News

Glass First Reviews: Jackson and McAvoy Shine in What Critics Are Calling a Disappointing Trilogy Conclusion

Early reviews say M. Night Shyamalan's much-anticipated thriller is an underwhelming missed opportunity.

by | January 9, 2019 | Comments

M. Night Shyamalan seems to have delivered the first disappointment of 2019 with Glass, the much-anticipated sequel to both 2000’s Unbreakable and 2017’s Split. The first two installments, which stand mostly alone from one another, were received rather positively (69% and 76% Tomatometer scores, respectively, with the latter Certified Fresh). Unfortunately, Glass, which stars Samuel L. Jackson, Bruce Willis, James McAvoy, and Sarah Paulson, looks to be another one of Shyamalan’s duds (initial score: 40%) based on the buzz from initial reviews.

Here’s what the critics are saying about Glass:


Does it meet expectations?

Glass is a major disappointment.
Germain Lussier, io9

Shyamalan always swings for the fences… This time, though, it’s a swing and a miss.
Alissa Wilkinson, Vox

Glass shatters under the weight of Shyamalan’s ambition. It’s a messy, muddled, often downright stupid movie. It broke my heart.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

The movie, watchable as it is, is still a disappointment… more dutiful than necessary.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

One of the biggest personal disappointments I’ve ever experienced in a theater.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx


Is it not satisfying to see the gang all together?

Instead of having his two earlier movies dovetail to create something deeper and richer, it quickly begins to feel like subtraction by addition.
Chris Nashawaty, Entertainment Weekly

In Unbreakable, David and Elijah went together like a lock and key. Here, everyone feels like spare parts.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Its first hurdle is telling a story that connects everything in a satisfying, logical way. To that end, the film succeeds…the film’s first act is absolutely excellent.
Germain Lussier, io9


Universal Pictures

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

Will die-hard comic book fans appreciate it?

Glass certainly feels like it’s made by someone who both hates superhero movies and also has never seen one.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

Price’s adulations of comic tropes… [feel] as if they were scripted by someone who’s only read a few comic books and is pretty sure they know what they’re about.
Alissa Wilkinson, Vox

Although he’s made three movies about them, Shyamalan doesn’t actually seem to know much about comic books, and he’s certainly got nothing to say about their journey to cultural dominance.
– Sam Adams, Slate

I’m sure M. Night Shyamalan has read some comic books in his day. I do sometimes wonder how many, though.
– Matt Singer, ScreenCrush


Is it full of Shyamalan’s trademark twists?

This one will not start, or go, or end like you think.
Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

[There are] a bunch of big reveals to unmask Scooby Doo style and a greater universe to ta-da! unfurl like one of his many, not-always-successful magic tricks.
– Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist


And the ending?

I can also confidently predict that the ending is going to piss more than a few people off.
Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

[Glass] throws its own three-film buildup under the bus for the sake of a twist and an open-ended non-resolution that can be seen coming down the pike from miles away.
Karen Han, Polygon

Glass is a good ending to the Unbreakable trilogy, but it may not give you the conclusion you were hoping for. You’ll probably either love or hate the ending.
Kirsten Acuna, Insider

That ending— which can’t really be explained, for lack of time, space, and to avoid spoilers— is really something, but suffice it to say, it’s a bit baffling.
Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist


Universal Pictures

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

What about the positives?

It’s not a bad film.
Don Kaye, Den of Geek

Glass is still a spectacle, but in a singularly un-Marvel manner… Think The Flash getting caught in a traffic jam or The Hulk filing a W-2.
Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

Glass feels like a giant middle finger to the very people who would be excited to see Glass. That, on its own, is inherently fascinating.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

Each time Glass seems like a lost cause, Shyamalan pulls something truly affecting out of his hat.
Karen Han, Polygon

There is enough experimentation — such as the stirring POV shots during the fight scenes — that shows a director still pushing his craft to bring his viewers something new. He’s not done surprising us.
Monica Castillo, The Wrap

Glass looks great… Shyamalan and cinematographer Mike Gioulakis compose each frame — sharp and crisp — with a careful offness.
Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair


How is Bruce Willis’ return as David Dunn?

Willis is phoning in his performance.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

Jackson and Willis fit back into their older characters like well-worn gloves, both of them knowing what to do and how to move, although Willis gets less to do than the others.
Don Kaye, Den of Geek


Universal Pictures

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

And Samuel L. Jackson as Mr. Glass?

