5 Big Fan Questions About the Disney-Fox Deal

Here are the whos — X-Men, the Simpsons — and whats — 'Avatar,' FX Networks, National Geographic — behind Disney's acquisition of 21st Century Fox properties and what it all means to fans like us.

by | December 14, 2017 | Comments

Deadpool, Robin Hood (Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation; Everett Collection)

(Photo by Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation; Everett Collection)

The Walt Disney Company’s acquisition of 21st Century Fox is finally official, and while the deal suggests a big upheaval in the media industry with rival studios reshuffling, streaming services like Netflix preparing for a subscriber war, and Fox employees refreshing their resumes for the mass-firings to come, there are still plenty of content-related questions to consider. The Fox library of films and television shows is shockingly massive. When you consider things like Avatar, Planet of the Apes, and American Horror Story are all owned by the same company that produced The Omen, Cleopatra, and Die Hard, Disney’s eventual control of those films — and remake rights — is staggering.

Here’s the quick and dirty of the deal, according to Disney’s statement:

  • Transaction to include 21st Century Fox’s film and television studios, cable entertainment networks and international TV businesses;
  • Entertainment properties including X-Men, Avatar, The Simpsons, FX Networks and National Geographic to join Disney’s portfolio;
  • Expands Disney’s direct-to-consumer offerings with addition of 21st Century Fox’s entertainment content, capabilities in the Americas, Europe and Asia; Hulu stake becomes a controlling interest;
  • Addition of extensive international properties, including Star in India and Fox’s 39 percent ownership of Sky across Europe, enhances Disney’s position as a truly global entertainment company with world-class offerings in key regions.

In addition, because Disney, which owns ABC, is not allowed to own a second broadcast network under current government regulations, 21st Century Fox will spin off the Fox Broadcasting network and stations to its shareholders in a deal that will also include Fox News, Fox Business, FS1, FS2 and Big Ten Network.

Oh, and there are those bits of Marvel and Star Wars that Fox controlled. But as the deal is so incredibly huge, there are plenty of fun, practical and, frankly, depressing questions to ask about the upcoming Disney acquisition of Fox. The following present just five of the more interesting questions fans of Fox properties are asking this morning.

1. Will Marvel Really Get the Fantastic Four Back?

Ryan Fujitani

One absolute certainty of a successful Disney and Fox merger is the return of the X-Men to Marvel and its feature film and television divisions. Usually spoken of in the same breath is Marvel’s first family, the Fantastic Four, who have definitely suffered under Fox stewardship. The first two feature films produced by the studio underperformed, were critically panned (27% and 37% on the Tomatometer, respectively), and are not fondly remembered. The 2015 reboot was widely reviled (just 9% on the Tomatometer) and seemingly ended the career of director Josh Trank.

But in all the excitement, many have overlooked another player in the Fantastic Four saga, namely Constantin Film founder Bernd Eichinger.

Eichinger has been part of the Fantastic Four’s film saga since the unreleased 1994 Roger Corman–produced Fantastic Four. In fact, that film, which has a 29% Tomatometer score, only came about so that Eichinger could hold onto the rights. After the ploy failed to secure him a big budget film in the time allotted, his company, Constantin Film, and Fox approached Marvel about a contract extension in 1999, leading to the 2005 Fantastic Four feature Fox released and its subsequent sequel.

But as Slashfilm noted recently, this is where ownership gets fuzzy. No one is sure how Fox and Constantin shared the rights when they renegotiated with Marvel. The latter is the production company of note for all three of the films made this century, with Fox assuming the distribution role.

If Fox was only the distributor, then Constantin could take their Marvel properties to Sony or Universal, but it is also likely that Fox has exclusive distribution rights to Fantastic Four features. If there is some sort of deadlock between the companies waiting in the not-too-distant future, then a stalemate would eventually mean all FF rights revert to Marvel. It would be in Constantin’s interest to play nice with Disney and get a piece of the pie that seemingly only Marvel Studios can bake.

While there are a lot of potential downsides to the merger, a good Fantastic Four film would definitely be a plus.

2. Do We Finally Get the Star Wars Trilogy in Its Original Form?

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

This is the big one for Star Wars fans. As part of Lucasfilm’s original deal to produce Star Wars, Fox retained ownership of the 1977 feature film, while George Lucas and his production company owned the characters, worlds, branding, toy rights, and everything else except the actual film and the Fox fanfare that preceded it.

Even now, the absence of the fanfare in the new Disney-produced Star Wars films is difficult to accept.

