Critics Consensus

The Predator Is a Disappointment

Plus, A Simple Favor is twisty fun, White Boy Rick is well-acted but flat, Mandy is Certified Fresh, and BoJack Horseman and American Vandal return in stellar form.

by | September 13, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have survival of the dreadlocked fittest (The Predator, starring Olivia Munn and Boyd Holbrook), a mommy blogger on the trail of a mystery (A Simple Favor, starring Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively), a war veteran’s search for peace (Unbroken: Path to Redemption, starring Samuel Hunt and Merritt Patterson), and the incredible — yet ultimately cautionary — tale of the FBI’s youngest-ever informant (White Boy Rick, starring Matthew McConaughey and Richie Merritt). What are the critics saying?

The Predator (2018) 32%

Some franchises evolve naturally, with a story that lends itself easily to follow-up chapters, while others are a little more difficult to will into being, no matter how tempting the box office receipts might be. The latter has always been the case for the Predator movies, which have offered a case study in diminishing returns since the beefy fun of the first installment; whether facing off against Danny Glover, Adrien Brody, or even Xenomorphs, these nasty-looking intergalactic big game hunters have never been quite as much fun as they seemed in 1987. This weekend’s franchise reboot — suitably titled The Predator — was supposed to change all that with an adventure that brought the big guys back to Earth for a hunt that echoed the original while upping the ante in various ways. With director/co-writer/Predator vet Shane Black at the helm, and an ensemble cast that includes Sterling K. Brown, Olivia Munn, and Jacob Tremblay, it looked like a solid blend of top-shelf talent and genre thrills; unfortunately, the disappointing reality is more of a noisy muddle that fails to clear the bar set by the first film — or even 2010’s space-set Predators. Critics say The Predator has its moments, but they’re neither plentiful nor impactful enough to ever be as much fun as they ought to be. If the past is any indication, we may very well see a sequel at some point, so here’s hoping that one hits closer to the mark; in the meantime, this is one would-be franchise revival that needs to get to the choppa.

A Simple Favor (2018) 84%

From Poltergeist to Desperate Housewives and beyond, filmmakers have used well-groomed suburbs as a deceptively placid mask for countless types of nastiness, so on the surface, A Simple Favor — starring Anna Kendrick as a blogger determined to uncover the truth behind the disappearance of her friend (Blake Lively) — might seem to be another variation on a familiar theme. On the other hand, it also has a terrific cast (rounded out by Jean Smart and Crazy Rich Asians star Henry Golding), a talented director at the reins in Paul Feig, and a script adapted from the Darcey Bell novel by American Horror Story vet Jessica Sharzer. Critics say all that talent makes all the difference for a movie that adds up to a fairly delightful — and delightfully ridiculous — mommy noir, with all the plot twists, dark humor, and beautiful people audiences might expect. It isn’t the most high-profile wide release of the weekend, but filmgoers who aren’t absolutely intent on seeing alien blood spilled may want to do themselves this Favor.

White Boy Rick (2018) 59%

Richard Wershe Jr. became an FBI informant at the age of 14, ended up in jail for selling cocaine before he turned 20, and has endured further painful scrapes with the law since being paroled in 2017. It’s a grim story tinged with sensationalism, which makes it somewhat surprising that it took until now for it to reach the big screen in the form of White Boy Rick. Starring Richie Merritt as Wershe and Matthew McConaughey as his father, this Yann Demange-directed drama seeks to highlight the surreal aspects of the story while also making it clear that his economic background — and a judicial system stacked against non-violent drug offenders — are tied into much broader problems in America, and while that’s certainly an admirable goal, critics say it can make for a somewhat less than satisfying viewing experience. Although Merritt and McConaughey have both received their share of praise for their performances, White Boy Rick can’t quite reconcile its domestic drama elements against its social commentary components, and in presenting Wershe as a sympathetic product of unusual circumstance, the story undermines some of its own points. It isn’t without its strengths, but this is one fascinating real-life story that isn’t always well served by its dramatization.

