Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Superman" And "Devil" Are Certified Fresh

by | June 29, 2006 | Comments

This week’s wide releases both involve publishing. In "The Devil Wears Prada," the setting is a fashion magazine, and in "Superman Returns," it’s The Daily Planet. So maybe that’s why the critics like both these movies so much…

While there has been some debate over the quality of Lauren Weisberger’s novel "The Devil Wears Prada," there’s less divergence over the movie adaptation, particularly because of the presence of Meryl Streep in the titular role. Anne Hathaway plays an earnest small-town girl who hopes to write high-minded stuff for the New Yorker, but is little match for the Cruella De Ville-esque Miranda Priestly (Streep). The scribes say the film ultimately works because of Streep’s excellent performance, but "The Devil Wears Prada" is also an incisive examination of workplace politics. At 76 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Devil" wears a Certified Fresh badge.

After a long, arduous trial, Meryl Streep was acquitted by the fashion police, but convicted by the sunglass police.

You may have heard that there’s a new Superman movie out. It’s called "Superman Returns," and it stars a relative unknown as the Man of Steel (Brandon Routh), an actress who was in that Bobby Darin movie (Kate Bosworth), and the guy who played Bobby Darin himself in that same movie, this time playing Lex Luthor (Kevin Spacey). (Dude, he was probably Keyzer Soze as well) The critics say "Superman Returns" is able to pull off the neat trick of sticking closely to the age-old particulars of the Superman myth, while making them fresh. "Superman Returns" is at 76 percent on the Tomatometer, and it’s Certified Fresh.

"I’ll have a root beer float, hold the kryptonite."

This is a week of well-reviewed releases in general. Also opening, albeit in limited release: "Who Killed the Electric Car," a documentary about the short-lived EV1, is at 87 percent; "The Motel," a coming-of-age tale set in a fleabag motel, is at 82 percent; "The Blood of My Brother," a documentary about death in Iraq, is at 67 percent; and the big-screen adaptation of the cult TV hit "Strangers With Candy" is at 57 percent.

Recent Meryl Streep Movies:
80% — A Prairie Home Companion (2006)
50% — Prime (2005)
81% — The Manchurian Candidate (2004)
71% — Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (2004)
62% — Stuck On You (2003)

Recent Bryan Singer Movies:
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
80% — X-Men (2000)
53% — Apt Pupil (1998)
90% — The Usual Suspects (1995)
50% — Public Access (1993)

