The Stand First Reviews: New Take On Stephen King's Viral Apocalypse Is Entertaining, If Uneven

With a handful of standout performances, "exquisite" tension, and ambitious world-building, critics say CBS All Access's take on King's epic novel makes for thrilling, demanding, often uncomfortable, viewing.

by | December 13, 2020 | Comments

After a deadly virus wipes out the majority of the world’s population, two groups of survivors end up picking sides — with 108-year-old prophet Mother Abigail (Whoopi Goldberg) or the demonic Randal Flagg (Alexander Skarsgård) — in a supernatural battle between good and evil to decide the fate of mankind. That, in a nutshell, is the gist of Stephen King’s The Stand.

The author’s iconic novel is considered by many to be one of his best works — it has been updated multiple times by King and was adapted into an Emmy Award-winning mini-series by Mick Garris in 1994. Now, a new version of the story is hitting CBS All Access on Thursday, December 17, in the form of a nine-episode mini-series.

This highly-anticipated series, which was brought to life by Josh Boone, Benjamin Cavell, and Taylor Elmore, features a packed cast, including Goldberg, Skarsgård, James Marsden, Odessa Young, Jovan Adepo, Amber Heard, Owen Teague, Henry Zaga, Brad William Henke, Greg Kinnear, Irene Bedard, Katherine McNamara, and Nat Wolff.

It’s been two-and-a-half decades since we’ve seen Mother Abigail face-off against the Dark Man — that mini-series is Certified Fresh on the Tomatometer with a score of 71%. Will this new adaptation of Stephen King’s novel fare better than its predecessor? Or will it end up dead-on-arrival? Here’s what the critics are saying about CBS All Access’s The Stand.

How Faithful Is It to the Book?

Jovan Adepo and Heather Graham in The Stand

(Photo by © CBS All Access)

“This adaptation – developed by Josh Boone and Benjamin Cavell – takes the unique approach of telling the story in a nonlinear fashion, one that introduces viewers less to the pandemic itself more to the characters, the hearts and souls that the story is ultimately about. It’s a move that may not sit well with some die-hard King fans, but it’s one that injects a new life into the story. Starting with people, not with plague and it immediately sets the series out on a much better foot and almost immediately will hook audiences.” — Nicole Drum,

“If you are familiar with the first mini-series, there are a lot of scenes that looks eerily similar in the new iteration, but there is so much more. Those that have read the novel will find this adaptation does better justice to the massive cast of characters. But, you may not like all of the changes.” — Alex Maidy, Jo Blo’s Movie Network

“This new format also asks a lot of its viewers, particularly those who aren’t Constant Readers. With all of this leaping around, so much of the characterization draws upon an inherent knowledge of the source material. Relationships are formed without much connective tissue, narrative beats are well underway with nary a point of origin, and references are dropped at a brisk pace. Again, all of this will likely make for a disorienting experience for newcomers in King’s Dominion.” — Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

How Is the cast?

Alexander Skarsgård as Randall Flagg in THE STAND

(Photo by Robert Falconer/CBS ©2020 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.)

“Skarsgård does for Randall Flagg what his brother Bill did for Pennywise. This Randall Flagg is the force of evil that Matthew McConaughey failed to evoke in The Dark Tower. This Flagg is more than a monster but a true force of evil. Goldberg was also born to play Abigail Freemantle and brought me to tears during this series.” — Alex Maidy, Jo Blo’s Movie Network

“This version of the story more richly develops some of the key characters from the novel and indeed even the previous live-action adaptation. Frannie Goldsmith (played by Odessa Young), for example, is fleshed out in a more grounded and realistic way while Tom Cullen (Brad William Henke) is given more humanity than perhaps we’ve seen before. It helps that both Young and Henke deliver solid performances that feel less like archetype characters and more like people we can easily identify from our own lives.” — Nicole Drum,

“The cast mostly doesn’t rise much above the level of competence – nor, to be fair, drop much below it. The notable exceptions are Brad William Henke (Orange Is the New Black) making his mentally challenged character Tom Cullen impossible not to love; Alexander Skarsgård (True Blood) projecting a palpable sense of evil as Randall Flagg, the baddest of the bad guys; and Henry Zaga, who pulls off a nearly impossible assignment in portraying Nick Andros, a man who can’t hear or speak and can barely see.” — Glenn Garvin, Reason Online

“If there’s a standout here it’s Teague, who plays Harold as an incel sociopath who can just pass as an ordinary, happy citizen. In one of his best moments he fakes his way through the rebuilding utopia with a smile that tries to look winning but mostly looks like Jim Carrey in full manic mode.” — Keith Phipps, TV Guide

Is the World-Building Epic Enough?

