6 Horror Films That Will Give You All the Feels... After They Terrify You

It doesn't happen often, but sometimes the scariest horror flicks can also move you to tears. Valerie Complex breaks down the 21st-century terrifiers that moved her the most.

by | October 27, 2020 | Comments

My motto is, no matter what, if a film moves me, there is no shame in turning on the waterworks. I ugly cried in the theater during Disney’s Coco, I sobbed through the second half of Titanic, and I bawled my eyes out for the third and fourth installments of Toy Story. But I’ve been known to get teary-eyed during scary movies, too — when I say I’ll cry if a film moves me, I do mean any film, including horror.

It may seem odd to get emotional during horror films, but they can do so much more than just be terrifying. Some can inspire sadness, hope, or even happiness. The first one I remember getting me in my feelings is Candyman (1992); I was nine years old and begged my father to take me to see it. While the film terrified me throughout, a dramatic tear rolled down my cheek during the last 15 minutes. There was something about sacrifice and children that got to me, even at a young age — it still gets me to this day.

As Halloween approaches, we revisited some of the films that include a little slashing, a little bashing, and a little sensitivity. Got suggestions of horror movies that made you weep? Let us know in the comments. 

[Warning: Major spoilers follow below.]

The Monster (2016)


Lizzie (Ella Balentine) is a bright young 11-year-old who has to deal with her mother Kathy’s (Zoe Kazan) alcoholic, abusive, unpredictable ways. As they travel on the road at night, they find themselves stranded on an isolated road in the middle of nowhere, fighting for their lives against one ugly forest monster.

Cry Factor: The best mother and daughter bonding happens on this frightful night. You don’t get the sense that Kathy cares for Lizzie until it’s life or death; as a mother who feels she’s given her child nothing but strife, the only thing left for Kathy to do is to sacrifice her own life so Lizzie has a fighting chance to survive. The characters started crying, and then I started crying. It’s a scary cry fest!

Dark Water (2002)


In this moody Japanese horror film by Hideo Nakata, single mom Yoshimi Matsubara (Hitomi Kuroki) is dealing with a bitter divorce and custody battle for her young daughter, Ikuko (Rio Kanno). As the two try to start life anew in their new apartment, ghostly apparitions of a young girl with a red backpack begin to haunt them, and it’s clear something supernatural — and evil — is afoot.

Cry Factor: This movie is just sad all around. The body of a young girl who drowned in the building water tower still lingers in it; her spirit haunts the building’s hallways looking for a new “mother” to latch onto, and Yoshimi is it. The woman must choose between crossing over to be with this ghost child or allowing her own daughter to be possessed by the spirit. Yoshimi ultimately decides to sacrifice herself so Ikuko can live in peace. Ten years later, Ikuko returns to the site of her mother’s disappearance and sees her ghost, who assures her that she’s OK in the afterlife and not to worry, providing rare horor-film closure for Ikuko.

Pulse (2001)


A college student commits suicide on a live internet stream, setting off a chain reaction across Tokyo that causes others to follow suit. The film follows Michi (Kumiko Aso), Ryosuke (Haruhiko Kato), and Harue (Koyuki), three unrelated folks whose stories eventually converge in this atmospheric, supernatural horror in which the internet plays a pivotal role.

Cry Factor: Kairo isn’t a typical horror film as it’s more about existentialism than anything else. Ghosts are lonely, and they travel through the internet to make contact with the living. In the end, 85% of the population is gone, and Michi begins to realize the power of human connection. The film asserts that death is just as finite as the living world, and if people cannot connect in life, they will be forced to do it in death. It will hit you in the feels, ya’ll.

Pan's Labyrinth (2006)


Many consider this to be Guillermo del Toro’s best film. The horror/fantasy tale is told against the backdrop of Franco’s authoritarian rule over Spain amd packs an emotional punch. The film follows 12-year-old Ofelia (Ivana Baquero), otherwise known as Princess Moanna of the underworld, who meets a faun that wants to help her return to her kingdom. In reality, Ofelia lives a harsh life with her stepfather, a captain under Franco’s regime.

Cry Factor: Ofelia’s mortal mother dies, and she herself is abused by her stepfather and nearly eaten by the Pale Man, all while living under Franco’s rule. This kid goes through it all. Just when you think she’s victorious, she’s shot and killed by her stepfather. Not all is bleak in death, though: she returns to the underworld to rule as its princess once again. How can you not feel anything from that?

