Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Carrie Won't Replace the Original

Plus, Escape Plan and The Fifth Estate are both uneven.

by | October 17, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a telekinetic teen (Carrie, starring Chloe Grace Moretz and Julianne Moore); a pair of jail-breakers (Escape Plan, starring Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger); and a document leaker (The Fifth Estate, starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Daniel Brühl). What do the critics have to say?



Carrie

50%

The original Carrie holds a special place in the hearts of horror buffs, so a remake is inherently fraught with peril. And critics say that while director Kimberly Peirce turns in a respectable effort, there’s little in this new Carrie that feels necessary. Chloe Grace Moretz stars as the title character, a teenage outcast with a demanding mom and telekinetic powers. Will the snobby kids at Carrie’s school learn not to mess with her? The pundits say Carrie is competently made, but does little to distinguish itself from Brian De Palma’s beloved original film. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some memorable horror movie remakes.)



Escape Plan

50%

God bless Sly and Arnie; it’s pretty inspiring to see the 1980s’ two biggest action stars still slugging it out well into their sixties. That said, critics feel Escape Plan isn’t the best vehicle for their talents; despite a few decent thrills, it’s a middling action flick with a flimsy plot and an overall lack of panache. Stallone stars as a security expert who’s been wrongly imprisoned, so he teams up with a fellow inmate (Schwarzenegger) and devises a plan to bust out. The pundits say the stars keep Escape Plan watchable, but they’re ultimately defeated by inert pacing and a by-the-numbers script.



The Fifth Estate

35%

Like The Social Network, The Fifth Estate is a ripped-from-the-headlines drama about how new technology is impacting our lives. Unfortunately, critics say that despite an impressive performance from Benedict Cumberbatch, this dramatic retelling of the WikiLeaks story is ill-prepared to tackle the issues it raises. Julian Assange (Cumberbatch) and hacker Daniel Domscheit-Berg (Daniel Brühl) create a site to publish clandestine information. However, when WikiLeaks scores a series of big scoops that infuriate the powerful, the site’s founders become divided on their mission and motives. The pundits say The Fifth Estate is a mostly skin-deep examination of the ethical questions that Assange raised, one that fails to bring its characters to life, despite the best efforts of a strong cast.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