Fox’s ownership of the original film is one of the reasons the original Star Wars trilogy lacks for a high-definition home video release. Well, that and Lucas’ stated belief that the films no longer exist in their original forms. But with Disney assuming control of the Fox film library, they get ownership of the 1977 Star Wars. So Disney’s home video unit could take advantage of fan interest in the films’ theatrical versions and make a killing on home video — even if that market is a sinking proposition.

One obstacle in this ultimate Life Day wish may be Lucas himself, whose growing myth over the years includes possible contractual stipulations about which versions Disney may re-release and the possibility that he irreparably altered the camera negatives in preparing the late 1990s Special Edition releases and subsequent home video versions.

But if Lucas’ tampering is not an issue, there will be nothing to prevent Disney from releasing the original version of Star Wars or its sequels in their high-def glory.

3. Will the X-Men Get a Complete Reboot?

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

As mentioned earlier, the return of the X-Men film and TV rights to Marvel is a given. But how will Marvel Studios and the television division proceed with integrating the characters into their established “it’s all connected” world? Since the acquisition is still at least a year from being finalized, Fox must continue to produce X-Men products independently of any Marvel plans; 2018 is already filled with Deadpool 2, The New Mutants, and X-Men: Dark Phoenix, but the 2019 slate becomes unclear as the uncertainty about ownership creeps in.

Before rumors of the merger surfaced, 20th Century Fox CEO Stacey Snider committed to diversifying the studio’s X-Men offerings. The long-in-development Gambit feature found a new director in Pirates of the Caribbean‘s Gore Verbinski, and The Disaster Artist director James Franco signed on to develop a feature based around popular X-Factor character Jamie Maddrox, the Multiple Man.

Disney will presumably honor any contracts signed before they officially take possession of the Fox assets, so Gambit and Multiple Man will happen. But any plan after that leads to a wide-open realm of possibility.

One clue may exist in the form of Dark Phoenix director Simon Kinberg. Rumors recently surfaced that he is developing a standalone Star Wars movie featuring Boba Fett. He is also one of the producers of the Disney XD program Star Wars Rebels. With these roots in Burbank already established, he may be able to carve out territory for himself as the creative steward of the brand.

Then again, Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige has already indicated his excitement at getting control of the X-Men. If he does so, then a total reboot of the brand seems more likely, as it gives Marvel Studios complete freedom to integrate mutants into MCU history or introduce them as new elements following Avengers: Infinity War. It also means they will supervise the search for a new Wolverine — that is, barring a change of heart by beloved X-Men franchise actor Hugh Jackman and a Disney stamp of approval on his return. Jackman has said “the ship has sailed” about the likelihood of his return to the role, however.

One thing is certain though: Deadpool will not be affected by any reboots or restructuring, as he and Disney CEO Bob Iger are already pals.

4. Will Ridley Scott Exit the Alien Franchise?

(Photo by Mark Rogers/20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

The Disney corporate culture is one of brand synergy and tight control across their spectrum of media and consumer products. Without a tight company direction, 20th Century Fox is often a filmmaker haven. This loose attitude toward creative control is no better exemplified than with Ridley Scott’s recent additions to the Alien franchise — a series of films which used to be known as “The Franchise” within Fox’s offices. Despite its importance to the studio in the 1990s, Alien was dead after the third and fourth installments led to mixed results (46% and 56% on the Tomatometer) and the infamous Alien vs. Predator films (also Rotten at 20% and 11%) seemingly killed any hope of further outings. Scott’s return to that universe was greeted with much anticipation until Prometheus (73% fresh) proved he was not interested in rebuilding the brand. Alien: Covenant (68% fresh) only further underscored Scott’s real fascination in these newer works: androids.

Both films arguably could have been more interesting and, perhaps, better received if they were not framed as parts of the Alien world. Scott himself has already said the next Alien film will focus more on his android passion than his waning interest in the Xenomorphs. Considering Prometheus and Covenant, that is probably for the best, but Disney will want to maximize its investment by producing Alien films that actually feature the Alien.

Will Scott be amenable to that or step aside?

This also leads to a broader question, as Fox’s level of creator freedom may disappear under Disney leadership: will notoriously headstrong directors like James Cameron chafe when the Disney managers try to employ the “Disney Way” on their projects? Under his current deal with Fox, Cameron is poised to make four sequels to Avatar. And despite his intent to film as much of them as he can at once, production, marketing, and distribution decisions will still need to be made after the merger.

