Critics Consensus

Suburbicon Is a Stale Satire

Plus, Thank You for Your Serviceis a sobering drama, Stranger Things season 2 is Certified Fresh, and guess Jigsaw's Tomatometer.

by | October 26, 2017 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have the latest directorial outing from George Clooney (Suburbicon, starring Matt Damon and Julianne Moore), a war drama that follows its protagonists from the front lines to the homefront (Thank You For Your Service, starring Miles Teller and Haley Bennett), and the revival of a once-ubiquitous horror franchise (Jigsaw, starring Matt Passmore and Callum Keith Rennie). What are the critics saying?


Suburbicon (2017) 28%


George Clooney and the Coen brothers have made Hollywood magic together on more than one occasion — from O Brother, Where Art Thou? to Intolerable Cruelty, Burn After Reading, and Hail, Caesar!, whenever you see their names together, it’s a pretty reliable indicator that you’re in for a fun time at the movies. They’ve reunited for Suburbicon, with a twist: this time out, Clooney’s in the director’s chair, working from an older Coens script that he polished with his longtime collaborator Grant Heslov — and unlike their previous projects, it’s far less of a goofball laugher. Instead, this dark comedy stars Matt Damon as a ’50s suburbanite embroiled in a murder mystery that’s unraveling while the neighborhood is up in arms about a black family moving in — all ingredients that Clooney and the Coens have made effective use of before. Here, however, critics say the plots feel awkwardly jammed together, and the end result is a movie that’s fatally undermined by tonal inconsistencies that serve to highlight the flaws in that long-shelved screenplay. Less than the sum of its impressive parts, Suburbicon seems destined to become an unloved footnote in the filmographies of all parties involved.

Thank You for Your Service (2017) 77%


For decades in Hollywood, soldiers were treated more or less like action heroes, with noble adventures whose broader implications — and aftereffects — weren’t cause for concern after the closing credits. In more recent years, however, it’s become far more common for movies to delve into what it means to be a soldier, and how difficult it can be to grapple with one’s actions on the battlefield once your tour of duty is over. Writer-director Jason Hall adds to that tradition with Thank You for Your Service, which stars Miles Teller as one among a group of veterans who return from the war in Iraq to discover that their time in the emotional trenches is just beginning. It’s far from feel-good entertainment, in other words, but the story’s nothing if not timely — and critics say Hall and his cast honor real-life veterans with an admirably straightforward drama whose quiet, grounded approach to depicting post-traumatic stress disorder only augments its power. This definitely isn’t the easiest watch among the new arrivals at the cineplex, but if you’re searching for something thought-provoking at the theater this weekend, start with Service.

Jigsaw (2017) 32%


Between the 2004 original and 2010’s Saw 3D, the Saw franchise was an annual institution for horror lovers, with an increasingly elaborate mythology to match the wickedly inventive (and frequently lethal) traps that sent a long list of victims screaming over the edge. Diminishing returns brought the saga to its alleged end with the seventh installment, but no film series stays dead for long anymore — and with this weekend’s Jigsaw, the Saw franchise gets its own stab at reinvention. This time around, police investigators are faced with a spate of new murders that seem to fit the Jigsaw killer’s M.O.; while they race against time to catch the culprit (or culprits), the killings pile up, presumably laying the groundwork for a new era of Saw movies along the way. Obviously, it remains to be seen whether audiences will turn out in sufficient numbers to justify any sequels — and unfortunately, we know just as little about how the critics will react to Jigsaw, because it wasn’t screened in advance. While we wait, let’s make do with a round of Guess the Tomatometer… which is still a lot more fun than trying to extricate yourself from one of those gross traps.

