Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Man of Steel Is Up, Up, and Okay

Plus, This Is the End and Before Midnight are Certified Fresh.

by | June 14, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the return of Superman (Man of Steel, starring Henry Cavill and Amy Adams), an apocalyptic laugh-riot (This Is the End, starring James Franco and Seth Rogen), and a one-of-a-kind love affair (Before Midnight, starring Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy). What do the critics have to say?

Man of Steel


Superman is arguably the definitive comic book hero, but few would argue that he’s had the kind of unqualified big-screen success as his DC buddy Batman. With Man of Steel, Zack Snyder attempts to update Supe for the 21st Century, but critics say he’s only moderately successful; the action scenes are often rousing and Henry Cavill brings an undeniable charisma to the character, but the film is weighted down by an overabundance of spectacle and a disappointing lack of wit. A child from the planet Krypton is sent to Earth, where he’s raised by the Kent family. He learns to utilize his incredible abilities for good, and becomes Superman in the process, but eventually, the nefarious General Zod goes looking for him. The pundits say Man of Steel delivers plenty of muscular action, but it’s overlong and unfortunately short on character development. (Check out this week’s Total Recall for a rundown of Superman movies, as well as our interviews with the Man of Steel cast and crew.)

This Is the End


Take a bunch of well-known comic actors, stick them in the midst of the apocalypse, and mix liberally. That’s the basic recipe for This Is the End, which critics say is a rapid-fire, absurdist meta-comedy that’s raunchy and surprisingly heartfelt in equal measure. Playing themselves, James Franco, Seth Rogen, Jonah Hill, Craig Robinson and a few other famous pals are partying together when the Rapture hits Los Angeles. Our heroes embark on a cameo-laden quest for salvation, and learn the true meaning of friendship along the way. The pundits say the Certified Fresh This Is the End has so many gags that a few inevitably miss the mark, but for the most part, this is a smart, boundary-pushing comedy from an ensemble that seems to be enjoying every minute of it. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of actors playing themselves, as well as our interview with stars Rogen, Robinson, and Jay Baruchel.)

Before Midnight


In Before Sunrise, Jesse (Ethan Hawke) and Celine (Julie Delpy) were two young travelers who formed a bond after a chance meeting in Vienna. In Before Sunset, they were older, wiser, but no less enamored with one another. Now, in Before Midnight, they’re married and hoping to recapture the spark that first brought them together. The third installment in Richard Linklater‘s enduring love story goes wide this weekend, and critics say the Certified Fresh Before Midnight is as funny, insightful, and achingly poignant as its predecessors.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • More Than Honey, a doc about the relationship between people and bees, is at 100 percent.
  • Call Me Kuchu, a documentary about an openly gay man fighting persecution in Uganda, is at 95 percent.
  • 20 Feet From Stardom, a documentary tribute to some of rock’s finest backup singers, is at 94 percent.
  • In the Fog, a World War II drama about a Russian village that suspects one of its citizens is collaborating with the Nazis, is at 86 percent.
  • Far Out Isn’t Far Enough: The Tomi Ungerer Story, a documentary portrait of the influential illustrator, is at 80 percent.
  • Berberian Sound Studio, a psychological thriller about a sound technician who becomes unnerved while working on a gruesome horror movie, is at 78 percent.
  • Sofia Coppola‘s The Bling Ring, starring Emma Watson and Leslie Mann in the ripped-from-the-headlines tale of a group of teens who robbed various Hollywood stars, is at 63 percent.
  • Pandora’s Promise, a doc about the potential environmental benefits of nuclear power, is at 58 percent.
  • Hatchet III, the latest installment in the slasher series about a swamp-dwelling psycho, is at 56 percent.
  • Vehicle 19, starring Paul Walker in a thriller about an ex-con who becomes a target when he takes the wrong rental car is at 33 percent.
  • The Guillotines, a period action epic about a clandestine group of assassins who employ deadly metal blades, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

