The Boys Season 2 First Reviews: Superhero Hit's Return Is 'Hugely Diabolical,' Say Critics

Eric Kripke's comic book adaptation ups the action and violence in its new season, making the superhero satire darker, more hilarious, and way more terrifying this time around.

by | August 24, 2020 | Comments

From the very beginning, Amazon’s The Boys set itself apart within the superhero television realm. Based on the comic books by Garth Ennis and Darick Robinson, the program, from executive producer Eric Kripke (Supernatural), explores an alternate reality in which superheroes not only exist, but are mostly supreme a-holes. The Seven, as they’re known globally, is made up of seven “supes,” as they call them: American flag–caped sociopath and leader Homelander (Antony Starr), Wonder Woman–esque hesitant sidekick Queen Maeve (Dominique McElligott), lightning-fast and egocentric A-Train (Jessie T. Usher), rape-y ocean-dweller The Deep (Chace Crawford), electrified newcomer Stormfront (Aya Cash), and starry-eyed outlier Starlight (Erin Moriarty), the only one among them with a moral compass.

On a mission to keep the supes in check, and quite possibly eradicate them all entirely for good, is the “Boys” — a ragtag team led by Karl Urban’s constantly-grinning, yet completely self-destructive William Butcher. As the first season’s episodes progressed, Butcher’s reasoning for this mission of violence was eventually revealed: His wife Becca (Shantel VanSanten) had been presumed dead and Homelander, as Butcher understood it, was the one who killed her.

The Boys s2 keyart

(Photo by Amazon Prime Video)

In season 1, Butcher and his crew — Frenchie (Tomer Kapon), Mother’s Milk (Laz Alonso), Hughie (Jack Quaid), and the mysterious and powered Kimiko (Karen Fukuhara) — uncovered a plot involving “Compound-V,” a drug that makes supes, and Vought Industries, the company commoditizing The Seven.

The first three episodes of The Boys season 2 land on Amazon on Friday, September 4. How do these new episodes compare to the show’s freshman season, which is currently Certified Fresh at 88% on the Tomatometer? Here’s what the critics are saying about season 2 of The Boys.


Season 2 is an attempt to re-contextualize modern ethical heroics and our relationship to publicly anointed figures. It also dispels any romantic notions we have about the agendas of powerful institutional bodies such as big business, government and religions; pillars of “civilized” society that are meant to provide security and structure. Instead, they sow chaos. — Brandon Katz, Observer

 A major part of The Boys Season 1’s appeal — and of the comic, too — was its deconstruction of superhero culture, which worked especially well considering the popularity of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and DC Extended Universe. While that exploration still plays a role in Season 2, the focus is much more on politics, particularly contemporary alt-right and Neo-Nazi discourse. — Liam Nolan, CBR

The Boys’ critique of the rise of an anti-immigrant sentiment in the United States is abundantly apparent. The show repeatedly draws attention to the fact that Vought purposefully uses racial animus to its advantage. Even when the camera is trained on someone’s head exploding—something that happens an alarming number of times this go around—the show is trying to make a number of valid points about the destructive influence megacorporations can have on society. That message is still rather rich coming from a show produced by Amazon Studios, but The Boys makes no pretense of trying to hide what it is. — Charles Pulliam-Moore, I09


Urban’s Butcher, so single-minded and reductive in season one, finally gets to start digging into some ambiguities with his grizzled antihero, teasing out the guy’s darker side while finding ways to reveal some weaknesses. — Alex McLevy, The AV Club

Jack Quaid and Erin Moriarty are the heart of the show as Hughie Campbell and Annie January (aka Starlight), two characters yet to have their moral compasses bashed entirely out of alignment. That said, both have been forced to evolve in order to survive their toxic surroundings, pushing them in interesting new directions. — David Craig, Radio Times

Kripke expands The Female’s story with some new elements that we won’t go into too much detail on here for fear of spoilers. But Fukuhara’s emotive expressions and body language effectively communicate the nuanced emotions she’s feeling throughout. Her friendship with Frenchie continues to develop and is one of the more tender-hearted relationships in this otherwise-cynical take on superheroes. — David Griffith, IGN

But Homelander (Antony Starr) has more important things on his sociopathic mind. Now that he knows he has a son, he can’t wait to provide the kid with the father figure he never had, and his simmering, unpredictable bouts of ultra-violence have never been so pronounced when faced with his own failures in the family department. — Jon Negroni, The Spool