Spring (2014)


If Before Sunrise and H.P. Lovecraft had a baby, it would be the horror/romance film Spring. Evan (Lou Taylor Pucci) is an American in Italy learning how to farm. He meets Louise (Nadia Hilker), a genetics student, and it’s love at first sight. The two exchange life stories, but Louise forgets to mention she is a 2,000-year-old Cthulhu-like monster. Until, that is, Evan catches her one day in the midst of a transformation phase that’s pretty gnarly to witness.

Cry Factor: Evan sees this transformation and doesn’t care; he is still in love with Louise. She explains this is a hereditary trait that helps her achieve immortality. She injects a special serum to keep herself in human form, but every 20 years, she must transform into a new look and new body – the only thing that will stop this process is falling in love. The duo decide to spend Louise’s final moments in her present form together, but when the time comes, the transformation doesn’t happen because she’s in love with Evan. It’s enough to bring tears to your eyes and butterflies to your stomach.

The Orphanage (2007)


Creepy dead children, a haunted house, and a mother at her wits’ end trying to find her missing son – nothing is as it seems in The Orphanage. Laura’s (Belén Rueda) son Simón (Roger Princep) is missing, and she is desperate to find him. The cops aren’t helpful, and she’s seeing frightening apparitions of dead children in her home, a former orphanage. Laura can’t decipher if she’s going mad or if the ghosts are trying to tell her something.

Cry Factor: Laura has truly lost all hope, but emotions escalate when she discovers she killed her son by accident and didn’t even realize it: What she thought was the ghost of one of the creepy children was, in fact, her own child in disguise. You’ll tear up just thinking about it even years after watching. The film ends on a bittersweet note, as Laura commits suicide to cross over and be with Simon and the other children. Now she too is a part of the orphanage.

