Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Rock of Ages Hits a Sour Note

Plus, That's My Boy is juvenile.

by | June 15, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a rock ‘n’ roll romance (Rock of Ages, starring Julianne Hough and Tom Cruise) and some father-son bonding (That’s My Boy, starring Adam Sandler and Andy Samberg). What do the critics have to say?

Rock of Ages


Given the runaway success of Glee, it’s no surprise that the hit jukebox musical Rock of Ages — featuring songs by Journey, Bon Jovi, Poison, and the like — made the transition from the stage to the screen. Unfortunately, critics say this headbanger’s ball is unlikely to rock you like a hurricane; though it provides some campy thrills, the film is overstuffed with underdeveloped characters and plot strands. Rock of Ages stars Julianne Hough as Sherrie, a small town girl with dreams of rock stardom. She works at a struggling club on the Sunset Strip, where high-maintenance rock god Stacee Jaxx (Tom Cruise) rules the scene. The pundits say Rock of Ages‘ talented cast (especially Cruise) is clearly having a lot of fun, but the plot is wafer thin and the antics surprisingly tame, given the excess of the period it’s supposedly celebrating. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Cruise’s best-reviewed movies.)

That’s My Boy


Adam Sandler has never exactly been a critical darling, but his most recent starring vehicles (Jack and Jill, Just Go with It, Grown Ups) have been rated lower than usual. The trend continues with That’s My Boy, which critics say is more juvenile than most Happy Madison Productions. The Sandman stars as Donny, who fathered a son named Todd (played by Andy Samberg as a grownup) while in middle school; when Todd turned 18, Donny disappeared from his son’s life. Now strapped for cash, Donny attempts to end their estrangement in order to persuade Todd to take part in a reality TV show; hilarity, in the form of familial discord, ensues. The pundits say That’s My Boy has a few decent lowbrow yuks, but it’s relentlessly sophomoric and tasteless. (Check out 24 Frames for a pictorial rundown of Sandler’s most memorable roles.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

