Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dinner for Schmucks Serves Up An OK Time

Plus, Charlie St. Cloud and Cats and Dogs fail to wow the critics.

by | July 30, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a dinner party disaster (Dinner for Schmucks, starring Steve Carell and Paul Rudd), some after-death bonding (Charlie St. Cloud, starring Zac Efron and Kim Basinger), and a joint canine-feline mission (Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore, starring Chris O’Donnell and Jack McBrayer). What do the critics have to say?


Dinner for Schmucks

It’s not unusual for a remake to lose something in transition, and that’s the case with Dinner for Schmucks, an American take on the acid French farce The Dinner Game. Still, critics say even if this isn’t the most biting comedy, the inventiveness of Steve Carell and Paul Rudd make it consistently watchable and occasionally hilarious. Rudd stars as a guy struggling to get ahead at his company, until his boss invites him to a dinner party. One problem: the dinner is a competition, and he has to bring the biggest idiot he can find. So he brings Barry (Carell), a world class fool who also has a core of decency and some interesting talents. The pundits say Schmucks lacks the bite of the original, and often devolves into empte slapstick. However, it’s also got goofiness and absurdity to spare, and its performers are on top of their games. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Rudd’s best-reviewed movies.)


Charlie St. Cloud

Slowly but surely, Zac Efron is moving away from the teenybop material that made him a star. However, if his turn in last year’s Me and Orson Welles signaled a new maturity, the critics say the generic weepy Charlie St. Cloud is a big step backward. Efron stars as a young man overcome with grief at the death of his younger brother; soon however, he’s communicating with his sibling from the beyond. Will he stay true to the little guy even after meeting the girl of his dreams? The pundits say Charlie St. Cloud is a melodramatic mess, uneasily mixing romantic and supernatural elements with a bit too much schmaltz to resonate.


Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore

Nine years ago, Cats and Dogs was a surprise box office hit that generated some tepid but decent reviews. Not this time: critics say the sequel, subtitled The Revenge of Kitty Galore, is a dull satire of James Bond movies that’s unlikely to generate much enthusiasm among the kiddies in the audience. This time out, the cats and dogs join forces to defeat an evil plan by Kitty Galore, a rogue housecat bent on world domination. The pundits say this one’s a dog, with mediocre CGI effects, little storytelling to speak of, and an utter lack of originality.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Sci-Fi Marvel Studios Walt Disney Pictures marvel cinematic universe FOX HBO Max serial killer Western Freeform scary movies The CW streaming fresh christmas movies scorecard docuseries Infographic child's play 2021 movie streaming movies mcc cartoon History high school news legend emmy awards Adult Swim animated doctor who Set visit Ellie Kemper Watching Series video slashers Amazon new york deadpool The Arrangement Mary Poppins Returns anthology 72 Emmy Awards concert Red Carpet ratings Television Critics Association VOD canceled TV shows Spectrum Originals Rocky Calendar Masterpiece Pirates OWN unscripted Star Wars documentaries action-comedy cancelled TV series hispanic heritage month book heist movie Amazon Prime indie 73rd Emmy Awards Mary Tyler Moore crime thriller Hollywood Foreign Press Association Superheroes quibi scene in color Hallmark Grammys Tomatazos Sundance know your critic romantic comedy Premiere Dates hollywood foreign First Reviews ABC sequels Spring TV Tarantino independent aliens Black History Month GLAAD anime Television Academy 4/20 Alien series Trophy Talk CNN all-time ABC Signature docudrama PlayStation zombies Dark Horse Comics football Lifetime Christmas movies Exclusive Video nfl 007 Pop TV natural history The Walt Disney Company critics FXX TruTV elevated horror Prime Video theme song Columbia Pictures 79th Golden Globes Awards asian-american Trailer boxing composers comics Sundance Now Ovation Mindy Kaling Binge Guide BAFTA HFPA TV movies FX on Hulu Cannes boxoffice justice league classics Pop Winter TV Mudbound psycho USA comic jamie lee curtis Superheroe james bond sequel 2015 free movies Amazon Prime Video rt labs critics edition spider-verse Disney+ Disney Plus GIFs President Drama superman italian cancelled television Brie Larson disaster TCA 2017 wonder woman USA Network Comic Book Film Festival superhero black green book stoner game of thrones TCA Winter 2020 BBC One slasher blockbuster ViacomCBS blaxploitation franchise Image Comics thriller ID YA DC streaming service criterion sports book adaptation revenge olympics Hulu Universal Pictures vs. HBO Go Comics on TV Opinion 24 frames Hear Us Out Bravo The Academy HBO The Witch Crackle 99% Summer scary social media historical drama MSNBC Christmas canceled leaderboard Comedy Central Arrowverse Pet Sematary reboot Tumblr DGA japan new zealand DC Comics VH1 E! Schedule spanish language telelvision politics 71st Emmy Awards adenture Music Shudder television spider-man WGN MCU Tokyo Olympics sopranos National Geographic IMDb TV TV Extras Animation crossover Toys 20th Century Fox young adult films live event golden globes zombie Black Mirror TV renewals 45 diversity Avengers international Rocketman breaking bad Marathons pirates of the caribbean CW Seed Nickelodeon Neflix adaptation Netflix Christmas movies dceu Chernobyl New York Comic Con saw joker 90s comedies die hard Netflix gangster TCA Awards Film cinemax Sony Pictures E3 hispanic X-Men fast and furious AMC Plus technology biopic Ghostbusters rt archives dc sitcom Cosplay worst period drama DirecTV LGBTQ Tubi Marvel Holiday obituary crime Election parents comiccon aapi nature halloween Writers Guild of America Fall TV Hallmark Christmas movies hist Lucasfilm Disney Plus Shondaland The Walking Dead DC Universe Apple TV Plus hidden camera cops art house archives TCA Super Bowl science fiction cancelled Star Trek CBS All Access Cartoon Network The Purge comic book movie Photos renewed TV shows 2017 movies TIFF Legendary travel marvel comics reviews laika posters suspense Fox Searchlight supernatural rotten Starz Nominations VICE 21st Century Fox Logo Instagram Live south america stop motion binge jurassic park See It Skip It australia Tags: Comedy festivals Funimation Winners SXSW medical drama political drama japanese Baby Yoda versus Action CBS facebook Country ESPN 93rd Oscars Anna Paquin Warner Bros. Podcast spy thriller lord of the rings Amazon Studios target war prank A&E Disney Channel stand-up comedy Peacock comic book movies debate live action APB Turner Classic Movies video on demand cars Emmys 2016 Universal Paramount screenings directors TV Land dreamworks genre Vudu rt labs WarnerMedia spinoff TV One Awards Tour witnail true crime American Society of Cinematographers Quiz AMC psychological thriller dexter Classic Film CMT screen actors guild IFC Films chucky Pixar what to watch kong YouTube Premium Apple Video Games spanish trailers Creative Arts Emmys NBA cancelled TV shows Year in Review singing competition Awards ABC Family latino robots Best and Worst Holidays BET Awards Food Network dark BBC indiana jones golden globe awards batman satire documentary Elton John Crunchyroll Interview mutant Disney streaming service YouTube ghosts biography sag awards Women's History Month El Rey Wes Anderson Emmy Nominations TBS Family NBC razzies RT History women Stephen King First Look miniseries dramedy mission: impossible a nightmare on elm street Horror rom-coms talk show Acorn TV discovery dogs Musicals cooking mob Comedy feel good PBS Character Guide zero dark thirty Travel Channel cats police drama Reality Competition Rock universal monsters game show Showtime A24 Esquire MTV Apple TV+ Oscars worst movies Academy Awards twilight 2018 2019 vampires Fantasy Sneak Peek San Diego Comic-Con Disney rotten movies we love popular Countdown harry potter space adventure nbcuniversal Pacific Islander RT21 romance Certified Fresh monster movies Paramount Plus Turner halloween tv ITV Syfy critic resources Heroines name the review Teen Martial Arts toy story remakes Trivia basketball kaiju based on movie LGBT Broadway Mary poppins Polls and Games Discovery Channel Pride Month werewolf mockumentary award winner transformers IFC Spike OneApp best Song of Ice and Fire Endgame Musical godzilla Valentine's Day comic books Fargo king arthur 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BBC America richard e. Grant Rom-Com 1990s SundanceTV kids Lifetime Paramount Network tv talk crime drama Mystery Marvel Television GoT Box Office SDCC teaser black comedy Reality Nat Geo Fox News dragons toronto TCM PaleyFest Comic-Con@Home 2021 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina children's TV BET cults trophy finale Thanksgiving Kids & Family french NYCC new star wars movies TLC venice blockbusters casting Lionsgate king kong 2020 TNT festival FX Biopics Sundance TV Captain marvel Britbox strong female leads Epix spain YouTube Red royal family