Sundance Reviews: "American Crime" Is Painful, "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" Is Haunting

by | January 21, 2007 | Comments

Here are some short reviews of "An American Crime," starring Catherine Keener and Ellen Page, and the Iraq war doc, "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib," both of which screened at the Sundance Film Festival.

Filled with grotesque human cruelty and limited character development, "An American Crime" is a "based on true events" film that never makes the case for its existence. With their parents on the road as carnival workers, sweet, God-fearing Sylvia (Ellen Page) and her sister are taken in as boarders by Gertrude (Catherine Keener), a single mother with a house full of kids and financial woes — not to mention a substance abuse problem. Trouble starts early for the girls — and the film — when they are beaten for a minor infraction (from scene to scene, Gertrude moves from stern-but-caring single parent to Mommie Dearest). Things get worse when the eldest daughter, Paula (Ari Graynor), tells Sylvia in confidence she’s pregnant by a married man; Sophie eventually reveals her secret under duress. Paula tells Gertrude that Sylvia has spread lies about her, and Sophie is locked in the basement and subjected to a series of humiliations and cruelties that are excruciating to witness — not least because the film lingers over them in explicit detail while failing to make the characters’ motivations clear. The makers of "An American Crime" may be trying to make a comment on the nature of torture — that is, good people do nothing if what’s going on seems sanctioned by an authority figure — at a time when detainee rights are being heatedly debated. But any such commentary is undermined by the film itself. At the press screening I attended, several scenes elicited incredulous guffaws, including a pointless trick resolution and an unintentionally ridiculous voiceover in the final scene. The period detail is painstaking, and the actors are clearly committed to the material; it’s just that the material isn’t insightful enough to warrant such devotion.

When pictures of tortured Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib surfaced in 2004, everyone from President Bush to Donald Rumsfeld took great pains to explain that the American soldiers who committed these acts were a few "bad apples." "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" convincingly posits that if anything, it was the barrel that was bad. In "Ghosts," we hear from several of the MPs who were charged in the scandal, and what’s alarming is how normal they all sound; in their voices, there’s a flat, almost shell-shocked tone, as if they can’t believe what they did. They describe the prison as a nightmarish maze of filth, haunted by the lost souls of Saddam’s regime. Once the U.S. took control of Iraq, the prison was reopened to house a number of local criminals and those purported to have information relating to potential terrorist plots. Almost immediately, a number of extreme practices – from sleep deprivation to humiliation – were utilized to extract information from suspects. It’s clear from nearly everyone interviewed in the film that the go-ahead for such drastic measures came from the top, but the irony is that such cruel practices elicited nothing of value for intelligence agents; in addition, many of the incarcerated were guilty of nothing. "Ghosts of Abu Ghraib" is not particularly slick filmmaking, but that’s one of the reasons it’s so effective; it makes its points with minimal ceremony, but those points hit hard.

