Critics Consensus

The Witch and Eye in the Sky are Certified Fresh

Plus, I Saw the Light is a disappointing biopic, and God's Not Dead 2 and Meet the Blacks were not screened for critics.

by and | March 31, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got demonic happenings (The Witch, starring Anya Taylor-Joy and Ralph Ineson), a muddled military mission (Eye in the Sky. starring Helen Mirren and Aaron Paul), cheatin’ hearts (I Saw the Light, starring Tom Hiddleston and Elizabeth Olsen), a contentious courtroom (God’s Not Dead 2, starring Melissa Joan Hart and Jesse Metcalfe), and a family under siege (Meet the Blacks, starring Mike Epps and Charlie Murphy). What do the critics have to say?


The Witch (2016) 90%

The Witch returns to exactly 666 theaters this weekend, so audiences will get another chance to bask in its sinister glow. Set in New England in the 1600s, The Witch is the tale of a family that establishes a homestead in a remote wooded area after being exiled from their Puritan community. But when they are threatened by otherworldly horrors, the family members accuse each other of consorting with the demonic. Critics say the Certified Fresh The Witch conjures a mood of profound dread that will linger long after the lights go up in the theater.


Eye In The Sky (2016) 95%

Eye in the Sky has earned praise for its thoughtful, tense depiction of the moral hazards of drone warfare, and now, this Certified Fresh thriller expands to wide release this weekend. A thriller about a military mission to capture a terrorist that escalates to dangerous levels, the film stars Helen Mirren, Aaron Paul, Barkhad Abdi, and, in his final role, Alan Rickman.


I Saw the Light (2016) 18%

Hank Williams remains one of popular music’s most beloved and influential figures, but critics say that, despite a fine lead performance from Tom Hiddleston, I Saw The Light is too episodic and cliched to do justice to the astonishing songs and colorful life of its subject.


God's Not Dead 2 (2016) 8%

Neither God’s Not Dead 2 nor Meet the Blacks were widely screened for critics prior to their releases in theaters Friday. The former is a loose sequel to the wildly profitable eveangelical hit, and stars Melissa Joan Hart as a teacher on trial for teaching the Bible in her public school classroom; the latter stars Mike Epps in a comedy about a family whose relocation to a posh new neighborhood coincides with violent looting and burglary a la The Purge.


What’s Hot on TV

The Path: Season 1 (2016) 78%

With strong performances, deep writing, and skilled direction, The Path offers an absorbing observation of the human condition, even if a rushed pace occasionally blunts the impact.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Dark Horse (2016) , starring Cliff Curtis as a mentally ill former chess champion who attempts to rescue his nephew from a life of crime, is at 97 percent.
  • Everybody Wants Some!! (2016) , Richard Linklater‘s freewheeling comedy about a party-hearty college baseball team, is at 97 percent.
  • Francofonia (2016) ,  a documentary tour of the Louvre museum through a historical lens, is at 93 percent.
  • Standing Tall (La Tête Haute) (2016) , a French drama about a troubled youth and the adoptive family who attempts to keep him out of trouble, is at 88 percent.
  • Thank You For Playing (2016) , a documentary about a programmer who develops a cancer-themed video game with his wife after their infant son is diagnosed with the disease, is at 88 percent.
  • Marinoni: The Fire in the Frame (2016) , a documentary about bicycle craftsman Giuseppe Marinoni’s attempt to break a world record, is at 83 percent.
  • Darling (2016) , a psychological thriller about a lonely woman who loses her grip on reality after moving into a purportedly haunted mansion, is at 73 percent.
  • Miles Ahead (2016) , directed by and starring Don Cheadle in a biopic of legendary jazz trumpeter Miles Davis, is at 70 percent.
  • Pandemic (2016) , starring Rachel Nichols and Alfie Allen in a sci-fi thriller about a doctor searching for the cure to a virus that has overtaken the planet, is at 43 percent.
  • Kill Your Friends (2016) , starring Nicholas Hoult in a dark comedy about a despicable, ambitious A&R man attempting to keep his career afloat in the 1990s, is at 27 percent.
  • The Girl In The Photographs (2016) , starring Claudia Lee and Kal Penn in a thriller about a woman who begins receiving gory photographs from a pair of serial killers, is at 14 percent.
  • Alex Meyer

    I predict an eventual 10% tomatometer for both God’s Not Dead 2 and Meet The Blacks.

  • CursedJoe

    Woah woah woah, there are TWO movies called “I Saw The Light” both premiering today? And one is about serial killers? Has that ever happened before?

