Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Superman" And "Devil" Are Certified Fresh

by | June 29, 2006 | Comments

This week’s wide releases both involve publishing. In "The Devil Wears Prada," the setting is a fashion magazine, and in "Superman Returns," it’s The Daily Planet. So maybe that’s why the critics like both these movies so much…

While there has been some debate over the quality of Lauren Weisberger’s novel "The Devil Wears Prada," there’s less divergence over the movie adaptation, particularly because of the presence of Meryl Streep in the titular role. Anne Hathaway plays an earnest small-town girl who hopes to write high-minded stuff for the New Yorker, but is little match for the Cruella De Ville-esque Miranda Priestly (Streep). The scribes say the film ultimately works because of Streep’s excellent performance, but "The Devil Wears Prada" is also an incisive examination of workplace politics. At 76 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Devil" wears a Certified Fresh badge.

After a long, arduous trial, Meryl Streep was acquitted by the fashion police, but convicted by the sunglass police.

You may have heard that there’s a new Superman movie out. It’s called "Superman Returns," and it stars a relative unknown as the Man of Steel (Brandon Routh), an actress who was in that Bobby Darin movie (Kate Bosworth), and the guy who played Bobby Darin himself in that same movie, this time playing Lex Luthor (Kevin Spacey). (Dude, he was probably Keyzer Soze as well) The critics say "Superman Returns" is able to pull off the neat trick of sticking closely to the age-old particulars of the Superman myth, while making them fresh. "Superman Returns" is at 76 percent on the Tomatometer, and it’s Certified Fresh.

"I’ll have a root beer float, hold the kryptonite."

This is a week of well-reviewed releases in general. Also opening, albeit in limited release: "Who Killed the Electric Car," a documentary about the short-lived EV1, is at 87 percent; "The Motel," a coming-of-age tale set in a fleabag motel, is at 82 percent; "The Blood of My Brother," a documentary about death in Iraq, is at 67 percent; and the big-screen adaptation of the cult TV hit "Strangers With Candy" is at 57 percent.

Recent Meryl Streep Movies:
80% — A Prairie Home Companion (2006)
50% — Prime (2005)
81% — The Manchurian Candidate (2004)
71% — Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004)
62% — Stuck On You (2003)

Recent Bryan Singer Movies:
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
80% — X-Men (2000)
53% — Apt Pupil (1998)
90% — The Usual Suspects (1995)
50% — Public Access (1993)

