Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Pain & Gain is Visceral But Uneven

Plus, The Big Wedding is a big misfire.

by | April 25, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got bodybuilding bad guys (Pain & Gain, starring Mark Wahlberg and Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson) and matrimonial mishaps (The Big Wedding, starring Robert De Niro and Diane Keaton). What do the critics have to say?

Pain & Gain


Michael Bay is not the kind of guy to tone things down just because he’s working with a smaller budget. However, critics say the auteur behind Armageddon and the Transformers franchise has tempered the visceral impact of Pain & Gain with a fair amount of black comedy, and the result is uneven but often queasily compelling. Based on a bizarre true story, Pain & Gain is the tale of three bodybuilders who concoct a scheme to kidnap a wealthy businessman and wrest control of his riches. However, the plan quickly goes awry, with violent repercussions. The pundits say Pain & Gain‘s pitch-black sense of humor and charismatic leads can’t quite make up for the movie’s stylistic excess and lack of nuance. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of films based on magazine and newspaper articles.)

The Big Wedding


Critics say The Big Wedding is a comedy that audiences should decline with regrets; its all-star cast is stranded in a contrived, strained plot that features broad stabs at humor but few laughs. Robert De Niro and Diane Keaton star as a divorced couple who reunite for their son’s wedding and pretend to be happily married for the sake of his bride-to-be’s conservative mother; hilarity allegedly ensues. The pundits say The Big Wedding is a big misfire, with shopworn slapstick gags and stereotypical characters.Check out this week’s Total Recall for a countdown of Keaton’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

war The Arrangement aliens FOX historical drama APB History X-Men Mary Tyler Moore VICE GIFs ABC Horror Cartoon Network Animation LGBTQ TCM crime thriller Adult Swim ESPN Toys adventure sports Pirates American Society of Cinematographers Martial Arts Star Trek Premiere Dates Fantasy Disney Netflix zombie WGN Starz Rom-Com Schedule vampires El Rey Super Bowl Reality SundanceTV Hulu TIFF NBC Teen Country DirecTV Nat Geo AMC DC Comics TruTV Video Games Oscars Mystery period drama Showtime TLC Esquire Marvel SDCC Character Guide travel Drama Biopics Best and Worst comiccon GoT technology MSNBC Pop Kids & Family Fall TV Opinion Winners TV supernatural 2017 Infographic Dark Horse Comics Logo Photos CNN Food Network 2015 Marathons Spring TV sitcom Awards boxoffice IFC PBS CBS All Access Grammys Fox News Interview Extras Bravo RT History CBS 24 frames Superheroes Calendar Lifetime Sci-Fi cinemax harry potter Sundance Countdown TBS Reality Competition Nominations E! Musical Comic Book FXX Holidays GLAAD Cosplay docudrama Masterpiece Winter TV FX Valentine's Day Comedy Central composers First Look Writers Guild of America Red Carpet MTV Universal crime Election A&E Watching Series VH1 Trivia Disney Channel Certified Fresh Emmys TV Land 007 Lionsgate Comedy Ghostbusters ITV Musicals Nickelodeon TCA science fiction Freeform USA biography Star Wars Rock ABC Family cops Box Office Music discovery NYCC cooking TNT OWN Action President TCA 2017 crime drama PaleyFest Tomatazos Summer politics Set visit Thanksgiving CMT Amazon HBO Rocky Podcast Year in Review serial killer Tumblr singing competition Sneak Peek thriller Crackle psycho Syfy based on movie BBC Trailer police drama BBC America social media 2016 diversity BET dramedy The CW Polls and Games