Tag Cloud

Mary Tyler Moore social media Dark Horse Comics Grammys Mary poppins strong female leads E! facebook docudrama technology 4/20 binge Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Christmas Lifetime sequel die hard documentary jamie lee curtis psychological thriller Logo police drama Apple TV Plus Western free movies DGA richard e. Grant 007 Marvel Television Extras Acorn TV screen actors guild Cannes name the review Paramount Network FOX SXSW dceu game of thrones spain child's play YouTube Rom-Com Tarantino MSNBC Black Mirror foreign Mary Poppins Returns Black History Month spinoff PaleyFest ABC Comics on TV asian-american dc Emmys Superheroe rotten movies we love zombie Pet Sematary parents SundanceTV GIFs spanish language Arrowverse Crackle Martial Arts cancelled Discovery Channel Brie Larson Winter TV Esquire medical drama Captain marvel Chernobyl X-Men Box Office Masterpiece Nickelodeon DirecTV Animation supernatural Drama composers Trailer BBC Endgame spy thriller Comedy Paramount Columbia Pictures dark Election 24 frames Netflix CBS concert Premiere Dates Classic Film Song of Ice and Fire Heroines First Reviews Comedy Central Teen sports stand-up comedy Pirates Funimation Awards aliens ITV robots Turner TV independent Binge Guide franchise Travel Channel Sneak Peek cinemax TLC theme song Toys animated FXX Lifetime Christmas movies witnail Podcast El Rey Shondaland travel based on movie History 2018 Winners best Amazon Prime comedies APB award winner Holiday WGN WarnerMedia Ovation Turner Classic Movies boxoffice children's TV Awards Tour The CW criterion YouTube Red batman period drama adventure serial killer festivals Star Trek LGBT joker Comic Book The Witch Peacock a nightmare on elm street Britbox TIFF New York Comic Con DC streaming service green book chucky PBS Set visit 21st Century Fox Apple TV+ justice league Universal what to watch revenge RT History Red Carpet video HBO Quiz movies Shudder FX DC Universe TBS discovery ABC Family politics Summer book OWN diversity television hispanic Country slashers dragons Rock war RT21 Tubi TCA Winter 2020 Schedule hist USA Network cancelled TV shows cults Super Bowl American Society of Cinematographers Star Wars cars crime thriller unscripted A&E thriller breaking bad Showtime science fiction GoT zero dark thirty Fox News vampires Opinion Hulu Hallmark Christmas movies space mockumentary Mystery Warner Bros. sag awards Musical doctor who comic latino spider-man cooking Hear Us Out Infographic talk show reboot Marvel Studios crime crossover screenings Trivia crime drama kids political drama Disney Channel Family TV Land comiccon 20th Century Fox Avengers CNN Best and Worst Disney Plus streaming Freeform Rocketman See It Skip It Certified Fresh Disney streaming service harry potter Kids & Family IFC historical drama Spring TV ESPN natural history Anna Paquin Mudbound werewolf GLAAD Photos Hallmark Nat Geo game show true crime Marathons scary movies Netflix Christmas movies elevated horror Lionsgate BET ratings Pride Month San Diego Comic-Con Starz TCA Crunchyroll 2017 casting Epix Holidays HBO Max teaser IFC Films series cops cancelled television directors National Geographic Cosplay Countdown BBC America Nominations halloween Disney mutant Biopics VICE 45 First Look renewed TV shows Baby Yoda universal monsters adaptation cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling ghosts miniseries TV renewals TNT Disney+ Disney Plus Watching Series south america finale Amazon Studios TruTV Reality Musicals Film Festival 2015 Thanksgiving The Arrangement DC Comics Amazon Prime Video Rocky Ellie Kemper nature Amazon Adult Swim blaxploitation Sony Pictures Video Games MCU CW Seed canceled TV shows christmas movies Marvel Lucasfilm Superheroes CMT dogs The Purge Sci-Fi Creative Arts Emmys Pop TV dramedy Cartoon Network 2019 Ghostbusters comics Food Network Music Horror Fall TV Calendar Tomatazos Spike toy story Reality Competition Sundance TV E3 2020 SDCC Emmy Nominations Writers Guild of America Elton John OneApp romance USA NBC TCA 2017 blockbuster NYCC zombies YA quibi President biography singing competition Character Guide Sundance Now Academy Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt psycho Stephen King Apple indie Year in Review cats LGBTQ transformers cartoon mission: impossible Sundance anthology Women's History Month Syfy MTV Vudu TCM versus sitcom stoner Interview VH1 2016 AMC romantic comedy Action tv talk The Walking Dead Tumblr Spectrum Originals Film Television Academy A24 71st Emmy Awards Fantasy golden globes Polls and Games FX on Hulu Pixar Pop movie Walt Disney Pictures Bravo Trophy Talk anime reviews YouTube Premium disaster Valentine's Day Oscars canceled CBS All Access