5 Ways David Lowery Boldly Changed The Green Knight’s Arthurian Source (And Made Camelot Relevant Again)

With incredible design work, fresh characterizations, and a unique solution to 'The Captain America Problem,' the acclaimed filmmaker unearthed the modern in the medieval.

by | August 8, 2021 | Comments

David Lowery’s The Green Knight has earned a solidly Fresh Tomatometer score thanks to largely positive reviews and its position as theatrical counter-programming against the glut of big-budget summer blockbusters hitting theaters as of late. It’s a reimagining of the late 14th-century poem “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight,” which tells one of the most well-known stories in Arthurian legend canon – the tale of Sir Gawain, who accepts a terrifying challenge from a stranger on Christmas, and the quest he must embark on one year later.

It was a bold choice for Lowery to adapt a 700-year-old chivalric romance for the 21st century, and one that required a number of changes so that a story so profoundly rooted in the morality and literary style of the Middle Ages resonated with a modern audience. Here are five ways he changed the original Arthurian epic to do just that… and one important way he kept the medieval story intact.

The Green Knight Gets Wild

Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

In Lowery’s vision of Arthurian legend, the Green Knight is a primal supernatural entity, one whose ties to the natural world are right in his design. He is the Green Man of ancient myth come to life with his bark face accented by a beard made of curling twigs. Neither fully man nor tree, he harkens back to an older, pagan time when the lines between the natural world and the supernatural were far more blurred. Even the offshoot “branches” that crown his head vaguely evoke the horns of Cernunnos, the Celtic Horned God and lord of wild things. It’s deliberate character design meant to evoke the ancient unease of humanity realizing it doesn’t have full control of the world, and it’s a smart decision on Lowery’s part.

The design of the Green Knight in the original poem is a less wild thing; the antagonist is more nobleman who just happens to be green. When Arthur’s court meets him, he’s kitted out in forest green finery, with emeralds and jewels encrusting his ax and bridle, his fine-spun clothes trimmed with silk and ermine. It was a striking image, one that made an impression in the late 14th century, but one that today would fail to impress modern moviegoers who have seen it all. By stripping the sense of rich civility from the Green Knight, Lowery draws out the inherent otherness of the character and tinges it with horror.

Mother Knows Best: Recasting Morgan le Fay and Enriching Her Motivation

The Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

When the original poem was written, it was during a time in the Middle Ages in which Morgan le Fay’s role in Arthurian legend was transitioning from benevolent protector to villain. As patriarchal Christian morality took root and began heavily influencing writing of the era, Morgan (Arthur’s half-sibling), previously an amalgam of earlier revered, magical female Celtic deities, was recast as a malevolent sorceress of evil intent. Her role was often to play the antagonist in the mythology, intent on causing chaos in her half-brother’s court.

Her motivations for summoning the Green Knight and arranging the challenge in the original poem were fittingly petty: hoping Arthur would take up the challenge, Morgan merely wanted to frighten Guinevere in a bit of spite. Gawain taking up the challenge instead was coincidental. That’s a flimsy and wildly outdated premise to build a story around in modern times. Lowery changed Morgan’s connection to Gawain and, in doing so, changed her motivation. By making Morgan Gawain’s mother in the film, her game, while harsh, made much more sense. A petty, inexplicably cruel woman sending a man to his potential death because she’s miffed at another woman is nonsensical and regressive; but a powerful woman secretly pushing her son to find his greatness is something one can understand, if not necessarily agree with.

Sir Gawain: Peak Millennial

Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

As with so many things in “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight,” what makes perfect sense in a medieval poem doesn’t translate so well to the big screen in 2021. This is arguably never truer than with Gawain himself. Dev Patel’s portrayal of Gawain is vastly different than the Gawain of the poem; while he’s less likable, he’s also more relatable.

Poem Gawain was not so much a character in his own right, but a noble archetype and morality tale in one. He was meant to be the chivalric ideal and had the depiction to match. In fact, Gawain held himself to such a high standard in the poem that his test was to learn he was human and fallible, and that perfection is something that only God himself can achieve. Gawain is pious and pure, humble and extraordinarily chaste, courageous and benevolent to all he meets.

Thus, Lowery was presented with the Captain America problem: how does one make a character so inherently perfect interesting? Marvel achieved it not by changing Captain America, but by changing the world around him. Lowery achieved it by doing the opposite: keeping the world the same but changing Gawain. His Gawain is far more flawed than the version in the poem, an entitled wastrel who is squandering his potential in sex and drink. Purity and chastity are not in movie Gawain’s nature and his test, in many ways, is the opposite of the test presented in the source. Poem Gawain had to learn that even great knights can wobble; movie Gawain had to see if he could even be great at all.