Cameron may have an easier go than Scott, as he has already worked with Disney in creating Pandora — The World of Avatar at Disney’s Animal Kingdom in Florida. But Scott and other filmmakers may face tougher transitions unless Disney decides to use Fox as a director’s showcase brand punctuated by occasional Alien, Predator, and Planet of the Apes films to bolster the performance of the division.

As organizations like the Writer’s Guild of America are already declaring the acquisition to be harmful to creative output, giving filmmakers freedom at Fox may be the best use of the resources and branding.

5. Is There Room for the Simpsons in the Disney Family?

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

Decades ago, when Disney was known for the aggressive business tactics of its then-CEO Michael Eisner, The Simpsons made a joke about Fox becoming a Disney subsidiary. While the show’s jokes often demonstrate an eerie prescience, the program itself represents one of the more difficult aspects of the deal: the overall family-friendly image of the Walt Disney Company and how that might affect the typically edgier content Fox Television has produced for Fox networks.

Since the founding of the Fox broadcast network in 1986, Fox’s television offerings have always been a little, well, crude. The network itself was built on shows like Married With Children, The Simpsons, In Living Color, and Melrose Place. Those programs pushed the envelope with regards to broadcast standards and all featured content Disney’s ABC would never air. (Well, not outside of the 10 p.m. slot anyway. Disney never had a problem with NYPD Blue after they bought the network in 1995.)

In fact, Disney’s image is not as squeaky clean as it seems. When Eisner joined the studio, outgoing Disney boss Ron Miller created Touchstone Films — later Touchstone Pictures — with the express purpose of creating film and television that did not fit the Disney image. The results were films like Splash and Armageddon and television programs like The Golden Girls and Lost. Another Disney film division, Hollywood Pictures, pushed the boundaries even further, though few of their films are fondly remembered, with the possible exceptions of The Joy Luck Club and Encino Man. Later, Disney bought Miramax from the now-disgraced Harvey Weinstein to bolster its reach into the edgy, indie film market. There is a value in owning non-Disney products, in other words, and the company, historically, is aware of that.

To be clear, Disney is taking over Fox’s television production studio, but not its Fox Broadcasting network. That said, Disney welcomed The Simpsons into its portfolio in its statement and will have some leverage over other Fox Television productions that may be out of step with Disney’s wholesome image.

These are only a few of the geekier questions facing the company, consumers and the various people employed by Disney and Fox as the merger process begins. Some of them are more fun to consider than others — seriously, the extent of the layoffs is likely to be as staggering as the amount of content Disney is buying — but they all point to a 2020s with a very different media landscape. And it’s only just beginning.

