Michael vs. Freddy vs. Jason: Who Is the Ultimate Horror Baddie?

Who makes the most money? Whose movies are the best? Who has the most creative kills? We break it all down. You know, for science.

by | October 14, 2020 | Comments

It’s machete vs. butcher knife vs. razor-glove thingy. It’s hockey mask vs. Shatner mask vs. serious burns. It’s hulkish brute vs. silent-type vs. pun-loving babbler. That’s right, it’s Jason vs. Michael vs. Freddy in a special episode of Vs. where we answer once and for all: Who is the ultimate horror baddie? We don’t answer the question by throwing them in a sorority house and seeing who does the most damage (though we’re now going to copyright that film idea), but with math: we’re grading these bad boys on box office performance, as well Audience and Tomatometer Scores. Plus, host and Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis looks at their cultural relevance and carnage creativity to determine a victor. And if you don’t agree, as ever, let us know in the comments.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Thumbnail image: ©Dimension Films, ©New Line Cinema/courtesy Everett Collection, ©New Line Cinema

Tag Cloud

Winners Drama sag awards cats screen actors guild Reality golden globes animated Fall TV miniseries laika TCA 2017 Ellie Kemper political drama Dark Horse Comics X-Men cooking Women's History Month Food Network documentary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt critics Holiday LGBT HBO anthology Watching Series movies nature Cosplay true crime die hard DirecTV Oscars Television Critics Association toy story social media comic parents robots cartoon boxoffice Film LGBTQ FX Elton John Mindy Kaling psycho 21st Century Fox Infographic Masterpiece foreign Turner Classic Movies AMC spain USA Network best Columbia Pictures Esquire mockumentary Certified Fresh vampires IFC Films Reality Competition 2020 Emmys docudrama independent Arrowverse Discovery Channel TCA FXX Musicals period drama Family dragons E! unscripted quibi Marathons romance south america batman police drama elevated horror Western Musical Mary Poppins Returns Video Games Horror emmy awards Box Office spinoff Election Britbox biography Quiz Funimation Disney teaser travel Spike hispanic natural history 2018 anime 4/20 YouTube Premium Christmas Trophy Talk Lucasfilm Rocketman award winner dceu Baby Yoda Biopics directors GoT zombies Stephen King aliens game show FOX video on demand Apple TV Plus cancelled Trailer Vudu theme song documentaries Netflix binge Marvel Television 2016 dark VOD PaleyFest Lionsgate Rocky Martial Arts thriller TBS Ghostbusters cinemax Countdown comiccon 2017 crossover Mystery Academy Awards Tubi Tarantino Superheroes crime TruTV Freeform nbcuniversal RT21 OWN news blaxploitation MTV indiana jones TLC superhero Year in Review dramedy PlayStation DC streaming service hollywood toronto VICE supernatural Disney streaming service CW Seed cops scorecard Pop Spring TV SDCC Mudbound war Crunchyroll serial killer DC Comics El Rey Teen revenge Acorn TV kids Cannes comedies justice league strong female leads composers Star Trek Amazon Prime Schedule TCA Awards sequel Comedy Central Amazon festival football cars Emmy Nominations nfl Summer book Universal Epix YA Song of Ice and Fire child's play Premiere Dates History archives medical drama Awards Kids & Family Awards Tour scary movies Creative Arts Emmys Photos New York Comic Con Ovation BAFTA Bravo television witnail cancelled TV series Hear Us Out talk show casting universal monsters worst Disney+ Disney Plus CNN french Valentine's Day BET Awards Trivia Thanksgiving sitcom President Marvel Studios Amazon Prime Video Turner dogs finale children's TV Fantasy transformers Nat Geo APB spanish language Action technology American Society of Cinematographers twilight Fox News 71st Emmy Awards Peacock richard e. Grant stoner crime thriller slashers Chernobyl Pride Month Extras Grammys dc adaptation Shondaland Crackle Television Academy Avengers satire GIFs canceled TV shows Sundance TV The CW Interview See It Skip It Calendar CMT obituary spanish disaster politics VH1 BET Captain marvel christmas movies Endgame National Geographic indie Apple TV+ crime drama werewolf blockbuster Sony Pictures MSNBC Polls and Games Sci-Fi remakes Winter TV zombie cancelled television Lifetime TIFF San Diego Comic-Con Travel Channel Set visit Nickelodeon diversity Sneak Peek YouTube Red WarnerMedia what to watch spy thriller screenings doctor who Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Walt Disney Pictures Writers Guild of America adventure Brie Larson Toys Holidays Super Bowl jamie lee curtis sequels DGA Paramount ghosts Nominations Pet Sematary TCM space classics Comics on TV SXSW concert Character Guide cancelled TV shows First Reviews DC Universe Mary Tyler Moore Adult Swim BBC MCU discovery historical drama Comic Book A&E BBC America USA Showtime ABC Country Tumblr based on movie TV stop motion Comedy 45 YouTube The Purge harry potter fast and furious ESPN spider-man CBS versus chucky ITV halloween Rock free movies stand-up comedy CBS All Access Lifetime Christmas movies all-time BBC One franchise 007 Star Wars Netflix Christmas movies NYCC 20th Century Fox Film Festival HBO Max TCA Winter 2020 hist science fiction Logo HBO Go Black Mirror Classic Film Starz E3 Disney Channel Anna Paquin facebook Marvel Fox Searchlight The Academy Shudder criterion 2019 canceled Spectrum Originals IFC rotten Red Carpet Cartoon Network a nightmare on elm street singing competition Binge Guide Sundance Now Music mutant NBC game of thrones 2015 Hallmark Christmas movies comics Pirates video asian-american 24 frames ABC Family series Superheroe Warner Bros. Heroines romantic comedy Best and Worst venice name the review The Walking Dead worst movies Black History Month zero dark thirty Pop TV breaking bad reboot Amazon Studios Podcast halloween tv A24 TV renewals Disney Plus SundanceTV Hulu mission: impossible OneApp The Witch sports Hallmark Apple latino WGN films The Arrangement Rom-Com cults rotten movies we love 72 Emmy Awards green book GLAAD reviews FX on Hulu tv talk PBS TV Land Opinion Animation First Look RT History Mary poppins festivals renewed TV shows TNT Syfy joker Tomatazos Pixar streaming Sundance ratings psychological thriller Paramount Network italian movie