Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: A Star Wars: Episode X Could Actually Be Great For Everything Not Skywalker

The Star Wars saga is so much bigger than the Skywalkers, and an Episode X is inevitable. Here's how and why we think it can work.

by | January 10, 2020 | Comments

In its rush to close out the Skywalker Saga, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker left a lot on the table. Pretty much everything not directly related to Rey, Luke, Leia, Ben Solo, and Sheev Palpatine was left hanging for future storytellers to resolve in comics, novels, television shows, and, yes, future films. And, as it happens, at least a few ideas directly related to them are still in the margins as well. But with so much about the other characters (and the galaxy for that matter) unresolved, it would seem there is plenty of material for a direct follow-up to The Rise of Skywalker – an Episode X, as it were.

So let’s go on a thought experiment and consider what an Episode X might look like and why it may eventually be vital for Star Wars to continue to the episode saga… if perhaps in a slightly different way going forward.

Episode X Was Part Of The Original Plan

TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by TM and ©copyright Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved courtesy Everett Collection)

In the very early days of Star Wars success, George Lucas’ vision was very much in flux. As he has mentioned in numerous interviews, the film was the result of a massive 200-page script that more or less formed the backbone of the Original Trilogy (and, as we’ve discussed elsewhere, the eventual Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace). Early drafts also hinted at the sequels, with one revision directly telling the reader the Leia character would have a larger role in the next film.

But even as The Empire Strikes Back began to coalesce into a shooting script, Lucas and his collaborators considered a 12-episode series. That sequence was envisioned as more of a James Bond-style format, with fewer narrative ties between episodes and certain films acting more as preludes or epilogues to larger story ideas like the Clone Wars. It was abandoned in favor of a nine-episode story in which the later sequels would see Leia become “queen of her people,” Luke finding his sister (who was not initially intended to be Leia), and an Episode IX introduction of the Emperor. All of this changed as Lucas became disenchanted with Star Wars during the development of Return of the Jedi, which condensed several ideas from the later episodes into its plot.

Nonetheless, we totally expect the early references to the 12-episode cycle to become part of the Lucasfilm narrative when it inevitably announces Episode X.

And make no mistake, Episode X is inevitable.

A Matter of Timing

Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Although inevitable, the timing of Episode X is less of a certainty. After its experiment with yearly Star Wars films proved untenable, Disney pulled back and cancelled all of its Star Wars Story spin-off pictures. A film is scheduled for a 2022 release – with a director reportedly already on board and subsequent films scheduled every two years afterward through 2026 – but it is understood this project will not continue story threads from the Skywalker Saga.

Granted, the possibility still exists that this film could be labeled as Episode X.

But presuming Disney sticks to its new plan of slightly more sporadic Star Wars film releases, an Episode X might be what people want after a decade away from the episodic saga and, seemingly, the forward momentum of Star Wars into an uncharted, post-Palpatine age.

A New New Republic?

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Lucasfilm)

As much as the films are about the Skywalker clan struggling to save the galaxy, the are also about the galaxy’s own failure to prevent its fall into an Empire. Even in the Sequel Trilogy, we see its influence continue and the New Republic unable to cope with those remnants coalescing into the First Order.

It leaves the galaxy with the problem the Republic faced in the infamous Phantom Menace senate scenes: the centralized government is ill-equipped to prevent its own collapse. In its final form, the Sequel Trilogy was also not equipped to address this problem; it chose to wipe out the New Republic instead. So it leaves the remains of the Resistance with a different set of questions than those the Rebel Alliance faced after the Battle of Endor. For the latter, there was a stated goal of restoring the Republic. But will the weary Resistance fighters of the Sequel Trilogy want to do that?

In lieu of a Republic, Episode X could take us into a galaxy without that central leadership. It could be an era when the hyperspace routes are patrolled by more localized coalitions with uneasy alliances and a tacit agreement not to disrupt trade. If we need some familiar faces to give it Star Wars continuity, the Trade Federation could re-emerge as a power player as it maintains security along the spaceways.

Sure, it sounds a little dry – and maybe too much like The Phantom Menace for some – but it offers a new context in which to set up a new adventure. Perhaps a core group of Resistance fighters are still trying to restore the Republic. Or, maybe, just trying to survive in this more lawless galaxy is enough motivation for heroes new and old to engage in a star war.

