Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Puss in Boots is the Cat's Meow

Plus, The Rum Diary is sporadically compelling, and In Time takes a great idea and does a so-so job with it.

by | October 28, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a swashbuckling feline (Puss in Boots, with voice work from Antonio Banderas and Salma Hayek), a gonzo journalist (The Rum Diary, starring Johnny Depp and Aaron Eckhart), and monetary mortality (In Time, starring Justin Timberlake and Amanda Seyfried). What do the critics have to say?

Puss in Boots


The Shrek franchise keeps rolling along, this time ogre-free, with Puss in Boots, which critics find to be a witty, action-packed romp in its own right. In this prequel, ever-daring Puss (voiced by Antonio Banderas) teams up with the tough, alluring Kitty Softpaws (Salma Hayek) to protect the world from a pair of villains named Jack and Jill. The pundits say Puss in Boots is smart and funny, a clever send-up of fairy tale conventions with vibrant animation and inspired vocal performances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Banderas’ best-reviewed films.)

The Rum Diary


Johnny Depp steps back into Hunter S. Thompson’s shoes for The Rum Diary, but critics say that, like its predecessor Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, its sporadic moments of colorful madness are undercut by an uneven script. The Run Diary chronicles one of the gonzo reporter’s memorable early assignments: a wild trek to Puerto Rico in which our hero uncovers a shady business plot and drinks a ton of booze. The pundits say the film is a mostly agreeable mix of picturesque settings and eccentric characters, but it lacks the focus needed to be a truly cohesive head trip. (Check out director Bruce Robinson’s Five Favorite Films.)

In Time


It’s a high concept cross between Logan’s Run and Occupy Wall Street, but critics say gaping plot holes and excessive action sequences keep In Time from measuring up to its intriguing premise. Set in a world where everyone is genetically engineered to die shortly after they turn 25 (except for the rich folks, who can purchase more time), Justin Timberlake stars as a man of modest means on the run from the cops after he’s been gifted a life-extension. The pundits say In Time has a sleek look and some interesting ideas, but it runs out of steam pretty quickly.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