Jackson is clearly having a blast playing such a devious character. But it’s almost too little, too late.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

[Jackson is] devilishly fun as Mr. Glass but is ultimately only given a few moments to truly shine. In a movie called Glass, you wish there was more of him.
Germain Lussier, io9

Although the movie is named after his character, Jackson really doesn’t shine until its final third. He’s delightful in a maniacally sinister way.
Monica Castillo, The Wrap

For a good third of the film, Jackson outacts anyone sharing his scenes without even saying a word.
Kirsten Acuna, Insider


Is James McAvoy still amazing as “The Horde”?

He’s more fun to watch now that he doesn’t have to be the whole show.
Owen Gleiberman, Variety

McAvoy is once again top notch. He lights up the screen with his eerie physicality every time he appears, and cascades crazily through the Horde’s personalities like a human radio with a dial that can’t stop spinning.
Don Kaye, Den of Geek

McAvoy’s acting abilities… are pretty extraordinary, considering we meet even more of Kevin’s many personalities this time around.
Germain Lussier, io9


Universal Pictures

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

How are the action scenes?

Every clash between David Dunn and The Beast is bone-crunchingly satisfying.
Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

The action sequences in Glass are the best of the filmmaker’s career.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

[There is] a fight scene that’s filmed with all the excitement of a knitting circle.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire


At least we can always enjoy the first two movies, right?

[Glass] manages to diminish both Unbreakable and Split in retrospect.
Alissa Wilkinson, Vox

Shyamalan now takes a huge, unfortunate step backwards, tarnishing the legacy of Unbreakable, his best movie, in the process.
Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm


Glass opens everywhere on January 18.

#1

Glass (2019)
36%

#1
Adjusted Score: 58317%
Critics Consensus: Glass displays a few glimmers of M. Night Shyamalan at his twisty world-building best, but ultimately disappoints as the conclusion to the writer-director's long-gestating trilogy.
Synopsis: David Dunn looks to deliver vigilante justice to the Beast -- the madman who has superhuman strength and 23 personalities.... [More]
Directed By: M. Night Shyamalan