What’s New on TV

Stranger Things: Season 2 (2017) 94%

Stranger Things‘ slow-building sophomore season balances moments of humor and a nostalgic sweetness against a growing horror that’s all the more effective thanks to the show’s full-bodied characters and evocative tone.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Work (2017) , a documentary look at a groundbreaking prison therapy group, is at 100 percent.
  • Bill Nye: Science Guy (2017) , a documentary about the personal and professional life of the titular celebrity scientist, is at 100 percent.
  • God's Own Country (2017) , about a farm worker whose quiet existence is upended by the arrival of a migrant farmhand, is Certified Fresh at 98 percent.
  • Félicité (2017) , about a mother’s desperate efforts to save her son — and support them both — after he’s hospitalized in an accident, is at 92 percent.
  • Novitiate (2017) , about a young nun’s struggles to hold onto her faith during a period of upheaval in the Catholic church, is at 90 percent.
  • Joan Didion: The Center Will Not Hold (2017) , an appreciative look back at the life — and life’s work — of author Joan Didion, is at 83 percent.
  • Mansfield 66/67 (2017) , a documentary investigation into the final years of actress Jayne Mansfield’s short life, is at 83 percent.
  • The Square (2017) , about the existential drama that unfolds after an artist’s new project gathers momentum at an awkward time in his private life, is at 76 percent.
  • The Divine Order (2017) , about upheaval in a Swiss town after a young woman begins agitating for suffrage, is at 71 percent.
  • Crash Pad (2017) , a comedy about two men united in an unlikely friendship after one discovers the other is having an affair with his wife, is at 50 percent.
  • Nails (2017) , in which a woman struggles to hold onto her sanity after a car accident leaves her dependent on machines, is at 44 percent.
  • All I See Is You (2016) , a drama examining the effects on a marriage once a physically dependent partner regains her sight, is at 31 percent.
  • Amityville: The Awakening (2017) , in which the long-running horror series gets a modern-day revival, is at 25 percent.

