Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Puss in Boots is the Cat's Meow

Plus, The Rum Diary is sporadically compelling, and In Time takes a great idea and does a so-so job with it.

by | October 28, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a swashbuckling feline (Puss in Boots, with voice work from Antonio Banderas and Salma Hayek), a gonzo journalist (The Rum Diary, starring Johnny Depp and Aaron Eckhart), and monetary mortality (In Time, starring Justin Timberlake and Amanda Seyfried). What do the critics have to say?

Puss in Boots


The Shrek franchise keeps rolling along, this time ogre-free, with Puss in Boots, which critics find to be a witty, action-packed romp in its own right. In this prequel, ever-daring Puss (voiced by Antonio Banderas) teams up with the tough, alluring Kitty Softpaws (Salma Hayek) to protect the world from a pair of villains named Jack and Jill. The pundits say Puss in Boots is smart and funny, a clever send-up of fairy tale conventions with vibrant animation and inspired vocal performances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Banderas’ best-reviewed films.)

The Rum Diary


Johnny Depp steps back into Hunter S. Thompson’s shoes for The Rum Diary, but critics say that, like its predecessor Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, its sporadic moments of colorful madness are undercut by an uneven script. The Run Diary chronicles one of the gonzo reporter’s memorable early assignments: a wild trek to Puerto Rico in which our hero uncovers a shady business plot and drinks a ton of booze. The pundits say the film is a mostly agreeable mix of picturesque settings and eccentric characters, but it lacks the focus needed to be a truly cohesive head trip. (Check out director Bruce Robinson’s Five Favorite Films.)

In Time


It’s a high concept cross between Logan’s Run and Occupy Wall Street, but critics say gaping plot holes and excessive action sequences keep In Time from measuring up to its intriguing premise. Set in a world where everyone is genetically engineered to die shortly after they turn 25 (except for the rich folks, who can purchase more time), Justin Timberlake stars as a man of modest means on the run from the cops after he’s been gifted a life-extension. The pundits say In Time has a sleek look and some interesting ideas, but it runs out of steam pretty quickly.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

2018 LGBTQ Musical Trophy Talk Sundance Now Song of Ice and Fire Character Guide Brie Larson Grammys TBS Super Bowl SXSW IFC Films Disney Channel Amazon 2016 GoT green book witnail Martial Arts Lionsgate Biopics Opinion 20th Century Fox facebook war IFC TCM hist Star Trek Walt Disney Pictures Comedy Central 21st Century Fox Spectrum Originals Rocky Bravo Podcast dragons HBO Max Summer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina WGN President spinoff 2019 zombie period drama transformers award winner Heroines Country TV Food Network justice league biography DC Universe science fiction romance NBC ABC Family See It Skip It Mary poppins golden globes police drama DGA BBC Winners Pixar game show dceu Comic Book aliens Trailer psycho SundanceTV YA technology Starz talk show finale Oscars Year in Review spy thriller Interview TCA 2017 TCA harry potter based on movie crime drama singing competition BBC America DC streaming service E! Mystery Election Star Wars 2017 Ellie Kemper New York Comic Con Trivia adaptation political drama Anna Paquin richard e. Grant sitcom Britbox Quiz Countdown Nat Geo Paramount Network Fall TV Chernobyl Stephen King Writers Guild of America television ABC TV Land Creative Arts Emmys miniseries Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cats LGBT ESPN travel Pop Acorn TV American Society of Cinematographers OWN Esquire docudrama Ghostbusters festivals MCU Winter TV Extras comiccon USA Disney TIFF Awards YouTube Premium Reality Ovation NYCC natural history Mudbound 45 Comedy Watching Series true crime mockumentary Fantasy Musicals Cannes Premiere Dates WarnerMedia Mary Tyler Moore Marathons Cartoon Network Sci-Fi Kids & Family Sundance GLAAD dramedy FOX supernatural toy story diversity Set visit Photos CBS composers PaleyFest Netflix Polls and Games USA Network E3 Syfy sequel CMT Infographic Teen crime discovery SDCC Hulu cults El Rey thriller psychological thriller MTV Mindy Kaling CW Seed Showtime strong female leads Cosplay TNT Horror disaster space medical drama Best and Worst Animation CBS All Access Reality Competition comic adventure zero dark thirty Spike Crackle YouTube Red First Look cops jamie lee curtis RT History Captain marvel Calendar AMC unscripted Video Games The Arrangement 007 RT21 Tarantino Shudder elevated horror Rom-Com dc MSNBC Nominations The Witch Superheroes anime Marvel animated DC Comics 24 frames History politics A&E VH1 Valentine's Day serial killer Pride Month Pet Sematary Superheroe Box Office Amazon Prime Red Carpet theme song Emmy Nominations Mary Poppins Returns X-Men Shondaland Awards Tour Black Mirror Tomatazos historical drama Dark Horse Comics crossover Thanksgiving Christmas casting nature doctor who Spring TV sports ITV Sneak Peek Schedule teaser TruTV BET The CW boxoffice Tumblr crime thriller Action binge Lifetime Epix PBS spider-man anthology VICE Columbia Pictures Rock Drama Paramount cinemax robots blaxploitation Logo Certified Fresh Comics on TV Vudu Film Festival Emmys what to watch FXX San Diego Comic-Con Warner Bros. mutant streaming DirecTV Pirates Rocketman Masterpiece Universal TLC Sony Pictures Women's History Month social media Lucasfilm Music GIFs APB National Geographic Elton John Freeform Toys Nickelodeon Western ratings vampires HBO CNN 2015 Fox News cooking Adult Swim zombies FX Apple Holidays