Critics Consensus

Jack Reacher: Never Go Back Probably Shouldn't Have Gone Back

Plus, Ouija: Origin of Evil is a vastly superior sequel, Keeping Up with the Joneses is a dud, and Black Mirror is masterful dystopian storytelling.

by | October 20, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have the return of Jack Reacher (Jack Reacher: Never Go Back, starring Tom Cruise and Cobie Smulders) a board game prequel (Ouija: Origin of Evil, starring Lulu Wilson and Elizabeth Reaser), a suburban spy comedy (Keeping Up with the Joneses, starring Zach Galifianakis and Isla Fisher), and Tyler Perry‘s latest drag (Boo! A Madea Halloween, starring Perry and Cassi Davis). What are the critics saying?

Jack Reacher: Never Go Back (2016) 38%

The first Jack Reacher wasn’t exactly a critical darling in 2012, but it had a slew of bestselling books just waiting to inspire sequels — and more importantly, a hefty enough worldwide gross to justify the expenditure — so Tom Cruise comes sprinting back into action this weekend with Jack Reacher: Never Go Back. Unsurprisingly, critics are even less enthused this time around, and reviews describe Reacher’s second big-screen outing about the way you’d expect; although Cruise remains an aggressively watchable presence and Cobie Smulders makes for a fine co-star, the boilerplate plot (and the absence of Werner Herzog, who played the first film’s villain) adds up to a sequel that struggles to (ahem) reach its predecessor’s rather low bar. See it if you’re itching for action this weekend, but temper your expectations accordingly.

Ouija: Origin of Evil (2016) 83%

Speaking of sequels to movies that didn’t inspire much in the way of critical applause, here’s Ouija: Origin of Evil. The 2014 original racked up a pitiful 7 percent on the Tomatometer — but it also made more than $100 million against a budget of $5 million, so a follow-up was a foregone conclusion. Few might have guessed, however, the critical reversal of fortune enjoyed by this new installment, which is garnering some of the best reviews earned by any horror movie this year. Although a number of writers have pointed out that Origin of Evil isn’t anywhere near the scariest or most original movie in its genre, they’re just as quick to praise director Mike Flanagan (Oculus, Hush), whose skill helps make this not only better than its predecessor, but solidly entertaining in its own right.

Keeping Up With the Joneses (2016) 19%

Are you an impassioned fan of Jon Hamm, Gal Gadot, Isla Fisher, or Zach Galifianakis? Have you ever stopped to consider the hilarity that might ensue if a couple of secret agents moved in next door to a pair of bored suburbanites? If you answered “yes” to either of those questions, then Keeping Up with the Joneses might be just the movie for you — but otherwise, the vast majority of critics are urging you to give this putative comedy a wide berth. Reviews say the cast gives it their all, but they’re consistently let down by Greg Mottola‘s listless direction and an uninspired script. If you’re in the mood to watch any or all of these stars, you’ll probably be far better served by queuing up one of their many superior efforts.

Tyler Perry's Boo! A Madea Halloween (2016) 19%

Last but not least, we have Boo! A Madea Halloween, writer-director Tyler Perry’s ninth outing as the titular tough matriarch. This time around, she’s apparently facing off against an array of paranormal entities — all while dealing with some juvenile delinquents. Unfortunately, because it wasn’t screened in advance, that’s all we can tell you… and you know what that means: it’s time to Guess the Tomatometer!

What’s New on TV


Black Mirror: Season 3 (2016) 86%

Black Mirror answers the call for a larger season with half a dozen solid episodes that prove Charlie Brooker remains a masterful dystopian storyteller.

