Frozen II First Reviews: Olaf Is MVP in a More Complex but Still Magical Sequel

Critics say it isn't quite on par with the first, but its dazzling visuals, laugh-out-loud humor, and catchy songs should make fans happy.

by | November 14, 2019 | Comments

Six years have passed since Frozen became one of the biggest pop culture phenomenons of the decade (maybe of all time?). Now Disney has finally made a sequel with the same team involved, and it’s sure to be one of the biggest movies of the year (maybe of all time?).

But is Frozen II worth the wait, or is it just a pointless cash grab? The first reviews of the follow-up aren’t as enthusiastic as they were for its predecessor, but most critics agree it’s a worthy new adventure that should dazzle fans with its stunning animation, laugh-out-loud humor, and fun soundtrack.

Here’s what critics are saying about Frozen II:

How does the sequel compare to the original?

“The sequel is not only better than the 2013 original, but it also improves the original film by adding to its mythology and shining a light on the events of that story in a whole new way.” – Germain Lussier, io9

Frozen II is nominally a slight improvement on its predecessor.” – Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

Frozen II is as magical as its predecessor.” – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

“It’s a sequel that stands toe-to-toe with the original, which isn’t exactly an easy feat to accomplish.” – Matt Rodriguez, Shakefire

“If it doesn’t quite match the original, it comes very, very close.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“The film itself is a satisfying but very familiar retread of the first movie.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

And how does it compare to other Disney sequels?

“It carries the same lackluster energy of one of Disney’s direct-to-video sequels from times past: 1998’s Lion King 2: Simba’s Pride, or 1994’s The Return of Jafar.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies

Frozen 2 gives off the same lackluster dimness that hand-drawn direct-to-video sequels like Return of Jafar and Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas did back in their humbler day.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Will fans enjoy it?

“The characters and music plus the gorgeous visuals are enough to make Frozen II a fun film even if it has none of the staying power of its predecessor.” – Matt Goldberg, Collider

Frozen II is anything but a mindless remake. Ironically, Frozen fans may secretly be wishing for a more straightforward rehash.” –  Peter Debruge, Variety

Is the new story worth the wait?

Frozen 2 is crammed with material, most of which works.” – Kate Erbland, IndieWire

“The mythology is somehow both overly complicated and oddly perfunctory. Really, the plot is mainly an excuse for the characters to hang out. And why not?” – Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

“The Frozen team is forced to go bigger, grander, more existential, while still keeping things accessible to children. That’s a really tough balancing act, one Frozen 2 can’t manage.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“A lot goes on but nothing really happens…the only surprising thing about this film is how complex and contrived it is.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies

“Here’s the one problem with Frozen II: the structure of the story…most of it comes in dense, exposition-heavy chunks that are staggered across the film.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“The narrative is a disastrous mess, to a thoroughly disappointing degree, where character and story aren’t appropriately motivated.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

What about its message?

Frozen II certainly delivers a solid morality tale without being overly moralizing.” – Linda Marric, HeyUGuys

“Female empowerment and finding strength through sisterhood assuredly remain sturdy tethers. There’s also a hearty ecological message instilled about working with nature, not against it.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“All children should see Frozen 2, not just little girls. Because when Kristoff says, ‘I’m here. What do you need?’ that’s worthy of a discussion with everyone.” – Tania Lamb, Lola Lambchops

Walt Disney Pictures

(Photo by Walt Disney Pictures)

Is it funny?

“Several times I started crying because I was laughing so hard, and once, I had a hard time catching my breath. This movie was funnier than I ever imagined it would be.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“The sequel is funnier, with Olaf stealing the show… even the most die-hard Olaf critics will find him hilarious in this.” – Ian Sandwell, Digital Spy

“The biggest problem is that Olaf’s lines are all so funny the audience was laughing too hard for me to hear half of them.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“What surprised me most about the film was just how hilarious they make Olaf. He was great in Frozen, but he absolutely steals the entire film this time around.” – Matt Rodriguez, Shakefire

“Olaf totally steals the show this time as he grows up to ask the serious questions that every child is thinking.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“This time around, [Olaf is] a scene-stealing, joke-dispensing machine from start to finish, and with a pretty good hit-to-miss ratio.” – Justin Chang, Los Angeles Times

“Every time he opens his mouth I felt like doing cartwheels.” – Charlotte O’Sullivan, London Evening Standard

How are the new characters?

