UK Critics Consensus: Indifference For Defiance, Whilst Slumdog Millionaire Shines

Plus, UK Scribes Enjoy Both Role Models & Sex Drive

by | January 9, 2009 | Comments

A trip to the cinema is a sure-fire way to beat the January blues, but which film should you be shelling out to see? Vying for your pennies this weekend we have Daniel Craig in non-Bond mode for the WWII epic Defiance. Already a big festival hit, Danny Boyle‘s Slumdog Millionaire finally hits the UK cinemas, as do two US comedies in the Apatow-vein, Role Models and Sex Drive. So what did the British critics have to say?

Defiance tells the incredible true story of the Bielski brothers, a trio of Jewish resistance fighters in Belarus, who saved thousands of lives through their actions in WWII. Directed by Edward Zwick and starring Daniel Craig, Jamie Bell and Liev Schreiber, Defiance is an all-action epic with an amazing true story at it’s heart, but it has split the critics. Currently standing at 52% on the Tomatometer, most critics were wowed by the previously rarely heard story, but felt the production was let down by clichéd narrative, drab cinematography and an all-round muddled approach to the central story. Xan Brooks of The Guardian summed up the general consensus:

Defiance makes a noise but leaves no echo. It feels progressively more bogus and less significant the further it recedes from view, and myths are meant to wax in the memory, not wane.”

Danny Boyle has been a stalwart of British cinema since breaking onto the scene first with Shallow Grave, then the critically acclaimed Trainspotting. Always defying convention, Boyle has tried his hand at many genres, and has now turned his eye to Bollywood, with his Mumbai-set Slumdog Millionaire. With no Rotten ratings compiled from the UK reviews, Slumdog proudly stands at a very healthy, and Certified Fresh, 94% on the Tomatometer. There was universal praise for its uplifting tone, inspirational fairytale story, and stunning use of location and setting. Rob Daniel, Sky Movies, said about the film:

“Hard hearts may balk at the unashamed sentiment, black and white morality, and question-flashback contrivances, but let them eat pie and mash: this is a tangy banquet of smile-on-the-face feel good.”

Role Models and Sex Drive hit the UK cinemas this week both boasting impressive current US-comedy pedigree. Role Models stars Paul Rudd, Seann William-Scott and Christopher Mintz-Plasse (AKA McLovin of Superbad fame) in a comedy about two thirty-something slackers on community service, whilst Sex Drive features Clark Duke, James Marsden and Seth Green in a teen coming-of-age road movie. Role Models is currently faring better on the Tomatometer at a Certified Fresh 76%, whilst Sex Drive is lagging behind at 42% overall, but both films tallied a similar number of fresh ratings with the UK critics, so if a laugh-out-loud comedy is what you are looking for this weekend, you are spoilt for choice. Nigel Andrews of The Financial Times said of the two films:

“Neither film wins a prize for visual style. Each deserves one for clever gags and zanily zig-zagging dialogue.”

Quote Of The Week

“This unfunny studio comedy is so downright demeaning I ended up hating not only it but my entire gender — and most specifically myself for secretly quite wanting to watch it.”

Bride Wars

Larushka Ivan-Zadeh, Metro.

