The Witcher First Reviews: Henry Cavill Is at His Monster-Fighting Best

Netflix's new fantasy series brings loads grit and gore, but might disappoint its die-hard franchise fanbase.

by | December 20, 2019 | Comments


Henry Cavill has replaced the iconic Man of Steel cape with some sleek white locks and a shiny, sharp sword in Netflix’s new fantasy series, The Witcher. Based on the popular stories by Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski, which spawned the wildly popular video game series, the eight-episode first season follows the story of swordsman-for-hire Geralt of Rivia, whose supernatural skills come in handy for profession: hunting monsters. In the series, the solitary warrior seeks princess-in-exile Ciri (Freya Allan) and runs across sorceress Yennefer (Anya Chalotra), who is just discovering her powers at the outset of season 1.

As with most recent genre shows of this ilk, comparisons have already been made to Game of Thrones. Netflix has already seen value in their highly-anticipated series and renewed The Witcher for a second season in November. A studio’s confidence and noteworthy buzz can work wonders for a fledgling program such as this. But has Netflix’s bet paid off? Will The Witcher scratch that White Walker itch? And is the Cavill-starrer strong enough to hack-and-slash its way through the ever-cluttered realm of Peak TV to make an impact?

Here’s what critics are saying about The Witcher.


HOW DOES IT COMPARE TO THE BOOKS?

Yennifer in The Witcher (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

Fans of the books and the game are likely to have a field day with the swarm of character references throughout, and whilst it’s paying fan service with how casually these names are mentioned, general unversed audiences may need to pay a bit more closer attention, especially when Cavill is speaking as his low growl can often be inaudible.  —Peter Gray, This Is Film

The problem is, there’s very little reason to get invested enough to attempt to make sense of the whole thing. From the jump, in the very first episode, characters constantly yammer at Geralt about “destiny” this and “destiny” that, which isn’t nearly as interesting in 2019 as it might have been in the 1980s when the stories were originally published. Even if you love the original stories and books, they’re remixed and altered here to the point that they often no longer make sense. —Michael Rougeau, GameSpot

In faithfully adapting the book it brings with it some questionable elements, but it at least adapts these tales with a more modern sensibility.   —Kambole Campbell, Little White Lies

Indeed, the one thing that I worry viewers might dislike about The Witcher is that without a strong knowledge of the books, or at least a good grasp on fantasy fiction in general, this show might require some hard work. Game of Thrones is, quite simply, easier to get into.  — Erik Kain, Forbes


DOES HENRY CAVILL SLAY?

The Witcher, Henry Cavill as Geralt of Rivia (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

Henry Cavill’s character … could scan as a spin on the actor’s most notable prior role. Monster hunter Geralt of Rivia resembles a reclusive medieval Superman—all principle, brawn, and jawline—clad in a white wig and cat-like contact lenses. But rather than reheating the Man of Steel, Cavill quickly melts into Geralt, capturing his aloof yet winsome confidence with sardonic one-liners and baritone grunts. —Niv M. Sultan, Slant Magazine

Thankfully, Cavill as Geralt is beyond anything I expected. While this is a testament to Cavill’s acting, its also because of his ability to nail the physicality that the role deserves.   —Kate Sanchez, But Why Tho

Cavill delights in every grimace as his grimy, sour Geralt traverses locales familiar to any Dungeons & Dragons campaign. Candle-strewn taverns, pornographic wizard illusions, and foolish nobles—no matter the job, Geralt perseveres in true Lawful Neutral form (to keep things in D&D terms). A bemused yet not unkind cynicism comes across in Cavill’s slow baritone and rare, slight smile. It’s the best he’s been aside from The Man from U.N.C.L.E. and everyone either hates him or is horny for him.  — Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine


READ ALSO: Henry Cavill on Why He Had To Play the Witcher


HOW’S THE REST OF THE CAST?

