De Palma Fights Redacted Edits

Director's war film provokes purple-faced right-wing hysteria.

by | October 12, 2007 | Comments

In a classic example of irony in film, Brian De Palma has found that portions of his war drama Redacted have been…well, redacted.

The film, currently receiving decidedly mixed reviews during its limited run, closes with a montage of photos taken from the Iraq front — photos De Palma was forced to edit by Redacted‘s distributor, Magnolia Pictures, due to what The Hollywood Reporter describes as “legal and financial concerns.” The director took his concerns to the New York Film Festival on Wednesday, where he told an audience:

“The irony of all this is that even though everyone (in Iraq) has a digital camera and access to the Internet, somehow we don’t see any of these images…why are things being redacted? My own film was redacted.”

Movies about the Iraq war have proven to be a tough sell thus far, and given Redacted‘s particularly challenging storyline — the Reporter describes it as depicting “fictional soldiers raping an Iraq teenager and killing her family” — it’s likely that the Mark Cuban-owned Magnolia was one of the only places De Palma’s film could have been made. Still, De Palma feels misled. From the article:

De Palma added that he “lost” the long-running fight with producers to allow the images only 24 hours before the screening. At a postscreening dinner, producers acknowledged that it was a difficult decision but, given the legal and financial concerns, one in which they had little room to maneuver.

The graphic photos depict victims of the war; with the black magic-marker etchings across their faces, though, the faces are now difficult if not impossible to recognize. Magnolia execs have said that it’s impossible to get legal releases for the photos, while Cuban has been quoted as saying he found the unredacted images problematic.

Redacted has already attracted criticism from right-wing pundits such as the popular comedian and respected film critic Bill O’Reilly, who the Reporter quotes as calling De Palma “a true villain in our country” and suggesting that even though “no one” will actually see it, the movie will somehow lead to the deaths of American troops.

De Palma’s comments at the New York Film Festival were met with an emotional response from Magnolia executives Eamonn Bowles and Jason Kliot, who stood up from the audience to disagree:

Bowles countered the charge that Magnolia was taking the easy way out when he asked De Palma in front of reporters, “Who else would make this movie?”

Redacted is scheduled to see wide release on November 30.