Tag Cloud

History psycho ABC Signature Turner National Geographic marvel comics comic books cinemax FX on Hulu Emmys YouTube Pirates romance Country versus Podcast hispanic new zealand Food Network television Bravo toy story Paramount Plus FOX psychological thriller comic NYCC mission: impossible Black Mirror video SDCC MSNBC saw a nightmare on elm street Spectrum Originals black comedy Film Festival Song of Ice and Fire kaiju Ghostbusters DC Comics stand-up comedy stop motion Set visit BBC America art house CMT cops Adult Swim Trophy Talk rt labs japan Disney+ Disney Plus elevated horror Apple TV+ Endgame teaser Brie Larson Election 2019 Spike aliens docuseries game show Funimation FX serial killer Women's History Month zombie series HBO remakes biopic composers live action First Reviews Rock comics Comics on TV joker heist movie cooking dogs Columbia Pictures DC Universe witnail IFC Films DC streaming service blockbusters war WGN new star wars movies marvel cinematic universe period drama game of thrones thriller Wes Anderson docudrama GLAAD Elton John Tomatazos Action GIFs Lionsgate kids south america New York Comic Con HBO Go CBS 2015 disaster what to watch Star Wars spider-man justice league harry potter legend A&E blaxploitation Epix BAFTA Tumblr richard e. Grant E! Logo Writers Guild of America Winners Fantasy die hard Amazon Studios latino singing competition Marathons Marvel Winter TV TV renewals dc First Look ghosts 007 Captain marvel emmy awards sopranos parents sitcom CBS All Access Character Guide Opinion romantic comedy festivals The Arrangement Animation kong Cartoon Network foreign Universal SXSW TruTV royal family Trailer adenture police drama Alien TCM golden globe awards 2021 IFC Star Trek Hallmark superman independent 24 frames 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Awards Tour 20th Century Fox Spring TV Quiz hollywood RT21 twilight ratings Rocketman Disney Plus vs. MTV SundanceTV Cannes critics Apple TV Plus breaking bad 99% natural history vampires spy thriller Exclusive Video comiccon scary Syfy robots comedies AMC Biopics films dceu Discovery Channel The Walt Disney Company ITV doctor who Vudu sports Broadway ID quibi PaleyFest The Purge Britbox Heroines diversity 21st Century Fox rt labs critics edition Comedy El Rey Superheroes wonder woman olympics laika technology scary movies Box Office Walt Disney Pictures VH1 werewolf Pacific Islander Paramount Network Comic-Con@Home 2021 rom-coms nbcuniversal strong female leads Disney Channel travel See It Skip It theme song Comic Book TV One Acorn TV Reality Competition casting cars Marvel Television facebook TBS DirecTV suspense Amazon Prime Video jurassic park Interview 90s Disney streaming service Mindy Kaling golden globes Tarantino 1990s godzilla book crime thriller dreamworks 45 Tubi Starz cancelled TV series Pop cults Music X-Men DGA 4/20 American Society of Cinematographers indiana jones APB Lucasfilm Disney news Sneak Peek TCA 2017 Esquire satire AMC Plus Anna Paquin Television Critics Association japanese nfl TLC USA Amazon Sundance TV mob TV movies Pet Sematary Amazon Prime Crackle MCU Neflix PBS talk show Photos chucky documentary debate Apple live event king kong miniseries directors Best and Worst Lifetime Showtime hispanic heritage month TIFF dragons OWN Fox Searchlight dramedy ESPN worst movies Polls and Games Family spider-verse adventure Baby Yoda Fall TV Watching Series Creative Arts Emmys Pixar anime documentaries Pride Month Premiere Dates finale medical drama IMDb TV Rocky Black History Month Mystery Image Comics classics slasher Mary poppins italian video on demand ViacomCBS zombies Sci-Fi movies book adaptation aapi Ellie Kemper Rom-Com Ovation Horror Oscars jamie lee curtis reboot movie Stephen King Academy Awards Extras cancelled Musical australia Musicals rt archives Lifetime Christmas movies Chernobyl 71st Emmy Awards E3 child's play BBC biography zero dark thirty Red Carpet christmas movies archives Travel Channel name the review crossover know your critic The CW VICE anthology cancelled TV shows popular Schedule social media best Nickelodeon free movies RT History comic book movies Paramount action-comedy hidden camera obituary slashers Freeform Peacock asian-american green book discovery TCA Drama fast and furious 72 Emmy Awards Nat Geo Television Academy high school Crunchyroll halloween tv BET Martial Arts The Academy superhero LGBT Year in Review Warner Bros. streaming movies adaptation Universal Pictures Thanksgiving posters nature Valentine's Day Hear Us Out black trailers crime drama children's TV sag awards lord of the rings all-time Sundance Now Emmy Nominations 2018 Grammys WarnerMedia streaming indie politics The Witch Toys rotten movies we love screen actors guild stoner criterion TNT Pop TV canceled genre spanish festival batman HBO Max Arrowverse hist Superheroe supernatural binge ABC sequels award winner PlayStation telelvision Mudbound spinoff YouTube Premium Turner Classic Movies women mockumentary ABC Family based on movie Shondaland Christmas Hallmark Christmas movies President Trivia pirates of the caribbean revenge historical drama international Kids & Family Awards YA San Diego Comic-Con LGBTQ canceled TV shows unscripted Teen comic book movie young adult Certified Fresh rotten YouTube Red transformers Super Bowl CW Seed venice TV Land target Holidays TCA Winter 2020 Infographic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spanish language political drama Reality Cosplay science fiction prank Countdown CNN tv talk Tokyo Olympics BET Awards sequel dark Marvel Studios TCA Awards GoT new york critic resources cartoon 2017 The Walking Dead Legendary Netflix james bond crime USA Network VOD Sundance 2020 NBA BBC One NBC toronto blockbuster Summer gangster Mary Tyler Moore universal monsters Film cats king arthur true crime Instagram Live franchise Comedy Central Shudder scorecard feel good renewed TV shows 93rd Oscars FXX OneApp razzies mcc Western deadpool Masterpiece football 73rd Emmy Awards boxing Classic Film A24 fresh animated monster movies concert worst spain Mary Poppins Returns space cancelled television dexter halloween Calendar french scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Binge Guide basketball Netflix Christmas movies mutant reviews Holiday boxoffice Avengers screenings Dark Horse Comics Fox News Sony Pictures Hulu TV 2016 Nominations Video Games