YA dragons CNN First Look Chernobyl psycho Song of Ice and Fire streaming mission: impossible Country Stephen King Film Festival teaser medical drama Mindy Kaling mockumentary Image Comics IFC Films Cartoon Network Pixar remakes dceu crime thriller LGBT Rocky Election talk show Summer A24 criterion Countdown jurassic park book breaking bad Mystery DC streaming service versus aapi Family Amazon Prime Broadway WarnerMedia BET Awards USA Network Oscars Extras 24 frames new zealand festivals films fast and furious scene in color french crime drama Lucasfilm 2015 king kong E3 Marvel Music concert kids Interview Spring TV sports Year in Review Esquire HBO Go LGBTQ documentaries children's TV NBC Rocketman toronto Television Academy adventure 72 Emmy Awards comics Mary Tyler Moore reboot all-time halloween tv 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards festival nbcuniversal Star Trek Disney streaming service President Awards Tour singing competition latino telelvision PlayStation binge hidden camera ViacomCBS international video cults docuseries See It Skip It true crime Mary poppins golden globe awards DirecTV GLAAD Warner Bros. blaxploitation Rock black Pop TV sitcom screenings Red Carpet YouTube Premium screen actors guild south america Grammys OneApp San Diego Comic-Con golden globes spy thriller stop motion rotten Epix zombies Shondaland Christmas women Columbia Pictures 2021 rotten movies we love independent VH1 sag awards Vudu FOX batman MTV Comic Book CMT Hallmark finale DGA spider-man lord of the rings Certified Fresh ABC Signature The Walt Disney Company robots hist facebook Valentine's Day richard e. Grant worst movies social media tv talk Turner Classic Movies new york superman BBC America Elton John comic books 4/20 Tubi anime Amazon Prime Video Heroines APB Netflix Christmas movies Netflix PBS directors Action Showtime movie TV renewals romantic comedy Apple TV Plus documentary 2016 strong female leads new star wars movies Tarantino quibi Best and Worst biography transformers police drama jamie lee curtis 20th Century Fox SDCC slashers justice league Fox Searchlight obituary GIFs casting christmas movies Sundance TV HBO Max razzies space universal monsters Lifetime Christmas movies dark Reality Competition Reality animated Lifetime Photos ABC high school Crackle indie blockbuster TV One Infographic TV Land crime Paramount Network Comedy Nominations Writers Guild of America Paramount Plus rt archives Emmy Nominations Discovery Channel Hear Us Out ghosts Freeform cats archives TCA Winter 2020 Video Games BAFTA Lionsgate dogs cancelled TV series Funimation Emmys asian-american Holidays laika Schedule TIFF television worst Turner reviews australia Britbox 71st Emmy Awards Western Calendar FX best Sony Pictures Acorn TV italian Exclusive Video Rom-Com adaptation stoner critics The Purge rom-coms halloween deadpool marvel cinematic universe 99% Food Network CW Seed war Disney Plus Creative Arts Emmys Brie Larson fresh sequels doctor who Opinion comedies green book NYCC psychological thriller Star Wars dramedy Nickelodeon hollywood kaiju werewolf news emmy awards target 2020 2017 Awards ABC Family elevated horror boxoffice Trophy Talk spain mutant HBO romance anthology Disney Channel zero dark thirty canceled TV shows RT21 know your critic blockbusters Super Bowl IFC live action El Rey Paramount TLC Syfy AMC Watching Series YouTube Red popular Tumblr award winner Mary Poppins Returns kong ratings video on demand toy story Fox News Toys TCM Pacific Islander historical drama Comics on TV Arrowverse Superheroes free movies Teen classics GoT Disney+ Disney Plus supernatural parents Sci-Fi Sundance heist movie FXX TCA Awards 93rd Oscars 2019 Box Office TCA 2017 spinoff Kids & Family 45 what to watch satire cancelled television comiccon Pride Month Television Critics Association Spectrum Originals YouTube Martial Arts boxing cooking superhero renewed TV shows period drama Musical chucky Logo Animation SXSW Crunchyroll Baby Yoda scary movies series Marvel Studios scorecard Spike Women's History Month Mudbound SundanceTV American Society of Cinematographers Walt Disney Pictures Film die hard BET The Academy spanish language aliens Sneak Peek Drama MCU ESPN theme song The Witch book adaptation Fall TV Academy Awards science fiction Pop History comic Classic Film Endgame 21st Century Fox Bravo name the review Apple TV+ foreign venice The Walking Dead prank TV movies monster movies BBC Universal saw nature Apple Black Mirror cinemax football docudrama RT History Ghostbusters PaleyFest movies twilight CBS VICE composers disaster Thanksgiving political drama Pet Sematary Avengers Hulu cars Marathons X-Men 2018 OWN VOD trailers Alien serial killer Dark Horse Comics Winter TV Cosplay joker Nat Geo miniseries Comedy Central Marvel Television ID Winners Hallmark Christmas movies The CW japanese Character Guide sequel TCA New York Comic Con Captain marvel Quiz Ovation dc Tomatazos A&E Podcast First Reviews cops politics CBS All Access DC Universe Cannes Polls and Games 007 Trivia TV Pirates Horror Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TNT Superheroe MSNBC Set visit Trailer TruTV cancelled Legendary streaming movies harry potter travel Travel Channel diversity stand-up comedy revenge Amazon Studios Shudder canceled based on movie franchise spanish game show a nightmare on elm street Anna Paquin Peacock The Arrangement BBC One Musicals Premiere Dates E! TBS child's play cancelled TV shows thriller nfl USA james bond National Geographic vampires Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Biopics technology Ellie Kemper Holiday Binge Guide FX on Hulu Amazon natural history crossover godzilla indiana jones Disney ITV WGN Adult Swim Fantasy Sundance Now Black History Month game of thrones Masterpiece cartoon Starz hispanic unscripted discovery zombie pirates of the caribbean DC Comics witnail