The Stand

(Photo by James Minchin/CBS)

“Because things are moving at such a rapid clip, it’s hard to really get a grasp on what’s at stake, and that feeling extends towards much of the world building. At times, it’s a very claustrophobic experience with so much of what’s happening in this world being told rather than shown. And while some of this exposition is wisely left to our own imaginations, most of these comments feel like tossed in signposts, leaving the narrative feeling often hollow.” — Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

“The series’ first couple of hours, premiere “The End” and second episode “Pocket Savior,” build an exquisite amount of tension: The shifting locations capture the permeation of the outbreak; each cough and sniffle portends upcoming doom; and the series’ makeup department should be commended for making the physical effects of “Captain Trips” very, very gross. But after those initial world-building episodes, The Stand never feels dirty enough — neither in its presentation of the physical and emotional impact of all this sickness, loss, and death, nor in its consideration of the lure of Flagg’s totalitarianism-as-hedonism rule in his New Vegas bacchanalia.” — Roxana Hadadi, Variety

“The series’ generous budget keeps its post-apocalyptic America convincing and its tense moments deliver the scares. If these first four episodes offer little in the way of unforgettable moments, they’re always intriguing enough to keep curiosity burning about what will happen next (or, for those who know the book, how the series will stage or reshape it).” — Keith Phipps, TV Guide

Is Now the Right Time for Another Apocalyptic TV Series?

(Photo by Photo Cr: Robert Falconer/CBS ©2020 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.)

“Whether the world needed another TV adaptation of The Stand (there was a 1994 version with Gary Sinise and Molly Ringwald) is a fair question, particularly when the COVID-19 pandemic continues to rage around us. If it was just a reminder of the world around us, the answer might be no. But approached as an intriguing diversion, it works.” — Bill Goodykontz, Arizona Republic

“The apocalypse isn’t the point – it’s simply the backdrop for what is unabashedly an epic modern fantasy.” — Joshua Sargent, San Francisco Chronicle

“In a year ravaged by a far different virus, The Stand carries a different significance as it closes out a year terrifyingly similar to the story on screen. Told over nine episodes, including an all-new ending written by Stephen King and his son Owen, this new version of The Stand is a very uncomfortable story to watch while the world is mired in a real pandemic but still manages to be a faithful adaptation of King’s masterpiece with timely updates that more or less work.” — Alex Maidy, Jo Blo’s Movie Network

Any Final Thoughts?

(Photo by Robert Falconer/CBS ©2020 CBS Interactive, Inc. All Rights Reserved.)

“This adaptation of one of Stephen King’s most dense, sprawling works never quite reaches the epic scope illustrated so clearly in the 1978 novel.” — Roxana Hadadi, Variety

“It’s a sometimes overstuffed, sometimes overly simple book, but also one whose vision of a fantastic America whose potential for greatness and moral clarity is always at war with its self-destructive impulses. Even if many missed it at the time, King found a way to express an underlying truth about the place he calls home. The best parts of this adaptation channel that well.” — Keith Phipps, TV Guide

“The performances are strong, the set pieces are cinematic, and, most importantly, the commitment to King’s prose is stonier than a man’s heart.” — Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

