This Is Us Fans Tell Kate Not To Blame Herself for Jack's Death, But Should She?

Do you suspect Jack died a different way? Take our poll.

by | March 8, 2017 | Comments

Even by This Is Us standards, which is a three hankie minimum every week, “What Now?” was an emotional episode. Everyone knew William (Ron Cephas Jones)’s memorial would be powerful, but probably didn’t expect all the extra baggage it unleashed.


The service brought back Kate (Chrissy Metz)’s painful memories of Jack (Milo Ventimiglia)’s death, for one. The bride-to-be finally told her fiancé, Toby (Chris Sullivan), the heartbreaking reason she avoids talking about her father’s passing: She feels it’s her fault.

Earlier in the episode, young Kate (Mackenzie Hancsicsak) sensed the turmoil in Jack and Rebecca (Mandy Moore)’s marriage. In the car, she told Jack to try to work it out. But in the final scene of the episode, it appears Jack’s decision to fight for his marriage came at a bad time. He looks visibly drunk as he gets into his car, and the promo for the season finale hints at an automobile accident.

Immediately, Team Kate on Twitter jumped to her defense:

Perhaps more importantly, Jack of all people certainly wouldn’t want Kate feeling this way:

Some fans noticed the foreshadowing earlier in the episode:

Others are awaiting confirmation about what actually happened in the season finale next week. This Is Us confirmed five episodes in that Jack was not alive in 2016 (and hinted at his fate in the series premiere). We’ve seen glimpses of his funeral, but the show still hasn’t confirmed when it happened. Each week has contained a pretty major twist reveal, but maybe the biggest twist of all would be if the show kept fans in the dark about his fate until next season.

Then again, fans of This Is Us know there could always be another twist. Scarlett Splane, below, even noticed some behind-the-scenes photos of Jack meeting Rebecca again.

One thing is for sure, Kate and Jack’s relationship seems pretty universal:

And it wouldn’t be This Is Us without plenty of tears:

The season finale of This Is Us airs Tuesday, March 14 at 9/8C on NBC

[socialpoll id=”2425528″]