The Fate Of The Jedi

John Wilson/© Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

(Photo by John Wilson/©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

We’ll be honest, the only final end for the Sith and the Jedi would be a galaxy-wide repudiation of the Force itself – something it seems cannot actually happen, as the Force will always find sentient beings happy to access its power. This means the fate of the Jedi must be decided beyond the vague allusions to the future at the end of The Rise of Skywalker. And while Rey’s (Daisy Ridley) story is seemingly done with her finding an identity, the Expanded Universe has taught us – to borrow a Watchmen line – nothing ever ends.

Your desire to see the restoration of the Jedi depends entirely on how much you like their view of the Force. We’ll admit the Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic video game and its sequel colored our understanding of their absolutism. In that light, we hope the Order can emerge in the post-TROS time period as something more gray. Both the Prequel and Sequel Trilogies seemingly call for a notion of balance as well.

But it is possible that subtext is just too unruly for a continuing series of space adventure movies. Maybe the Order just needs to be unambiguously restored with Rey and Finn (John Boyega) leading the way. An Episode X in this vein could mirror something like The 36th Chamber of Shaolin, with a young adherent learning the ways of the Force and, perhaps, undergoing a trial to face their own Dark Side. While the conflict would be more personal, it would reveal an Order more stabilized than we ever see in any of the films.

And in an interesting quirk, this new Order could be filled with all of those escaped stormtroopers like Finn and Jannah (Naomi Ackie), who felt the pull of the Force so strongly that it prevented them from engaging in the First Order’s oppression. Also, for just this moment, we’ll disregard the fact a bunch of former child soldiers are learning to become warrior magicians because we’re still trying to get an unambiguous victory here for the Jedi.

Allowing Other Stories To Advance

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

(Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Lucasfilm)

In concluding the Skywalker story, Poe (Oscar Isaac), Finn, and Rose (Kelly Marie Tran) were left by the wayside. New characters like Jannah, Zorri (Keri Russell), and Beaumont (Dominic Monaghan) barely had a moment to establish themselves before the final iris-out. And though the actors all seem pretty burned out on Star Wars at the moment – a common occurrence at the end of these trilogies – the characters deserve better.

Giving any one of them the lead position in Episode X would lead to interesting new directions and satisfy fans of those characters – yes, they exist – who felt they all got short shrift in the resolution of Rey and Ben’s (Adam Driver) story.

And since some of them are certainly underdeveloped, Episode X could be a film in which they receive that much-needed development. An ace X-Wing pilot, a former Stormtrooper, a mechanic, and a smuggler form a pretty strong starting point in terms of character dynamics. No doubt many Star Wars RPG parties are composed of that exact mixture right now. With the burden of Palpatine and the Skywalkers off their backs, this group could go chart some of the uncharted new galaxy left in The Rise of Skywalker’s wake.

Breaking The Trilogy Cycle

Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Throughout this discussion, we’ve avoided looking at a potential Episode X as the beginning of a new trilogy for a very specific reason: the format no longer works for the open-ended narrative Star Wars evolved into. The fans’ love of the EU, the success of The Mandalorian, and Disney’s investment in the property as a whole means there can never be a true conclusion. Star Wars is a suite of storytelling tools now. And though commodified by a gigantic corporation, it is the modern mythology early fans always hoped it would become. Star Wars would continue even if there wasn’t a huge monetary benefit in its longevity.

At the same time, it still needs a major storyline to anchor the various ways people interact with the mythology. Episode X could be the beginning of a new saga structure. Like the looser concept of the 12-episode cycle, new Star Wars episode films could be more complete story units on their own while furthering an overall vision of the post-Skywalker galaxy. Sure, it could become as vast and unwieldy as the old EU and its tiered canon structure, but the essential bits of Star Wars lore are for another civilization to agree on a long, long time from now. For those of us living in it, it means an almost boundless array of Star Wars ideas to call our own, while we occasionally gather together for a new episode. And that next new planet, character, or idea may be reason enough for Episode X to become a reality.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

