Critics Consensus

Holmes & Watson Is a Clueless Comedy

Plus, Vice is flawed but intriguing and Destroyer is Certified Fresh.

by | December 27, 2018 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got daffy detectives (Holmes & Watson, starring Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly) and a ruthless veep (Vice, starring Christian Bale and Amy Adams). What are the critics saying?


Holmes and Watson (2018) 10%

One of the most enduring literary characters of all time, Sherlock Holmes has been portrayed on stage, television, and film hundreds of times by dozens of actors, from Basil Rathbone to Robert Downey Jr. to Benedict Cumberbatch. With this week’s Holmes & Watson, Will Ferrell adds his name to the list, appearing opposite Step Brothers co-star John C. Reilly as the iconic duo, whose talents are enlisted to help prevent the assassination of the Queen of England. Unfortunately, critics almost unanimously agree that this comedic take on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s legendary sleuth is an unfortunate misfire that squanders the talents of all involved, including a supporting cast that includes Ralph Fiennes, Rebecca Hall, Kelly Macdonald, and Rob Brydon. There are far better comedies showcasing the chemistry between Ferrell and Reilly, and the unwieldy mix of anachronistic references and potty humor on display here do little to reinforce their on-screen legacy.


Vice (2018) 66%

After directing a series of absurd comedies starring Will Ferrell like the Anchorman movies, Talladega Nights, and Step Brothers, Adam McKay took a soft turn into more adult territory with 2015’s The Big Short, an unusual and inventive look at the housing bubble that led to the 2008 financial crisis. This week marks the next step in his evolution, as he tackles the rise to power of former U.S. Vice President Dick Cheney with similar storytelling panache in Vice, starring Christian Bale as the enigmatic veep, Amy Adams as his wife Lynne, Steve Carell as Donald Rumsfeld, and Sam Rockwell as George W. Bush. Critics say McKay’s irreverent tone sometimes feels like a mismatch for the serious material the film covers, but it’s nevertheless an ambitious undertaking that’s made better by strong performances from its A-list cast — especially Bale, who disappears into the role under eerily spot-on makeup and more than a few extra pounds. While it may not be as incisive or amusing as The Big Short, Vice is still worth a watch for a glimpse into the life of a famously unknowable man.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

CW Seed TBS VICE Sundance streaming USA Network Esquire comiccon X-Men LGBTQ President Fall TV Fantasy Sci-Fi ITV Music 45 Ovation Marvel Pirates Superheroes social media cops dramedy Box Office Emmys Winter TV Tomatazos Crackle period drama Countdown Christmas Writers Guild of America television cats Infographic Country Lifetime History The Arrangement IFC El Rey Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Universal Super Bowl Rocky Apple Rom-Com Video Games Nat Geo Year in Review Valentine's Day Showtime Superheroe Paramount Spectrum Originals Cartoon Network Watching Series YA Anna Paquin Mary Tyler Moore Toys SXSW TV Land dceu Calendar Best and Worst SDCC award winner vampires TIFF biography NYCC singing competition Dark Horse Comics Amazon cooking ESPN Awards Tour police drama hist Netflix sports YouTube Premium RT History Certified Fresh BET true crime MTV MCU Grammys PaleyFest Mystery A&E Sneak Peek Nominations Martial Arts FOX TCA 2017 docudrama mockumentary supernatural Extras Pop 2018 Action historical drama TCA National Geographic composers Lionsgate SundanceTV crime thriller E3 TNT Interview 2016 binge TV medical drama Spring TV Election Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Character Guide Columbia Pictures Podcast Western Ghostbusters Pixar miniseries doctor who BBC America Walt Disney Pictures based on movie golden globes Brie Larson Masterpiece Musicals GLAAD Drama 21st Century Fox CMT aliens CBS USA TruTV Comics on TV DirecTV political drama Trophy Talk talk show Food Network 20th Century Fox adaptation green book what to watch discovery Hulu Musical adventure Photos Star Trek Quiz Syfy harry potter TCM Teen Warner Bros. ABC Family thriller DGA American Society of Cinematographers WGN San Diego Comic-Con 2015 psycho jamie lee curtis HBO casting Captain marvel Disney Channel spy thriller TLC Epix comic ABC Trailer facebook Freeform IFC Films 2017 sequel serial killer Comedy Central crime drama Comic Book Animation DC Universe Comedy Ellie Kemper PBS war Awards 2019 Thanksgiving Paramount Network See It Skip It sitcom E! First Look transformers boxoffice technology diversity Shondaland robots Rock NBC Cosplay Amazon Prime Reality Competition Trivia Sony Pictures Black Mirror justice league anthology Mary Poppins Returns MSNBC Winners FXX Set visit VH1 Opinion Summer unscripted Nickelodeon Schedule ratings Horror Bravo New York Comic Con Biopics blaxploitation Star Wars Holidays GIFs Mary poppins cults Creative Arts Emmys crime Reality DC streaming service Kids & Family Disney APB spider-man FX Spike Fox News Shudder festivals anime dc The CW Oscars Britbox YouTube Red Sundance Now cinemax Premiere Dates CNN finale Tumblr zombie Adult Swim 24 frames Marathons CBS All Access Mindy Kaling mutant DC Comics 007 Starz BBC science fiction crossover OWN Logo Red Carpet Song of Ice and Fire GoT travel Acorn TV romance politics zombies Lucasfilm Polls and Games AMC