Critics Consensus

Is Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice Critical Kryptonite?

Plus, My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 is a stale sequel.

by and | March 24, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a superhero battle royale (Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, starring Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill) and a family reunion (My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2, starring Nia Vardalos and John Corbett). What do the critics have to say?


Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) 29%

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice promises both an epic throwdown between two of popular culture’s most beloved characters and a world-building introduction to the DC Comics Extended Universe. Unfortunately, critics say this hotly-anticipated superhero flick is a big misfire — a narratively slack, overly self-serious action fest that fails to do justice to the essence of its titular heroes. Following the events of Man of Steel — in which much of Metropolis was reduced to rubble — Bruce Wayne (Ben Affleck) becomes deeply concerned about Superman’s unchecked power. Meanwhile, Clark Kent (Henry Cavill) has some quibbles with Batman’s vigilante approach to fighting crime in Gotham City. The critics say Batman V Superman benefits from strong performances (particularly Affleck and Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman) and moments of striking visual panache, but overall, it’s less gritty than depressing, and less exciting than bombastic.


My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 (2016) 27%

Back in 2002, former Second City member Nia Vardalos earned heaps of praise and a Best Original Screenplay Oscar nod for writing and starring in the surprise hit rom-com My Big Fat Greek Wedding. It’s unclear what prompted a sequel 14 years later, but it’s here now, and critics say it’s not likely to win any awards. Vardalos reprises her role as Toula Portokalos, who discovers her parents were never officially married and decides to organize a bigger, fatter, Greeker wedding for them. The pundits say My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 is predictably sentimental and harmless enough, but its recycled jokes and aimless narrative do little to justify its existence.


What’s Hot on TV

The Catch: Season 1 (2016) 74%

While the jury is out on its weekly worthiness, The Catch largely yields satisfying results with tried-and-true Shondaland production qualities, fun cases of the week, and bendy plot twists.


Heartbeat: Season 1 (1992) 20%

Heartbeat is a Frankensteined drama made up of hospital genre cliches and unlikable characters, though the cases-of-the-week are sporadically interesting.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • April and the Extraordinary World (2015) , an animated sci-fi adventure from France about a girl who finds herself wrapped up in a conspiracy after her scientist parents mysteriously disappear, is at 100 percent.
  • Everything Is Copy (2015) , a documentary portrait of writer/director Nora Ephron, is at 100 percent
  • Mapplethorpe: Look at the Pictures (2016) , a documentary about the work and life of the controversial photographer, is at 100 percent.
  • My Mother (2015) ,  a drama about a film director dealing with on-set problems and family issues, is at 91 percent.
  • Born to Be Blue (2015) , starring Ethan Hawke and Carmen Ejogo in a biopic of doomed jazz trumpeter and vocalist Chet Baker, is at 85 percent.
  • Valley of Love (2015) , starring Isabelle Huppert and Gérard Depardieu as ex-spouses who journey to Death Valley to fulfill the wishes of their deceased son, is at 80 percent.
  • Fastball (2015) , a documentary about baseball’s most powerful pitch, is at 78 percent.
  • Seve: The Movie (2014) , a biopic of legendary golfer Seve Ballesteros’ early years, is at 73 percent.
  • Baskin (2015) , a Turkish horror film about a group of cops who stumble into an otherworldly realm, is at 62 percent.
  • They're Watching (2016) , a found footage horror film about the bedeviled crew of a home improvement reality TV show, is at 60 percent.
  • I Saw the Light (2015) , starring Tom Hiddleston and Elizabeth Olsen in a biopic of country music legend Hank Williams Sr., is at 18 percent.
  • Get a Job (2016) , starring Miles Teller and Anna Kendrick in a comedy about a pair of recent college grads facing an uncertain job market, is at 11 percent.