The action scenes are tight, smart, and surprising, there are delightful moments of dialogue that deliver both character, humor, and heart, and there are world details so skillfully embedded into the backgrounds of certain scenes that they almost at times serve as spoilers. — Liz Shannon-Miller, Collider

With so much hype surrounding this second batch of episodes, we’re sure you’ll be glad to know that it doesn’t just live up to what came before, but exceeds it with a bigger, crazier, and more violent season. — Josh Wilding,


Aya Cash’s Stormfront has all of the edgy humour and some of the best jokes of the season. — Brian Lloyd,

Season 2 introduces a new member of The Seven named Stormfront (Aya Cash), a social-media savvy supe who pokes fun at the stiff and overly-produced nature of her colleagues and infuriates Homelander with the way she so easily pulls the spotlight away from him. — Hannah Lodge, Screen Rex

She’s the livewire that creates chaos wherever she goes, and that chaos is a big reason why the season works so well as a whole. Trust me, you’ll hate her plenty by season’s end, and I couldn’t envision the season working so well without her. — Matthew Aguilar, Comic Book


With a higher budget, they’ve polished the special effects that were glossed over in the first season, the romance between some of the characters has improved strongly, and the villains are still, well, super. Here’s hoping The Boys really will return in Season 3. — Jon Negroni, The Spool

If the rest of Season 2 stays on the same path as the first three episodes, it’s going to prove the perfect commentary for the tense times in which we live. — Michael Rougeau, GameSpot

Rude, crude and ultra-violent; The Boys are back with another hugely diabolical but enjoyable outing! — Nicola Austin, We Have a Hulk

The Boys: Season 2 (2020)

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: The Boys comes out swinging in a superb second season that digs deeper into its complicated characters and ups the action ante without pulling any punches.

