Showdowns

Wes Craven Vs. John Carpenter: Who Is the Ultimate Master of Horror?

Who has the Fresher movies, bigger box office, and more terrifying moments? It's our bloodiest battle yet.

by | October 14, 2020 | Comments

One gave us Michael Myers and the Thing, the other Freddy Krueger and Ghostface – and both gave us many, many sleepless nights. But who is the king of making us quake? In our latest episode of Vs., we’re slicing and dicing the numbers to find out who is the true master of horror: John Carpenter or Wes Craven. Will it be the famed director – and killer composer – who essentially defined the slasher genre with Halloween? Or will it be Craven, who let us know that danger lurked under the stairs, in the last house on the left, and in our dreams? Our favorite Final Boy and Rotten Tomatoes contributing editor Mark Ellis is examining Tomatometer and Audience Score data, box office performance, iconic moments and characters from their films, to make a call. And if you don’t agree, have at him: He’s just putting on some Jiffy Pop right now and his phone number is… we mean, let us know in the comments!


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.


Thumbnail image: © New Line, © First Run Features

Tag Cloud

The Walking Dead cops Warner Bros. RT History based on movie medical drama Fox Searchlight Crackle Baby Yoda Mary Poppins Returns versus Quiz ID spanish Year in Review telelvision The Witch Vudu Syfy chucky renewed TV shows stop motion YouTube elevated horror Hulu space venice Holidays TV renewals Cannes vampires Watching Series Box Office Dark Horse Comics ABC animated Spring TV Hallmark Rock BBC One Emmy Nominations 93rd Oscars National Geographic TCA 2017 Lifetime child's play science fiction political drama screen actors guild Interview comic Thanksgiving Legendary Shondaland Winter TV diversity Amazon slashers Nominations anthology women cults Paramount Plus YouTube Premium CBS All Access heist movie comiccon Tarantino Sundance indie all-time BET Awards Star Trek The Arrangement Stephen King VH1 french Sneak Peek TV Land thriller 2015 The Academy christmas movies fast and furious italian Certified Fresh Hallmark Christmas movies Grammys politics finale popular Spectrum Originals Ellie Kemper anime Trivia adaptation NYCC aliens BET HBO Avengers Brie Larson spy thriller Cartoon Network docudrama Rocky Holiday 99% Marvel Studios USA Network festival indiana jones comic books Martial Arts GoT FX Valentine's Day Set visit Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt latino DGA screenings concert Sundance TV blockbuster Teen reboot toy story canceled TV shows singing competition Netflix crime Exclusive Video mockumentary BBC American Society of Cinematographers 2016 strong female leads Disney+ Disney Plus universal monsters kids X-Men archives Video Games south america spinoff Tumblr Calendar Podcast Tubi independent australia Awards Tour Black History Month cars new star wars movies police drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Heroines fresh talk show dc Epix quibi die hard Rom-Com serial killer TCM CMT sitcom dogs WGN true crime game of thrones TLC rotten cinemax documentary Song of Ice and Fire WarnerMedia Logo what to watch asian-american Pop Alien GLAAD PaleyFest ghosts Mudbound unscripted TV One Family superman blockbusters dceu FX on Hulu deadpool disaster scorecard psychological thriller Western Countdown NBC Fantasy supernatural sports PBS 45 hidden camera travel Comic Book 2017 Pixar Apple TV+ Superheroes dramedy See It Skip It Election Amazon Studios teaser DC Universe Hear Us Out cancelled TV series festivals sequel saw franchise spider-man Starz SDCC Creative Arts Emmys rotten movies we love hispanic zero dark thirty sag awards Arrowverse VOD Premiere Dates Toys E! Fox News technology 2021 theme song robots HBO Go ratings natural history Bravo high school nbcuniversal comics name the review video TBS Black Mirror Star Wars laika children's TV ITV ABC Signature IFC kong joker Country Pet Sematary Ghostbusters A&E Nickelodeon 71st Emmy Awards Marathons 24 frames book adaptation Summer directors Music ABC Family Elton John Classic Film zombie YA Shudder black GIFs TruTV The CW richard e. Grant Lucasfilm superhero President documentaries 20th Century Fox boxing Marvel Television 4/20 Marvel remakes USA Emmys news cartoon golden globe awards discovery harry potter canceled LGBT Super Bowl emmy awards Musical Turner TV Lifetime Christmas movies television spain james bond breaking bad Biopics halloween tv 2018 historical drama Trophy Talk Musicals game show Rocketman Red Carpet Chilling Adventures of Sabrina boxoffice book crime drama video on demand Britbox OneApp casting Chernobyl Paramount comedies FXX TCA jamie lee curtis SundanceTV Cosplay biography Film witnail crime thriller nfl Disney worst movies TNT Tomatazos films Oscars HBO Max Columbia Pictures Awards obituary 2020 Women's History Month pirates of the caribbean SXSW The Purge Showtime a nightmare on elm street football CW Seed Funimation Horror nature Discovery Channel Photos Schedule war zombies DirecTV Best and Worst 2019 Television Academy Disney Channel cancelled television mutant APB Food Network Winners Adult Swim kaiju Nat Geo miniseries critics Masterpiece Comedy Central Peacock cats Universal Superheroe CNN razzies CBS ViacomCBS foreign Mary poppins worst BAFTA series Sci-Fi TCA Awards Endgame adventure psycho hollywood composers VICE parents Amazon Prime Video reviews best Polls and Games Comedy TIFF batman OWN stoner romance justice league scary movies Mindy Kaling PlayStation Binge Guide Trailer Kids & Family Infographic transformers Pride Month cancelled Travel Channel Spike A24 DC streaming service El Rey Mystery hist dragons First Reviews Lionsgate trailers revenge Disney streaming service Television Critics Association prank New York Comic Con Animation criterion Action LGBTQ Amazon Prime mission: impossible sequels FOX Netflix Christmas movies monster movies toronto Anna Paquin Broadway doctor who Reality jurassic park green book MCU spanish language First Look Turner Classic Movies Extras docuseries dark Reality Competition facebook twilight MSNBC IFC Films Christmas rt archives stand-up comedy Opinion E3 king kong Disney Plus RT21 romantic comedy History Acorn TV satire Comics on TV werewolf Film Festival TCA Winter 2020 007 free movies movies Walt Disney Pictures MTV YouTube Red AMC Fall TV streaming Apple TV Plus Sony Pictures period drama godzilla Freeform DC Comics Pop TV japanese halloween Pirates Ovation golden globes rom-coms binge 72 Emmy Awards social media cooking ESPN Mary Tyler Moore 21st Century Fox Character Guide Paramount Network Drama Crunchyroll The Walt Disney Company BBC America movie classics Esquire Sundance Now crossover Captain marvel Apple Academy Awards cancelled TV shows San Diego Comic-Con blaxploitation award winner Writers Guild of America tv talk