The Witcher keyart Yennifer, Geralt, Ciri (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

Showrunner Lauren Hissrich and executive producer Tomek Baginski really knocked the casting out of the park with this series. Henry Cavill, Anya Chalotra, Freya Allan, and Joey Batey all bring the necessary gruff, edge, and charm of their famous characters to life throughout the series, and they contrast incredibly well with each other once they all get a chance to unite on screen.   —Matthew Aguilar, comicbook

While Cavill is the famous face, it’s actually a three-lead show with three distinct storylines, co-starring the Anya Chalotra as the trainee witch Yennefer, and Freya Allan as Ciri, a fugitive teen princess. These two young women are much more interesting than Geralt, partly because they have solid character arcs, but mostly because Henry Cavill is a block of beautifully carved wood.  — Gavia Baker-Whitelaw, Daily Dot


HOW DETAILED IS THE WORLD-BUILDING?

The Witcher, s1, ep 3 (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

The production design does look impressive and you really get the sense that money is being fired at this to give it every possible opportunity. The difference, however, is that while ‘The Witcher’ may exist in a fantastical world, you can never really shake the feeling that you’re looking at a set, or that you’ve seen some of this before.   —Brian Lloyd, entertainment.ie

There’s not quite enough fully developed characters to make this feel like a big ensemble show like “Thrones,” and so we crave a single center of gravity. The decentralized aspect of “The Witcher,” instead, emphasizes certain faults, like how Cavill doesn’t quite embody the Han Solo aspect of his roguish-hero role enough to hold the screen fully.   —Daniel D’Addario, Variety


HOW ARE ITS FIGHT SCENES?

Renfri and Geralt in in The Witcher (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

One fight sequence towards the end of episode one is quite special, seemingly achieved in one unbroken take and with Cavill visibly involved, instead of a stunt double. —Rohan Naahar, Hindustan Times

Violence and sexuality are both major components of the source material, and The Witcher certainly doesn’t skimp in either category. The aforementioned carving up of the village riffraff is gruesome, as are Geralt’s frequent encounters with all manner of sinister creatures, and there’s no shortage of bare bodies on display.  —Brent Hankins, Lamplight Review

That’s the real star of The Witcher: the fight scenes. Filled with terrifying monsters, brutal thugs, and shots lifted straight from classic horror movies, each battle has been so stylishly executed, they almost feel sensual. The Witcher’s fight scenes aren’t merely good enough to be entertaining, they’re “make you scream like you’re at a playoff game” great.   — Kayla Cobb, Decider

Where The Witcher succeeds is in its action sequences. A face-off between the super-human Geralt and a Lovecraftian nightmare in a crumbling castle is gruesome and fast-paced. And a struggle between the anti-hero and his lover (Emma Appleton) is appropriately heart-rending. If you like this sort of thing, it’s worth putting up with the bleary plot and dialogue just to get from one confrontation to the next.   — Ed Power, Daily Telegraph (UK)


WAIT, IS IT SUPPOSED TO BE FUNNY?

Henry Cavill as Geralt of Rivia in The Witcher (Netflix)
(Photo by Netflix)

Worse, the wink, wink nature of the oddly misplaced humor makes clear that the writers are clearly trying to have their cake and eat it too, which comes off like an eleven-year-old who’s satisfied enough by dipping a finger into the frosting before licking it off instead of making an actual meal.   —Andrew Bundy, The Playlist

“The Witcher” has a lighthearted sense of humor — another difference between it and “Game of Thrones,” whose jokes landed with the force of tankards slammed on oaken boards. We’re not talking high comedy, but you could do worse than watching Cavill, as Geralt, pour out his troubles to his horse, the only creature the Witcher will really open up to.   — Mike Hale, New York Times

#1
Adjusted Score: 72.503%
Critics Consensus: Though the world of The Witcher at times feels only half-formed, Henry Cavill brings brawny charisma to a series teeming with subversive fantasy elements and dark humor.
Synopsis: Geralt of Rivia, a mutated monster-hunter for hire, journeys toward his destiny in a turbulent world where people often prove... [More]
Directed By: Tomasz Baginski

