Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Carrie Won't Replace the Original

Plus, Escape Plan and The Fifth Estate are both uneven.

by | October 17, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a telekinetic teen (Carrie, starring Chloe Grace Moretz and Julianne Moore); a pair of jail-breakers (Escape Plan, starring Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger); and a document leaker (The Fifth Estate, starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Daniel Brühl). What do the critics have to say?



The original Carrie holds a special place in the hearts of horror buffs, so a remake is inherently fraught with peril. And critics say that while director Kimberly Peirce turns in a respectable effort, there’s little in this new Carrie that feels necessary. Chloe Grace Moretz stars as the title character, a teenage outcast with a demanding mom and telekinetic powers. Will the snobby kids at Carrie’s school learn not to mess with her? The pundits say Carrie is competently made, but does little to distinguish itself from Brian De Palma’s beloved original film. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some memorable horror movie remakes.)

Escape Plan


God bless Sly and Arnie; it’s pretty inspiring to see the 1980s’ two biggest action stars still slugging it out well into their sixties. That said, critics feel Escape Plan isn’t the best vehicle for their talents; despite a few decent thrills, it’s a middling action flick with a flimsy plot and an overall lack of panache. Stallone stars as a security expert who’s been wrongly imprisoned, so he teams up with a fellow inmate (Schwarzenegger) and devises a plan to bust out. The pundits say the stars keep Escape Plan watchable, but they’re ultimately defeated by inert pacing and a by-the-numbers script.

The Fifth Estate


Like The Social Network, The Fifth Estate is a ripped-from-the-headlines drama about how new technology is impacting our lives. Unfortunately, critics say that despite an impressive performance from Benedict Cumberbatch, this dramatic retelling of the WikiLeaks story is ill-prepared to tackle the issues it raises. Julian Assange (Cumberbatch) and hacker Daniel Domscheit-Berg (Daniel Brühl) create a site to publish clandestine information. However, when WikiLeaks scores a series of big scoops that infuriate the powerful, the site’s founders become divided on their mission and motives. The pundits say The Fifth Estate is a mostly skin-deep examination of the ethical questions that Assange raised, one that fails to bring its characters to life, despite the best efforts of a strong cast.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

toy story what to watch Set visit award winner Shondaland supernatural Grammys science fiction vampires See It Skip It YouTube Premium casting Nat Geo crossover Showtime natural history Oscars Disney TNT 2019 police drama anime El Rey IFC Films Rock Lucasfilm ABC Heroines Epix romance TruTV YA crime thriller justice league Women's History Month Esquire LGBT Hulu Emmys Sci-Fi Polls and Games zero dark thirty serial killer crime drama Winners DirecTV Country Animation doctor who Extras sports Musicals cinemax FXX Writers Guild of America Quiz Comedy docudrama USA Martial Arts History Starz ratings 2017 Freeform Britbox Reality Fall TV Summer zombie Comedy Central Acorn TV SDCC cops GLAAD Mudbound theme song psycho true crime Pop Crackle Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ITV Apple BBC America CBS All Access Ellie Kemper crime Rom-Com Valentine's Day Character Guide FOX historical drama comic dramedy 2016 GoT TCM boxoffice Star Trek Nominations sequel 21st Century Fox Ghostbusters talk show Disney Channel politics war Fox News spider-man GIFs President Emmy Nominations Horror Star Wars Black Mirror unscripted cults Reality Competition DC Universe The Arrangement Tarantino National Geographic Chernobyl E3 Lifetime strong female leads Sneak Peek miniseries Year in Review spy thriller travel Box Office Holidays Spike cats comiccon New York Comic Con APB aliens ESPN Mystery Schedule DC streaming service Best and Worst Superheroe anthology A&E Elton John Comic Book CNN robots Pride Month Ovation TBS Brie Larson Awards Paramount Network Thanksgiving CBS Walt Disney Pictures cooking Western Election Teen Shudder Musical RT21 Certified Fresh NBC Biopics Toys Bravo festivals Universal dceu American Society of Cinematographers harry potter Amazon YouTube Red Opinion Trophy Talk mutant Interview disaster Trivia binge ABC Family MCU BET Captain marvel 45 TLC VICE Christmas Video Games SXSW Creative Arts Emmys discovery Columbia Pictures 24 frames Trailer adaptation Watching Series nature space Food Network political drama FX 007 thriller Tumblr Logo CW Seed Pirates 2015 Action LGBTQ biography Comics on TV Adult Swim Marathons Winter TV Super Bowl TCA 2017 Cartoon Network Sony Pictures WGN Podcast period drama Lionsgate Song of Ice and Fire E! 2018 Kids & Family animated witnail Amazon Prime Cannes golden globes medical drama TV Land Tomatazos PaleyFest Masterpiece hist Film Festival game show X-Men TV finale Marvel Spectrum Originals Rocky dc Calendar dragons sitcom Infographic SundanceTV Netflix Dark Horse Comics TCA CMT richard e. Grant based on movie jamie lee curtis Nickelodeon adventure HBO The Witch DC Comics PBS Mary Tyler Moore Syfy TIFF RT History Countdown Drama VH1 transformers social media 20th Century Fox IFC Superheroes Mindy Kaling NYCC Sundance Now OWN technology Red Carpet mockumentary Fantasy composers Photos MTV facebook Pet Sematary Rocketman USA Network Anna Paquin San Diego Comic-Con Vudu DGA Music Mary Poppins Returns singing competition Premiere Dates Mary poppins teaser Stephen King Pixar AMC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cosplay Warner Bros. Awards Tour blaxploitation First Look television Paramount Spring TV elevated horror spinoff psychological thriller diversity zombies MSNBC The CW green book BBC streaming Sundance