Source: The Hollywood Reporter

Tag Cloud

war BBC One boxing Sundance USA Network Nickelodeon Black Mirror Summer AMC sports APB 2016 007 ID cops Crackle psychological thriller spinoff award winner razzies TV movies Showtime young adult Tumblr Peacock FX on Hulu Discovery Channel marvel cinematic universe anime TV Land cinemax YA Certified Fresh Family Oscars Marvel Television Amazon Studios cancelled TV shows Teen TCA 2017 high school First Look Epix fresh 2015 comic books rotten movies we love asian-american The Purge Pet Sematary book police drama Pop live event period drama See It Skip It Television Academy Rocketman worst dark Sundance Now ITV children's TV The Academy ghosts NYCC Fall TV Acorn TV genre NBC toy story HBO Go spider-verse romantic comedy Reality LGBT WGN Awards emmy awards book adaptation comic book movies 71st Emmy Awards binge black comedy BET parents new york series TCM Amazon Prime A&E Winners franchise MTV justice league Columbia Pictures Disney Channel 2020 E! leaderboard Captain marvel Hulu politics VH1 aapi Schedule Creative Arts Emmys blaxploitation chucky Legendary obituary Superheroe Ghostbusters Mudbound Wes Anderson james bond space Marvel Funimation quibi docudrama Anna Paquin Mary Poppins Returns Mystery DC streaming service Elton John Infographic Fox Searchlight hidden camera science fiction jurassic park what to watch telelvision blockbuster richard e. Grant spanish language 2019 4/20 CBS movies dc DC Comics Valentine's Day TV One Character Guide Rom-Com screenings Alien lord of the rings HBO GIFs dreamworks cars supernatural X-Men Exclusive Video TruTV Freeform Lionsgate Trophy Talk Logo Music twilight video on demand Election cancelled television USA Television Critics Association CBS All Access classics Marathons Animation Tubi streaming movies universal monsters pirates of the caribbean new star wars movies anthology composers television SundanceTV biography name the review Warner Bros. NBA Pixar stand-up comedy foreign Comic Book Cannes stop motion rt archives game show japanese TV cancelled Starz Watching Series italian adenture Brie Larson canceled superman Trivia target Song of Ice and Fire OWN crime thriller DGA Holidays Amazon hispanic FOX theme song Best and Worst suspense Neflix cooking Country saw Broadway Extras heist movie basketball king arthur The Arrangement know your critic A24 crime drama Photos VICE El Rey TV renewals dramedy Action PaleyFest The Witch hollywood independent mob ABC Signature godzilla mission: impossible black versus werewolf YouTube Red Set visit Writers Guild of America stoner 90s critics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina die hard TCA Shondaland Mindy Kaling indie olympics scene in color Baby Yoda American Society of Cinematographers movie Dark Horse Comics Thanksgiving finale RT History revenge Vudu casting Biopics cancelled TV series Star Trek 99% spanish rt labs critics edition Spike technology sequel social media zombie Travel Channel new zealand doctor who romance action-comedy Netflix Christmas movies harry potter cats Women's History Month football VOD 20th Century Fox comedies reboot New York Comic Con best comics CW Seed Disney Plus dogs Food Network adventure Apple TV+ Musical travel GoT halloween tv streaming strong female leads FX ABC The CW scary Turner satire sopranos DirecTV Walt Disney Pictures ViacomCBS Comedy Central sag awards History Arrowverse Grammys TCA Awards 45 TIFF dexter animated kong hist Tomatazos Bravo boxoffice cults reviews trophy Paramount Plus popular Binge Guide Paramount Network Ovation Comedy remakes scary movies zombies Apple TV Plus zero dark thirty Sci-Fi Quiz feel good Academy Awards President Christmas WarnerMedia nature Cosplay Red Carpet serial killer 2017 natural history Spring TV rt labs gangster Pirates batman ESPN Lucasfilm Disney+ Disney Plus The Walking Dead Pop TV Toys facebook aliens 24 frames hispanic heritage month Rock art house TLC unscripted E3 Trailer adaptation 1990s Universal Pictures Superheroes biopic Horror Opinion Adult Swim MCU Lifetime Christmas movies 21st Century Fox Super Bowl cartoon singing competition Shudder sitcom archives live action Disney Tokyo Olympics Drama marvel comics IMDb TV women rom-coms breaking bad game of thrones YouTube Year in Review 93rd Oscars trailers superhero medical drama Sony Pictures Pacific Islander Holiday Netflix prank slasher directors PlayStation Fantasy Winter TV Endgame Mary Tyler Moore Apple crime Sneak Peek Heroines christmas movies Avengers teaser OneApp GLAAD talk show Mary poppins Image Comics king kong posters french Countdown docuseries mockumentary kaiju BET Awards golden globe awards LGBTQ National Geographic IFC Turner Classic Movies First Reviews latino 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards jamie lee curtis MSNBC discovery San Diego Comic-Con documentaries deadpool Emmy Nominations ABC Family international spider-man CNN historical drama vs. Interview canceled TV shows tv talk Reality Competition documentary DC Universe Britbox all-time Lifetime AMC Plus IFC Films Masterpiece Crunchyroll Ellie Kemper debate scorecard Comics on TV Cartoon Network Rocky Marvel Studios Polls and Games The Walt Disney Company Fargo crossover a nightmare on elm street fast and furious free movies worst movies dragons Hear Us Out Podcast Amazon Prime Video Premiere Dates kids wonder woman halloween 72 Emmy Awards elevated horror YouTube Premium robots criterion films Calendar ratings TBS Film Martial Arts Nominations monster movies Box Office diversity comiccon FXX legend Star Wars Emmys Pride Month 2018 venice TNT political drama Western Film Festival Comic-Con@Home 2021 SXSW psycho mcc news festivals south america BAFTA transformers Paramount indiana jones Kids & Family comic book movie Tarantino nbcuniversal vampires BBC comic video Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Video Games japan laika disaster HBO Max sequels PBS Spectrum Originals CMT Fox News slashers joker Instagram Live Stephen King Hallmark Christmas movies toronto critic resources RT21 renewed TV shows Classic Film golden globes australia dceu spy thriller spain Hallmark thriller BBC America Chernobyl TCA Winter 2020 royal family Disney streaming service Universal nfl true crime Esquire green book based on movie Black History Month Musicals Syfy witnail Sundance TV miniseries mutant rotten screen actors guild Awards Tour 73rd Emmy Awards blockbusters concert child's play SDCC Nat Geo 2021 festival