Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Maleficent is So-So, But Jolie is Great

Plus, A Million Ways to Die in the West is decidedly short of a million laughs.

by | May 30, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a legendary villainess (Maleficent, starring Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning) and some silly cowpokes (A Million Ways to Die in the West, starring Seth MacFarlane and Charlize Theron). What do the critics have to say?



Maleficent

50%

In the past few years, audiences have been treated to a tough-as-nails Snow White, an emotionally complex Snow Queen, and, ahem, Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters. Maleficent offers a more sympathetic take on the evil fairy queen from Sleeping Beauty, but critics say that an outstanding performance from Angelina Jolie and some striking visuals can’t redeem the movie’s slack narrative and uncertain tone. Maleficent (Jolie), a powerful fairy, is betrayed by a childhood friend, who becomes a king; in turn, she places a curse upon his daughter. As the child grows up, however, Maleficent reconsiders her feelings, even as the king plots her destruction. The pundits say Maleficent deserves credit for putting a feminist spin on an old tale, but the movie can’t quite live up to its thoughtful premise — or Jolie’s inspired work in the title role. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Jolie’s best-reviewed movies, as well as our video interviews with Jolie and other members of the cast.)



A Million Ways to Die in the West

33%

Some comedies fail because they’re short on gags. On the other end of the spectrum, critics say the problem with A Million Ways to Die in the West is that it has too many — writer/director/star Seth MacFarlane packs so many jokes into this Western spoof that the most inventive comic moments are often elbowed aside by scatological smuttiness. MacFarlane stars as Albert, a cowardly rancher in a wild west town who falls for Anna (Charlize Theron), who’s handy with a gun. However, Anna is married to a wanted outlaw, and soon Albert is in his crosshairs. The pundits say A Million Ways to Die in the West has an appealing cast and some really big laughs, but overall, it’s a few notches below its obvious inspiration — Mel BrooksBlazing Saddles. (Flip through our gallery of memorable Western comedies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

thriller PaleyFest sports A&E Teen Opinion cooking 2015 serial killer Mary Tyler Moore singing competition Watching Series BBC Star Wars SDCC TIFF Podcast TCA AMC First Look Superheroes Marvel Showtime police drama GLAAD Trailer Rocky Character Guide Awards BBC America Countdown TCA 2017 Grammys Cosplay 2017 Winter TV USA Toys Comedy Central Ghostbusters GoT WGN Nickelodeon biography Logo APB science fiction American Society of Cinematographers Extras NYCC Esquire Music Disney CBS Marathons Mystery crime thriller dramedy CBS All Access BET FXX harry potter OWN VH1 Exclusive Video TNT Spring TV adventure Winners HBO President Rock History Emmys Fantasy Photos discovery TCM Year in Review E! GIFs Sneak Peek 007 Star Trek Freeform TBS Cartoon Network X-Men PBS Kids & Family technology Sundance Election Fall TV Comic Book Fox News cops MTV ITV Calendar Oscars RT History Pirates LGBTQ DC Comics The CW Musicals Schedule Food Network comiccon Tumblr MSNBC CNN Reality Competition Starz VICE Hulu docudrama Certified Fresh travel period drama Biopics Interview Box Office cinemax Sci-Fi IFC boxoffice Syfy El Rey ABC Universal Tomatazos Pop 2016 Summer politics Premiere Dates aliens Animation FX TruTV Rom-Com Red Carpet Comedy Writers Guild of America CMT NBC Holidays Nominations Super Bowl Set visit Action TV Lionsgate Crackle Country Infographic sitcom Amazon war Video Games ESPN Horror Trivia crime drama Bravo Masterpiece Adult Swim based on movie DirecTV Disney Channel TV Land Reality social media Polls and Games diversity Thanksgiving Best and Worst FOX SundanceTV Drama Lifetime Netflix Martial Arts 24 frames ABC Family vampires Nat Geo Valentine's Day