The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again (2016) 27%

Laverne Cox‘s fabulous portrayal of Frank N. Furter leads a strong ensemble effort, but the stars can’t infuse this reimagining with enough energy, creativity, and quirk to make TRHPS: Let’s Do the Time Warp Again a worthwhile endeavor.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • A Stray (2016) , about the travails of a homeless Muslim teen in Minneapolis, is at 100 percent.
  • We Are X (2016) , a documentary look at the wildly popular band X Japan on the eve of a long-awaited reunion, is at 100 percent.
  • Moonlight (2016) , a gently probing look at one man’s search for meaning across several stages of his life, is Certified Fresh at 98 percent.
  • Fire at Sea (2016) , a documentary about the humanitarian crisis unfolding in and around the Mediterranean island of Lampedusa, is at 98 percent.
  • The Handmaiden (2016) , director Park Chan-wook‘s period drama inspired by the Sarah Waters novel Fingersmith, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Creepy (2016) , which marks writer-director Kiyoshi Kurosawa’s return to the thriller, is at 92 percent.
  • In a Valley of Violence (2016) , director Ti West‘s affectionately faithful take on the Western genre, is at 78 percent.
  • King Cobra (2016) , about the potentially deadly competition that erupts over the services of a gay porn star, is at 56 percent.
  • The Beat Beneath My Feet (2014) , starring Luke Perry as a former rock star hiding out in suburbia after faking his death to avoid the IRS, is at 50 percent.
  • 31 (2016) , the latest luridly violent outing from director Rob Zombie, is at 46 percent.
  • Michael Moore in TrumpLand (2016) , the veteran documentarian’s attempt to sway voters in the 2016 presidential election, is at 43 percent.
  • The Whole Truth (2016) , a courtroom drama starring Keanu Reeves and Renee Zellweger, is at 21 percent.
  • Autumn Lights (2016) , about an American photographer’s fateful meeting with a pair of strangers in Iceland, is at 20 percent.
  • Jacqueline Argentine (2016) , about the aftermath of a woman’s alleged leak of state secrets, is at 20 percent.
  • American Pastoral (2016) , debuting director Ewan McGregor‘s adaptation of the 1997 Philip Roth novel, is at 17 percent.