“The newbies have their moments and all together make for a grander experience.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“There’s also a handful of new friends to meet, all of which are welcome, many of which are underserved (Sterling K. Brown is the lone newbie who really gets to leave a mark).” – Kate Erbland, IndieWire

“New sidekicks like playful wind spirit Gale and Bruni the Salamander are fun and cute but don’t add much to the proceedings.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

“There are very few new characters of any consequence.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

Walt Disney Pictures

(Photo by Walt Disney Pictures)

And the visuals?

“The real power of this movie comes through its gorgeous, often jaw-dropping animation… whatever else can be said, Frozen II is truly beautiful.” – Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

“Aesthetically speaking, this a dazzling beauty. The animators have created powerful imagery… highly detailed work [that] always shines through the fray.” – Courtney Howard, Fresh Fiction

Frozen 2’s weirdest, and maybe worst, sin is how routinely unpleasant it is to look at. The animation is oddly bland and inert.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“What Disney hasn’t quite solved is its digitally rendered character designs, subtly altered from the earlier movie but still more akin to computer-generated Bratz dolls.” – Peter Debruge, Variety

More importantly, how’s the music?

“The soundtrack is just as fun as the first Frozen.” – Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

“When I tell you that this soundtrack is better than the first one, I know it will be hard for you to believe me. But it is true.” – Tessa Smith, Mama’s Geeky

“There really is a song for every mood, and I can see myself listening to the soundtrack on repeat.” – Matt Rodriguez, Shakefire

“The song-writing team’s contribution to the franchise’s success can scarcely be over-estimated.” – Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter

“There’s nothing wrong with these songs, per se, but the effort to replicate their previous success weighs down any possibility of letting them shine on their own.” – Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

“They all sound fine, and are sung with the usual bombast… and yet, not a half-hour after seeing the movie, I couldn’t call up a single melody.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“The creative team have brought in the D-list for songwriting detail… with every song coming across like over-produced, over-polished album track filler with no hooks and no heart.” – David Jenkins, Little White Lies

Walt Disney Pictures

(Photo by Walt Disney Pictures)

Does it deliver the next “Let It Go?”

“The ‘Let It Go’ of Frozen II is called ‘Into the Unknown’… it’s guaranteed to entrance exhibitionist preschoolers looking for a new song to belt out at the top of their lungs.” – Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

“There isn’t one A-plus standout like ‘Let It Go’ from the first film, but this time around, all the songs feel more uniform quality-wise. There isn’t a dud in the bunch.” – Germain Lussier, io9

“The songs don’t have that same punch this time around… there’s nothing in here that I think will take the world by storm like ‘Let It Go.’” – Matt Goldberg, Collider

“Although not a single song in this sequel is likely to have the same iconic reach of songs such as ‘Let It Go’ or ‘Love Is An Open Door,’ there is still plenty here to shout about.” – Linda Marric, HeyUGuys

Is it still a good time for families?

“For the most part, the kids seemed to think Frozen 2 was pretty great — pretty exciting, pretty funny, pretty transporting.” – Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

“Tip: the youngest Frozen fans might need some warm hugs to get through a fraught final act.” – Kate Erbland, IndieWire

Frozen II is arguably a darker, more mature film… it feels like it’s marketed to a slightly older fanbase than the first – perhaps the kids who grew up loving the initial entry.” – Hannah Lodge, The Beat

Frozen II is the must-see movie for families this year.” – Tania Lamb, Lola Lambchops

Frozen II is in theaters November 22. 


Frozen II (2019)