adventure dramedy LGBTQ Horror werewolf Netflix Christmas movies First Reviews Legendary dc Sci-Fi Paramount Plus Fall TV Spring TV feel good SXSW a nightmare on elm street hispanic heritage month Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Television Academy reviews Christmas true crime thriller Alien Shondaland critic resources james bond international Amazon emmy awards HBO Interview Cartoon Network disaster witnail cancelled comics Instagram Live blaxploitation PlayStation crime renewed TV shows richard e. Grant comic books Ghostbusters TBS legend Polls and Games A&E PBS Infographic Tubi dragons Tarantino hispanic social media Arrowverse Black History Month sitcom SDCC festival cancelled TV shows ghosts 2019 TNT hidden camera canceled TV shows latino DC Comics politics Pirates sports Comedy Central Comic-Con@Home 2021 Musicals Kids & Family Lifetime Christmas movies Lionsgate cartoon SundanceTV MCU Rocketman nature Valentine's Day Video Games Britbox TV versus VH1 Holiday anthology hist italian Tomatazos Adult Swim best obituary Podcast gangster Drama Mystery Grammys PaleyFest debate Star Wars black comedy Lucasfilm RT21 popular Comics on TV police drama Crackle scary sequels CNN die hard Bravo supernatural jurassic park TCM E! medical drama cars Oscars TLC Calendar Amazon Prime YouTube Red children's TV jamie lee curtis Reality spider-verse Paramount Network 45 Elton John Fargo streaming movies fresh festivals suspense Ovation australia Vudu rom-coms psychological thriller Sundance reboot Hallmark Pet Sematary discovery cooking screen actors guild Pixar rt labs critics edition BBC America 24 frames spinoff First Look Binge Guide Epix Best and Worst Baby Yoda Apple TV+ book adaptation Western slashers child's play The Purge critics Lifetime Heroines Photos wonder woman Nickelodeon romance Box Office docuseries Marathons Walt Disney Pictures TIFF History king arthur 2021 indie christmas movies MSNBC new star wars movies Disney streaming service book Pride Month satire 73rd Emmy Awards WGN Premiere Dates Universal crime thriller news DC Universe Trivia twilight BET miniseries breaking bad The Walking Dead FXX American Society of Cinematographers Emmys Masterpiece Character Guide art house 2016 toy story prank 93rd Oscars Teen boxoffice scorecard cinemax posters Countdown Super Bowl NYCC Sony Pictures Fox News Sundance TV 90s talk show football documentary RT History lord of the rings 2018 NBA parents Musical kids name the review Schedule Pop TV Tokyo Olympics marvel comics The CW Action The Academy 21st Century Fox mockumentary chucky live action Sneak Peek X-Men Travel Channel Mindy Kaling ABC theme song pirates of the caribbean Columbia Pictures trailers sequel japan diversity Spectrum Originals archives aapi rt archives stand-up comedy 4/20 TCA 2017 dexter aliens ABC Family YA Pacific Islander CBS elevated horror ViacomCBS rotten godzilla Summer superman Biopics dogs Exclusive Video Trophy Talk classics rt labs high school comic book movies trophy Awards Tour Marvel Studios crossover NBC 2017 Hallmark Christmas movies spy thriller TV Land unscripted Emmy Nominations natural history ABC Signature Mudbound dark IMDb TV stop motion Year in Review slasher deadpool YouTube Black Mirror cats green book Stephen King new york rotten movies we love YouTube Premium composers Amazon Studios See It Skip It laika quibi IFC mcc films zero dark thirty San Diego Comic-Con foreign worst franchise comedies dreamworks halloween superhero crime drama action-comedy historical drama Disney Plus Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comedy animated The Walt Disney Company directors joker E3 Rocky anime saw game show Superheroes basketball Endgame Election Nat Geo doctor who south america strong female leads documentaries Syfy USA Network free movies Thanksgiving Food Network Country criterion target Avengers movies ratings Film Festival cancelled TV series Extras Chernobyl sopranos Wes Anderson 2015 Television Critics Association Quiz cops cancelled television 1990s Image Comics facebook 20th Century Fox El Rey DC streaming service Brie Larson WarnerMedia binge BBC king kong LGBT period drama Logo psycho Apple TV Plus harry potter indiana jones The Arrangement Comic Book streaming HBO Max Red Carpet Mary poppins 72 Emmy Awards comic series VOD nfl Awards black robots video on demand Crunchyroll Ellie Kemper APB young adult Freeform Disney+ Disney Plus Rom-Com GoT video vampires space Mary Tyler Moore mutant kong zombie mob Fantasy Acorn TV FX japanese asian-american TCA Captain marvel FX on Hulu CMT teaser travel ID Trailer Toys romantic comedy Star Trek boxing blockbusters 99% National Geographic Song of Ice and Fire BET Awards Rock golden globe awards based on movie Broadway telelvision New York Comic Con Family A24 genre all-time Spike Martial Arts award winner Paramount Dark Horse Comics Netflix Discovery Channel Women's History Month Holidays royal family remakes Cannes casting Academy Awards DirecTV Disney Channel Marvel Television docudrama Cosplay Winter TV Funimation marvel cinematic universe french Nominations comiccon dceu Esquire scene in color fast and furious science fiction Mary Poppins Returns Animation monster movies independent canceled USA ESPN Superheroe AMC universal monsters know your critic Starz blockbuster 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards venice CW Seed Film Watching Series golden globes Peacock Amazon Prime Video The Witch revenge Turner finale BBC One television heist movie worst movies CBS All Access GIFs Showtime Fox Searchlight BAFTA cults Pop GLAAD 71st Emmy Awards transformers IFC Films war stoner Disney TV renewals razzies Writers Guild of America Reality Competition serial killer TruTV Apple screenings tv talk spider-man Turner Classic Movies TV One what to watch scary movies 2020 Certified Fresh TCA Awards comic book movie leaderboard OWN movie OneApp toronto Tumblr kaiju spanish language FOX HBO Go justice league concert political drama hollywood Opinion biography live event TV movies spain 007 Universal Pictures adenture TCA Winter 2020 mission: impossible singing competition Neflix halloween tv Winners adaptation spanish sag awards President Classic Film Music zombies nbcuniversal Set visit women Anna Paquin Sundance Now Shudder AMC Plus biopic Hear Us Out Marvel olympics VICE new zealand MTV ITV Hulu technology vs. batman game of thrones Creative Arts Emmys Warner Bros. DGA