LGBTQ criterion Black History Month worst movies new york Comic Book Warner Bros. stand-up comedy YA Syfy Sci-Fi Crackle talk show Winter TV adaptation Winners The Witch a nightmare on elm street PBS Baby Yoda spanish language kids spinoff child's play DC streaming service indie BET elevated horror Adult Swim 2016 serial killer award winner festivals based on movie YouTube Red Teen Summer Comics on TV romantic comedy sitcom Fargo golden globes comic book movie cats Sneak Peek dramedy Polls and Games Superheroe discovery Chernobyl superman 73rd Emmy Awards richard e. Grant harry potter comic books comedies best 2015 Fantasy FOX GIFs Nickelodeon Paramount japanese french USA Network suspense nbcuniversal FXX japan cops rt labs critics edition Red Carpet Pacific Islander transformers Walt Disney Pictures Countdown all-time The CW book adaptation medical drama Anna Paquin Oscars VOD Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hollywood basketball Trailer Women's History Month teaser Nat Geo aapi VH1 Tomatazos Masterpiece mob Marvel Television spanish Cartoon Network joker Video Games screenings gangster Paramount Plus Lifetime Christmas movies BET Awards dogs royal family TV renewals PlayStation fast and furious olympics revenge blockbuster Hear Us Out Super Bowl Musicals spain foreign 2021 OneApp mutant sequel Photos SundanceTV 20th Century Fox sequels Reality Captain marvel police drama Turner Classic Movies Wes Anderson rotten movies we love Academy Awards Year in Review know your critic Rock scene in color nature Marvel movie hidden camera rt labs popular Turner Television Academy Spring TV El Rey period drama 21st Century Fox BBC strong female leads Disney films jurassic park 007 crossover TCA 2017 golden globe awards social media ghosts CMT science fiction Pop television video Awards Mary Poppins Returns spider-man Black Mirror cars anthology marvel comics posters DC Comics Broadway diversity cults south america Amazon Studios parents Musical comics NBA screen actors guild The Walking Dead video on demand DGA Exclusive Video New York Comic Con dreamworks X-Men History blaxploitation HFPA true crime hispanic TV movies Prime Video Amazon ID MTV Opinion Columbia Pictures children's TV green book psycho TruTV Apple italian Certified Fresh Comedy Central unscripted First Reviews Trivia canceled TV shows Starz DirecTV Holiday See It Skip It biography prank hispanic heritage month Amazon Prime series Disney Plus Tags: Comedy versus TCA Awards comic rom-coms Hulu Mystery miniseries Comedy IFC Films 2019 Star Trek cooking 79th Golden Globes Awards legend Pet Sematary rt archives 4/20 NBC football cancelled television Mary Tyler Moore crime A24 Pixar APB high school Instagram Live superhero Hallmark Christmas movies Mudbound natural history Sony Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus comiccon festival worst genre PaleyFest Music WarnerMedia Schedule Spike slashers scary reboot Pirates Comic-Con@Home 2021 Fox Searchlight Apple TV+ directors The Academy Stephen King Funimation Sundance 24 frames TV adventure marvel cinematic universe vampires Avengers TV Land pirates of the caribbean laika docudrama Calendar Showtime HBO Max Election emmy awards justice league disaster crime drama international Amazon Prime Video Rocky space Ovation Cosplay 1990s Pride Month 99% 90s Disney Channel classics Netflix Christmas movies dexter jamie lee curtis sag awards Film concert President kong werewolf Interview Shondaland Apple TV Plus doctor who 72 Emmy Awards boxoffice obituary action-comedy Drama ITV Biopics casting Emmy Nominations stoner GoT ABC Family cinemax cartoon The Purge Dark Horse Comics news HBO Go 2020 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt WGN 93rd Oscars A&E CNN Lucasfilm E3 Image Comics renewed TV shows Disney streaming service lord of the rings Watching Series Star Wars RT21 Endgame cancelled TV series SDCC Box Office target anime breaking bad cancelled TV shows streaming quibi latino Writers Guild of America Freeform YouTube Premium james bond hist dragons OWN Netflix Hallmark game show documentaries TNT ABC Signature CW Seed witnail halloween FX australia Valentine's Day asian-american docuseries leaderboard christmas movies Rom-Com toy story sports CBS All Access Britbox 45 CBS mcc Christmas robots indiana jones historical drama new zealand MSNBC Hollywood Foreign Press Association live action political drama Logo Food Network reviews Universal composers godzilla documentary 71st Emmy Awards Action live event Acorn TV Lifetime First Look die hard archives satire ABC universal monsters slasher Set visit game of thrones debate remakes zero dark thirty Shudder biopic comic book movies rotten Tokyo Olympics adenture crime thriller ratings zombie RT History Film Festival BBC America Cannes E! MCU Peacock Premiere Dates black comedy Awards Tour tv talk technology zombies king arthur young adult women deadpool Tarantino Western HBO war TIFF Ellie Kemper vs. Character Guide scorecard Extras Horror LGBT Country facebook Nominations singing competition Animation Mindy Kaling spy thriller batman toronto binge Marathons romance name the review Legendary TLC Mary poppins ESPN BBC One TBS DC Universe SXSW American Society of Cinematographers Epix Television Critics Association Marvel Studios Discovery Channel Toys Travel Channel trophy 2018 Tumblr independent spider-verse finale telelvision new star wars movies feel good Brie Larson black Superheroes streaming movies Song of Ice and Fire Elton John dceu cancelled Neflix critics dark Emmys Classic Film USA theme song The Arrangement Creative Arts Emmys psychological thriller Podcast Vudu critic resources Crunchyroll monster movies YouTube Fox News razzies heist movie TCA stop motion kaiju Heroines dc Esquire TCA Winter 2020 Arrowverse Lionsgate Pop TV Ghostbusters IMDb TV AMC twilight Infographic San Diego Comic-Con Binge Guide nfl blockbusters IFC Alien travel canceled TV One movies Bravo sopranos Martial Arts Universal Pictures free movies book scary movies franchise 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Family mockumentary trailers venice Spectrum Originals art house king kong Trophy Talk politics what to watch thriller aliens Quiz saw Best and Worst Fall TV Grammys AMC Plus Rocketman Tubi boxing National Geographic TCM 2017 Thanksgiving The Walt Disney Company supernatural Sundance Now animated Holidays Paramount Network BAFTA Reality Competition chucky VICE wonder woman GLAAD mission: impossible halloween tv Kids & Family FX on Hulu fresh Sundance TV ViacomCBS NYCC