Unbroken: Path to Redemption (2018) 38%

With 2014’s Angelina Jolie-directed Unbroken, audiences were offered a dramatized version of the stranger-than-fiction real-life saga of Louie Zamperini, an Olympic runner and U.S. Army officer who survived against incredible odds — and through unconscionable treatment — as a prisoner of war during World War II. As incredible as the events depicted might have been, they only told part of Zamperini’s story, an oversight that this weekend’s Unbroken: Path to Redemption seeks to correct. Dubbed a “spiritual sequel” and starring a completely different cast, this chapter focuses on Zamperini’s (Samuel Hunt) struggles after the war, as well as the religious awakening that helped him let go of the past. It’s an undeniably inspiring tale, but critics say the film version — directed by Harold Cronk, who brought the similarly faith-focused God Bless the Broken Road to theaters last week — preaches ham-handedly to the choir with a screenplay that fails to find much relatable drama in Zamperini’s journey in spite of Hunt’s best efforts. Evangelically inclined filmgoers will likely be comfortable ignoring the reviews, but for everyone else, this is one life that’s still better summed up in the pages of its bestselling source material, Laura Hillenbrand’s Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption.

What’s New on TV

BoJack Horseman: Season 5 (2018) 98%

BoJack Horseman continues confidently down the thematic rabbit hole with a fresh and poignant season that’s as devastating as it is hilarious.

American Vandal: Season 2 (2018) 98%

American Vandal trades one type of potty humor for another in an ambitious second season that manages to double down on the explicit gags while subtly addressing serious social issues.

The First: Season 1 (2018) 66%

Sean Penn gives an intensely poignant performance as the driven but conflicted Tom Hagerty in The First‘s rather slow-moving first season.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Dawn Wall (2018) , a documentary about the life and public exploits of free climber Tommy Caldwell, is at 100%.
  • Science Fair (2018) , a documentary following the efforts of nine high school science fair contestants, is at 100%.
  • Mandy (2018) , starring Nicolas Cage as a man out for bloody revenge after his wife is killed by a cult, is Certified Fresh at 96%.
  • Hale County This Morning, This Evening (2018) , a documentary following the lives of two young African-American men in the titular Alabama county, is at 92%.
  • Rodents of Unusual Size (2018) , a documentary look at efforts to thwart or contain the rise of the nutria in Louisiana’s coastal wetlands, is at 92%.
  • A Boy. A Girl. A Dream. (2018) , a romance set on the evening of the 2016 election, is at 88%.
  • Don't Leave Home (2018) , in which an artist lives to regret accepting an invitation to rural Ireland, is at 75%.
  • American Chaos (2018) , a documentary about the 2016 election, is at 73%.
  • Lizzie (2018) , starring Chloë Sevigny and Kristen Stewart in a new dramatization of the legend of Lizzie Borden, is at 71%.
  • I Think We're Alone Now (2018) , a post-apocalyptic drama led by Peter Dinklage and Elle Fanning, is at 68%.
  • The Children Act (2018) , starring Emma Thompson as a London judge presiding over a case with a uniquely personal impact, is at 67%.
  • The Public Image is Rotten (2018) , a documentary appraisal of John Lydon‘s post-Sex Pistols work as the leader of Public Image Limited, is at 67%.
  • Final Score (2018) , starring Dave Bautista as a combat veteran racing against time to rescue his kidnapped niece from terrorists, is at 67%.
  • MDMA (Cardinal X) (2018) , an ’80s-set period drama about a college student who augments her financial aid by making and selling drugs, is at 64%.
  • Slice (2018) , starring Chance the Rapper as a werewolf who just wants to deliver quality Chinese food at affordable prices, is at 63%.
  • Where Hands Touch (2018) , in which two teens develop a dangerous bond in 1944 Germany, is at 50%.
  • Bel Canto (2018) , starring Julianne Moore and Ken Watanabe in a drama about an opera singer trapped in a guerrilla invasion at a posh party, is at 42%.
  • The Basement (2018) , in which a man is kidnapped and tortured by an assailant who adopts a series of different personas during the ordeal, is at 17%.

