Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Mr. Peabody & Sherman is a Blast From the Past

Plus, 300: Rise of an Empire is a good looking but empty spectacle.

by | March 6, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a dog and his boy (Mr. Peabody & Sherman, with voice performances by Ty Burrell and Stephen Colbert) and some raging Spartans (300: Rise of an Empire, starring Sullivan Stapleton and Eva Green). What do the critics have to say?

Mr. Peabody & Sherman


It’s never easy to stretch a series of shorts to feature-film length, especially when the source material is largely unfamiliar to its intended audience. Fortunately, critics say Mr. Peabody & Sherman is a mostly successful big screen adaptation, with enough cleverness and goofy action to please kids and their parents. Canine genius Mr. Peabody (voiced by Ty Burrell) and his adopted charge Sherman (Max Charles) use the WABAC machine to travel back in time and ensure that history’s greatest moments happen as they should. However, when Sherman takes the machine for a joyride to impress a classmate, it’s up to his doggie guardian to rescue him. The critics say Mr. Peabody & Sherman sometimes strains to maintain the inspired lunacy of the original cartoons, but most of the time, it’s bright, funny, exciting, and heartfelt. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some memorable time travel movies, as well as our interviews with the cast.)

300: Rise of an Empire


If you’re in the mood stylized bloodshed, you’re in luck: 300: Rise of an Empire is chock full of beheadings, hacked-off limbs, and gallons of blood. But critics say beyond its admittedly impressive visuals, the film is short on the heroic bombast of its predecessor. This time out, it’s a band of plucky seafaring Greeks, lead by Themistokles (Sullivan Stapleton) against the mighty Persian navy, headed by Artemisia (Eva Green); as we eventually learn through a series of flashbacks, this fight is partially driven by personal animosity. The pundits say Green is fantastic as a bellicose she-devil, but little resonates in 300: Rise of an Empire beyond the lovingly rendered killings and decapitations. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of big stars in togas.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Miele, a drama about a woman who secretly helps people with terminal illnesses to die on their own terms, is at 100 percent.
  • Particle Fever, a documentary about the physicists working to find the Higgs boson particle, is at 92 percent.
  • In Fear, a thriller about a couple that gets lost en route to a would-be romantic getaway, is at 90 percent.
  • Journey To The West, Stephen Chow‘s adaptation of the classic Chinese novel about a Buddhist monk’s epic excursion from China to India, is at 90 percent.
  • Wes Anderson‘s The Grand Budapest Hotel, starring Ralph Fiennes and Saoirse Ronan in a period comedy about the adventures of a concierge and the oddball inhabitants of an ornate hotel, is Certified Fresh at 86 percent.
  • Grand Piano, starring Elijah Wood and John Cusack in a thriller about a concert pianist who must deliver a flawless performance to stave off a sniper, is at 82 percent.
  • Bethlehem, a drama about the tense relationship between an Israeli Secret Service officer and a Palestinian informant, is at 65 percent.
  • The Face of Love, starring Annette Bening and Ed Harris in a drama about a widow who meets a man who’s the spitting image of her dead husband, is at 53 percent.
  • Haunt, a horror film about a family that moves into an old house and stirs a malevolent curse, is at 20 percent.