Tag Cloud

critics satire kong Universal Crunchyroll Reality Competition based on movie Syfy award winner El Rey TV Land ID adenture Superheroes political drama Mudbound concert Ghostbusters italian Turner Classic Movies Tarantino MTV Winners AMC Plus Hollywood Foreign Press Association Rock DC streaming service zombie BET Awards Fall TV Disney Tokyo Olympics Women's History Month breaking bad Set visit pirates of the caribbean Mary Poppins Returns Apple nbcuniversal versus 24 frames medical drama critic resources GoT period drama Music Universal Pictures American Society of Cinematographers Elton John 1990s Pixar olympics Year in Review Teen hist docuseries suspense Sundance Comedy Central 90s anthology Instagram Live Thanksgiving golden globe awards new york Star Wars sitcom TCA summer preview Awards Tour true crime Sundance TV ViacomCBS Kids & Family Disney Channel die hard Fox Searchlight Holidays rt labs genre golden globes Food Network TCA Awards 73rd Emmy Awards movies Horror Marathons Christmas cults ghosts Lifetime binge robots CBS All Access Valentine's Day Netflix Christmas movies First Reviews obituary revenge Chernobyl dragons psycho godzilla cats Comics on TV japan FOX thriller screen actors guild social media james bond parents universal monsters scorecard leaderboard 2015 DC Universe prank kids Nominations australia feel good Crackle 2018 BAFTA History canceled FXX Sony target scene in color See It Skip It Logo Certified Fresh Apple TV+ Hallmark YA jamie lee curtis 2021 Fantasy posters jurassic park Oscars women finale a nightmare on elm street The Walking Dead movie police drama miniseries VICE adaptation doctor who animated 2016 The Walt Disney Company TV One independent VH1 criterion Winter TV action-comedy cancelled television Polls and Games what to watch romance heist movie MSNBC Sneak Peek harry potter royal family Epix Amazon Prime Video indiana jones Family OWN talk show Mystery MGM 007 Avengers space marvel cinematic universe Sci-Fi HFPA APB comiccon Grammys teaser slashers 2017 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pacific Islander reviews A24 theme song Tags: Comedy disaster Interview TV renewals Disney streaming service series Warner Bros. Alien Focus Features Character Guide The CW Marvel Studios Drama mockumentary Musicals chucky worst movies 2020 football Box Office Lucasfilm spain WarnerMedia Sundance Now Funimation New York Comic Con Peacock halloween tv Countdown festival Pop Lifetime Christmas movies 45 Amazon Academy Awards Exclusive Video Baby Yoda A&E japanese black comedy SundanceTV Comic-Con@Home 2021 Disney Plus new zealand hispanic documentary joker obi wan Amazon Studios Chilling Adventures of Sabrina basketball serial killer high school YouTube ABC Oscar First Look foreign sequel Pride Month rotten Arrowverse Dark Horse Comics 94th Oscars Acorn TV monster movies rt archives 93rd Oscars LGBTQ Hallmark Christmas movies wonder woman Cartoon Network Schedule Marvel venice asian-american hispanic heritage month Neflix rom-coms CBS TCA 2017 deadpool DC Comics stand-up comedy streaming movies diversity TruTV Netflix Red Carpet vampires trailers cooking Travel Channel CMT NYCC historical drama Comic Book Animation facebook docudrama popular remakes Western latino dreamworks comic Britbox biography fast and furious Wes Anderson war WGN batman razzies casting classics live action TLC TV movies X-Men crime thriller Hear Us Out TBS San Diego Comic-Con Stephen King BET ABC Signature Adult Swim spider-man 2019 spy thriller 79th Golden Globes Awards fresh Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HBO Go Country trophy supernatural Shudder cancelled USA Network 72 Emmy Awards TIFF VOD festivals Film Festival cartoon television saw Spring TV comedies international Video Games vs. Trivia Nickelodeon mcc IMDb TV richard e. Grant Creative Arts Emmys Premiere Dates Marvel Television dogs children's TV Toys summer TV preview new star wars movies CNN scary nature YouTube Premium broadcast directors elevated horror spanish language blockbuster BBC Prime Video target Fox News Extras Ovation young adult Cannes justice league Geeked Week Tubi Indigenous mob films toronto blockbusters Film ABC Family Broadway The Purge marvel comics werewolf anime franchise TNT live event RT21 zombies Watching Series twilight cancelled TV series aapi archives 21st Century Fox hidden camera Vudu video gangster PBS The Academy ESPN mutant Esquire lord of the rings superman sag awards green book quibi HBO child's play Fargo streamig Summer Song of Ice and Fire BBC America MCU BBC One dceu Disney+ Disney Plus Action Podcast technology hollywood Best Actress TCM scary movies Image Comics king kong reboot E! mission: impossible streaming know your critic cinemax scene in color NBA witnail Biopics Paramount Network toy story superhero best christmas movies FX on Hulu composers emmy awards unscripted Trophy Talk Heroines Shondaland legend Infographic dexter Rom-Com 4/20 Spectrum Originals Best Actor Photos halloween Super Bowl interviews Hulu Legendary LGBT Quiz Binge Guide documentaries adventure spider-verse Pirates Calendar Musical stop motion Spike all-time Brie Larson renewed TV shows SDCC rt labs critics edition Reality OneApp summer TV Amazon Prime Starz NBC news art house Bravo science fiction Ellie Kemper singing competition Anna Paquin debate DirecTV USA comic book movie name the review Black Mirror rotten movies we love 71st Emmy Awards boxoffice biopic Classic Film comic book movies video on demand comics Star Wars Celebration worst crime drama crossover boxing discovery south america Masterpiece YouTube Red Writers Guild of America HBO Max spanish Best Picture Paramount Pictures tv talk king arthur Columbia Pictures cancelled TV shows Rocketman Black History Month Holiday game show Superheroe Apple TV Plus Television Critics Association book GIFs dark Discovery Channel comic books sopranos CW Seed 20th Century Fox sports Sony Pictures telelvision game of thrones laika Opinion President South by Southwest Film Festival cops travel Trailer Best and Worst Captain marvel french stoner Martial Arts Comedy National Geographic Paramount Plus Mary poppins screenings TV Star Trek sequels Native RT History politics Awards blaxploitation kaiju Walt Disney Pictures Pet Sematary The Arrangement E3 crime Cosplay zero dark thirty PaleyFest transformers psychological thriller Freeform GLAAD Endgame dc 99% canceled TV shows FX dramedy Showtime SXSW black nfl Best Director book adaptation Tomatazos ITV indie Mindy Kaling Pop TV TCA Winter 2020 aliens ratings The Witch Nat Geo Rocky Mary Tyler Moore Emmy Nominations Emmys IFC Films PlayStation Election scene in color series slasher romantic comedy Television Academy strong female leads cars Paramount spinoff free movies Tumblr SXSW 2022 Turner scene in color film series natural history AMC IFC DGA Lionsgate