Thumbnail image by ©Picturehouse Entertainment courtesy Everett Collection

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

99% ratings hidden camera game of thrones comiccon scary movies boxing Nickelodeon high school Musicals binge Comics on TV 79th Golden Globes Awards jamie lee curtis CBS CW Seed Reality Competition Elton John USA Network politics prank Travel Channel X-Men genre vampires toronto NBA children's TV VH1 Television Academy godzilla spider-man 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Purge Legendary scene in color cars Endgame Video Games critics scary Mary poppins USA HBO Max Tubi IMDb TV Extras dexter spider-verse all-time Apple TV+ Martial Arts HBO Lifetime Teen green book Cosplay Thanksgiving PBS Horror biopic werewolf Broadway Election Spectrum Originals Super Bowl Sneak Peek The Walking Dead target know your critic talk show 73rd Emmy Awards Ellie Kemper 71st Emmy Awards Tokyo Olympics witnail 72 Emmy Awards National Geographic IFC historical drama ITV Countdown 2018 gangster Pop Sci-Fi Calendar Valentine's Day Spike blockbuster Esquire scorecard royal family book canceled WarnerMedia spanish language pirates of the caribbean streaming movies art house Stephen King Infographic First Look Hulu latino mcc worst movies die hard slasher Sundance 007 sequel Universal cancelled Binge Guide independent Emmy Nominations young adult TV renewals toy story Universal Pictures Creative Arts Emmys Turner Classic Movies fast and furious Cannes Western thriller Wes Anderson Podcast Syfy Pride Month new star wars movies 24 frames blaxploitation cops Quiz supernatural streaming Superheroe doctor who TV One remakes Image Comics emmy awards Musical RT21 romantic comedy movie asian-american leaderboard Summer series Alien justice league OWN DC Universe A&E NYCC Film Festival SDCC NBC Rocky Avengers marvel cinematic universe Winter TV American Society of Cinematographers golden globes Captain marvel war deadpool razzies dragons Netflix Christmas movies AMC Disney Channel psycho legend Turner political drama marvel comics TV Land spy thriller Discovery Channel black Ovation Epix theme song Mudbound Watching Series Warner Bros. Prime Video comedies TCA 2017 Interview Tags: Comedy Hollywood Foreign Press Association anime BET 2017 Trivia Comic Book See It Skip It franchise Opinion FOX TV movies TNT GIFs action-comedy The Academy hispanic heritage month rt labs ghosts spinoff blockbusters mission: impossible crossover name the review feel good indie Toys based on movie rt archives Marvel Television reviews Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt mutant Nat Geo jurassic park free movies hist women elevated horror comic book movie Film Tomatazos child's play award winner zero dark thirty teaser Pet Sematary Reality indiana jones versus worst Tarantino docuseries lord of the rings Disney+ Disney Plus Family Fargo batman transformers adventure Awards TruTV MCU LGBTQ cults Mary Tyler Moore Television Critics Association Polls and Games miniseries YouTube Star Wars Shondaland reboot basketball vs. criterion BET Awards new zealand christmas movies sopranos Winners satire LGBT YA saw 2016 news Photos SundanceTV king arthur Fox News FX travel films comic obituary Shudder natural history MSNBC unscripted Pirates Women's History Month CBS All Access Song of Ice and Fire Comic-Con@Home 2021 Trailer Neflix robots Funimation nature ESPN ABC Family Marvel italian Writers Guild of America international aliens 90s Paramount Network james bond boxoffice E3 foreign TCA Amazon Prime australia popular cancelled TV shows kids strong female leads Awards Tour sitcom DirecTV BBC One ViacomCBS GoT History cats japan Paramount DC streaming service FXX facebook Disney Emmys Crackle Animation VOD cooking Disney streaming service Acorn TV E! venice comics fresh BAFTA Brie Larson The CW PaleyFest cancelled television Peacock The Witch Masterpiece cartoon VICE suspense Sony Pictures a nightmare on elm street San Diego Comic-Con Dark Horse Comics stand-up comedy Ghostbusters best breaking bad Classic Film dramedy Red Carpet game show twilight CNN APB revenge Nominations Grammys Rock Chernobyl Superheroes halloween tv universal monsters OneApp Certified Fresh screen actors guild Mystery Logo TCM FX on Hulu 2015 serial killer critic resources biography Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Action tv talk rom-coms TCA Winter 2020 kong kaiju Apple richard e. Grant black comedy WGN Columbia Pictures social media Instagram Live japanese comic books live action directors dogs 45 golden globe awards king kong documentaries Rocketman Comedy concert YouTube Premium Kids & Family crime adenture Premiere Dates superman Comedy Central The Arrangement what to watch dceu BBC America police drama wonder woman Fantasy BBC Apple TV Plus Heroines diversity IFC Films First Reviews sports A24 crime drama nfl Mindy Kaling stoner Cartoon Network hispanic MTV romance Black History Month Pixar movies trailers Sundance TV casting composers Fox Searchlight Pop TV french cinemax new york Starz GLAAD Drama Schedule Rom-Com technology science fiction Mary Poppins Returns joker singing competition period drama Star Trek Holidays Spring TV discovery Lionsgate DGA Black Mirror Arrowverse south america mob 93rd Oscars renewed TV shows Christmas Baby Yoda dark Britbox 2021 Best and Worst Bravo spain Showtime New York Comic Con monster movies video on demand superhero Amazon Prime Video Pacific Islander nbcuniversal Food Network Music Hallmark 20th Century Fox 21st Century Fox Lucasfilm dc Hear Us Out slashers El Rey halloween true crime olympics Lifetime Christmas movies Exclusive Video Paramount Plus Amazon Studios Amazon DC Comics Trophy Talk adaptation Walt Disney Pictures parents HBO Go quibi President zombies cancelled TV series hollywood sequels CMT crime thriller aapi comic book movies football archives Biopics Sundance Now anthology Netflix RT History screenings 4/20 Oscars Crunchyroll PlayStation TIFF TCA Awards harry potter debate festivals rotten movies we love zombie sag awards ABC trophy YouTube Red video dreamworks live event TLC Adult Swim telelvision classics ABC Signature rt labs critics edition Country chucky space book adaptation Academy Awards Marvel Studios SXSW television mockumentary documentary animated stop motion Box Office 2020 psychological thriller medical drama AMC Plus laika Anna Paquin rotten spanish festival Freeform finale HFPA Set visit 1990s Holiday disaster Character Guide Hallmark Christmas movies TV TBS ID docudrama Tumblr Fall TV Marathons Disney Plus heist movie posters Year in Review 2019 canceled TV shows The Walt Disney Company Vudu