Adjusted Score: 91.344%
Critics Consensus: Frozen II can't quite recapture the showstopping feel of its predecessor, but it remains a dazzling adventure into the unknown.
Synopsis: Why was Elsa born with magical powers? The answer is calling her and threatening her kingdom. Together with Anna, Kristoff,... [More]
Directed By: Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TIFF crime Best and Worst Apple Binge Guide CBS Nominations award winner romantic comedy The Witch The Purge kids toy story Nickelodeon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Teen Comic Book jamie lee curtis GIFs travel Trophy Talk APB Winners psychological thriller Tumblr italian Vudu Year in Review criterion reviews Mary poppins stand-up comedy The CW Stephen King Marathons green book classics harry potter space Reality Competition Music Starz SundanceTV TCA Awards Pirates Thanksgiving die hard french Premiere Dates Warner Bros. PlayStation Masterpiece Rom-Com Drama Musical critics BBC One Heroines Video Games 4/20 comic books Funimation toronto james bond Photos GoT AMC 20th Century Fox golden globes disaster Showtime 71st Emmy Awards CBS All Access Film Festival tv talk Television Critics Association spain period drama Sony Pictures History Toys Freeform Comedy stop motion 2015 TBS Disney Plus TNT hispanic children's TV Quiz spanish language Country scorecard sitcom A&E thriller boxing Marvel video emmy awards Esquire robots strong female leads scary movies black Pet Sematary TruTV Apple TV+ Turner Classic Movies satire Rock Nat Geo Anna Paquin Cartoon Network crime thriller Travel Channel IFC 2017 casting supernatural ITV Women's History Month Disney+ Disney Plus films sports 2019 Lifetime Christmas movies Syfy FOX spy thriller Elton John finale deadpool halloween boxoffice asian-american fast and furious Lifetime Peacock indie historical drama Fox Searchlight ABC The Academy biography 45 ABC Family obituary Superheroes Cannes richard e. Grant ghosts NYCC 2020 FX on Hulu all-time chucky Sneak Peek animated south america PaleyFest political drama revenge book psycho See It Skip It Logo adventure Summer LGBTQ ID ratings mutant X-Men stoner witnail twilight Ellie Kemper DC Universe Pop TV versus Lucasfilm parents Fantasy game of thrones video on demand festival Classic Film canceled TV shows Winter TV Ghostbusters sequels E! medical drama news universal monsters Spring TV 99% theme song diversity transformers FXX war Disney streaming service Hulu Podcast Amazon police drama australia Marvel Television Superheroe Pride Month American Society of Cinematographers Pop facebook Netflix Christmas TV Land HBO Go MSNBC rt archives Britbox Apple TV Plus what to watch name the review Cosplay a nightmare on elm street venice blockbuster festivals singing competition BBC America remakes Sundance romance nature anime E3 WarnerMedia BAFTA DGA adaptation Mystery concert streaming Interview franchise FX Netflix Christmas movies child's play cats The Walking Dead composers Trivia Universal Endgame rotten movies we love movie Disney Spectrum Originals Holiday teaser series Red Carpet Avengers First Reviews Fox News RT21 renewed TV shows San Diego Comic-Con USA dragons Amazon Studios Star Trek documentaries sequel YouTube Crunchyroll IFC Films worst Academy Awards Adult Swim El Rey USA Network 21st Century Fox game show 2016 nbcuniversal HBO Max Calendar Schedule Tomatazos joker Emmy Nominations Song of Ice and Fire Dark Horse Comics Family true crime Creative Arts Emmys serial killer Bravo justice league social media Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Emmys DC Comics CW Seed werewolf elevated horror Super Bowl Mary Tyler Moore Baby Yoda cops Comedy Central Awards Tour Trailer Certified Fresh LGBT Valentine's Day dogs Grammys discovery dceu Set visit GLAAD Fall TV A24 YouTube Premium indiana jones TLC BET Awards CNN Mary Poppins Returns OWN Chernobyl crossover christmas movies ESPN Paramount VH1 technology Oscars cancelled comiccon Epix 72 Emmy Awards Hallmark docudrama directors cults sag awards mockumentary SXSW free movies vampires worst movies Rocketman Shudder Acorn TV OneApp miniseries Martial Arts TCA Winter 2020 breaking bad archives spider-man First Look Writers Guild of America Pixar fresh Extras Columbia Pictures cancelled TV series Countdown 2018 dc laika Lionsgate WGN crime drama Awards independent television Box Office NBC The Arrangement Hear Us Out dramedy HBO batman natural history Infographic best Mindy Kaling Film foreign binge Opinion unscripted TCA latino President Kids & Family talk show Paramount Network rotten Brie Larson Tubi RT History TCM spanish Captain marvel BET PBS Alien cinemax japanese hollywood movies screenings TCA 2017 cars politics MTV cancelled television Western aliens Horror DirecTV Shondaland Hallmark Christmas movies DC streaming service CMT Arrowverse Spike football based on movie Marvel Studios Biopics anthology comic Sci-Fi TV Ovation Crackle Polls and Games Holidays cartoon Animation Amazon Prime Video Black History Month National Geographic Mudbound canceled slashers Television Academy zero dark thirty MCU comics reboot mission: impossible Comics on TV Election dark zombie SDCC superhero spinoff zombies YouTube Red Rocky doctor who hist blaxploitation nfl Sundance TV Amazon Prime science fiction halloween tv screen actors guild Black Mirror Star Wars cooking quibi Discovery Channel BBC documentary Sundance Now 24 frames Reality Watching Series Action YA Disney Channel cancelled TV shows Character Guide Musicals VICE Tarantino comedies TV renewals VOD New York Comic Con Walt Disney Pictures Food Network 007 Turner