Tag Cloud

Mary Poppins Returns popular YouTube Premium Nominations Elton John DC Universe Alien Sundance Captain marvel universal monsters MTV Paramount Western TV renewals politics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards olympics A24 cinemax Creative Arts Emmys Tokyo Olympics Sci-Fi talk show Cosplay NBC DC streaming service diversity TIFF FX TV One A&E obituary halloween Syfy films venice Character Guide rotten anime psychological thriller LGBT zombie social media Fantasy Superheroes parents concert screen actors guild based on movie Classic Film spanish language toy story Walt Disney Pictures lord of the rings 90s Podcast spanish HBO Max Reality Competition cancelled TV shows 2020 Brie Larson SDCC RT21 21st Century Fox 2019 Apple TV+ documentaries Disney Plus The Purge Rocky nbcuniversal football 2016 zero dark thirty doctor who President TNT DGA History Awards IFC Films CNN scorecard high school 1990s what to watch GIFs Marvel Television cancelled Paramount Network composers Binge Guide Sneak Peek Nat Geo Martial Arts children's TV adenture Quiz free movies Pacific Islander golden globes Acorn TV dark richard e. Grant mockumentary jamie lee curtis BBC America 007 cults Ovation HBO BBC One Infographic stoner Red Carpet 2018 Awards Tour Television Critics Association Fox Searchlight foreign ABC Signature 45 all-time singing competition comic book movie monster movies Masterpiece romance Box Office ESPN criterion dexter mutant directors marvel comics TCA cancelled television spinoff boxoffice joker blockbusters Super Bowl Animation Certified Fresh Biopics asian-american Showtime DirecTV Horror TCM Musicals 71st Emmy Awards Cartoon Network Trophy Talk Mindy Kaling elevated horror Music rt labs critics edition kong discovery critics San Diego Comic-Con Hulu binge toronto finale sequels basketball Warner Bros. Musical Watching Series Family international comics WarnerMedia casting Extras Academy Awards USA 93rd Oscars dramedy VOD Hallmark Christmas movies comic book movies animated dogs Photos true crime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt die hard MSNBC TCA 2017 Black Mirror Rock Sony Pictures Tumblr Sundance TV Turner Classic Movies Calendar Chernobyl thriller Shudder American Society of Cinematographers game of thrones TV Land black worst movies YouTube new york video on demand FOX X-Men indiana jones prank TV PaleyFest Winners video Kids & Family Paramount Plus indie mcc Set visit Opinion CW Seed Schedule james bond japan YouTube Red Amazon cats Mystery Endgame witnail television Rom-Com justice league disaster Winter TV quibi Pirates Anna Paquin BET Awards Thanksgiving Lionsgate IFC The Academy Women's History Month Fox News SXSW Tubi superhero 2015 Drama zombies TruTV Pride Month sag awards royal family Oscars hidden camera Hallmark remakes hollywood Countdown OWN dceu comic crime rt labs crossover Chilling Adventures of Sabrina target aapi Video Games ABC Family docudrama golden globe awards The Witch Logo ABC Food Network award winner BET comiccon posters Netflix FX on Hulu Crackle werewolf women Adult Swim Holidays WGN E3 Exclusive Video Lifetime Christmas movies a nightmare on elm street strong female leads name the review Emmy Nominations TLC ID natural history First Look Polls and Games Valentine's Day robots 73rd Emmy Awards know your critic Lucasfilm Comics on TV Christmas Image Comics australia Song of Ice and Fire canceled Netflix Christmas movies Disney PlayStation Year in Review king arthur Television Academy wonder woman archives latino Star Trek Spectrum Originals game show Baby Yoda italian crime drama comic books Marvel CMT feel good SundanceTV serial killer Cannes 99% live action HBO Go Pixar OneApp Emmys superman anthology ITV Film Columbia Pictures fast and furious rom-coms dc Amazon Studios crime thriller telelvision book BAFTA medical drama nature young adult Wes Anderson Mary poppins Disney+ Disney Plus Disney Channel Spring TV The Arrangement halloween tv streaming Spike new star wars movies tv talk Toys revenge LGBTQ 2017 franchise Comic-Con@Home 2021 action-comedy Epix facebook streaming movies E! Crunchyroll Legendary aliens TCA Winter 2020 DC Comics Summer Lifetime south america Interview science fiction trailers legend VICE GoT sequel child's play The Walking Dead Nickelodeon Superheroe travel NBA war versus satire adaptation TCA Awards Disney streaming service Trivia cooking critic resources ratings kids rt archives The Walt Disney Company suspense series Trailer PBS Shondaland Marathons Rocketman spy thriller ViacomCBS USA Network nfl teaser docuseries Esquire MCU Premiere Dates Stephen King Broadway political drama boxing festival Country Starz spain romantic comedy jurassic park Ghostbusters pirates of the caribbean YA Freeform Heroines CBS All Access RT History slasher gangster APB marvel cinematic universe Comedy canceled TV shows Marvel Studios Holiday Sundance Now 2021 Apple TV Plus 20th Century Fox New York Comic Con Bravo The CW mission: impossible Comic Book Reality cops scene in color comedies kaiju sitcom spider-man Pet Sematary stop motion Action best Vudu batman chucky First Reviews cancelled TV series biopic movie independent Film Festival Comedy Central Black History Month debate El Rey unscripted Apple Turner king kong hispanic heritage month Star Wars cars renewed TV shows book adaptation Amazon Prime Amazon Prime Video Peacock stand-up comedy psycho Pop Travel Channel rotten movies we love news emmy awards Arrowverse Ellie Kemper documentary 72 Emmy Awards TBS TV movies hist BBC Writers Guild of America Election blockbuster cartoon adventure blaxploitation reboot technology Hear Us Out festivals miniseries laika ghosts dragons theme song GLAAD deadpool Grammys 24 frames reviews VH1 sports CBS AMC twilight scary movies 4/20 heist movie movies Best and Worst Fall TV christmas movies Tarantino transformers Pop TV historical drama Funimation classics biography National Geographic green book FXX screenings Tomatazos vampires period drama Mary Tyler Moore Britbox Teen new zealand Universal supernatural razzies breaking bad Avengers french godzilla NYCC japanese Dark Horse Comics worst saw police drama Discovery Channel space harry potter fresh See It Skip It Mudbound slashers hispanic