Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dinner for Schmucks Serves Up An OK Time

Plus, Charlie St. Cloud and Cats and Dogs fail to wow the critics.

by | July 30, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a dinner party disaster (Dinner for Schmucks, starring Steve Carell and Paul Rudd), some after-death bonding (Charlie St. Cloud, starring Zac Efron and Kim Basinger), and a joint canine-feline mission (Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore, starring Chris O’Donnell and Jack McBrayer). What do the critics have to say?


Dinner for Schmucks

It’s not unusual for a remake to lose something in transition, and that’s the case with Dinner for Schmucks, an American take on the acid French farce The Dinner Game. Still, critics say even if this isn’t the most biting comedy, the inventiveness of Steve Carell and Paul Rudd make it consistently watchable and occasionally hilarious. Rudd stars as a guy struggling to get ahead at his company, until his boss invites him to a dinner party. One problem: the dinner is a competition, and he has to bring the biggest idiot he can find. So he brings Barry (Carell), a world class fool who also has a core of decency and some interesting talents. The pundits say Schmucks lacks the bite of the original, and often devolves into empte slapstick. However, it’s also got goofiness and absurdity to spare, and its performers are on top of their games. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Rudd’s best-reviewed movies.)


Charlie St. Cloud

Slowly but surely, Zac Efron is moving away from the teenybop material that made him a star. However, if his turn in last year’s Me and Orson Welles signaled a new maturity, the critics say the generic weepy Charlie St. Cloud is a big step backward. Efron stars as a young man overcome with grief at the death of his younger brother; soon however, he’s communicating with his sibling from the beyond. Will he stay true to the little guy even after meeting the girl of his dreams? The pundits say Charlie St. Cloud is a melodramatic mess, uneasily mixing romantic and supernatural elements with a bit too much schmaltz to resonate.


Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore

Nine years ago, Cats and Dogs was a surprise box office hit that generated some tepid but decent reviews. Not this time: critics say the sequel, subtitled The Revenge of Kitty Galore, is a dull satire of James Bond movies that’s unlikely to generate much enthusiasm among the kiddies in the audience. This time out, the cats and dogs join forces to defeat an evil plan by Kitty Galore, a rogue housecat bent on world domination. The pundits say this one’s a dog, with mediocre CGI effects, little storytelling to speak of, and an utter lack of originality.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Video Games south america Superheroe classics blaxploitation Paramount Network anthology 45 Drama TCM MGM Logo a nightmare on elm street casting festival MCU 2017 facebook Calendar latino legend Musical LGBTQ Writers Guild of America richard e. Grant Countdown scary movies The CW Thanksgiving robots HFPA BBC America TIFF AMC Plus suspense The Witch sag awards Pet Sematary Teen 94th Oscars Biopics serial killer streamig Emmys psycho Starz Family DGA Country halloween tv saw El Rey football President cinemax australia Disney marvel cinematic universe doctor who biography Comedy Central spider-verse Character Guide ID Prime Video Mudbound Geeked Week Sundance popular 2018 concert IMDb TV CBS All Access Peacock comic book movies Musicals spinoff Reality Competition 72 Emmy Awards Nat Geo TCA Discovery Channel FX on Hulu Holidays medical drama book adaptation Oscars Endgame zombie Best and Worst SundanceTV crime drama Black Mirror hispanic CBS sports LGBT Marvel Television Amazon dc Lionsgate HBO Go YouTube Red 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Television Critics Association The Academy video on demand cancelled TV series Amazon Prime golden globe awards Dark Horse Comics Tomatazos Cosplay japanese pirates of the caribbean Mindy Kaling TV movies golden globes 20th Century Fox Pop Comic-Con@Home 2021 SDCC Turner Classic Movies unscripted know your critic Tarantino streaming History basketball children's TV VOD NBC strong female leads Exclusive Video transformers NYCC toy story Interview kong action-comedy Marvel Studios genre Star Trek young adult ABC Pirates Sundance TV talk show Infographic ghosts Tags: Comedy Oscar discovery comedies Walt Disney Pictures criterion diversity black comedy cults best die hard Rocketman Winners science fiction new york Esquire Tubi Neflix revenge romance Rock spanish language zombies broadcast anime superman natural history BBC cancelled TV shows TV Land Comics on TV scene in color series 93rd Oscars news DC Comics italian Pop TV batman CMT Instagram Live Warner Bros. TV renewals Hollywood Foreign Press Association Chernobyl canceled TV shows laika Disney streaming service FXX Film Festival Indigenous RT History BAFTA Polls and Games royal family Crackle summer TV preview asian-american Film satire women PaleyFest festivals 24 frames name the review cancelled television psychological thriller olympics rt labs critics edition target Universal Pictures Hallmark Christmas movies Heroines feel good quibi Summer Kids & Family X-Men Elton John Awards binge Martial Arts stoner Pride Month BET Awards Trailer universal monsters game show Shudder rt archives 79th Golden Globes Awards Certified Fresh FOX reboot ESPN Hallmark Bravo comic books dark scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comiccon Epix child's play tv talk independent Pacific Islander A&E Apple TV Plus Nickelodeon new zealand Year in Review canceled crossover Rom-Com king arthur docudrama Grammys directors Showtime Fall TV Britbox Spectrum Originals prank Baby Yoda sopranos supernatural Lifetime Christmas movies critics Crunchyroll BET TCA Winter 2020 National Geographic 73rd Emmy Awards Photos Sony gangster ratings posters CW Seed Ellie Kemper hidden camera Holiday TruTV interviews Paramount Pictures nature Opinion Tumblr Red Carpet NBA cats werewolf New York Comic Con Sundance Now leaderboard Apple TV+ Food Network social media Fox Searchlight screenings kaiju Best Picture 1990s Arrowverse witnail wonder woman heist movie superhero FX The Purge Netflix Amazon Studios Emmy Nominations sequel Mystery politics political drama aliens toronto dreamworks Stephen King Paramount TLC war scary TV Television Academy breaking bad Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers scene in color film series GLAAD TCA 2017 spanish Premiere Dates archives Valentine's Day SXSW 007 Quiz true crime DC Universe cooking high school parents YA mutant Lucasfilm Best Actor Comedy Avengers Apple Best Actress rt labs spider-man debate reviews stand-up comedy Tokyo Olympics Focus Features new star wars movies Universal PBS scorecard worst movies Paramount Plus Fox News OneApp TCA Awards Nominations Comic Book all-time Super Bowl E3 vampires Academy Awards blockbuster Ghostbusters live event finale comics GoT Syfy Shondaland TNT twilight BBC One WarnerMedia Black History Month movie target scene in color international what to watch nfl Action adventure TV One Hulu Fantasy teaser romantic comedy streaming movies The Arrangement Mary poppins theme song HBO Max chucky comic book movie Mary Tyler Moore live action Sneak Peek Schedule spy thriller E! MSNBC Fargo PlayStation king kong mockumentary franchise 90s animated Rocky ITV 2015 godzilla Awards Tour Pixar Best Director indiana jones USA Network biopic Ovation hollywood Alien boxing aapi Mary Poppins Returns Adult Swim rom-coms sitcom documentaries documentary Spike Creative Arts Emmys nbcuniversal slashers Superheroes obi wan Western Star Wars Celebration black MTV telelvision rotten movies we love Captain marvel dogs Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dexter Horror 2016 screen actors guild The Walt Disney Company Lifetime comic ABC Family deadpool Vudu Spring TV Disney Channel The Walking Dead Classic Film A24 DC streaming service Hear Us Out Netflix Christmas movies razzies zero dark thirty Music thriller video Binge Guide mcc worst HBO historical drama Native game of thrones Song of Ice and Fire summer preview 2021 disaster OWN marvel comics Brie Larson See It Skip It trailers Marvel travel monster movies series Animation dragons slasher blockbusters Toys Disney+ Disney Plus Travel Channel Christmas Anna Paquin CNN ViacomCBS 4/20 technology Legendary RT21 Broadway lord of the rings movies Reality emmy awards foreign fresh cancelled Acorn TV 2019 71st Emmy Awards free movies Disney Plus mob critic resources summer TV mission: impossible book IFC Films Cannes based on movie adaptation Set visit jamie lee curtis art house renewed TV shows IFC 2020 Box Office versus Star Wars cars television WGN indie AMC jurassic park french halloween USA crime thriller police drama trophy boxoffice christmas movies cartoon green book Funimation SXSW 2022 Sony Pictures Winter TV Cartoon Network vs. james bond stop motion singing competition japan Image Comics ABC Signature Freeform First Reviews Watching Series Women's History Month VICE cops Turner joker dceu docuseries kids award winner Masterpiece space Trivia Wes Anderson YouTube Election miniseries First Look films hist Marathons Podcast sequels venice TBS DirecTV period drama composers remakes elevated horror fast and furious spain GIFs 21st Century Fox crime VH1 rotten Columbia Pictures YouTube Premium Sci-Fi Extras South by Southwest Film Festival dramedy San Diego Comic-Con harry potter hispanic heritage month 99% APB obituary justice league adenture Amazon Prime Video