The Stand premieres on Thursday, December 17 to CBS All Access.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Hallmark Christmas movies Masterpiece live action Hulu Disney Channel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Universal Pictures TruTV mob Schedule Extras Fargo dogs The CW Emmy Nominations Oscars Alien Holidays Epix hispanic heritage month rt labs critics edition Sci-Fi remakes asian-american Marvel Studios Anna Paquin Elton John Emmys RT21 Captain marvel justice league supernatural Prime Video The Academy Countdown HFPA news criterion king arthur Fall TV Mary Poppins Returns Sundance Disney biography Baby Yoda FXX 2019 Marathons Watching Series The Witch Trophy Talk comic rt archives Awards Tour ABC MSNBC Trivia period drama technology Nat Geo Calendar Cosplay AMC Plus Video Games First Reviews spain critics chucky composers TCA Awards new york spider-verse jurassic park Set visit spanish television Tags: Comedy satire Image Comics golden globes versus classics toy story Lifetime Christmas movies 21st Century Fox twilight wonder woman Hear Us Out new zealand Television Academy lord of the rings unscripted PBS A24 Sundance TV American Society of Cinematographers comic book movie Apple TV+ sag awards adventure slashers Esquire Academy Awards adaptation NBA elevated horror politics dexter quibi YA Lifetime festival renewed TV shows Action Wes Anderson Comedy Central Film Festival San Diego Comic-Con Bravo theme song Mary poppins 2016 discovery Quiz Food Network X-Men name the review Music Showtime singing competition Brie Larson Funimation harry potter series pirates of the caribbean Comic Book 20th Century Fox live event Thanksgiving Summer 93rd Oscars Columbia Pictures football Rocky streaming OneApp green book documentaries spy thriller cartoon Certified Fresh transformers TV renewals japanese monster movies Sneak Peek laika WGN canceled GIFs Marvel Television The Arrangement Infographic venice Premiere Dates superman BBC One Rock trailers Amazon Studios trophy Mary Tyler Moore rotten Pirates WarnerMedia new star wars movies Toys Heroines FX Superheroes obituary australia VICE Disney Plus movie south america TBS YouTube Red Britbox Adult Swim action-comedy Winners Warner Bros. Family ABC Family aapi Election Classic Film independent batman kaiju ratings Trailer Disney streaming service marvel comics Star Wars Acorn TV nbcuniversal witnail art house mission: impossible know your critic comics screen actors guild scary Biopics 2017 french Arrowverse crime rotten movies we love child's play anthology psycho Spectrum Originals Tomatazos CNN posters Awards SDCC Binge Guide DC streaming service 79th Golden Globes Awards TV ViacomCBS Travel Channel CBS All Access comedies RT History CW Seed book Pet Sematary royal family Apple TV Plus Turner Tokyo Olympics dark canceled TV shows debate LGBTQ Pop TV Crunchyroll best PlayStation serial killer basketball 90s Reality Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TCM IMDb TV popular Tumblr Chernobyl black psychological thriller Horror TV One emmy awards international boxoffice black comedy superhero SXSW Mindy Kaling leaderboard documentary cats E3 ID OWN MCU sequel Fox Searchlight medical drama social media Writers Guild of America dragons Amazon Prime telelvision indie 2020 saw Neflix young adult Legendary stoner Netflix Christmas movies Syfy book adaptation thriller Nominations Country heist movie TCA 2017 TV Land HBO Comic-Con@Home 2021 Shudder deadpool National Geographic sequels rt labs 72 Emmy Awards legend Disney+ Disney Plus universal monsters stop motion Paramount Plus IFC USA Network what to watch concert animated El Rey CMT BAFTA Super Bowl doctor who streaming movies Animation Nickelodeon Christmas halloween tv TNT Fox News Interview Winter TV casting ABC Signature cancelled TV series movies New York Comic Con Cannes spider-man cults binge game of thrones Podcast worst die hard romance vs. reviews DC Comics HBO Go zombies feel good GoT Red Carpet tv talk Ovation diversity 2021 YouTube Premium PaleyFest cars Box Office The Walt Disney Company crime drama ESPN SundanceTV parents President Martial Arts E! Crackle blaxploitation finale based on movie aliens Starz Avengers NYCC Broadway stand-up comedy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards blockbuster razzies hist Walt Disney Pictures Valentine's Day BET Awards Kids & Family breaking bad First Look adenture vampires king kong richard e. Grant police drama Musicals indiana jones Instagram Live Opinion children's TV MTV marvel cinematic universe Comedy a nightmare on elm street Mudbound Spring TV Stephen King Character Guide See It Skip It Exclusive Video natural history scary movies blockbusters APB women Hollywood Foreign Press Association dceu disaster archives Rom-Com scorecard robots GLAAD teaser target cops Creative Arts Emmys free movies zombie 1990s genre hispanic 71st Emmy Awards DC Universe Paramount Women's History Month science fiction toronto cinemax spinoff The Walking Dead festivals Song of Ice and Fire Drama Best and Worst Fantasy comic book movies boxing HBO Max The Purge suspense Endgame Rocketman Pride Month comiccon dc scene in color james bond godzilla award winner war Logo screenings sopranos Discovery Channel IFC Films Reality Competition directors NBC fresh political drama spanish language halloween Ghostbusters Turner Classic Movies DGA worst movies Amazon nfl Polls and Games Superheroe Hallmark Holiday Marvel japan Mystery FOX hidden camera true crime 007 73rd Emmy Awards jamie lee curtis foreign USA TLC Tubi golden globe awards LGBT franchise Freeform historical drama ITV TV movies dramedy CBS kids mutant Sony Pictures History 45 reboot fast and furious rom-coms VH1 high school crossover crime thriller comic books 4/20 Pop Teen anime critic resources ghosts Tarantino YouTube video on demand Star Trek FX on Hulu talk show 24 frames cancelled Cartoon Network Ellie Kemper italian Western Black History Month hollywood all-time 99% space nature TCA sitcom mcc video TCA Winter 2020 Netflix Dark Horse Comics werewolf cooking facebook Pacific Islander films TIFF mockumentary Lucasfilm docuseries docudrama 2015 Universal travel strong female leads Paramount Network Black Mirror slasher gangster Vudu BBC America prank VOD miniseries 2018 Television Critics Association Pixar Lionsgate Photos Grammys zero dark thirty DirecTV A&E cancelled television Spike game show AMC revenge Apple Sundance Now dreamworks kong olympics Amazon Prime Video joker Shondaland christmas movies Year in Review biopic BBC Film Musical Comics on TV latino BET cancelled TV shows Peacock romantic comedy sports