YouTube Premium stoner Lionsgate MSNBC Song of Ice and Fire movies FX anthology Election renewed TV shows golden globes series Bravo Rock zombie Box Office Superheroe Britbox dogs documentaries Apple Captain marvel APB christmas movies Starz Best and Worst DGA Lucasfilm political drama boxoffice X-Men what to watch twilight DC streaming service criterion Comics on TV CNN Winners canceled TV shows OWN Disney streaming service Showtime television ratings slashers hispanic YA Lifetime Kids & Family mockumentary Epix Sony Pictures Amazon Prime Video FXX spanish language strong female leads elevated horror screen actors guild BET Awards RT History CBS Schedule dc Winter TV Ghostbusters Comedy Central game of thrones cults festivals Awards Tour YouTube Red Paramount Network romance Marathons Apple TV Plus based on movie sports Rocky serial killer Pop American Society of Cinematographers The Purge VICE comics universal monsters dceu mission: impossible venice travel worst movies Polls and Games Marvel Studios PBS Women's History Month Sci-Fi HBO die hard romantic comedy technology TCA 2017 period drama Adult Swim New York Comic Con Summer revenge news cancelled TV series spanish FX on Hulu cops hollywood biography cats Holiday Trailer Mystery Mary Tyler Moore FOX docudrama rotten movies we love Holidays Teen Video Games anime theme song San Diego Comic-Con Marvel Television BBC America police drama obituary Pirates Peacock Amazon latino VOD quibi superhero mutant scorecard Film Festival GIFs Logo Reality Freeform TCA Awards Food Network italian Warner Bros. cinemax Vudu Pop TV spider-man halloween tv PlayStation sequel Opinion The Walking Dead reboot comic Cartoon Network thriller crime drama Christmas animated Pixar Emmy Nominations indiana jones BAFTA Hear Us Out free movies politics psycho Apple TV+ diversity 71st Emmy Awards foreign green book Tarantino video Disney Plus reviews miniseries zombies National Geographic 2020 Columbia Pictures ITV Stephen King Shondaland TCA Winter 2020 Avengers blaxploitation true crime concert Disney+ Disney Plus Crackle Cosplay TV SXSW AMC tv talk Year in Review facebook child's play streaming Red Carpet RT21 IFC Travel Channel crossover Endgame Pride Month IFC Films spy thriller joker Ellie Kemper Oscars worst Action 20th Century Fox Comic Book Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mudbound CBS All Access Sneak Peek Turner Reality Competition Sundance TV Lifetime Christmas movies ghosts PaleyFest Fall TV Rocketman Ovation cancelled television ABC Family Western A&E Mindy Kaling Quiz harry potter Spike Comedy Trophy Talk LGBT rotten Film Valentine's Day stop motion El Rey Television Academy Sundance Now Shudder Interview Chernobyl Hallmark Christmas movies Fantasy CMT Arrowverse Amazon Studios Star Wars spinoff social media 72 Emmy Awards richard e. Grant TCA classics Walt Disney Pictures parents blockbuster black The Witch HBO Max Baby Yoda USA DC Universe 45 Tomatazos Tubi space cartoon Set visit Pet Sematary canceled critics book zero dark thirty Martial Arts 2019 comiccon ABC OneApp Spring TV TBS comic books dramedy war Hulu ESPN VH1 dark Academy Awards Heroines spain Creative Arts Emmys 007 rt archives Certified Fresh Sundance HBO Go Hallmark Disney Channel MCU DirecTV Nominations The Academy best kids batman Family directors scary movies ID A24 Mary poppins WarnerMedia Acorn TV binge historical drama sitcom halloween Fox Searchlight SDCC 4/20 Black Mirror Writers Guild of America breaking bad Universal 2017 witnail Elton John movie Extras Nickelodeon TruTV robots 2016 sequels Cannes comedies Horror Country science fiction 21st Century Fox laika Toys GoT adventure Crunchyroll Grammys TV renewals screenings children's TV Super Bowl E3 Turner Classic Movies independent Animation Netflix hist casting Photos sag awards Funimation supernatural Podcast toronto crime thriller TIFF Nat Geo Biopics discovery remakes 2018 USA Network indie cars Netflix Christmas movies vampires Watching Series doctor who football See It Skip It emmy awards 24 frames films SundanceTV Dark Horse Comics BBC One DC Comics TLC Classic Film adaptation dragons teaser franchise Black History Month Star Trek japanese a nightmare on elm street Music Anna Paquin Syfy nature justice league video on demand The CW President CW Seed Premiere Dates First Reviews Rom-Com south america Paramount nfl Tumblr Marvel Countdown Fox News Calendar award winner Trivia MTV unscripted archives Television Critics Association NBC cooking Disney Esquire Spectrum Originals transformers Drama Thanksgiving cancelled TV shows First Look cancelled aliens chucky TV Land versus Infographic TNT festival Brie Larson french stand-up comedy talk show Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt GLAAD Musicals australia History 2015 name the review fast and furious composers Amazon Prime natural history TCM disaster singing competition Mary Poppins Returns NYCC werewolf Awards BET WGN crime deadpool Masterpiece The Arrangement jamie lee curtis E! toy story LGBTQ Emmys finale Discovery Channel Superheroes all-time asian-american YouTube documentary nbcuniversal medical drama game show Musical Binge Guide Character Guide satire BBC psychological thriller