh 24 frames binge Funimation SXSW Rocketman werewolf Polls and Games rotten movies we love ABC Tomatazos psycho LGBT romantic comedy Tokyo Olympics spain rotten Marvel Netflix Christmas movies dragons best kaiju king arthur Walt Disney Pictures sequels 4/20 Television Critics Association docudrama Syfy blockbusters trophy 93rd Oscars blaxploitation hispanic police drama leaderboard VICE Endgame what to watch basketball rt labs Valentine's Day BBC superhero Wes Anderson Starz news rom-coms Universal Marvel Television scene in color film series 2016 classics cops Star Wars Celebration Infographic Fargo based on movie venice Apple facebook Pride Month james bond political drama halloween tv Rocky rt labs critics edition kids X-Men Oscar genre Brie Larson Horror summer preview GLAAD adenture indiana jones Hulu stop motion Podcast vampires live event HFPA 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Lifetime comic books obi wan Freeform ABC Family Photos franchise Geeked Week 007 movies slasher obituary screen actors guild BAFTA serial killer sports 2020 Mindy Kaling Countdown dceu Arrowverse Classic Film war comic Epix AMC spy thriller casting scary ratings Best Picture Nat Geo Broadway pirates of the caribbean Legendary mcc Fantasy Musical Esquire 2021 batman debate italian universal monsters HBO Go Paramount Pictures toronto cats HBO Max MGM FXX Tarantino cooking Elton John Captain marvel comic book movies First Reviews criterion adventure DirecTV christmas movies international Disney Plus FOX YouTube Premium vs. IMDb TV SXSW 2022 Lionsgate Lucasfilm mutant animated Black Mirror sopranos cults kong politics streamig elevated horror BET Awards Crunchyroll trailers tv talk nfl Tags: Comedy YouTube Red streaming movies ITV dreamworks hispanic heritage month Winners Cannes cancelled supernatural NBA Britbox Musicals Women's History Month remakes suspense YouTube saw broadcast Native wonder woman GoT talk show godzilla Amazon Studios Ovation DC streaming service crime drama concert nature Mary Tyler Moore Opinion USA golden globes worst Action Pixar cartoon movie summer TV preview marvel cinematic universe Country Nickelodeon dark joker feel good reboot TV indie NYCC Schedule Indigenous ESPN art house SundanceTV slashers Film Festival SDCC diversity Western MCU Logo Hallmark anthology unscripted Drama comedies book The Arrangement adaptation game show Watching Series science fiction historical drama Sci-Fi anime japan women Crackle travel all-time prank History Comics on TV Fox Searchlight telelvision scary movies heist movie Ghostbusters emmy awards cinemax romance dexter asian-american Holiday canceled TV shows disaster festival Mudbound Summer independent Best Director ID Comic-Con@Home 2021 psychological thriller Black History Month justice league television IFC game of thrones true crime Exclusive Video Extras Disney Channel comiccon TV renewals series Comic Book Marathons NBC zombie Sony Pictures space CNN jamie lee curtis technology PlayStation target scene in color CBS crime The Walt Disney Company Adult Swim reviews Amazon Prime MSNBC blockbuster aapi Lifetime Christmas movies Superheroes 21st Century Fox Quiz halloween Pirates Disney streaming service Year in Review toy story spinoff Interview king kong Comedy Central sitcom BET scene in color series Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt black comedy FX south america Discovery Channel Mystery marvel comics Hollywood Foreign Press Association VOD monster movies Trivia royal family Tubi chucky RT History DC Universe worst movies 20th Century Fox Fox News Sundance young adult Star Trek Sony Emmys 2017 Showtime Pet Sematary spanish robots See It Skip It football foreign Amazon Prime Video PaleyFest American Society of Cinematographers Disney+ Disney Plus comic book movie Song of Ice and Fire Paramount TBS award winner 2018 Travel Channel Nominations YA critics canceled theme song spider-man festivals australia USA Network OneApp Television Academy IFC Films Baby Yoda Spring TV mob high school nbcuniversal Oscars El Rey Sneak Peek TIFF Best Actress Reality Competition San Diego Comic-Con summer TV transformers dc book adaptation CBS All Access singing competition stoner The CW Reality Teen Warner Bros. VH1 Character Guide Mary Poppins Returns Trailer action-comedy name the review National Geographic WarnerMedia twilight free movies Pop TV latino Spectrum Originals Creative Arts Emmys harry potter 2019 TV movies interviews posters composers Emmy Nominations cancelled TV series ghosts quibi french dramedy legend Instagram Live Awards Tour witnail New York Comic Con MTV Anna Paquin ABC Signature E! video scene in color Rom-Com Chernobyl 1990s versus crime thriller 72 Emmy Awards green book mockumentary TCM Film natural history films TCA 2017 know your critic discovery stand-up comedy TruTV Cosplay Shudder Pop TCA Awards AMC Plus GIFs APB BBC One TCA Winter 2020 Tumblr superman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Apple TV+ biography biopic Comedy