Tag Cloud

television Polls and Games RT21 Discovery Channel Walt Disney Pictures Emmys GoT Wes Anderson parents Travel Channel CBS All Access indie worst Brie Larson spider-verse Cartoon Network hispanic Adult Swim fresh news TV renewals streaming superhero HBO Max ghosts FX on Hulu President universal monsters SXSW nbcuniversal zombie E3 Ellie Kemper anthology Amazon toy story Fall TV Britbox hidden camera Superheroe finale Turner Classic Movies comics Exclusive Video Sci-Fi casting WGN supernatural rt labs critics edition legend New York Comic Con Starz TCA joker kids telelvision classics TIFF The Witch biography witnail harry potter kong Funimation Writers Guild of America Apple TV Plus The Academy rt archives comic CNN Christmas japan Disney Plus Nominations APB cooking comic book movies pirates of the caribbean Box Office YouTube Red 21st Century Fox teaser First Reviews Countdown OneApp Spike documentary razzies Epix ViacomCBS WarnerMedia Interview Fox News AMC Plus rotten PBS werewolf nfl fast and furious DGA cartoon adventure X-Men cancelled TV shows Disney latino docuseries james bond travel HFPA Podcast The Purge Calendar international Universal Pictures YouTube Premium Netflix Christmas movies Comedy Central 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards french Lucasfilm Comedy BBC SundanceTV new york TCM video YouTube LGBTQ Video Games Lifetime comiccon 20th Century Fox political drama ABC Signature VICE Pirates Rom-Com AMC Apple reviews Best and Worst spain zombies crime drama Tumblr 2018 foreign El Rey free movies halloween tv Black History Month Paramount Network Rocky SDCC king kong cancelled Women's History Month Amazon Prime dragons Pacific Islander romance Freeform book adaptation heist movie DC Comics Action golden globe awards 007 transformers NBA critics Reality Competition tv talk movie docudrama Holiday BET IMDb TV anime Captain marvel psychological thriller 2015 sequels green book IFC Films Hallmark sopranos Tomatazos suspense mutant doctor who Comic Book FX a nightmare on elm street Marvel Television CMT BBC America Cosplay Showtime godzilla scene in color Music ESPN Chilling Adventures of Sabrina critic resources crime diversity TLC MTV politics breaking bad trailers Prime Video feel good American Society of Cinematographers award winner die hard batman spanish language Crackle Anna Paquin Election wonder woman Neflix unscripted theme song Alien FOX Hear Us Out VH1 IFC Academy Awards TV One Amazon Prime Video San Diego Comic-Con Fargo directors screenings TV movies posters Martial Arts Spectrum Originals action-comedy renewed TV shows Hollywood Foreign Press Association black Thanksgiving OWN Pride Month revenge Ovation spy thriller comic books scary Extras Marvel Studios concert NYCC Elton John documentaries king arthur Nat Geo Crunchyroll Country Star Trek The Walking Dead Amazon Studios dceu satire technology Red Carpet Creative Arts Emmys slasher laika Family sag awards Awards Film canceled TV shows Hallmark Christmas movies police drama jamie lee curtis DirecTV social media elevated horror ratings Masterpiece Logo cops nature Quiz Peacock HBO Go monster movies mob Stephen King TNT mcc christmas movies chucky football Nickelodeon Arrowverse Pop TV Land Reality Disney+ Disney Plus know your critic book Heroines Comic-Con@Home 2021 dexter debate Tags: Comedy versus Mary poppins cats Pop TV spanish dogs Columbia Pictures vampires streaming movies blockbuster 93rd Oscars singing competition PlayStation adaptation best series serial killer Lifetime Christmas movies disaster The Walt Disney Company live action History jurassic park NBC DC streaming service strong female leads adenture PaleyFest Awards Tour Film Festival Schedule Superheroes sequel TV 99% Animation RT History Set visit Mudbound halloween blaxploitation 72 Emmy Awards twilight stand-up comedy richard e. Grant leaderboard war Drama Winners Turner A&E Mystery Avengers space Sundance TV olympics game show 79th Golden Globes Awards miniseries mockumentary TCA 2017 2016 FXX Apple TV+ 73rd Emmy Awards stoner indiana jones festivals criterion Chernobyl medical drama Sundance Now popular child's play Mary Tyler Moore canceled south america 2021 binge YA discovery Teen romantic comedy asian-american USA Marathons Photos First Look movies The CW cults 1990s CW Seed new star wars movies Western Sony Pictures Sundance Shondaland Winter TV Lionsgate young adult ITV Oscars Emmy Nominations royal family Summer Broadway Black Mirror new zealand comedies A24 slashers rotten movies we love science fiction Super Bowl black comedy period drama Holidays robots spider-man toronto kaiju Paramount facebook talk show Marvel Trophy Talk Warner Bros. LGBT USA Network natural history Binge Guide Esquire art house cars Disney Channel festival stop motion obituary justice league Dark Horse Comics Horror true crime target psycho venice Opinion Universal MSNBC women prank 45 National Geographic Watching Series Paramount Plus Endgame ID gangster Tarantino blockbusters hollywood marvel comics saw australia sports Star Wars Character Guide Pet Sematary Year in Review 24 frames HBO dramedy GIFs GLAAD japanese Bravo Baby Yoda screen actors guild archives name the review comic book movie trophy worst movies rt labs biopic TruTV Cannes quibi sitcom hist Mary Poppins Returns TCA Awards cancelled TV series crime thriller Trailer aliens live event Syfy spinoff Hulu TCA Winter 2020 marvel cinematic universe Netflix 2020 Television Academy historical drama Image Comics 2017 superman Premiere Dates Rock what to watch 2019 game of thrones BET Awards Sneak Peek ABC Family cinemax Musicals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt italian cancelled television dark Instagram Live Shudder video on demand 4/20 dc Mindy Kaling hispanic heritage month CBS vs. all-time Fox Searchlight Rocketman Biopics deadpool zero dark thirty golden globes children's TV VOD Food Network The Arrangement Television Critics Association rom-coms high school E! Kids & Family genre based on movie films franchise independent thriller Musical crossover Acorn TV BBC One 71st Emmy Awards scary movies composers Tokyo Olympics aapi boxoffice animated reboot BAFTA Song of Ice and Fire Certified Fresh Trivia emmy awards ABC See It Skip It Vudu scorecard dreamworks Spring TV Valentine's Day Grammys Comics on TV MCU Tubi Fantasy Disney streaming service lord of the rings Legendary boxing Toys Pixar remakes basketball Classic Film 90s Infographic DC Universe mission: impossible Ghostbusters TBS