Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Sucker Punch Gets KO'd

Plus, Diary of a Wimpy Kid 2 is a mixed bag.

by | March 25, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a violent fantasyland (Sucker Punch, starring Emily Browning and Abbie Cornish) and some brotherly love (Diary of a Wimpy Kid 2: Rodrick Rules, starring Zachary Gordon and Devon Bostick). What do the critics have to say?

Sucker Punch


Smoking-hot babes with swords! A daring escape from a creepy asylum! Samurais and dragons! Is there any way Sucker Punch could possibly go wrong? Well, yes, say critics, who find Zack Snyder’s latest to be a compendium of geeky obsessions in search of a story (or indeed, general coherence). Emily Browning stars as Babydoll, a young woman whose mother has recently died, leaving her in the care of her evil stepfather, who ships her off to a mental hospital. Babydoll retreats into a dreamworld, teaming up with a bevy of gals who plan a treacherous escape from the facility. The pundits say Sucker Punch is admirably ambitious, but it fails to add up to much; it’s an assault on the senses that suffers from jarring tonal shifts and a shortage of narrative logic. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a rundown of memorable prison break movies.)

Diary of a Wimpy Kid 2: Rodrick Rules


The first Diary of a Wimpy Kid, which hit theaters last year, got decidedly mixed reviews; a number of scribes found it sweet and perceptive, while others called it clichéd and over reliant on gross-out jokes. It appears Diary of a Wimpy Kid 2: Rodrick Rules won’t set the critical world on fire either — some critics say its life lessons and good humor are more pronounced this time out, but others feel it’s a little shopworn and occasionally cynical. Our hero Greg (Zachary Gordon) is starting seventh grade, and optimistically hopes that he will get in with the cool crowd. Unfortunately, his older brother Rodrick continues to torment him. Will these two ever get along? The pundits say Diary benefits from strong performances from its young actors and a couple of insightful laughs, but it also gets bogged down in scenes of public humiliation and bullying that don’t add much to the equation.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Honey, a drama about a boy’s spiritual awakening in a remote town in Turkey, is at 100 percent.
  • My Perestroika, a documentary about the lives of young people growing up in the waning days of communism, is at 83 percent.
  • Potiche, starring Catherine Deneuve and Gérard Depardieu in a comedy about a romance between an umbrella factory owner’s wife and a labor leader, is at 77 percent.
  • White Irish Drinkers, a coming-of-age drama about a group of petty crooks in 1970s Brooklyn, is at 46 percent.
  • Peep World, starring Michael C. Hall and Sarah Silverman in an ensemble comedy about a family reunion that’s been sabotaged by a scandalous tell-all book, is at 29 percent.
  • Miral, a drama about the lives of several generations of Palestinian women, is at 15 percent (check out director Julian Schnabel‘s Five Favorite Films here).

Finally, want to win a Rotten Tomatoes shirt? First, watch Sucker Punch. Then, on Sunday, tweet your review and tag it #fresh or #rotten. We’ll choose five winners! Check us out on Twitter!

Tag Cloud

science fiction Countdown Certified Fresh sports sitcom biography Election American Society of Cinematographers technology BBC period drama Star Trek TNT CBS All Access AMC Food Network TBS Best and Worst Winter TV psycho Biopics social media Nickelodeon Disney TV Land FOX 007 X-Men Amazon Emmys Valentine's Day Masterpiece Rock Red Carpet Animation Sneak Peek E! Tumblr binge Interview E3 politics The Arrangement TCA APB Premiere Dates Syfy SDCC Grammys singing competition historical drama Fox News Marathons Action BBC America Teen Universal police drama Adult Swim Mary Tyler Moore Lionsgate Character Guide cooking Music The CW Cosplay cinemax travel Box Office comiccon NYCC Trailer Disney Channel HBO Fall TV FX RT History Esquire Musical Superheroes ESPN First Look SundanceTV cats A&E harry potter crime crime drama Drama Ellie Kemper Thanksgiving ITV Starz Rocky TIFF Polls and Games Cartoon Network cops Winners boxoffice Writers Guild of America Holidays Trivia Super Bowl Summer 2017 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Star Wars Bravo LGBTQ VH1 Mindy Kaling Video Games Hulu Podcast Sci-Fi TCA 2017 Rom-Com El Rey Year in Review Logo Tomatazos WGN Pirates Watching Series CBS 2016 GLAAD zombie TruTV discovery President Toys aliens what to watch Warner Bros. 2015 VICE Schedule based on movie ABC dramedy Opinion Dark Horse Comics romance Extras GoT Comedy adventure TCM Nat Geo MTV Reality USA Crackle Nominations FXX 45 thriller CNN Marvel Oscars DirecTV Awards vampires Paramount war serial killer TV Ghostbusters GIFs talk show Netflix Comic Book Kids & Family IFC TLC Pop Horror YA Freeform OWN political drama Comedy Central Country docudrama Sundance Calendar supernatural CMT Fantasy diversity Musicals PaleyFest Photos MSNBC BET Reality Competition DC Comics Mystery crime thriller Martial Arts ABC Family Infographic History Lifetime Spring TV DC Universe 24 frames PBS Set visit NBC transformers Showtime composers