Tag Cloud

Lucasfilm Mindy Kaling Turner YA Calendar National Geographic Amazon Prime Video breaking bad 007 TV renewals Sundance TV USA Acorn TV CBS All Access book talk show south america TruTV golden globes concert revenge SXSW reviews facebook kids Trailer discovery Winter TV NBC Freeform Dark Horse Comics spy thriller Logo award winner TNT crossover Holidays X-Men Awards batman supernatural social media 20th Century Fox BBC America Netflix OWN Character Guide Animation APB Funimation cancelled TV shows spain PBS robots Superheroe canceled TV shows finale E3 Pop TV BBC FXX El Rey Britbox Comedy Amazon Studios rotten movies we love Spike elevated horror game show Rocky satire crime DirecTV Adult Swim cops cancelled television vampires Winners MTV blockbuster dceu Pop space cats Shudder technology VOD streaming Trivia Musical 4/20 SundanceTV Reality Competition die hard CMT video on demand Mary poppins Star Wars TCM scary movies Christmas Paramount Network comiccon sitcom television series Schedule Nat Geo spider-man boxoffice Arrowverse hist Hear Us Out ESPN The CW mutant Premiere Dates latino 2020 TIFF Grammys DC Universe Tubi Sony Pictures Biopics ghosts Writers Guild of America 2018 TCA Winter 2020 The Walking Dead History 24 frames unscripted true crime Marvel Studios Rock Bravo CBS children's TV Comics on TV Showtime GoT Hallmark Cannes Columbia Pictures Action DC Comics quibi Red Carpet CW Seed Music VICE Sundance Now game of thrones Sundance Oscars Esquire SDCC twilight FX indie ITV RT History binge dragons Chernobyl GLAAD theme song Film Festival Lifetime Christmas movies all-time joker PaleyFest dogs independent Amazon Prime Trophy Talk best free movies directors green book Horror foreign Captain marvel Fox News LGBT cancelled Lifetime Apple TV+ Election Quiz Shondaland dramedy Walt Disney Pictures Family stand-up comedy zombies Country criterion Extras See It Skip It singing competition Fall TV hispanic a nightmare on elm street adventure PlayStation Comedy Central Awards Tour Summer 45 cooking Infographic Rocketman Endgame asian-american Mudbound ABC Sneak Peek Spectrum Originals Disney Channel FX on Hulu Watching Series jamie lee curtis Opinion VH1 Turner Classic Movies Pirates Brie Larson Interview President Disney zombie Pixar cinemax Creative Arts Emmys Ovation period drama First Look police drama Avengers GIFs TCA RT21 Super Bowl MCU war Lionsgate spanish language stoner 2016 NYCC Hulu Cosplay science fiction political drama crime thriller 2019 Emmys politics CNN HBO miniseries movies Best and Worst zero dark thirty WarnerMedia Mary Poppins Returns anime casting historical drama animated Nickelodeon Television Academy what to watch slashers sag awards Stephen King transformers Musicals video Star Trek BET Awards Superheroes documentaries Ellie Kemper BBC One critics Reality indiana jones The Witch anthology serial killer A24 sequel festivals justice league Pet Sematary Tomatazos based on movie Anna Paquin LGBTQ MSNBC DGA HBO Max cancelled TV series comic movie versus TBS child's play Drama Hallmark Christmas movies Photos Disney Plus mission: impossible Holiday 71st Emmy Awards richard e. Grant dark Set visit BAFTA romance Mystery biography halloween Starz First Reviews teaser screen actors guild comics toy story WGN parents 21st Century Fox Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Emmy Nominations Black Mirror werewolf films Netflix Christmas movies Disney+ Disney Plus doctor who A&E Peacock Heroines natural history AMC screenings Amazon Comic Book mockumentary crime drama Ghostbusters romantic comedy YouTube Video Games Polls and Games Song of Ice and Fire dc TV Land name the review sports HBO Go Tumblr Western aliens Tarantino American Society of Cinematographers Disney streaming service adaptation Apple psychological thriller Paramount USA Network Kids & Family diversity The Purge cars universal monsters franchise Epix Film reboot San Diego Comic-Con news E! Marvel TCA 2017 IFC Mary Tyler Moore Certified Fresh Rom-Com ABC Family renewed TV shows Teen Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Universal Masterpiece Valentine's Day Martial Arts 2017 YouTube Premium harry potter Marathons Binge Guide YouTube Red Apple TV Plus Syfy blaxploitation Discovery Channel Pride Month medical drama Fantasy canceled BET New York Comic Con Box Office tv talk travel ratings Spring TV Countdown Baby Yoda The Arrangement Classic Film Travel Channel comedies Nominations Elton John psycho cartoon Black History Month FOX TV Sci-Fi Podcast nature chucky strong female leads Crackle Toys Cartoon Network Year in Review DC streaming service Vudu documentary Food Network OneApp spinoff Warner Bros. Thanksgiving Marvel Television christmas movies TLC cults Academy Awards composers Crunchyroll thriller Women's History Month witnail docudrama IFC Films disaster 2015