Sundance Reviews: "American Crime" Is Painful, "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" Is Haunting

by | January 21, 2007 | Comments

Here are some short reviews of "An American Crime," starring Catherine Keener and Ellen Page, and the Iraq war doc, "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib," both of which screened at the Sundance Film Festival.

Filled with grotesque human cruelty and limited character development, "An American Crime" is a "based on true events" film that never makes the case for its existence. With their parents on the road as carnival workers, sweet, God-fearing Sylvia (Ellen Page) and her sister are taken in as boarders by Gertrude (Catherine Keener), a single mother with a house full of kids and financial woes — not to mention a substance abuse problem. Trouble starts early for the girls — and the film — when they are beaten for a minor infraction (from scene to scene, Gertrude moves from stern-but-caring single parent to Mommie Dearest). Things get worse when the eldest daughter, Paula (Ari Graynor), tells Sylvia in confidence she’s pregnant by a married man; Sophie eventually reveals her secret under duress. Paula tells Gertrude that Sylvia has spread lies about her, and Sophie is locked in the basement and subjected to a series of humiliations and cruelties that are excruciating to witness — not least because the film lingers over them in explicit detail while failing to make the characters’ motivations clear. The makers of "An American Crime" may be trying to make a comment on the nature of torture — that is, good people do nothing if what’s going on seems sanctioned by an authority figure — at a time when detainee rights are being heatedly debated. But any such commentary is undermined by the film itself. At the press screening I attended, several scenes elicited incredulous guffaws, including a pointless trick resolution and an unintentionally ridiculous voiceover in the final scene. The period detail is painstaking, and the actors are clearly committed to the material; it’s just that the material isn’t insightful enough to warrant such devotion.

When pictures of tortured Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib surfaced in 2004, everyone from President Bush to Donald Rumsfeld took great pains to explain that the American soldiers who committed these acts were a few "bad apples." "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" convincingly posits that if anything, it was the barrel that was bad. In "Ghosts," we hear from several of the MPs who were charged in the scandal, and what’s alarming is how normal they all sound; in their voices, there’s a flat, almost shell-shocked tone, as if they can’t believe what they did. They describe the prison as a nightmarish maze of filth, haunted by the lost souls of Saddam’s regime. Once the U.S. took control of Iraq, the prison was reopened to house a number of local criminals and those purported to have information relating to potential terrorist plots. Almost immediately, a number of extreme practices – from sleep deprivation to humiliation – were utilized to extract information from suspects. It’s clear from nearly everyone interviewed in the film that the go-ahead for such drastic measures came from the top, but the irony is that such cruel practices elicited nothing of value for intelligence agents; in addition, many of the incarcerated were guilty of nothing. "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" is not particularly slick filmmaking, but that’s one of the reasons it’s so effective; it makes its points with minimal ceremony, but those points hit hard.

Tag Cloud

Amazon Valentine's Day aliens YouTube Red Starz Character Guide GLAAD Nominations Britbox YouTube Premium New York Comic Con Acorn TV RT History Sundance Cartoon Network Musicals Emmys dceu crime thriller comic Quiz BBC America El Rey Tomatazos what to watch Spike Country spider-man TCA psychological thriller CBS All Access Trophy Talk SXSW Syfy TCM docudrama Pirates FOX USA travel Paramount television sequel Sci-Fi anthology BET Mystery Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pet Sematary singing competition 2019 technology TV disaster strong female leads Drama E3 Countdown CW Seed Writers Guild of America Disney toy story police drama 2016 facebook Logo Trivia dc Winter TV GIFs CMT ratings mockumentary BBC Apple Spring TV Black Mirror Spectrum Originals historical drama medical drama PaleyFest Elton John richard e. Grant LGBTQ natural history Interview Film Festival Women's History Month period drama harry potter First Look Music Bravo Summer OWN ITV Infographic TNT Star Trek true crime MCU Box Office witnail X-Men Columbia Pictures Vudu DC Comics Video Games CNN ABC crime drama spinoff Ovation transformers TCA 2017 Awards Tour Nickelodeon HBO binge Superheroes vampires thriller Ellie Kemper Sundance Now Walt Disney Pictures Awards Extras IFC talk show jamie lee curtis Emmy Nominations Shudder MTV cults comiccon 21st Century Fox Biopics Comic Book Pride Month unscripted Christmas animated VICE Amazon Prime FX Thanksgiving zero dark thirty YA 007 Anna Paquin 45 Brie Larson Best and Worst History space Mary Tyler Moore The Witch Comics on TV Mudbound Fall TV Mary Poppins Returns serial killer TLC Sony Pictures San Diego Comic-Con Premiere Dates Certified Fresh DGA Shondaland Horror award winner 2017 Dark Horse Comics FXX Creative Arts Emmys Reality Competition PBS Stephen King Cannes Martial Arts DC streaming service zombie GoT Western finale sitcom WGN TV Land cinemax Marvel CBS based on movie justice league discovery Reality Universal psycho Netflix doctor who The CW Hulu Podcast SDCC game show Fantasy spy thriller Mindy Kaling DirecTV politics anime Tarantino NBC Comedy IFC Films 2015 E! casting LGBT Captain marvel Cosplay See It Skip It Warner Bros. Oscars Rocketman teaser SundanceTV AMC blaxploitation biography Heroines cooking ABC Family diversity romance Fox News adventure Star Wars Esquire composers Epix Teen Lifetime Tumblr 2018 war Freeform Opinion Lucasfilm Toys DC Universe Disney Channel TruTV supernatural Grammys Showtime Lionsgate National Geographic Rocky Sneak Peek WarnerMedia Comedy Central adaptation hist political drama 20th Century Fox Election American Society of Cinematographers social media USA Network Year in Review Watching Series Super Bowl Song of Ice and Fire Schedule science fiction festivals Food Network sports streaming dragons miniseries Photos elevated horror Calendar 24 frames boxoffice Trailer President Set visit Marathons Action Nat Geo Chernobyl Winners Mary poppins Polls and Games robots crime Crackle Rock zombies nature NYCC Masterpiece Kids & Family Ghostbusters TBS APB MSNBC Paramount Network A&E VH1 ESPN mutant golden globes The Arrangement Rom-Com HBO Max Holidays RT21 Pop Red Carpet theme song Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cops Animation Superheroe crossover Musical Pixar dramedy cats TIFF green book Adult Swim