japanese Endgame Film Festival 99% SundanceTV anime art house Indigenous international Universal zero dark thirty TV One all-time blaxploitation hispanic Opinion Geeked Week marvel comics ABC Signature 007 true crime cats ABC sag awards TLC Sundance TV Syfy political drama Superheroe 90s directors Tokyo Olympics Peacock young adult mockumentary technology Fox News child's play adaptation adventure Ovation Tomatazos crime drama Kids & Family PBS Comedy Central 72 Emmy Awards cancelled TV series leaderboard laika facebook Drama SXSW 2022 Netflix Christmas movies cults Mary poppins Video Games Crunchyroll suspense 1990s kaiju Polls and Games DGA screenings MTV Grammys theme song war venice natural history 2018 archives broadcast Netflix what to watch films Superheroes women Calendar biography comedies dragons heist movie Marathons latino slasher sitcom action-comedy cancelled TV shows WGN Best Director 2020 pirates of the caribbean indie Image Comics 24 frames aapi VOD Awards Tour Election toronto HBO Max teaser 2021 series worst monster movies Rom-Com olympics CMT italian cops franchise cars talk show Epix tv talk critic resources Hulu GLAAD National Geographic Biopics casting obi wan festival Tags: Comedy werewolf A&E American Society of Cinematographers IMDb TV SDCC comic book movies crossover Sundance Now asian-american sequel scene in color series BBC One versus Comic-Con@Home 2021 documentary Showtime james bond BBC America transformers deadpool Warner Bros. Amazon Winners robots Western Schedule breaking bad CNN Reality scary cancelled television chucky 20th Century Fox Stephen King ESPN joker Infographic Lucasfilm CBS prank canceled australia wonder woman ghosts marvel cinematic universe supernatural south america Baby Yoda Super Bowl Watching Series game of thrones high school 2017 Apple composers aliens nbcuniversal Best Actress superman Lionsgate book APB dexter 2019 New York Comic Con DC Comics nfl Hear Us Out A24 VH1 revenge Turner Song of Ice and Fire comic books rotten movies we love dramedy Martial Arts Masterpiece First Look rt labs critics edition die hard Bravo quibi Lifetime Christmas movies Best and Worst Premiere Dates Best Actor cooking OneApp MGM Cannes Year in Review independent Oscars video legend Ghostbusters Star Trek debate Reality Competition dogs renewed TV shows Sony Apple TV+ Logo binge Academy Awards Film social media indiana jones HFPA Comedy Extras CW Seed BBC blockbuster zombie Tarantino docuseries 4/20 Thanksgiving superhero basketball YouTube Red PaleyFest Mystery Classic Film royal family rotten Instagram Live Vudu Spectrum Originals Anna Paquin Pop TV trailers NYCC reboot Broadway Sneak Peek RT21 dc Awards CBS All Access Emmys Arrowverse unscripted Adult Swim Prime Video razzies Paramount Plus E! football new star wars movies cartoon Cosplay historical drama VICE 45 Binge Guide stoner MCU Comics on TV Box Office Best Picture TruTV romantic comedy streaming movies concert LGBTQ know your critic Wes Anderson discovery Focus Features Marvel reviews Pacific Islander Toys See It Skip It black Apple TV Plus USA Network Mudbound richard e. Grant Walt Disney Pictures Hallmark FX stand-up comedy 79th Golden Globes Awards summer TV Comic Book Country critics LGBT vampires dceu Interview lord of the rings streaming FX on Hulu Television Academy The Walking Dead The CW Rocketman mcc halloween FXX Columbia Pictures singing competition harry potter Sundance comics Winter TV universal monsters king arthur IFC Films award winner Set visit Character Guide History ratings Countdown Disney+ Disney Plus biopic Universal Pictures a nightmare on elm street DC streaming service Funimation satire Quiz kong criterion Family Animation Disney Channel 71st Emmy Awards medical drama zombies crime thriller jurassic park golden globe awards DirecTV SXSW live action Spike free movies Esquire rt archives Musical Photos classics streamig Black History Month rt labs San Diego Comic-Con live event South by Southwest Film Festival TCA Winter 2020 YouTube 21st Century Fox space Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt jamie lee curtis new york spider-man Amazon Prime The Arrangement dreamworks Discovery Channel spanish language cinemax gangster green book sequels french Black Mirror stop motion Trailer target scene in color Paramount Elton John scary movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards anthology Brie Larson Nickelodeon Star Wars Celebration emmy awards screen actors guild Valentine's Day batman Writers Guild of America Disney slashers fresh boxing sopranos genre popular 2016 based on movie comic book movie witnail 73rd Emmy Awards TBS Disney Plus politics TV Land FOX elevated horror Television Critics Association TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies AMC Marvel Television diversity feel good scene in color film series Fall TV hidden camera hispanic heritage month TNT President Captain marvel BAFTA The Witch documentaries vs. Pop Christmas parents Crackle hollywood children's TV Star Wars Turner Classic Movies twilight Ellie Kemper psycho japan NBC Shudder adenture Holiday Acorn TV finale Sony Pictures RT History mutant doctor who Certified Fresh Hollywood Foreign Press Association Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pirates GIFs summer TV preview TCA NBA Neflix Alien The Walt Disney Company docudrama Amazon Prime Video Nat Geo telelvision Shondaland book adaptation television HBO Go Tumblr MSNBC new zealand BET Awards Exclusive Video sports HBO First Reviews spain dark video on demand movie Paramount Network Freeform Travel Channel Rocky Oscar ITV Trophy Talk Paramount Pictures posters mob TV movies Chernobyl saw nature Summer name the review Heroines Creative Arts Emmys comiccon Rock justice league Fargo 93rd Oscars Musicals animated best Tubi obituary Music USA Emmy Nominations spy thriller fast and furious Cartoon Network Starz PlayStation Podcast Legendary rom-coms king kong festivals cancelled Disney streaming service Marvel Studios police drama golden globes ID TV renewals DC Universe blockbusters BET The Academy crime Avengers travel Fox Searchlight science fiction Nominations YA news WarnerMedia Red Carpet IFC hist TCA 2017 GoT disaster Sci-Fi Native Britbox Holidays canceled TV shows Amazon Studios romance game show mission: impossible Trivia godzilla YouTube Premium TCM Food Network OWN movies remakes X-Men period drama summer preview psychological thriller Lifetime Dark Horse Comics Pride Month E3 black comedy Women's History Month spinoff Teen Mary Poppins Returns AMC Plus scorecard target 94th Oscars worst movies Mary Tyler Moore thriller Pet Sematary spanish TV boxoffice 2015 Horror kids halloween tv miniseries Spring TV serial killer scene in color El Rey Action ABC Family trophy spider-verse The Purge Fantasy Pixar comic TCA Awards foreign interviews strong female leads Mindy Kaling ViacomCBS christmas movies toy story