UK Critics Consensus: Indifference For Defiance, Whilst Slumdog Millionaire Shines

Plus, UK Scribes Enjoy Both Role Models & Sex Drive

by | January 9, 2009 | Comments

A trip to the cinema is a sure-fire way to beat the January blues, but which film should you be shelling out to see? Vying for your pennies this weekend we have Daniel Craig in non-Bond mode for the WWII epic Defiance. Already a big festival hit, Danny Boyle‘s Slumdog Millionaire finally hits the UK cinemas, as do two US comedies in the Apatow-vein, Role Models and Sex Drive. So what did the British critics have to say?

Defiance tells the incredible true story of the Bielski brothers, a trio of Jewish resistance fighters in Belarus, who saved thousands of lives through their actions in WWII. Directed by Edward Zwick and starring Daniel Craig, Jamie Bell and Liev Schreiber, Defiance is an all-action epic with an amazing true story at it’s heart, but it has split the critics. Currently standing at 52% on the Tomatometer, most critics were wowed by the previously rarely heard story, but felt the production was let down by clichéd narrative, drab cinematography and an all-round muddled approach to the central story. Xan Brooks of The Guardian summed up the general consensus:

Defiance makes a noise but leaves no echo. It feels progressively more bogus and less significant the further it recedes from view, and myths are meant to wax in the memory, not wane.”

Danny Boyle has been a stalwart of British cinema since breaking onto the scene first with Shallow Grave, then the critically acclaimed Trainspotting. Always defying convention, Boyle has tried his hand at many genres, and has now turned his eye to Bollywood, with his Mumbai-set Slumdog Millionaire. With no Rotten ratings compiled from the UK reviews, Slumdog proudly stands at a very healthy, and Certified Fresh, 94% on the Tomatometer. There was universal praise for its uplifting tone, inspirational fairytale story, and stunning use of location and setting. Rob Daniel, Sky Movies, said about the film:

“Hard hearts may balk at the unashamed sentiment, black and white morality, and question-flashback contrivances, but let them eat pie and mash: this is a tangy banquet of smile-on-the-face feel good.”

Role Models and Sex Drive hit the UK cinemas this week both boasting impressive current US-comedy pedigree. Role Models stars Paul Rudd, Seann William-Scott and Christopher Mintz-Plasse (AKA McLovin of Superbad fame) in a comedy about two thirty-something slackers on community service, whilst Sex Drive features Clark Duke, James Marsden and Seth Green in a teen coming-of-age road movie. Role Models is currently faring better on the Tomatometer at a Certified Fresh 76%, whilst Sex Drive is lagging behind at 42% overall, but both films tallied a similar number of fresh ratings with the UK critics, so if a laugh-out-loud comedy is what you are looking for this weekend, you are spoilt for choice. Nigel Andrews of The Financial Times said of the two films:

“Neither film wins a prize for visual style. Each deserves one for clever gags and zanily zig-zagging dialogue.”

Quote Of The Week

“This unfunny studio comedy is so downright demeaning I ended up hating not only it but my entire gender — and most specifically myself for secretly quite wanting to watch it.”

Bride Wars

Larushka Ivan-Zadeh, Metro.

