Critics Consensus

The Witch and Eye in the Sky are Certified Fresh

Plus, I Saw the Light is a disappointing biopic, and God's Not Dead 2 and Meet the Blacks were not screened for critics.

by and | March 31, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got demonic happenings (The Witch, starring Anya Taylor-Joy and Ralph Ineson), a muddled military mission (Eye in the Sky. starring Helen Mirren and Aaron Paul), cheatin’ hearts (I Saw the Light, starring Tom Hiddleston and Elizabeth Olsen), a contentious courtroom (God’s Not Dead 2, starring Melissa Joan Hart and Jesse Metcalfe), and a family under siege (Meet the Blacks, starring Mike Epps and Charlie Murphy). What do the critics have to say?


The Witch (2015) 90%

The Witch returns to exactly 666 theaters this weekend, so audiences will get another chance to bask in its sinister glow. Set in New England in the 1600s, The Witch is the tale of a family that establishes a homestead in a remote wooded area after being exiled from their Puritan community. But when they are threatened by otherworldly horrors, the family members accuse each other of consorting with the demonic. Critics say the Certified Fresh The Witch conjures a mood of profound dread that will linger long after the lights go up in the theater.


Eye in the Sky (2015) 95%

Eye in the Sky has earned praise for its thoughtful, tense depiction of the moral hazards of drone warfare, and now, this Certified Fresh thriller expands to wide release this weekend. A thriller about a military mission to capture a terrorist that escalates to dangerous levels, the film stars Helen Mirren, Aaron Paul, Barkhad Abdi, and, in his final role, Alan Rickman.


I Saw the Light (2015) 18%

Hank Williams remains one of popular music’s most beloved and influential figures, but critics say that, despite a fine lead performance from Tom Hiddleston, I Saw The Light is too episodic and cliched to do justice to the astonishing songs and colorful life of its subject.


God's Not Dead 2 (2016) 10%

Neither God’s Not Dead 2 nor Meet the Blacks were widely screened for critics prior to their releases in theaters Friday. The former is a loose sequel to the wildly profitable eveangelical hit, and stars Melissa Joan Hart as a teacher on trial for teaching the Bible in her public school classroom; the latter stars Mike Epps in a comedy about a family whose relocation to a posh new neighborhood coincides with violent looting and burglary a la The Purge.


What’s Hot on TV

The Path: Season 1 (2016) 78%

With strong performances, deep writing, and skilled direction, The Path offers an absorbing observation of the human condition, even if a rushed pace occasionally blunts the impact.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Dark Horse (2014) , starring Cliff Curtis as a mentally ill former chess champion who attempts to rescue his nephew from a life of crime, is at 97 percent.
  • Everybody Wants Some!! (2016) , Richard Linklater‘s freewheeling comedy about a party-hearty college baseball team, is at 97 percent.
  • Francofonia (2015) ,  a documentary tour of the Louvre museum through a historical lens, is at 93 percent.
  • Standing Tall (2015) , a French drama about a troubled youth and the adoptive family who attempts to keep him out of trouble, is at 88 percent.
  • Thank You for Playing (2015) , a documentary about a programmer who develops a cancer-themed video game with his wife after their infant son is diagnosed with the disease, is at 88 percent.
  • Marinoni: The Fire in the Frame (2015) , a documentary about bicycle craftsman Giuseppe Marinoni’s attempt to break a world record, is at 83 percent.
  • Darling (2015) , a psychological thriller about a lonely woman who loses her grip on reality after moving into a purportedly haunted mansion, is at 73 percent.
  • Miles Ahead (2016) , directed by and starring Don Cheadle in a biopic of legendary jazz trumpeter Miles Davis, is at 70 percent.
  • Pandemic (2016) , starring Rachel Nichols and Alfie Allen in a sci-fi thriller about a doctor searching for the cure to a virus that has overtaken the planet, is at 43 percent.
  • Kill Your Friends (2015) , starring Nicholas Hoult in a dark comedy about a despicable, ambitious A&R man attempting to keep his career afloat in the 1990s, is at 27 percent.
  • The Girl in the Photographs (2015) , starring Claudia Lee and Kal Penn in a thriller about a woman who begins receiving gory photographs from a pair of serial killers, is at 14 percent.
  • Alex Meyer

    I predict an eventual 10% tomatometer for both God’s Not Dead 2 and Meet The Blacks.

  • CursedJoe

    Woah woah woah, there are TWO movies called “I Saw The Light” both premiering today? And one is about serial killers? Has that ever happened before?