Tag Cloud

Pet Sematary comic romantic comedy docudrama Endgame harry potter Tomatazos 2017 Country Dark Horse Comics crime drama children's TV Ghostbusters comiccon GIFs space psycho festivals Cannes DC streaming service The CW Musicals quibi Best and Worst National Geographic book comics Television Academy Fall TV justice league MCU Rom-Com canceled TV shows Lifetime cartoon Freeform Opinion cancelled GoT Schedule kids Family Year in Review 2015 directors politics Netflix Netflix Christmas movies Winners dramedy FXX blockbuster halloween RT History Extras American Society of Cinematographers USA nature award winner police drama Ellie Kemper sequel science fiction Thanksgiving A&E Film Festival Western BBC The Purge Columbia Pictures Photos Superheroes cars cinemax Sundance Now Calendar Amazon Prime Lifetime Christmas movies Marvel Television TCM Comics on TV joker christmas movies HBO NBC Oscars VICE vampires binge toy story Mary Poppins Returns TV Land travel 45 crime thriller cooking Superheroe Avengers crime Peacock Podcast TCA Winter 2020 Paramount Network boxoffice Stephen King true crime zombie Countdown Esquire Disney Animation Disney Channel Sundance TV Pride Month Discovery Channel Shondaland sitcom Spike Britbox Hallmark cats versus GLAAD CNN Epix Box Office DC Universe Logo Lionsgate casting CMT Reality Competition mutant Summer screen actors guild spider-man NYCC war anthology Tubi Hallmark Christmas movies dc green book LGBTQ Writers Guild of America Martial Arts strong female leads PaleyFest RT21 Reality MTV CBS independent robots historical drama Interview YouTube Premium cancelled TV shows Musical Holiday VH1 spanish language BBC America 2016 based on movie Rocketman Masterpiece Star Wars breaking bad Women's History Month Tumblr Fantasy Rocky Baby Yoda Teen Christmas adaptation IFC AMC Acorn TV FOX Anna Paquin Walt Disney Pictures A24 dragons ABC Family Pixar TNT Nat Geo 20th Century Fox TCA Polls and Games richard e. Grant Comedy Election Premiere Dates Heroines Amazon Prime Video Disney Plus Sneak Peek latino singing competition Song of Ice and Fire Fox News WarnerMedia renewed TV shows Academy Awards Biopics Winter TV dceu FX President sag awards Action Mary poppins OWN TV renewals X-Men Drama supernatural TIFF Emmys cops ABC ghosts Bravo PBS YouTube Red Food Network Sundance Marvel Studios Universal Black Mirror TruTV USA Network jamie lee curtis movies revenge Emmy Nominations Film Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt New York Comic Con Video Games name the review Trophy Talk teaser 2019 Kids & Family medical drama Ovation political drama elevated horror foreign TLC TCA 2017 video Chernobyl Nickelodeon unscripted SundanceTV discovery Marvel diversity Valentine's Day 2018 Nominations Trivia YouTube ITV miniseries Sci-Fi Crackle The Witch Watching Series reboot DGA LGBT OneApp Showtime zombies San Diego Comic-Con HBO Max romance game show canceled TBS Spring TV IFC Films ratings doctor who serial killer zero dark thirty WGN Warner Bros. Apple TV Plus south america APB Captain marvel Cosplay cancelled TV series Hulu Paramount Apple TV+ Tarantino Crunchyroll Brie Larson 007 Mindy Kaling crossover batman Apple indie First Look Quiz El Rey rotten movies we love Trailer mockumentary Red Carpet 24 frames Rock Star Trek spy thriller Set visit BET Mystery Classic Film SXSW CW Seed Infographic Character Guide Shudder Mary Tyler Moore animated adventure YA aliens DirecTV witnail E! Comedy Central Elton John talk show Sony Pictures golden globes free movies slashers psychological thriller 2020 theme song First Reviews spain series Certified Fresh Marathons The Walking Dead stand-up comedy Disney+ Disney Plus social media tv talk composers Holidays Awards Tour disaster See It Skip It Turner Classic Movies ESPN transformers Adult Swim TV Arrowverse 21st Century Fox screenings blaxploitation Horror Disney streaming service Mudbound technology sports Pirates Starz MSNBC game of thrones Turner Toys Comic Book Grammys what to watch cancelled television Amazon History hispanic anime Pop Music cults hist Binge Guide facebook Super Bowl television Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Creative Arts Emmys Vudu spinoff CBS All Access Awards biography natural history finale werewolf Cartoon Network thriller The Arrangement SDCC DC Comics Syfy Lucasfilm period drama streaming 71st Emmy Awards Spectrum Originals E3