Tag Cloud

Rock AMC aliens biopic Quiz Broadway Tomatazos Universal marvel cinematic universe X-Men LGBTQ Marvel Image Comics screen actors guild The Purge crime thriller hispanic heritage month dreamworks archives anime Elton John New York Comic Con Comedy Central cancelled television dc theme song 007 Hallmark Dark Horse Comics BBC America discovery The Walking Dead 2017 WarnerMedia name the review critic resources comiccon Oscars Box Office series Acorn TV TCA 2017 BET lord of the rings dexter Apple TV Plus films fresh comic book movies Comics on TV San Diego Comic-Con OWN 2021 TV Land laika aapi Sundance new zealand Oscar crime Universal Pictures strong female leads stand-up comedy cancelled TV shows quibi TBS Mindy Kaling Hollywood Foreign Press Association video on demand witnail E! reboot American Society of Cinematographers Peacock Best Director DC Comics kong 72 Emmy Awards Chernobyl satire heist movie police drama sports Sundance Now latino TV movies nbcuniversal Ovation Disney+ Disney Plus worst movies Paramount Pictures YouTube Premium Captain marvel Superheroes halloween tv tv talk Biopics Set visit live event wonder woman Ellie Kemper Cartoon Network CNN saw revenge stop motion Nickelodeon justice league Lifetime 2018 anthology spanish zero dark thirty DGA joker golden globe awards romantic comedy halloween trophy christmas movies Lucasfilm Super Bowl kaiju gangster scary movies Martial Arts rt archives Crackle hollywood Freeform foreign Rocketman rotten movies we love Binge Guide television TCM italian Crunchyroll natural history Marvel Television game show elevated horror dark action-comedy Food Network teaser E3 young adult Paramount SundanceTV war APB versus high school NBA 2019 Tags: Comedy toronto LGBT mob obituary VOD transformers GoT japanese VICE CBS All Access batman HBO Go Paramount Network Classic Film DirecTV Indigenous space singing competition black comedy A24 book adaptation First Look National Geographic Podcast Sony Pictures CW Seed The CW Pacific Islander comedies Amazon Pirates 21st Century Fox Awards festivals true crime Prime Video Sundance TV breaking bad award winner marvel comics classics Wes Anderson Exclusive Video die hard travel target scene in color children's TV IFC Hear Us Out Toys FOX 93rd Oscars WGN Reality Competition boxoffice zombie pirates of the caribbean Infographic harry potter Sony medical drama Television Academy HFPA comic book movie Disney Channel Sneak Peek Song of Ice and Fire ratings Trivia Women's History Month boxing Baby Yoda Action streaming Summer football Starz El Rey werewolf VH1 ABC Signature rotten rom-coms green book DC streaming service MCU scene in color film series Turner Classic Movies facebook Shondaland documentary 20th Century Fox Superheroe feel good 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards political drama what to watch south america hist 99% scorecard Fargo french broadcast Television Critics Association robots vampires independent Rom-Com psychological thriller canceled TV shows 24 frames fast and furious The Academy king arthur comics prank book festival indiana jones Year in Review streaming movies sitcom zombies Valentine's Day hidden camera jurassic park international Country australia First Reviews spy thriller Apple comic books casting Discovery Channel binge genre Mudbound spider-man asian-american summer TV Mystery Music Red Carpet toy story free movies BAFTA Pride Month 1990s Drama NBC TV See It Skip It BET Awards TV One Instagram Live 79th Golden Globes Awards rt labs mockumentary spinoff 45 posters Nat Geo deadpool richard e. Grant Marvel Studios Grammys interviews Marathons YouTube social media Sci-Fi cats leaderboard Tubi spain History Amazon Studios Logo TCA Winter 2020 art house Native cops Premiere Dates mutant docudrama know your critic AMC Plus Extras chucky child's play politics technology YouTube Red venice Photos SXSW GIFs GLAAD ViacomCBS twilight renewed TV shows Heroines 71st Emmy Awards Pet Sematary Western Tarantino Christmas diversity obi wan IFC Films cooking OneApp Mary Tyler Moore ESPN Esquire Star Wars Cosplay finale Travel Channel Britbox BBC One canceled based on movie Anna Paquin blockbusters movie MGM Musical franchise SXSW 2022 Hulu Vudu movies Avengers Black History Month indie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Adult Swim Holiday Lionsgate nfl Arrowverse Watching Series MSNBC Family Animation Tumblr dogs Opinion scary vs. Calendar South by Southwest Film Festival RT21 olympics Hallmark Christmas movies Amazon Prime Video The Witch Teen mission: impossible Endgame slasher Warner Bros. disaster target Best and Worst cancelled TV series FX superman Winners TruTV sopranos CBS legend PBS Awards Tour 2020 summer preview composers Stephen King Netflix ABC Family popular Best Actor Rocky trailers TV renewals Focus Features Schedule historical drama cancelled CMT stoner doctor who cartoon spanish language Emmys a nightmare on elm street Comic-Con@Home 2021 Best Picture USA 73rd Emmy Awards Tokyo Olympics TCA Awards universal monsters james bond Nominations adenture golden globes Apple TV+ directors all-time Horror king kong basketball Showtime adaptation concert Trailer Pop TV hispanic SDCC nature news monster movies unscripted USA Network Character Guide science fiction BBC sequels Countdown YA slashers A&E Fox Searchlight sag awards Paramount Plus Thanksgiving blaxploitation animated Neflix sequel The Arrangement streamig TLC Brie Larson psycho Film Festival Walt Disney Pictures debate miniseries Disney japan Best Actress Spike Fall TV women NYCC TIFF reviews FX on Hulu Kids & Family IMDb TV ID Funimation rt labs critics edition ITV scene in color series 94th Oscars ghosts Polls and Games Interview FXX dramedy Video Games Emmy Nominations 2015 cinemax black Comedy Bravo Star Trek telelvision romance Certified Fresh Fantasy dragons video Lifetime Christmas movies Disney streaming service Disney Plus Fox News royal family Cannes blockbuster Mary Poppins Returns Ghostbusters spider-verse thriller Amazon Prime Mary poppins Netflix Christmas movies crossover best 2016 Syfy criterion godzilla critics Masterpiece Alien Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TNT HBO Max supernatural Star Wars Celebration PaleyFest Academy Awards kids comic mcc Black Mirror period drama PlayStation Reality President Epix Legendary game of thrones ABC documentaries HBO suspense Spring TV jamie lee curtis worst Holidays crime drama Shudder dceu Spectrum Originals remakes Pixar cults cars TCA biography Geeked Week razzies adventure Columbia Pictures Turner parents summer TV preview RT History serial killer Pop 90s superhero 4/20 MTV Trophy Talk Election screenings Creative Arts Emmys docuseries Comic Book live action new star wars movies new york scene in color talk show Film Writers Guild of America Musicals DC Universe emmy awards The Walt Disney Company Winter TV