Tag Cloud

2021 justice league Apple TV Plus Pixar fresh award winner Sundance hidden camera Kids & Family new zealand women ViacomCBS 73rd Emmy Awards Apple TV+ Cartoon Network black comedy Ellie Kemper canceled TV shows green book Lucasfilm heist movie docudrama documentaries AMC Plus Country nature E! renewed TV shows south america Epix doctor who Mary poppins Biopics Fox Searchlight GoT reboot HBO Max young adult diversity criterion TruTV travel richard e. Grant game show PaleyFest Rock critics Holidays Fox News Set visit war Acorn TV 24 frames Tokyo Olympics South by Southwest Film Festival know your critic italian El Rey festival Amazon Studios TV YouTube Red 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards football First Reviews Comedy 1990s boxoffice spain Alien Hulu MTV BBC America A&E parents Year in Review SXSW what to watch Super Bowl 90s Arrowverse ABC Family Syfy The Walking Dead australia Focus Features Black Mirror comics SXSW 2022 police drama Comic Book Shudder worst Heroines spider-verse quibi Cosplay latino sag awards Avengers Holiday First Look Fargo GIFs breaking bad spanish language composers golden globes chucky spy thriller unscripted OneApp scary YouTube revenge canceled History Teen Fall TV Nat Geo jurassic park zombie Marvel Studios IFC streamig VICE Ovation Nominations TV renewals ghosts Animation christmas movies Turner Classic Movies psycho blockbuster period drama monster movies 2017 Pop TV obi wan slasher king kong tv talk adenture Spike archives olympics dreamworks 79th Golden Globes Awards rt labs critics edition Hollywood Foreign Press Association supernatural streaming movies Vudu miniseries children's TV Western nfl Peacock Television Critics Association FXX Crunchyroll dexter universal monsters San Diego Comic-Con Spring TV Drama Reality independent best Apple new york Thanksgiving Turner Fantasy Musical Comics on TV Sony Pictures royal family critic resources Film Festival TNT disaster Superheroe Oscars fast and furious satire Shondaland Chernobyl summer preview asian-american BBC kaiju VH1 zero dark thirty TCM news target Comedy Central Marathons Trophy Talk leaderboard concert Trivia all-time MSNBC 93rd Oscars series TCA Awards Wes Anderson LGBTQ comic art house Pet Sematary Film Tags: Comedy NBC Academy Awards hispanic Britbox indie Certified Fresh comic book movies Tarantino Netflix Best Actress interviews Netflix Christmas movies Pride Month Tumblr dark saw mockumentary The Purge debate Rocky IFC Films talk show comic books Warner Bros. Mystery singing competition Stephen King sopranos superman joker Star Trek screenings Paramount Pictures stand-up comedy free movies Columbia Pictures indiana jones biography japan reviews summer TV HFPA casting TIFF MGM boxing TCA 2017 Travel Channel X-Men 72 Emmy Awards Tomatazos Schedule 2018 Winter TV french Rocketman Universal screen actors guild mutant blaxploitation Winners dramedy Summer batman science fiction docuseries game of thrones Native feel good SDCC social media Election Baby Yoda NBA comedies adventure lord of the rings Music kong stop motion Action Writers Guild of America twilight Red Carpet adaptation LGBT Best and Worst prank international child's play 21st Century Fox Universal Pictures Infographic Walt Disney Pictures AMC Rom-Com Mary Tyler Moore deadpool Nickelodeon Endgame based on movie Food Network trophy A24 animated Family Television Academy cancelled franchise BET Awards Masterpiece Tubi Pirates rt archives romance finale a nightmare on elm street cancelled TV series ESPN ID 71st Emmy Awards PBS crime ITV Logo TCA Winter 2020 space films Legendary RT21 Polls and Games foreign Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt action-comedy Amazon Prime Brie Larson Broadway scary movies Funimation vampires Discovery Channel HBO 2015 Instagram Live Emmy Nominations crime drama halloween high school Horror serial killer mission: impossible video live event NYCC versus President nbcuniversal theme song Sneak Peek superhero live action Premiere Dates true crime genre FX on Hulu YouTube Premium Cannes CMT Podcast Toys festivals telelvision Disney+ Disney Plus 4/20 james bond trailers Disney Plus spinoff HBO Go summer TV preview romantic comedy dragons IMDb TV venice historical drama mob rt labs DGA Best Actor Chilling Adventures of Sabrina harry potter Hear Us Out thriller broadcast transformers strong female leads Elton John The Witch Paramount Image Comics Anna Paquin psychological thriller remakes VOD Comic-Con@Home 2021 Binge Guide Crackle Photos pirates of the caribbean comiccon WarnerMedia Mary Poppins Returns Hallmark Christmas movies popular The CW cults ratings 2016 movie DirecTV Mudbound SundanceTV DC Universe cooking 94th Oscars golden globe awards name the review ABC Signature legend CBS Sci-Fi Spectrum Originals FOX Christmas elevated horror Trailer robots crime thriller obituary Best Director new star wars movies CBS All Access CW Seed sports stoner BET classics New York Comic Con Superheroes cops Awards The Arrangement Amazon Prime Video rotten movies we love TV One rom-coms crossover 007 vs. halloween tv dc scene in color hollywood Creative Arts Emmys cinemax Extras godzilla Awards Tour japanese Valentine's Day toronto Prime Video Martial Arts Quiz sequels CNN 2020 Disney Channel medical drama Marvel ABC marvel comics posters Box Office DC Comics Grammys cats 20th Century Fox Sundance TV Disney streaming service sequel technology politics laika rotten binge RT History Video Games Geeked Week Showtime Indigenous Paramount Network Sony mcc Opinion TV Land hist werewolf black TV movies jamie lee curtis Ghostbusters E3 documentary slashers MCU National Geographic Watching Series Exclusive Video Song of Ice and Fire USA sitcom 2019 teaser Disney directors TBS natural history FX See It Skip It gangster Marvel Television DC streaming service 45 BBC One scene in color film series WGN Character Guide Lifetime Christmas movies Lionsgate book adaptation suspense streaming scene in color series Mindy Kaling Lifetime hispanic heritage month Emmys cancelled TV shows American Society of Cinematographers PlayStation television OWN emmy awards Bravo TLC spanish The Walt Disney Company Women's History Month Oscar Interview Black History Month anime target scene in color basketball book Dark Horse Comics movies zombies dceu dogs Star Wars Celebration razzies aapi Pop Hallmark TCA Classic Film Neflix witnail APB The Academy Esquire GLAAD Calendar Pacific Islander discovery scorecard BAFTA USA Network die hard toy story comic book movie blockbusters Sundance Now Adult Swim Freeform Amazon political drama 99% Countdown Musicals Star Wars spider-man biopic Reality Competition video on demand aliens marvel cinematic universe Best Picture Starz cartoon anthology Paramount Plus facebook worst movies cars king arthur YA wonder woman Captain marvel cancelled television kids