Tag Cloud

Classic Film true crime Television Critics Association Rocketman directors award winner Starz science fiction sitcom facebook critics cinemax romantic comedy SundanceTV universal monsters TLC sequels adaptation children's TV zombies technology Acorn TV Kids & Family 4/20 child's play Marvel archives Christmas Netflix VOD Drama zombie TIFF animated MTV Turner Cartoon Network Holiday Tubi APB slashers Mystery American Society of Cinematographers Peacock ratings YouTube Premiere Dates Creative Arts Emmys Holidays zero dark thirty Elton John game of thrones DC Comics Amazon X-Men TCA 2017 DC streaming service Freeform vampires WarnerMedia comic books biography anthology Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Vudu Hallmark aliens Emmys theme song Comedy Central Pop TV screenings 2015 independent Sundance TV Shudder all-time See It Skip It cars versus Shondaland dark Amazon Prime Video docudrama crime thriller CNN Binge Guide franchise Arrowverse reboot scorecard E! USA Network HBO Go binge Mary Poppins Returns Apple FX latino golden globes indie TBS movies green book political drama police drama PaleyFest a nightmare on elm street Countdown Toys kids Pop Biopics Lifetime Emmy Nominations Sci-Fi Showtime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina talk show Nominations Endgame MSNBC LGBTQ Hulu San Diego Comic-Con adventure comics blaxploitation Academy Awards breaking bad 21st Century Fox Apple TV Plus movie Comics on TV doctor who Spectrum Originals El Rey period drama Ghostbusters rt archives Horror National Geographic Family Musicals Disney Plus japanese Apple TV+ football Pride Month CMT anime ITV Travel Channel richard e. Grant Pixar Turner Classic Movies Marathons emmy awards Hear Us Out Schedule Calendar Tumblr OneApp Paramount Network quibi Film VICE cops A&E medical drama Warner Bros. stop motion batman halloween Esquire Oscars die hard FOX Television Academy Reality 2016 Mudbound social media Sneak Peek Bravo toy story justice league Brie Larson serial killer TruTV Pet Sematary unscripted book video OWN Animation AMC Western TV Land Country discovery Avengers Fantasy Lionsgate Ellie Kemper Rock Trophy Talk fresh Heroines GLAAD CW Seed television Infographic Tarantino cults Disney+ Disney Plus Netflix Christmas movies Winners spanish language space series 2020 Quiz History The Arrangement NBC SDCC Nat Geo french Awards Tour Disney psychological thriller christmas movies Lifetime Christmas movies strong female leads comiccon IFC Films cartoon jamie lee curtis Black Mirror Comedy 2017 SXSW TV renewals classics spider-man Trailer stoner Watching Series Food Network nature remakes Syfy Universal Music joker IFC The Purge foreign harry potter fast and furious CBS Alien Set visit Paramount canceled TV shows Action elevated horror BAFTA TCA Awards Mindy Kaling natural history Tomatazos mockumentary Video Games transformers mutant nfl Discovery Channel laika festival blockbuster james bond Crunchyroll Summer nbcuniversal teaser FX on Hulu obituary documentary BET Awards ABC GIFs BBC One BBC America Box Office dramedy Star Wars Britbox psycho deadpool Thanksgiving italian spy thriller Comic Book 2019 MCU disaster Rocky comedies DirecTV Baby Yoda supernatural free movies crossover ABC Family President The Academy rotten YA thriller rotten movies we love Columbia Pictures Musical Interview Certified Fresh Fall TV festivals VH1 satire singing competition 24 frames Best and Worst spanish south america romance Masterpiece Reality Competition Amazon Prime game show parents halloween tv Funimation Year in Review Fox News Stephen King indiana jones Rom-Com WGN sports witnail screen actors guild hollywood Sony Pictures black twilight ID Sundance Amazon Studios Ovation Women's History Month sequel The Walking Dead TCM cancelled television asian-american cats revenge finale films Fox Searchlight Cannes casting ghosts New York Comic Con 45 007 hispanic DC Universe Spring TV Writers Guild of America toronto boxoffice Martial Arts dc Anna Paquin cooking werewolf 72 Emmy Awards 2018 Film Festival 99% Polls and Games Dark Horse Comics miniseries historical drama hist Epix Black History Month TCA Winter 2020 diversity spain boxing venice Lucasfilm comic Star Trek cancelled TV shows YouTube Premium travel Super Bowl mission: impossible dceu name the review GoT cancelled The Witch LGBT TV BET BBC 20th Century Fox DGA worst movies Mary poppins what to watch Disney Channel 71st Emmy Awards Cosplay Awards war E3 superhero composers dogs Photos reviews NYCC USA Grammys First Look concert Pirates news based on movie Chernobyl documentaries australia Superheroes robots HBO Max YouTube Red stand-up comedy CBS All Access worst Marvel Studios Captain marvel Teen TNT canceled RT21 sag awards Podcast politics Superheroe chucky renewed TV shows tv talk crime drama FXX Walt Disney Pictures The CW Marvel Television criterion spinoff Character Guide video on demand crime Election scary movies Spike streaming PlayStation Sundance Now Crackle Red Carpet Adult Swim Winter TV Trivia ESPN A24 Extras First Reviews Disney streaming service Logo HBO Mary Tyler Moore best dragons TCA RT History cancelled TV series Nickelodeon PBS Hallmark Christmas movies Valentine's Day Song of Ice and Fire Opinion