Tag Cloud

suspense TV movies rom-coms comic books james bond dark teaser Winter TV Disney Plus Cannes TCA Awards dragons nfl Tomatazos Amazon Trophy Talk OneApp Quiz The Arrangement cinemax LGBT book adaptation prank E! Hear Us Out hist Legendary Mudbound genre Thanksgiving comiccon Black History Month french comic book movie dc The Walking Dead Peacock psycho Turner Classic Movies TruTV Television Academy Baby Yoda sports X-Men christmas movies breaking bad 24 frames zombie Schedule Amazon Studios Nat Geo basketball MSNBC trailers IFC Films E3 Tokyo Olympics animated children's TV New York Comic Con TLC Toys know your critic football Year in Review SundanceTV movies spanish language thriller Comics on TV Sony Pictures biography Sundance Now documentaries TV Land pirates of the caribbean YouTube fast and furious cars films comic book movies discovery anime TNT Ovation GIFs spanish serial killer Set visit FXX south america festival IMDb TV Television Critics Association indiana jones Image Comics RT History child's play Best and Worst streaming supernatural cancelled TV series Neflix Alien Nominations Dark Horse Comics 20th Century Fox directors adventure 2016 Emmys comedies FX ABC Signature facebook ABC Family award winner CBS All Access DC Universe Awards Tour PaleyFest transformers Ghostbusters lord of the rings 4/20 worst movies classics cancelled television japanese TIFF green book RT21 adenture Fall TV USA Network cops golden globes HBO Max live event Anna Paquin crime drama australia Broadway Hulu Classic Film Comic Book crime thriller Musical kaiju Mindy Kaling superman TBS Sci-Fi Fox Searchlight police drama kong twilight First Look halloween 45 HBO Family social media rt archives HBO Go CNN YouTube Red NYCC VH1 natural history Oscars rt labs critics edition telelvision spider-man new york target The Walt Disney Company marvel comics comics critic resources Cartoon Network toronto latino young adult halloween tv MTV romantic comedy Kids & Family high school theme song a nightmare on elm street 21st Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire Masterpiece TV remakes ratings Syfy The Witch Disney streaming service Marvel Superheroe Warner Bros. black AMC Plus black comedy Paramount Network emmy awards cancelled TV shows Horror streaming movies The CW historical drama Universal Pictures Lionsgate cancelled 2018 San Diego Comic-Con worst Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Arrowverse tv talk television CBS Certified Fresh See It Skip It cooking Mary Tyler Moore saw heist movie TV One Esquire Adult Swim rotten MCU justice league 72 Emmy Awards stoner elevated horror Amazon Prime Video Sneak Peek monster movies debate vampires vs. 93rd Oscars quibi boxing CMT action-comedy Avengers Mystery USA Sundance TV Musicals Paramount Rock DirecTV Ellie Kemper rt labs spy thriller canceled TV shows National Geographic blockbuster slashers Disney+ Disney Plus game of thrones Red Carpet The Academy robots Emmy Nominations GoT Acorn TV Chernobyl venice science fiction reboot Disney canceled Brie Larson italian Turner Apple TV Plus Tarantino kids independent Exclusive Video Rocketman Winners TCA 2017 Nickelodeon king arthur Pop TV period drama medical drama Pixar true crime VOD Pop asian-american feel good Podcast screen actors guild finale new star wars movies psychological thriller screenings ViacomCBS franchise cartoon joker sopranos movie docuseries Women's History Month jurassic park hidden camera ESPN Pirates Travel Channel YA 2017 Cosplay all-time 99% mission: impossible Holiday Shudder dramedy Marvel Studios IFC VICE Universal Britbox razzies unscripted Countdown Calendar war History golden globe awards superhero BET GLAAD festivals book scene in color Funimation Christmas Rom-Com stop motion Mary poppins foreign Hallmark Christmas movies Disney Channel 71st Emmy Awards Rocky Netflix Christmas movies series fresh Endgame NBA 73rd Emmy Awards Discovery Channel Vudu AMC Valentine's Day Election richard e. Grant sitcom versus Netflix TV renewals disaster news Captain marvel Academy Awards TCA PBS witnail spinoff Reality based on movie Grammys zero dark thirty renewed TV shows Sundance marvel cinematic universe binge Pride Month WarnerMedia Awards Comedy Central adaptation art house technology cats Western Lucasfilm Apple video free movies SXSW Infographic obituary royal family dexter The Purge Reality Competition mob Pacific Islander Drama zombies posters mutant international 90s LGBTQ scary movies Lifetime universal monsters Starz Spike Interview Tumblr dceu Binge Guide sag awards indie Stephen King parents spider-verse critics concert Box Office 2019 slasher scorecard Columbia Pictures El Rey Opinion 007 politics harry potter cults Walt Disney Pictures APB Premiere Dates jamie lee curtis Country new zealand miniseries legend laika political drama Spectrum Originals ITV popular criterion American Society of Cinematographers scary Comedy Lifetime Christmas movies DC streaming service dogs Action docudrama WGN Biopics Wes Anderson BBC One Animation FOX Heroines BBC America chucky godzilla blaxploitation DC Comics Showtime 1990s boxoffice Crunchyroll ghosts toy story CW Seed blockbusters Star Trek sequel Super Bowl mockumentary hollywood name the review nature gangster ABC werewolf Star Wars reviews TCA Winter 2020 strong female leads diversity crossover casting Comic-Con@Home 2021 deadpool Trivia singing competition Polls and Games spain YouTube Premium Tubi stand-up comedy biopic hispanic archives wonder woman anthology Paramount Plus PlayStation composers Music Mary Poppins Returns space NBC Elton John aliens Black Mirror batman BAFTA Marvel Television BET Awards Fox News live action nbcuniversal 2015 die hard Teen comic romance travel Hallmark Character Guide Film Festival President Food Network Fantasy A&E 2020 Spring TV sequels OWN Video Games First Reviews Trailer Photos Summer satire Marathons Logo Extras Shondaland ID Crackle game show Martial Arts what to watch doctor who rotten movies we love talk show hispanic heritage month BBC olympics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FX on Hulu aapi revenge Instagram Live 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards women Freeform Bravo Amazon Prime best Watching Series king kong video on demand A24 crime documentary Writers Guild of America Apple TV+ Creative Arts Emmys DGA dreamworks Holidays TCM mcc Film SDCC Superheroes Pet Sematary Epix 2021 japan