Tag Cloud

HFPA films Mudbound romance HBO Go witnail Best Director spanish language 21st Century Fox medical drama legend Elton John Red Carpet joker festival godzilla USA ghosts scary movies stoner Holiday asian-american dc Valentine's Day Showtime 007 99% debate New York Comic Con FX ABC Signature Oscar razzies mob IFC Films PBS breaking bad TBS worst movies Fantasy Winners superhero Dark Horse Comics zombie slasher Netflix Christmas movies spinoff Apple TV+ boxoffice Britbox marvel comics talk show Marvel Interview The Walt Disney Company Superheroe 93rd Oscars aliens Fargo fresh Ellie Kemper San Diego Comic-Con Schedule video rotten biography Awards Tour cults Arrowverse archives cinemax pirates of the caribbean feel good lord of the rings know your critic 45 hispanic crossover Horror biopic versus harry potter dark Star Wars X-Men japan posters nbcuniversal The Purge dexter A&E blockbuster Marathons TCA Drama streaming Comic Book war Western adaptation zombies Endgame vampires Musicals Travel Channel slashers Disney Channel Tumblr GoT football DGA trophy scorecard boxing Image Comics TV Land free movies Apple MGM Chernobyl mission: impossible comic book movies cancelled TV shows dragons American Society of Cinematographers CMT TCM DC Comics Film Festival Pride Month concert rt labs critics edition Podcast History dceu Pop DirecTV politics screenings docudrama 2020 Thanksgiving emmy awards wonder woman Amazon Cannes facebook HBO Max worst President YouTube DC streaming service finale Rock heist movie basketball remakes binge Ghostbusters 94th Oscars Tubi cops reviews game of thrones Legendary Broadway parents Year in Review Marvel Studios Mary Poppins Returns Sundance WGN Nat Geo Certified Fresh Best and Worst genre Brie Larson Ovation docuseries The Arrangement suspense Comedy Marvel Television deadpool APB tv talk TNT E! BET Awards Sony Pictures Superheroes Awards TV One E3 ViacomCBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina green book BAFTA 2018 comedies Disney GLAAD AMC women Character Guide A24 black comedy latino The Witch all-time leaderboard casting Musical Amazon Studios Action Hallmark superman doctor who CBS Exclusive Video Epix Amazon Prime Video sports Apple TV Plus Turner Classic Movies streamig supernatural Hear Us Out Instagram Live rt labs discovery TV renewals Starz Mary poppins NBC Lifetime Christmas movies Heroines Netflix Comics on TV blockbusters Vudu political drama crime drama Pet Sematary Avengers Spectrum Originals miniseries Freeform 24 frames directors transformers ratings 90s book adaptation CBS All Access sopranos police drama Walt Disney Pictures Lifetime Best Actor halloween science fiction jurassic park space Esquire satire crime mockumentary new zealand christmas movies cancelled TV series screen actors guild twilight rotten movies we love National Geographic period drama El Rey First Look Polls and Games Discovery Channel laika Crackle The Walking Dead Countdown fast and furious Winter TV thriller Disney+ Disney Plus Toys streaming movies Mystery cats Fall TV comiccon comic Rocketman 79th Golden Globes Awards quibi universal monsters Holidays NYCC richard e. Grant critics psychological thriller Tomatazos SXSW 2022 werewolf Masterpiece scary golden globes cancelled nature Black Mirror action-comedy Lionsgate 2015 TLC spider-man YouTube Red Hollywood Foreign Press Association marvel cinematic universe technology chucky based on movie 2017 news South by Southwest Film Festival Hulu YA 4/20 Captain marvel Creative Arts Emmys Family Mary Tyler Moore romantic comedy Wes Anderson VH1 Cartoon Network Sundance TV Country CW Seed composers venice obi wan rom-coms canceled 1990s Pacific Islander indiana jones adenture criterion IFC dreamworks toy story canceled TV shows CNN Stephen King zero dark thirty RT History saw USA Network prank classics Video Games Logo Tarantino FXX 71st Emmy Awards black robots award winner revenge best Kids & Family hidden camera kong TV movies sag awards ESPN italian batman Tokyo Olympics Adult Swim LGBT franchise Rocky BBC Fox Searchlight Trivia Trailer Music singing competition stop motion Sci-Fi critic resources PaleyFest Acorn TV Premiere Dates Shondaland documentary Paramount Network cartoon a nightmare on elm street Anna Paquin obituary game show ABC Family Reality SDCC Universal Pictures Alien Emmy Nominations hollywood TV series Food Network golden globe awards AMC Plus Star Trek elevated horror halloween tv blaxploitation Animation young adult comic books Cosplay toronto OWN Summer Pop TV aapi Martial Arts reboot Pirates Teen children's TV olympics sitcom 2021 See It Skip It australia Lucasfilm The CW YouTube Premium japanese new york Television Academy Disney streaming service theme song documentaries Hallmark Christmas movies Infographic Calendar strong female leads ABC Box Office king arthur SundanceTV serial killer Reality Competition cars Opinion kaiju monster movies Television Critics Association BBC America comics VICE Academy Awards Paramount Plus psycho Nickelodeon justice league Tags: Comedy indie MSNBC name the review FX on Hulu vs. Amazon Prime Sneak Peek 72 Emmy Awards television telelvision Warner Bros. scene in color foreign Quiz live action popular Paramount Spring TV Set visit live event target natural history First Reviews 20th Century Fox HBO james bond cooking ID sequel Nominations 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ITV true crime Christmas MCU Rom-Com Spike Black History Month Columbia Pictures TCA 2017 Best Picture what to watch movies LGBTQ Song of Ice and Fire Super Bowl RT21 Photos die hard video on demand spy thriller spider-verse new star wars movies movie hist Trophy Talk TCA Awards crime thriller Best Actress nfl historical drama international Neflix cancelled television Bravo independent Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt art house Watching Series WarnerMedia book Film teaser Emmys anime dogs royal family TCA Winter 2020 Sundance Now TruTV Comedy Central dramedy Universal PlayStation NBA travel FOX Writers Guild of America 73rd Emmy Awards MTV Grammys SXSW Biopics Peacock trailers spanish disaster Mindy Kaling BBC One The Academy renewed TV shows Baby Yoda TIFF stand-up comedy 2019 DC Universe diversity comic book movie Prime Video rt archives Extras OneApp Turner BET social media king kong Syfy Oscars spain anthology Binge Guide jamie lee curtis Election Shudder VOD adventure Fox News high school hispanic heritage month Crunchyroll Pixar sequels gangster Comic-Con@Home 2021 Women's History Month kids Disney Plus animated festivals GIFs Funimation south america child's play IMDb TV unscripted Classic Film 2016 mcc mutant french