Tag Cloud

spanish language Comic-Con@Home 2021 Captain marvel jurassic park Pop TV YouTube Premium Exclusive Video stop motion crime Sundance debate true crime new york National Geographic Mary Poppins Returns Classic Film Reality Hallmark GIFs 45 TCA Winter 2020 TCM SDCC natural history sitcom PlayStation Legendary telelvision cancelled TV shows Shondaland Cannes movie Trophy Talk supernatural high school 2015 scene in color Brie Larson joker dark Extras medical drama south america Peacock San Diego Comic-Con reboot Pride Month action-comedy Chernobyl werewolf Thanksgiving PaleyFest Black History Month Mudbound 93rd Oscars hispanic heritage month Year in Review Holidays ITV Amazon Prime Binge Guide Interview 24 frames Set visit A&E Amazon Prime Video Trailer Horror A24 spider-man Awards elevated horror Disney+ Disney Plus boxoffice Film Festival football Biopics Crunchyroll scary movies Superheroe 2019 crime drama TV One nfl target crossover Kids & Family docudrama comic book movies green book DC Comics CW Seed 71st Emmy Awards OWN binge Spectrum Originals Nickelodeon witnail hollywood all-time Pop ghosts TV Land parents italian Emmys Cartoon Network Fox Searchlight FXX Masterpiece Acorn TV Lifetime 4/20 Mystery Amazon dogs ID TV movies Alien teaser finale strong female leads History Pet Sematary comics SundanceTV TBS TLC monster movies festival ViacomCBS revenge news El Rey Shudder Emmy Nominations rt labs critics edition superman mcc TIFF stand-up comedy series Sony Pictures psycho worst cinemax movies DGA Academy Awards FX on Hulu Ellie Kemper BET Awards Oscars spanish BBC psychological thriller japanese boxing book adaptation children's TV christmas movies The Witch cults 2018 Video Games popular spinoff cartoon canceled TV shows Comics on TV NBA Elton John versus TCA 2017 biography Super Bowl Superheroes Tubi WarnerMedia posters rom-coms Pacific Islander prank LGBT VICE Heroines Rock crime thriller Apple TV+ television Reality Competition Arrowverse Western tv talk President trailers Wes Anderson batman Ovation E! Musicals Disney streaming service what to watch Paramount Plus 1990s Hallmark Christmas movies Box Office halloween tv festivals The CW YA comiccon BET space Calendar dexter universal monsters australia IFC Films WGN political drama adventure laika richard e. Grant black screenings Winter TV indie TCA Character Guide Holiday Animation heist movie American Society of Cinematographers Film pirates of the caribbean live action Funimation critics best comic book movie sports cats 90s X-Men stoner 2021 TNT Premiere Dates critic resources transformers historical drama animated New York Comic Con cooking rotten movies we love blockbusters halloween Discovery Channel technology twilight Warner Bros. indiana jones name the review talk show doctor who The Academy Television Academy Sneak Peek 2016 Awards Tour Certified Fresh science fiction saw kids Tarantino comic Turner lord of the rings ratings Rocky Baby Yoda remakes jamie lee curtis emmy awards suspense First Reviews nature comic books Tokyo Olympics Marvel Women's History Month video on demand HBO Podcast FOX worst movies TV spain obituary Turner Classic Movies Mary Tyler Moore rotten asian-american Opinion sequels die hard RT21 Summer See It Skip It streaming movies aliens king arthur MCU renewed TV shows Marvel Studios satire zero dark thirty toy story godzilla anthology biopic unscripted Schedule classics SXSW toronto Star Trek mockumentary Creative Arts Emmys APB zombie VH1 vampires Toys Avengers aapi based on movie Comic Book know your critic TCA Awards 20th Century Fox golden globes women blaxploitation Cosplay golden globe awards hist Photos blockbuster Countdown romantic comedy Dark Horse Comics Esquire dc TV renewals LGBTQ independent Syfy young adult YouTube Mary poppins wonder woman venice diversity free movies king kong comedies mutant thriller fast and furious BBC America new star wars movies VOD Stephen King Spike dragons Columbia Pictures romance period drama Musical new zealand marvel cinematic universe Television Critics Association legend Broadway IFC Apple a nightmare on elm street Pixar BBC One The Walt Disney Company 21st Century Fox singing competition james bond GoT cops Marvel Television french Travel Channel cancelled TV series Tomatazos cars Music hidden camera HBO Max TruTV adaptation royal family CBS Drama Paramount Network Disney Channel reviews award winner theme song First Look canceled franchise fresh 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Teen sag awards Crackle archives Nat Geo Rom-Com The Arrangement HBO Go films Family olympics Endgame YouTube Red Lionsgate Food Network Image Comics Paramount slasher Sundance Now documentaries Pirates japan DC streaming service feel good video dceu scorecard facebook spy thriller Rocketman OneApp marvel comics Netflix Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rt labs ABC Signature Martial Arts Lucasfilm cancelled television NYCC Fox News CBS All Access war deadpool FX USA Network foreign Writers Guild of America Epix police drama Fantasy rt archives Christmas documentary Comedy international Sundance TV Logo ABC RT History Nominations Spring TV Star Wars Sci-Fi CMT Hear Us Out Red Carpet GLAAD Country Trivia Polls and Games Adult Swim Action Comedy Central Disney Disney Plus Fall TV Election justice league Britbox quibi breaking bad Bravo adenture nbcuniversal 2017 casting mission: impossible book sequel CNN NBC The Walking Dead Hulu game show Starz DC Universe Universal DirecTV Ghostbusters razzies AMC 007 streaming kong zombies Walt Disney Pictures hispanic politics MTV Watching Series directors Freeform Tumblr The Purge miniseries slashers Grammys ESPN latino Showtime 73rd Emmy Awards PBS dramedy chucky ABC Family basketball robots E3 Amazon Studios travel screen actors guild kaiju 99% disaster concert composers child's play discovery social media USA Anna Paquin Mindy Kaling Vudu Black Mirror superhero BAFTA Infographic Netflix Christmas movies Best and Worst cancelled criterion MSNBC Lifetime Christmas movies docuseries serial killer Marathons harry potter 2020 Winners anime Quiz Song of Ice and Fire Valentine's Day Apple TV Plus game of thrones 72 Emmy Awards gangster Chilling Adventures of Sabrina