As a heroic ideal, The Green Knight’s protagonist is quite lacking, but as a character whose struggle makes sense for moviegoers today, he’s incredibly timely.

Making New Frenemies

The Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

“Sir Gawain and the Green Knight” is a true hero’s journey, an epic quest of man vs. nature, but moreover, of man vs. himself. There are only a handful of characters in the original poem and Gawain spends large chunks of the story by himself. For the purposes of depicting the Christ-like trials of a noble knight in a chivalric romance, it works; for a modern movie adaptation, however, it makes for an awfully boring on-screen story.

Lowery wisely recognizes this and addresses it by adding three characters who seamlessly blend into the story while playing key roles in Gawain’s growth. Essel (Alicia Vikander) is the earthly temptation he must set aside to fully devote himself to his quest; the Scavenger (Barry Keoghan) is meant to shatter the naiveté and sheltered worldview Gawain holds; Winifred (Erin Kellyman) presents Gawain with a test of his altruism and chivalry. Each brings something essential that Gawain must learn in order to evolve, and their use provides a blueprint for how to add original characters to Arthurian adaptations that still feel as vital and necessary to the story as any characters in the old mythology.

Bye, Bye to The Wild – and Potentially Slow – Hunt 

The Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

Adapting an older story requires an insightful balance of knowing what to keep and what to cut: Too slavishly devote yourself to the original source and you risk dragging the story down with unnecessary scenes; deviate too far and you risk undermining the very aspects that made the original story so beloved in the first place.

While Lowery certainly added to the story, he also excised certain parts with a decisive hand. The most impactful edit was Lowery’s compression of the poem’s lengthily told three-day hunting scene, during which readers follow Lord Bertilak as he rides out each day to hunt, with the third and final day offering a parallel narrative with Bertilak chasing a wily and evasive fox as Gawain tries to evade Lady Bertilak’s aggressive advances back at the castle. It’s a great bit of symbolism, but an unnecessary part of the story that would have further dragged down the already slow-burn movie.

Condensing it kept the crux of Gawain’s quandary intact in the film while not killing the momentum that was building up heading into the third act.

…And What Lowery Smartly Chose NOT To Change

Green Knight

(Photo by © A24)

Though Lowery took plenty of liberties with the original poem, The Green Knight remains true to the spirit of its source. So many layers are packed into “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight,” but what truly holds it up are two tentpole themes that remain searingly relevant: the duality of the pagan natural world vs. ordered Christianity, and the core story of a knight discovering the man he truly is. Remove or change other elements and the story still largely stands on its own, but remove those two foundational pillars and it comes crashing down.

Lowery’s instincts for what to change and what to leave intact served him well, and the result is the old, archetypal story told in a fresh new way. One that feels urgent and modern, and yet true to its source. After Hollywood’s recent, multiple failed attempts to bring more Arthurian stories to the big screen, it might look to The Green Knight for an example of how to make Camelot and its endless well of stories relevant again.

The Green Knight is in theaters now. 

