Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Rock of Ages Hits a Sour Note

Plus, That's My Boy is juvenile.

by | June 15, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a rock ‘n’ roll romance (Rock of Ages, starring Julianne Hough and Tom Cruise) and some father-son bonding (That’s My Boy, starring Adam Sandler and Andy Samberg). What do the critics have to say?

Rock of Ages


Given the runaway success of Glee, it’s no surprise that the hit jukebox musical Rock of Ages — featuring songs by Journey, Bon Jovi, Poison, and the like — made the transition from the stage to the screen. Unfortunately, critics say this headbanger’s ball is unlikely to rock you like a hurricane; though it provides some campy thrills, the film is overstuffed with underdeveloped characters and plot strands. Rock of Ages stars Julianne Hough as Sherrie, a small town girl with dreams of rock stardom. She works at a struggling club on the Sunset Strip, where high-maintenance rock god Stacee Jaxx (Tom Cruise) rules the scene. The pundits say Rock of Ages‘ talented cast (especially Cruise) is clearly having a lot of fun, but the plot is wafer thin and the antics surprisingly tame, given the excess of the period it’s supposedly celebrating. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Cruise’s best-reviewed movies.)

That’s My Boy


Adam Sandler has never exactly been a critical darling, but his most recent starring vehicles (Jack and Jill, Just Go with It, Grown Ups) have been rated lower than usual. The trend continues with That’s My Boy, which critics say is more juvenile than most Happy Madison Productions. The Sandman stars as Donny, who fathered a son named Todd (played by Andy Samberg as a grownup) while in middle school; when Todd turned 18, Donny disappeared from his son’s life. Now strapped for cash, Donny attempts to end their estrangement in order to persuade Todd to take part in a reality TV show; hilarity, in the form of familial discord, ensues. The pundits say That’s My Boy has a few decent lowbrow yuks, but it’s relentlessly sophomoric and tasteless. (Check out 24 Frames for a pictorial rundown of Sandler’s most memorable roles.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