Tag Cloud

Mary Tyler Moore cinemax scary movies Ghostbusters Columbia Pictures a nightmare on elm street new star wars movies cartoon 94th Oscars women Pop TV Shudder Calendar E3 2017 Image Comics BET supernatural Song of Ice and Fire Spring TV Black Mirror ABC Family wonder woman stand-up comedy zombie biography kids target Fargo Year in Review Bravo Sneak Peek pirates of the caribbean award winner Character Guide strong female leads HBO Go international docudrama serial killer Sony Pictures docuseries cancelled television cults natural history Funimation jurassic park know your critic cancelled ESPN Star Wars satire laika basketball golden globes PBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina talk show romantic comedy See It Skip It rt archives Cosplay Teen TIFF Apple TV Plus Prime Video OWN APB green book period drama American Society of Cinematographers Acorn TV comedies Paramount Comic-Con@Home 2021 OneApp composers RT History casting latino remakes new zealand GLAAD directors Photos Nickelodeon VH1 Trailer IFC Red Carpet sopranos TruTV godzilla Tubi FX mutant Election Mary Poppins Returns deadpool football renewed TV shows Wes Anderson sitcom Pride Month 2018 critics Universal comic ViacomCBS 1990s Pixar king arthur Comedy Central black universal monsters ABC Signature Neflix Dark Horse Comics Comics on TV IMDb TV cars Paramount Network Fall TV scene in color Broadway rt labs joker tv talk Disney Channel comic book movies teaser venice TCA Awards mcc PlayStation Apple TV+ 72 Emmy Awards Spike RT21 Valentine's Day stop motion MCU Best Actor Travel Channel richard e. Grant DirecTV movies Instagram Live ghosts Emmy Nominations worst NBC diversity TCA reviews Sci-Fi Adult Swim Musicals Legendary dc rotten movies we love TCM crime Marathons Crunchyroll Film Festival 007 comic book movie Showtime Trivia classics indiana jones Disney Plus crime thriller YouTube Anna Paquin critic resources halloween tv 20th Century Fox Pop transformers Best Director Biopics vampires Captain marvel telelvision Paramount Pictures Thanksgiving Oscar Turner Classic Movies Emmys Cannes italian book CBS TV One finale anime dogs TV Land TV renewals Mystery The Academy South by Southwest Film Festival Black History Month Schedule Food Network unscripted space 2020 FX on Hulu Infographic VOD Polls and Games cops dark Peacock debate obi wan revenge First Reviews Stephen King ratings nbcuniversal Rocketman Shondaland Holiday VICE trophy batman video spider-man video on demand 73rd Emmy Awards aliens royal family Amazon Prime Video Podcast Sundance Best and Worst Ellie Kemper Focus Features what to watch Apple feel good YA robots Crackle zombies superman halloween Comedy Video Games SXSW 2022 Action 90s San Diego Comic-Con slasher Tokyo Olympics Music Mary poppins WGN young adult Marvel Studios HFPA suspense Pet Sematary medical drama Epix Tumblr USA emmy awards Star Trek Superheroe Kids & Family blockbuster elevated horror The Witch MGM lord of the rings independent 99% hispanic franchise thriller Musical A24 indie BBC America superhero all-time TV 93rd Oscars news Interview 71st Emmy Awards legend Endgame cancelled TV shows Certified Fresh singing competition The CW toronto razzies movie Mudbound Fantasy Tags: Comedy Walt Disney Pictures australia TV movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt hidden camera Family game of thrones fast and furious die hard Super Bowl Heroines Sundance Now name the review Awards Tour comic books golden globe awards HBO Max Marvel Television Starz monster movies Binge Guide television james bond GIFs Tarantino technology criterion Paramount Plus twilight Martial Arts Holidays disaster Exclusive Video scorecard screen actors guild Netflix Christmas movies action-comedy MSNBC Ovation The Walking Dead WarnerMedia streaming children's TV Lucasfilm Mindy Kaling NBA Amazon Logo reboot political drama nature japanese films asian-american kaiju theme song summer TV Awards Writers Guild of America marvel cinematic universe Premiere Dates historical drama GoT heist movie dexter The Arrangement IFC Films jamie lee curtis series FOX ABC E! gangster politics documentary olympics SXSW boxing DGA spy thriller YouTube Premium versus Avengers President sports Pacific Islander 2021 canceled TV shows Winners dreamworks LGBT foreign Grammys spanish language animated based on movie game show canceled AMC First Look adventure cats Tomatazos TLC comiccon dceu Lionsgate 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards CBS All Access AMC Plus Oscars festivals kong parents Nat Geo screenings dragons marvel comics fresh live event art house Set visit Disney+ Disney Plus Disney streaming service Reality Competition Comic Book Arrowverse festival cooking Animation 2019 french mission: impossible worst movies Classic Film romance slashers Amazon Studios LGBTQ Lifetime Christmas movies social media Turner zero dark thirty hist CMT leaderboard documentaries stoner summer TV preview obituary japan DC Universe Fox Searchlight rotten hollywood Universal Pictures adenture archives YouTube Red TCA Winter 2020 History sequels spider-verse harry potter dramedy Drama Horror crossover Opinion sag awards true crime Western Pirates Freeform 21st Century Fox Cartoon Network saw spinoff science fiction Vudu DC Comics Extras Film aapi nfl anthology 2015 TCA 2017 police drama popular facebook New York Comic Con cancelled TV series ID SundanceTV Summer Hallmark MTV Hollywood Foreign Press Association Baby Yoda summer preview 4/20 Rocky Box Office book adaptation Best Picture rom-coms Country Television Critics Association 79th Golden Globes Awards CNN FXX breaking bad concert discovery best Television Academy psycho Sundance TV justice league Lifetime BBC 45 Academy Awards USA Network witnail streaming movies Toys BAFTA Alien 24 frames christmas movies Esquire comics Hallmark Christmas movies blaxploitation scary SDCC spain Quiz X-Men doctor who prank live action Marvel Spectrum Originals Superheroes war trailers vs. Warner Bros. Women's History Month Fox News Amazon Prime TBS binge genre Hear Us Out south america boxoffice toy story Syfy Rom-Com Brie Larson Watching Series HBO mockumentary spanish child's play free movies werewolf quibi Nominations National Geographic NYCC hispanic heritage month Masterpiece new york Christmas Winter TV adaptation king kong Creative Arts Emmys A&E TNT biopic travel 2016 black comedy The Purge El Rey PaleyFest high school chucky Netflix Hulu posters Discovery Channel sequel Rock BBC One Trophy Talk CW Seed blockbusters DC streaming service Chernobyl mob Elton John miniseries streamig Reality crime drama ITV BET Awards Best Actress Britbox Countdown psychological thriller The Walt Disney Company rt labs critics edition Disney