Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Maleficent is So-So, But Jolie is Great

Plus, A Million Ways to Die in the West is decidedly short of a million laughs.

by | May 30, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary villainess (Maleficent, starring Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning) and some silly cowpokes (A Million Ways to Die in the West, starring Seth MacFarlane and Charlize Theron). What do the critics have to say?



Maleficent

51%

In the past few years, audiences have been treated to a tough-as-nails Snow White, an emotionally complex Snow Queen, and, ahem, Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters. Maleficent offers a more sympathetic take on the evil fairy queen from Sleeping Beauty, but critics say that an outstanding performance from Angelina Jolie and some striking visuals can’t redeem the movie’s slack narrative and uncertain tone. Maleficent (Jolie), a powerful fairy, is betrayed by a childhood friend, who becomes a king; in turn, she places a curse upon his daughter. As the child grows up, however, Maleficent reconsiders her feelings, even as the king plots her destruction. The pundits say Maleficent deserves credit for putting a feminist spin on an old tale, but the movie can’t quite live up to its thoughtful premise — or Jolie’s inspired work in the title role. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Jolie’s best-reviewed movies, as well as our video interviews with Jolie and other members of the cast.)



A Million Ways to Die in the West

33%

Some comedies fail because they’re short on gags. On the other end of the spectrum, critics say the problem with A Million Ways to Die in the West is that it has too many — writer/director/star Seth MacFarlane packs so many jokes into this Western spoof that the most inventive comic moments are often elbowed aside by scatological smuttiness. MacFarlane stars as Albert, a cowardly rancher in a wild west town who falls for Anna (Charlize Theron), who’s handy with a gun. However, Anna is married to a wanted outlaw, and soon Albert is in his crosshairs. The pundits say A Million Ways to Die in the West has an appealing cast and some really big laughs, but overall, it’s a few notches below its obvious inspiration — Mel BrooksBlazing Saddles. (Flip through our gallery of memorable Western comedies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

CW Seed APB Oscars Toys aliens period drama American Society of Cinematographers Infographic TCA social media Country Trivia Drama singing competition IFC CBS All Access 45 GIFs TIFF Writers Guild of America Hulu TCM transformers BBC America Teen HBO Martial Arts romance DC streaming service Valentine's Day Video Games RT History 007 Summer Holidays cooking Polls and Games Trailer Marathons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mary Tyler Moore TBS Rocky Acorn TV 24 frames technology docudrama E! spy thriller binge Bravo Netflix Creative Arts Emmys Winter TV 21st Century Fox Ghostbusters 20th Century Fox Paramount Network ITV Christmas Marvel Pirates Star Trek Pop Food Network boxoffice what to watch adventure Mindy Kaling supernatural serial killer psycho DC Universe golden globes PaleyFest VH1 DirecTV Schedule Best and Worst Grammys Superheroes comiccon Western Syfy SundanceTV sitcom Britbox Cosplay science fiction Lucasfilm TNT justice league FXX Interview biography war cults The Arrangement Ellie Kemper Crackle Winners First Look 2016 ABC Family Premiere Dates Musicals E3 Spike Esquire LGBTQ CNN Freeform Biopics Nominations Starz Animation Countdown Sundance Musical ESPN GLAAD cats dc President TV politics SDCC Character Guide talk show Rom-Com dceu Mystery sports Lifetime ABC Set visit The CW Super Bowl History Showtime Certified Fresh Rock WGN Sony Pictures crime drama 2017 diversity Kids & Family Watching Series Calendar DC Comics CBS discovery based on movie BBC Lionsgate Disney Channel Warner Bros. El Rey USA TLC Horror IFC Films cinemax Disney Action Pixar crime thriller GoT Paramount VICE MTV Amazon BET Opinion composers USA Network Dark Horse Comics Red Carpet Comedy Year in Review A&E police drama NYCC political drama PBS 2015 Sneak Peek Sundance Now Logo Tomatazos TV Land CMT Podcast Extras AMC Masterpiece NBC travel Star Wars Universal FOX medical drama Comic Book ratings MSNBC Photos See It Skip It Music Election Cartoon Network dramedy TCA 2017 TruTV Comedy Central Nat Geo cops Sci-Fi Awards OWN Fall TV Nickelodeon Adult Swim Box Office unscripted harry potter YA zombie Tumblr crime thriller X-Men vampires Fantasy Thanksgiving Reality Competition Reality historical drama FX Spring TV Fox News Emmys