toronto festivals Teen comics Dark Horse Comics docuseries batman Comedy Ellie Kemper Amazon Studios Holiday live action President SDCC werewolf Paramount Network GLAAD FX on Hulu worst comic Pop TV Heroines BBC America BBC Adult Swim trailers Countdown Quiz facebook VICE Drama AMC Premiere Dates USA Election Polls and Games Marvel Studios Paramount Plus a nightmare on elm street comic books SundanceTV true crime spain Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Television Academy best legend based on movie breaking bad Holidays OWN TNT Hear Us Out zombie Amazon 2017 Classic Film Spike Writers Guild of America 93rd Oscars X-Men Rom-Com jamie lee curtis aliens Extras nature Superheroe Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV shows boxing 45 Calendar Film Festival TV Land Best and Worst Exclusive Video Schedule films E! Hallmark Christmas movies DirecTV adenture Pirates LGBT Action CW Seed james bond thriller war series chucky football 2015 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cooking CBS doctor who cancelled TV series ABC 21st Century Fox crossover Syfy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Set visit cancelled television Pop Trailer Esquire political drama Disney Channel Baby Yoda Disney+ Disney Plus nbcuniversal aapi kaiju Mindy Kaling Superheroes TruTV movies Lifetime Christmas movies Starz Mary Tyler Moore disaster classics science fiction cartoon Pacific Islander ABC Family Rock biography 2016 blockbuster History Red Carpet Awards Tour Photos E3 indiana jones Nominations Summer know your critic Rocky Winners Fantasy harry potter superman documentary RT History Hulu TIFF ITV Academy Awards NBA Britbox composers Logo Character Guide Brie Larson animated Sundance Now what to watch The CW Masterpiece DC Universe rom-coms versus australia technology PlayStation archives young adult video on demand italian Nat Geo prank NBC blaxploitation Valentine's Day natural history Apple TV Plus crime thriller Black History Month Tumblr casting robots Captain marvel Peacock rotten movies we love black psycho 73rd Emmy Awards TV Pride Month Disney Plus Musicals SXSW OneApp mockumentary Ghostbusters spinoff ESPN Freeform Tarantino YA women travel sports dark Toys YouTube USA Network Box Office RT21 TLC 90s DC streaming service Amazon Prime Video Certified Fresh Horror canceled TV shows movie name the review satire Walt Disney Pictures Sundance golden globe awards dramedy fresh mcc scene in color TCA 2017 Star Wars Cannes Television Critics Association vampires Country elevated horror Sneak Peek Apple Shondaland universal monsters Arrowverse international indie Mary poppins 2018 24 frames CBS All Access sag awards stop motion Disney streaming service reviews justice league VOD Reality Competition tv talk dexter psychological thriller Paramount 20th Century Fox BET Awards Vudu heist movie feel good First Reviews halloween Winter TV award winner kids concert Chernobyl kong teaser Universal cancelled new star wars movies Mudbound Emmy Nominations fast and furious television TV One Nickelodeon binge royal family reboot hispanic book asian-american anime Film toy story Disney Showtime BET TCA Winter 2020 venice APB supernatural criterion critic resources National Geographic stand-up comedy politics boxoffice BAFTA screenings Broadway The Walking Dead TV movies Animation all-time Tubi BBC One Warner Bros. zero dark thirty 1990s Fox News TCA GoT miniseries Grammys 99% hist Epix Trophy Talk HBO Max social media Ovation Pet Sematary rt archives joker ghosts Opinion The Purge ABC Signature Endgame ViacomCBS rt labs critics edition Sony Pictures Crackle Women's History Month anthology new york debate saw renewed TV shows Year in Review die hard Comedy Central Turner spanish Cosplay Bravo marvel cinematic universe zombies foreign adventure streaming movies LGBTQ Musical free movies HBO Go mutant YouTube Premium 4/20 Awards green book Crunchyroll See It Skip It children's TV cops ratings A24 Apple TV+ high school WGN Tomatazos king kong comic book movie DGA Interview halloween tv blockbusters 2021 Comic Book Oscars Music hispanic heritage month Legendary cars Amazon Prime sequel slasher PBS NYCC streaming superhero El Rey 2019 dogs monster movies marvel comics FOX diversity 007 A&E sitcom Star Trek spider-man Sundance TV crime drama Emmys Food Network pirates of the caribbean stoner FX Western The Walt Disney Company rotten Netflix Christmas movies Image Comics nfl medical drama Columbia Pictures lord of the rings Mystery south america Pixar docudrama Marvel franchise cults ID Acorn TV king arthur Tokyo Olympics screen actors guild Kids & Family FXX hidden camera The Arrangement Black Mirror discovery Comic-Con@Home 2021 Turner Classic Movies Family Watching Series wonder woman Avengers canceled scorecard rt labs Netflix historical drama Hallmark french New York Comic Con Fall TV mission: impossible Wes Anderson remakes HBO romance basketball book adaptation crime TCM directors 71st Emmy Awards Binge Guide witnail American Society of Cinematographers singing competition Sci-Fi Alien cinemax The Witch Stephen King Martial Arts laika theme song WarnerMedia olympics Spring TV talk show Marathons Lifetime Comics on TV Trivia 72 Emmy Awards Reality revenge MCU Travel Channel Podcast critics Creative Arts Emmys biopic YouTube Red police drama IFC Films Funimation Christmas richard e. Grant romantic comedy emmy awards Song of Ice and Fire First Look spanish language CMT MSNBC The Academy japan dc dceu Shudder action-comedy space worst movies IFC Spectrum Originals comedies Biopics twilight jurassic park telelvision game show period drama video Lucasfilm quibi Super Bowl Rocketman dragons Discovery Channel finale gangster deadpool 2020 Thanksgiving razzies CNN Marvel Television Lionsgate spy thriller documentaries obituary PaleyFest independent scary movies posters TV renewals festival unscripted TCA Awards japanese comiccon slashers Anna Paquin parents suspense adaptation Elton John Fox Searchlight game of thrones news DC Comics child's play comic book movies San Diego Comic-Con serial killer Video Games Cartoon Network popular new zealand sequels TBS MTV GIFs Infographic strong female leads golden globes hollywood latino target godzilla cats VH1 transformers christmas movies