Tag Cloud

crossover elevated horror aapi National Geographic Rock 72 Emmy Awards rotten Video Games jurassic park Set visit godzilla franchise emmy awards harry potter doctor who BAFTA spy thriller basketball Fox Searchlight dark stoner Alien TCA Awards international comiccon dceu Lionsgate finale IFC Films AMC First Reviews italian Shudder TV halloween Hallmark Christmas movies 20th Century Fox binge target technology posters Marvel Studios slashers archives suspense Esquire directors robots Best Actress cooking Certified Fresh FOX Chernobyl The Walt Disney Company Creative Arts Emmys medical drama The Academy chucky rt archives book adaptation Summer concert japan Sundance Now indiana jones Academy Awards superman APB Neflix MGM Musicals facebook Cannes spider-verse Acorn TV toronto First Look Year in Review dragons 24 frames Amazon Prime blockbusters theme song Peacock politics Paramount Network Mystery biopic olympics Trophy Talk Rocketman Image Comics Film Festival crime thriller Marvel rotten movies we love X-Men LGBTQ docudrama HFPA know your critic dexter venice new zealand new york psychological thriller animated OWN Logo mob joker The Arrangement Grammys singing competition Crackle news Emmy Nominations Netflix Christmas movies royal family The Purge dreamworks scene in color 007 award winner Bravo black comedy reboot Western Reality video Mary Poppins Returns sitcom TIFF TCA Winter 2020 YA Captain marvel comic book movies Film See It Skip It cancelled TV shows social media Biopics streaming movies Spike Oscar Disney streaming service Comics on TV boxoffice TNT versus Universal Reality Competition witnail TBS Awards Tour Holidays new star wars movies Tubi Oscars Action TCM latino Exclusive Video all-time sports Discovery Channel batman Super Bowl Best Picture Horror name the review romantic comedy The Walking Dead WarnerMedia Toys scary movies USA Network mission: impossible DC streaming service Adult Swim documentary IMDb TV spinoff Ovation game show independent The Witch cinemax TV One YouTube Red Disney Channel PaleyFest cars 79th Golden Globes Awards comic composers Character Guide Sundance TV serial killer zombie thriller worst movies Rom-Com comic books Paramount Pictures child's play FXX slasher 73rd Emmy Awards Freeform Ghostbusters vampires ESPN Crunchyroll obi wan strong female leads legend VH1 laika Broadway hispanic heritage month Travel Channel History LGBT Stephen King summer TV Song of Ice and Fire telelvision WGN Black Mirror justice league gangster Television Critics Association series zero dark thirty what to watch Country art house SXSW christmas movies YouTube Premium 90s video on demand BET Turner Classic Movies dramedy Music hispanic science fiction razzies Lifetime obituary prank Pixar CNN discovery football scary E! Comedy Central king arthur cartoon Teen black Watching Series Pop TV nbcuniversal A24 Superheroes Turner heist movie cops Disney+ Disney Plus james bond free movies political drama Best and Worst Tomatazos Winter TV Epix historical drama Food Network Fargo period drama romance 93rd Oscars Hulu BET Awards a nightmare on elm street lord of the rings young adult criterion comics travel ID casting Marvel Television SXSW 2022 fast and furious mutant rom-coms Trivia television Elton John TV Land streamig Legendary movie Paramount Television Academy Amazon Studios adventure E3 Disney Plus blockbuster CBS All Access Tokyo Olympics Trailer President docuseries Red Carpet VICE pirates of the caribbean Pacific Islander mockumentary miniseries spanish ViacomCBS ABC Family asian-american Disney space richard e. Grant disaster blaxploitation Holiday dogs Best Actor remakes Extras MTV movies reviews Polls and Games GoT 1990s Rocky Amazon Prime Video NBA book Musical summer TV preview Awards Netflix screenings kong police drama Drama nature TV renewals ABC Cosplay Fantasy Dark Horse Comics sequels crime Winners streaming Arrowverse Pop mcc MCU marvel cinematic universe PlayStation CMT golden globe awards classics trailers Heroines Binge Guide Calendar PBS documentaries Walt Disney Pictures monster movies Wes Anderson Animation Quiz Hollywood Foreign Press Association anthology Valentine's Day summer preview Masterpiece Apple TV Plus Apple ghosts cancelled TV series Best Director MSNBC deadpool japanese 2017 Avengers game of thrones Superheroe Election DC Comics werewolf Infographic TruTV dc The CW 45 Box Office Endgame Comic Book anime Prime Video spider-man Photos YouTube unscripted quibi aliens rt labs Mary Tyler Moore San Diego Comic-Con 2016 American Society of Cinematographers Spectrum Originals BBC golden globes Interview festivals critics indie south america sequel Cartoon Network cults Countdown cancelled women BBC America New York Comic Con FX 2021 Pet Sematary TV movies best Starz adenture screen actors guild supernatural TCA Nat Geo Tumblr Fox News Hallmark crime drama leaderboard popular stand-up comedy satire Spring TV South by Southwest Film Festival psycho BBC One Nickelodeon IFC Premiere Dates Nominations australia 21st Century Fox 2015 A&E canceled TV shows Amazon SDCC AMC Plus Kids & Family vs. hidden camera Apple TV+ Ellie Kemper high school diversity children's TV Shondaland Funimation HBO Go based on movie 94th Oscars Mudbound ITV Syfy Fall TV halloween tv FX on Hulu Marathons Vudu saw comic book movie transformers TCA 2017 tv talk Hear Us Out jamie lee curtis boxing GLAAD comedies spain DGA Sony Pictures USA Columbia Pictures ABC Signature teaser Sundance HBO action-comedy toy story live action spanish language 2018 RT21 71st Emmy Awards hist Britbox Showtime Comedy HBO Max marvel comics DirecTV Opinion die hard hollywood canceled 2020 foreign talk show RT History Chilling Adventures of Sabrina adaptation critic resources Warner Bros. kaiju Paramount Plus natural history Tags: Comedy stop motion Focus Features Emmys Sci-Fi OneApp El Rey Mary poppins genre Classic Film twilight feel good kids 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Star Wars Universal Pictures DC Universe GIFs 99% Podcast Lucasfilm CW Seed VOD renewed TV shows Mindy Kaling war Pride Month wonder woman Star Trek breaking bad king kong SundanceTV parents TLC sag awards worst cats Brie Larson Thanksgiving french Sneak Peek Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt scorecard 2019 Writers Guild of America Baby Yoda fresh debate cancelled television universal monsters 4/20 Instagram Live revenge biography sopranos Women's History Month live event Martial Arts superhero Comic-Con@Home 2021 Schedule films ratings festival Black History Month Lifetime Christmas movies CBS Pirates Family trophy true crime Tarantino NYCC Anna Paquin green book NBC nfl zombies rt labs critics edition Christmas