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

IFC Films Tumblr 73rd Emmy Awards TV know your critic sports IFC binge television Thanksgiving based on movie Western Valentine's Day foreign DC Comics breaking bad hist new star wars movies TV Land First Reviews Film Festival 1990s Sony Pictures razzies spain 99% Kids & Family Character Guide RT21 Paramount Plus Comedy Trailer Watching Series popular Chilling Adventures of Sabrina feel good ghosts Mary poppins basketball new zealand twilight ID SXSW debate Quiz RT History facebook Disney Plus E! Box Office supernatural San Diego Comic-Con psycho Captain marvel SDCC TBS FXX boxing Song of Ice and Fire indie Apple TV+ Christmas VH1 2020 wonder woman CNN 71st Emmy Awards Premiere Dates 45 Netflix Christmas movies french superman NBC Binge Guide political drama vampires Television Academy Amazon comic book movie gangster obituary 2021 Polls and Games nfl AMC dark 93rd Oscars worst movies Opinion Amazon Studios unscripted YA free movies Hallmark king arthur documentary Shudder HBO Go monster movies marvel comics concert MCU war TCA Awards Spring TV lord of the rings Chernobyl LGBTQ zombie Red Carpet deadpool 2018 Marvel Studios japan sag awards Interview rotten movies we love nbcuniversal high school TV renewals satire Hallmark Christmas movies Extras thriller NBA TLC Classic Film Awards Tour Oscars serial killer video Spike Comic Book romantic comedy The Arrangement El Rey Pacific Islander toronto Stephen King children's TV zero dark thirty spanish PaleyFest Pop TV Film stop motion Super Bowl Emmy Nominations A24 PlayStation Peacock WarnerMedia Legendary telelvision biography blockbuster historical drama 72 Emmy Awards GoT Adult Swim stand-up comedy spider-man TCA 2017 Family Wes Anderson Television Critics Association YouTube comic CBS All Access The Purge spinoff Netflix scene in color independent dragons TCM Shondaland Turner Photos BBC One godzilla crime football Reality Competition Rom-Com latino Ellie Kemper USA young adult heist movie festival all-time diversity harry potter biopic GIFs Pixar movies book adaptation PBS mission: impossible Logo justice league 24 frames Certified Fresh comiccon elevated horror kids BBC America cooking documentaries Women's History Month japanese blaxploitation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt pirates of the caribbean Black History Month green book Pride Month Crunchyroll Trivia video on demand asian-american Pop critic resources Winners golden globe awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 kong Dark Horse Comics indiana jones international animated LGBT Martial Arts cartoon CW Seed singing competition Turner Classic Movies psychological thriller australia DirecTV Reality cancelled Paramount Animation revenge crime thriller TIFF Creative Arts Emmys worst Britbox Universal target Tubi comics mockumentary teaser TV One CBS a nightmare on elm street stoner spy thriller Syfy Baby Yoda sitcom screenings classics tv talk boxoffice First Look Hulu Sundance TV OWN Emmys streaming discovery YouTube Red series natural history slashers Superheroe docuseries rom-coms olympics legend BET Awards Calendar Sundance Now E3 Vudu hidden camera Election live action Summer Set visit Ovation ViacomCBS Best and Worst Amazon Prime Video Mystery SundanceTV social media ABC 2019 renewed TV shows Cartoon Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards nature Countdown Sci-Fi Fox Searchlight Fall TV sequels FX on Hulu Crackle south america prank Podcast witnail Tokyo Olympics BAFTA halloween Sundance reboot cinemax Musicals TV movies versus quibi Black Mirror Nickelodeon anime Writers Guild of America directors The Walking Dead Fantasy remakes king kong anthology marvel cinematic universe American Society of Cinematographers MSNBC jurassic park comedies 20th Century Fox Comics on TV National Geographic universal monsters Grammys Discovery Channel comic books Avengers cops Nominations kaiju archives award winner Broadway rotten The Witch Arrowverse Lucasfilm TruTV Year in Review Mary Poppins Returns Hear Us Out 2017 best Rocketman Mary Tyler Moore disaster TNT jamie lee curtis Tarantino Rocky Horror Mudbound Alien BBC Ghostbusters hollywood Endgame adventure Columbia Pictures TCA Winter 2020 robots canceled TV shows joker ABC Signature Freeform Walt Disney Pictures Academy Awards Marvel royal family theme song Marathons blockbusters festivals President adaptation chucky james bond Travel Channel films Disney+ Disney Plus Exclusive Video Disney Channel superhero fast and furious romance cancelled TV shows Anna Paquin laika ESPN cars slasher zombies suspense BET rt labs critics edition History Rock Image Comics sequel science fiction DGA mutant finale critics streaming movies Apple Lifetime Christmas movies Elton John NYCC Bravo dexter Fox News Video Games Holidays Trophy Talk DC streaming service Esquire crossover VICE Nat Geo rt labs DC Universe Disney streaming service christmas movies cancelled TV series Country Heroines ABC Family Mindy Kaling New York Comic Con YouTube Premium politics Music halloween tv 4/20 Starz 90s Lifetime cancelled television Funimation Teen VOD adenture Holiday HBO casting Masterpiece CMT 007 fresh X-Men medical drama USA Network Epix toy story golden globes Amazon Prime police drama A&E Cannes true crime Toys women TCA Superheroes GLAAD WGN new york Food Network die hard Tomatazos franchise book posters MTV what to watch dc miniseries reviews black comic book movies Star Wars venice FOX dogs Cosplay cats action-comedy Musical composers saw Warner Bros. 2015 period drama ratings italian ITV OneApp Apple TV Plus 2016 Comedy Central technology scary movies transformers Pet Sematary parents game show talk show aapi emmy awards Disney name the review Drama The CW HBO Max hispanic Star Trek news child's play APB rt archives The Academy The Walt Disney Company Biopics Lionsgate screen actors guild Brie Larson Acorn TV Action batman hispanic heritage month Sneak Peek Schedule doctor who travel Winter TV richard e. Grant werewolf aliens crime drama Paramount Network game of thrones See It Skip It Infographic mcc strong female leads criterion Pirates canceled spanish language 21st Century Fox movie Awards scorecard dramedy docudrama space trailers Spectrum Originals Marvel Television Showtime cults dceu FX