The 50th-Anniversary Rocky Tomatometer Update

To celebrate 50 years of the Rocky franchise, the Rotten Tomatoes curation team swept over 300 reviews to update the franchise's Tomatometer scores.


TAGGED AS:

A collage of movie posters for the first five Rocky films

The Latest: See the making of Rocky dramatized in I Play Rocky. Get your tickets at Fandango.


In 1976, in the city of Philadelphia, Rocky Balboa went the distance in the ring against heavyweight champ Apollo Creed, and the world learned the name of the Italian Stallion. Rocky was a smash success, going on to win three Academy Awards and start a namesake franchise, complete with a spin-off film series about Apollo’s son Adonis. 

Now the franchise gets a look back at its humble origins with the upcoming release of I Play Rocky. The biopic, starring Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone (who, in turn, stars as Rocky Balboa), details the true story behind the development and production of Rocky, an unlikely success that echoes its protagonist’s journey from zero to hero. 

To celebrate the 50th anniversary of the release of Rocky, the Rotten Tomatoes archival team swept through contemporaneous reviews of the first five titles in the franchise. Overall, 334 archival reviews were added for a complete Tomatometer overhaul. Read on for the updated scores: 


ROCKY (1976)

Original Score: 93% with 74 reviews  
Updated Score: 95% with 140 reviews  
+2% with 66 archival reviews added 

Rocky was close to universally praised upon its release. Critics loved Sylvester Stallone’s naturalistic performance as the titular boxer, and many others also praised the movie’s Cinderella-story fable grounded in gritty realism. Rocky‘s triumphant ending was a huge breath of fresh air during an era when cinema was largely cynical. Stallone himself even hoped the ending would resonate with viewers, saying in a December 1976 interview with the Associated Press, “You gotta… give [the audience] a chance to root for themselves. They haven’t been getting that in movies. I hope Rocky becomes trendy, for that reason.” Liane Heller of the Waterloo Region Record eloquently summed it up in a review from February 1977: “Rocky is a movie for lovers.”  


ROCKY II (1979)

Original Score: 68% with 34 reviews  
Updated Score: 70% with 90 reviews  
+2% with 57 archival reviews added 

Rocky II generally cleared the bar of expectations for a sequel circa 1979, when critics had a ton of antipathy for them. Stallone remained a standout for his performance as Rocky: Gerald Nachman of the San Francisco Chronicle called Balboa “both a stereotype and an original…such a crowd-pleaser.” A good cluster of critics thought it was just as good, if not better than, the original Rocky, but most noted that it was more of a remake than a sequel, with an even more triumphant ending. Many found this to be lazy, but most thought that the formula was still effective enough — a compelling but “fairly cheap bid [for] your emotions,” as the Buffalo News’ John Dwyer put it. 


ROCKY III (1982)

Original Score: 68% with 41 reviews  
Updated Score: 66% with 94 reviews  
-2% with 53 archival reviews added 

The third time was not necessarily the charm for the Rocky franchise, as reviews for Rocky III were a mixed bag. Some, like the Gannett News Service’s Jack Garner, thought Rocky’s “top dog” status made him a less interesting character as the franchise started to wear out its welcome. What all critics could agree on, however, was that Carl Weathers delivered a knockout performance as Rocky’s former nemesis Apollo Creed — Michael Maza of the Arizona Republic wrote that Rocky’s alliance with Creed “propels Rocky III to a satisfying, if unsurprising, conclusion.” 


ROCKY IV (1985)

Original Score: 39% with 51 reviews  
Updated Score: 38% with 134 reviews  
-1% with 78 archival reviews added 

With the second-highest number of reviews added in the franchise’s archival sweep, Rocky IV saw the smallest change in its Tomatometer score. Critics noted the film began to look like Stallone’s other project Rambo, saying the franchise had lost its underdog spirit in favor of shots of Rocky’s “oiled pecs and delts,” according to the Philadelphia Inquirer’s Desmond Ryan. In terms of the film’s Cold War-centric narrative, critics found it crude, naive, and at times dangerously simplistic. Hampered by music video editing (Kathleen Carroll of the New York Daily News called the film a “juiced up MTV video”), overly flashy visuals, and an overreliance on recycled footage from past movies, Rocky IV was seen to be a complete reversal of everything the original Rocky movie was. That said, a handful of critics did manage to find some worth in the film as an in-your-face, turn-your-brain-off hardbody boxing showcase, and it remains something of a cult favorite, thanks in part to Dolph Lundgren’s quotable villain Ivan Drago.


ROCKY V (1990)

Original Score: 27% with 37 reviews  
Updated Score: 36% with 122 reviews  
+9% with 80 archival reviews 

Even though the film had the largest change in Tomatometer score, the majority of critics still found Rocky V to be a noble but vastly undercooked back-to-basics attempt to recapture the soul of the original film. Rocky’s return to his Philadelphia roots was appreciated for “regaining touch with the qualities that caused viewers to care so much for the guy,” per the Fort Worth Star Telegram’s Michael H. Price, but many critics found Rocky’s fall from grace too narratively rushed. While critics praised supporting cast performances like Sage Stallone and Richard Gant, Sylvester Stallone’s performance as Rocky was found to be at its dullest. Rocky V was also hindered by its script, rife with endless monologues, ropey platitudes, and hopelessly predictable plotting. “There’s more dramatic depth to TV’s Saturday-morning cartoons,” wrote Jeff Strickler of the Minneapolis Star Tribune.


For more of the critics’ perspective, check out the newly added reviews for Rocky, Rocky II, Rocky III, Rocky IV, and Rocky V.

Archival curation by Andrew Allen, Dom Pembleton, and Rob Fowler.

Find Something Fresh! Discover What to Watch, Read Reviews, Leave Ratings and Build Watchlists. Download the Rotten Tomatoes App.