Tag Cloud

art house archives black comedy Photos YouTube Premium APB zombie Superheroes anthology boxing blockbuster Baby Yoda Country Discovery Channel Women's History Month MCU all-time a nightmare on elm street cars Film Festival docudrama VH1 CW Seed Marvel Rom-Com vs. Food Network asian-american SundanceTV thriller ratings President hist Disney Channel screenings Musical Broadway biography ViacomCBS crime thriller comiccon GoT versus Apple nature Marvel Studios facebook cartoon DC Comics IFC Films Paramount Network Pop blaxploitation Character Guide Box Office fresh ghosts BBC One Shondaland robots justice league Mary Poppins Returns TruTV Sundance period drama BET Image Comics movies Paramount psychological thriller rotten movies we love war halloween tv Fox News YouTube Comic Book lord of the rings Reality Competition 45 Rocketman Interview WarnerMedia movie boxoffice History Musicals canceled TV shows cops Columbia Pictures cooking ESPN FX HBO remakes Schedule telelvision Esquire Paramount Plus NBA animated hollywood Sundance TV TV movies Netflix Christmas movies TCA Winter 2020 Exclusive Video quibi ITV TLC rotten theme song scene in color razzies Lucasfilm Black History Month 71st Emmy Awards Crunchyroll mutant Mindy Kaling Avengers Red Carpet Premiere Dates mcc travel toy story black See It Skip It Holidays 93rd Oscars fast and furious Horror Ellie Kemper marvel cinematic universe police drama tv talk Mudbound Marvel Television Wes Anderson royal family PlayStation what to watch based on movie critics Winners VOD Instagram Live Freeform Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Turner Year in Review Adult Swim live action Animation twilight politics concert TCA Awards criterion FOX 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards supernatural Walt Disney Pictures San Diego Comic-Con wonder woman BBC Legendary Sony Pictures Super Bowl Warner Bros. Universal Emmy Nominations joker Thanksgiving Captain marvel adenture Bravo dramedy CBS All Access game show Calendar 007 Disney streaming service AMC Plus kaiju USA Network 2017 Watching Series dreamworks cancelled teaser spinoff TV renewals PaleyFest LGBTQ El Rey Cartoon Network nfl monster movies CNN cancelled television Western Marathons feel good cancelled TV series Sneak Peek ABC Spike TV 2016 australia vampires slashers Academy Awards rom-coms deadpool Disney finale DC streaming service Starz DGA dceu Ovation target 2018 political drama Countdown 2020 independent ABC Signature Trailer E! 2015 spanish language X-Men Opinion toronto National Geographic 72 Emmy Awards Vudu IFC NBC FXX documentaries young adult 2021 Peacock BBC America Masterpiece chucky unscripted 1990s Neflix international Crackle binge Fox Searchlight Quiz SDCC live event Fantasy HBO Go japan harry potter comic book movie rt archives emmy awards Kids & Family Hulu Anna Paquin child's play parents king kong Arrowverse dc Shudder comic books Disney+ Disney Plus Christmas debate Creative Arts Emmys Song of Ice and Fire New York Comic Con historical drama Lifetime Christmas movies Disney Plus best french breaking bad Black Mirror book Set visit Trophy Talk social media Comedy Comics on TV Travel Channel scary movies Cannes south america CMT GIFs RT History Television Academy mission: impossible Tubi Pixar Rocky revenge Pride Month composers MTV Turner Classic Movies video rt labs halloween sequels basketball streaming movies hispanic screen actors guild indie TBS Grammys ID Hallmark Christmas movies kong LGBT YouTube Red Trivia Pacific Islander Mary poppins First Look Logo The Purge DC Universe zombies godzilla dogs science fiction directors crossover Amazon Prime Video Sci-Fi stop motion Action Dark Horse Comics Emmys true crime suspense documentary spider-verse 99% A&E casting Star Trek hispanic heritage month Tomatazos mob American Society of Cinematographers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cancelled TV shows Tarantino RT21 venice Sundance Now prank VICE OneApp Reality Winter TV zero dark thirty Awards legend christmas movies sports cinemax aapi Summer stand-up comedy Election nbcuniversal The Witch Toys Hallmark genre saw Pet Sematary docuseries ABC Family TCA 2017 20th Century Fox worst james bond laika reviews Video Games Endgame posters festivals Mary Tyler Moore richard e. Grant YA transformers Alien golden globe awards BAFTA Valentine's Day blockbusters elevated horror Tumblr Pop TV jamie lee curtis heist movie TV One high school Heroines FX on Hulu PBS game of thrones gangster doctor who Podcast First Reviews discovery foreign canceled Apple TV+ cults 21st Century Fox strong female leads DirecTV Fall TV action-comedy comic Film Elton John Binge Guide worst movies TIFF space satire Lionsgate talk show comics WGN technology AMC italian disaster USA Family spider-man renewed TV shows dark 73rd Emmy Awards die hard biopic trailers natural history crime drama Oscars singing competition Funimation Comic-Con@Home 2021 The CW Rock kids women The Arrangement OWN spain adaptation reboot series romance comedies The Walking Dead scary superman hidden camera video on demand The Walt Disney Company olympics IMDb TV universal monsters golden globes Television Critics Association Acorn TV superhero know your critic obituary Polls and Games Universal Pictures Fargo SXSW Superheroe Certified Fresh Nominations king arthur comic book movies Holiday cats GLAAD dragons rt labs critics edition franchise HBO Max Teen Drama Netflix green book sopranos 24 frames Hear Us Out award winner japanese football Showtime popular films Spring TV werewolf latino Biopics spy thriller Martial Arts adventure TCM medical drama miniseries TV Land news Amazon NYCC Chernobyl name the review psycho Nat Geo stoner Comedy Central Classic Film TNT The Academy Spectrum Originals Apple TV Plus critic resources 2019 Mystery jurassic park classics Ghostbusters batman Epix romantic comedy indiana jones Extras Stephen King 4/20 dexter slasher streaming MSNBC Syfy Infographic TCA 90s Cosplay Nickelodeon Lifetime anime E3 Tokyo Olympics Star Wars festival Music scorecard diversity new zealand A24 aliens Amazon Studios Writers Guild of America new star wars movies crime serial killer sequel new york free movies Awards Tour sag awards Amazon Prime mockumentary Best and Worst book adaptation children's TV CBS television witnail Britbox sitcom Brie Larson Pirates BET Awards marvel comics spanish pirates of the caribbean