Tag Cloud

supernatural italian space jamie lee curtis History Oscars spain Acorn TV Animation 45 Warner Bros. Tubi 4/20 science fiction blockbuster Endgame twilight CBS sequel DGA National Geographic football Trailer TLC dogs Hallmark video on demand A&E revenge comedies sitcom Pixar APB Apple TV Plus hist comiccon Certified Fresh Tumblr 20th Century Fox A24 TNT FXX spinoff award winner ITV Thanksgiving Crackle NBC Paramount Network cats quibi Spike SXSW ABC Family GoT Amazon Prime Video Black Mirror TCA Awards werewolf stoner crime Amazon Hear Us Out sag awards Nickelodeon justice league christmas movies binge venice Disney Television Critics Association boxoffice Showtime what to watch Travel Channel Walt Disney Pictures HBO Max Superheroe medical drama President Masterpiece 2019 Hallmark Christmas movies Comedy Central cooking miniseries Mudbound zombies Holiday Vudu Film Festival critics Countdown die hard Song of Ice and Fire social media cinemax RT History zero dark thirty Podcast spy thriller Baby Yoda Pride Month worst movies LGBT Photos Fantasy TCA 2017 japanese dc E! Trophy Talk 2016 TruTV archives batman franchise Sci-Fi spider-man TV Land rotten movies we love Music renewed TV shows criterion Sneak Peek OWN Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con war cops El Rey Best and Worst Set visit Logo USA natural history TCA Winter 2020 series universal monsters animated Nominations Netflix WGN teaser TBS Arrowverse VOD Amazon Studios canceled TV shows Lucasfilm BET Awards ghosts streaming Emmys Epix adaptation Sundance TV Creative Arts Emmys Academy Awards breaking bad television ESPN finale 99% USA Network crime thriller TCM Cosplay Awards Tour Lifetime cults news Bravo best Western reboot Rock Toys Tarantino BBC America rotten all-time foreign dark TV renewals laika Disney Plus TCA emmy awards comics Winners Country 2017 diversity Sundance boxing slashers harry potter richard e. Grant comic toy story Food Network American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Red Interview psycho BAFTA Election Heroines HBO Go talk show screenings DirecTV fast and furious Universal docudrama aliens psychological thriller Syfy The Arrangement historical drama Brie Larson CNN Elton John PaleyFest comic books IFC Films crime drama green book joker Ellie Kemper First Look Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ratings cancelled nature Red Carpet Rom-Com VICE Musical travel BET indiana jones CBS All Access canceled australia Reality Infographic SDCC scary movies Marathons YA rt archives game show Mary Poppins Returns MCU Grammys adventure Women's History Month Starz sports Watching Series worst classics movies Black History Month casting DC streaming service Biopics mockumentary mutant romantic comedy Christmas toronto dramedy vampires blaxploitation PlayStation Super Bowl GLAAD Family dragons Mystery composers Disney+ Disney Plus cartoon romance festival fresh Classic Film Mary Tyler Moore politics IFC Reality Competition golden globes halloween tv Chernobyl hispanic Winter TV Schedule Musicals FX Lionsgate witnail independent superhero thriller Drama WarnerMedia TV french mission: impossible remakes true crime nbcuniversal Pop TV name the review Marvel Television Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dceu Tomatazos strong female leads MTV Mindy Kaling police drama Turner Classic Movies Superheroes james bond Year in Review tv talk a nightmare on elm street singing competition X-Men black based on movie 71st Emmy Awards BBC ID Rocky 21st Century Fox Star Wars Columbia Pictures Freeform MSNBC 2018 HBO Sony Pictures Netflix Christmas movies Character Guide LGBTQ cars Apple TV+ stand-up comedy Shudder Marvel Pirates YouTube serial killer The Walking Dead Crunchyroll Trivia Ovation PBS parents crossover Funimation See It Skip It Britbox Amazon Prime Spectrum Originals kids Summer directors Comics on TV sequels Comedy festivals Paramount Apple technology FX on Hulu halloween deadpool YouTube Premium versus zombie Fox News Extras Fox Searchlight reviews Anna Paquin OneApp FOX Mary poppins cancelled television 007 Box Office Holidays Film documentaries RT21 SundanceTV Disney streaming service book E3 indie Spring TV cancelled TV shows The CW VH1 child's play facebook Writers Guild of America satire Lifetime Christmas movies The Purge children's TV Captain marvel Avengers anthology hollywood Quiz Rocketman free movies scorecard NYCC The Academy period drama Valentine's Day Esquire video Video Games 72 Emmy Awards CW Seed discovery ABC documentary Comic Book Calendar Awards Stephen King 2015 elevated horror Pet Sematary doctor who cancelled TV series game of thrones First Reviews Cartoon Network chucky Premiere Dates Alien GIFs Television Academy The Witch south america stop motion Turner biography Action anime Ghostbusters asian-american Opinion Discovery Channel Star Trek nfl Kids & Family screen actors guild DC Comics Dark Horse Comics robots obituary CMT theme song Marvel Studios Emmy Nominations movie Adult Swim Martial Arts DC Universe New York Comic Con concert Peacock transformers AMC Horror Pop spanish language films Polls and Games latino Disney Channel political drama disaster spanish unscripted Shondaland 2020 TIFF Nat Geo Fall TV BBC One Teen Hulu Cannes 24 frames Binge Guide