Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Arthur Is On The Rocks

Plus, Hanna is Certified Fresh, while Your Highness and Soul Surfer miss the mark.

by | April 8, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an eccentric imbiber (Arthur, starring Russell Brand and Greta Gerwig); medieval mischief (Your Highness, starring James Franco and Natalie Portman); a teenage assassin (Hanna, starring Saoirse Ronan and Eric Bana); and a surfing survivor (Soul Surfer, starring AnnaSophia Robb and Dennis Quaid). What do the critics have to say?



I know it’s crazy, but it’s true: if you get caught between the moon and New York City, critics say you can probably do better than this remake of Arthur, which lacks the charm and wit of the 1981 original. Stepping into the shoes of the late Dudley Moore, Russell Brand stars as the whimsical, heavy-drinking hedonist whose irresponsible pursuit of pleasure threatens the good name of his staid family’s foundation. Arthur is told that he’s obligated to marry a woman he doesn’t particularly like (Jennifer Garner) or lose his inheritance — which is a problem, because he’s just fallen in love with a fellow free spirit (Greta Gerwig). The pundits say that Arthur has some decent gags and a nice supporting turn from the always-stellar Helen Mirren, but it mostly feels like an uninspired cover version of the original, and its protagonist — a frivolous rich guy with a drinking problem — seems a little outdated in our current economic climate.

Your Highness


Theoretically, Your Highness has a lot going for it: a couple of big stars (James Franco, Natalie Portman), an undeniably talented director (the onetime indie darling David Gordon Green), and a reasonably funny premise (medieval swashbuckling mixed with goofy, bawdy yuks). Unfortunately, the critics say the whole of Your Highness is hardly the sum of its parts; it’s a crass, undisciplined lark that gives the impression that its makers decided to film every wacky idea they came up with after a long night hitting the bong. Franco and Danny McBride star as a pair of hapless princes who go on a journey to rescue Franco’s kidnapped fiancée; soon, they’re joined in their quest by a mysterious warrior woman (Portman), who helps them vanquish all sorts of evil monsters. The pundits say Your Highness is a seriously weird movie, and while its sophomoric smuttiness is good for some occasional chuckles, it gets old pretty quickly. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Franco’s best-reviewed movies.)



Director Joe Wright made his name with a pair visually striking, widely-praised period romances (Pride and Prejudice and Atonement), so it’s understandable that he’d want to branch out. The result is the action-packed, skillfully crafted Hanna, which critics say is a film so energetic and dreamy that its lapses are largely forgiven. Saoirse Ronan stars as the title character, a 16-year-old whose father (Eric Bana) raised her in seclusion and taught her to become a soldier and a spy. But the real world is a scary place, and soon Hanna is on the run from the CIA and Cate Blanchett, who may have knowledge of the dark secrets in Hanna’s family’s past. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Hanna is a sleekly stylish mix of fairytales and espionage thrillers, featuring a remarkable performance from Ronan and enough mystery and depth to help you ignore the fact that the plot is mostly ludicrous.

Soul Surfer


Bethany Hamilton’s life is so remarkable that no work of fiction could do it justice: as a teenager, she was attacked by a shark while surfing and lost an arm, but she persevered and now surfs professionally. Unfortunately, Hollywood has a way of turning even the most incredible stories into feel-good blandness, and critics say that’s the problem with Soul Surfer, a well-crafted film that can’t rise above its melodramatic trappings. AnnaSophia Robb stars as Hamilton, a deeply religious surfing prodigy whose life is changed forever after a near fatal shark attack. However, you can’t keep a good girl down, and spurned on by loving parents and her faith in God, Hamilton works tirelessly to get back on the board. The pundits say Soul Surfer‘s action scenes are remarkable, but the film follows the inspirational movie playback too closely, and softpeddles both Hamilton’s Christianity and her painful struggles in an attempt to broaden its appeal.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

book dceu Star Wars FOX Logo DC Comics Fall TV 2015 doctor who Masterpiece cars San Diego Comic-Con Lionsgate halloween jamie lee curtis parents crime thriller Country MSNBC crime documentaries IFC Marathons breaking bad Pop TV TV renewals hispanic CBS All Access 72 Emmy Awards casting WarnerMedia Animation transformers Opinion PlayStation sitcom ghosts foreign RT21 game show Disney+ Disney Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Premiere Dates halloween tv indie Countdown historical drama Adult Swim Toys emmy awards Sneak Peek Super Bowl ESPN vampires Teen TCA Awards rotten movies we love justice league obituary children's TV TIFF dark Family TCA 2017 south america harry potter australia child's play Showtime HBO Max FX documentary festival Mudbound batman Bravo Disney streaming service cancelled TV series DC Universe Apple TV Plus werewolf 21st Century Fox BAFTA blaxploitation Photos Comedy Central APB docudrama Starz FXX football movies indiana jones Pirates BBC One news First Reviews tv talk ABC sequels TNT politics Reality Competition Warner Bros. Grammys chucky spanish kids Nat Geo strong female leads psychological thriller Apple TV+ adventure elevated horror mockumentary Horror crime drama Winter TV toy story VH1 Amazon Prime Video Interview singing competition Avengers true crime Trophy Talk Trivia Chernobyl Endgame Musical Mary Poppins Returns video witnail political drama anime Polls and Games Spectrum Originals canceled Disney cancelled TV shows all-time talk show Sci-Fi Emmys Hallmark Christmas movies aliens scary movies PBS American Society of Cinematographers Heroines Academy Awards X-Men Walt Disney Pictures Discovery Channel Best and Worst Shondaland Rocketman First Look adaptation romance Amazon Studios Syfy die hard latino hollywood TruTV Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Thanksgiving space OWN Reality robots Mindy Kaling MCU comics DGA nature CMT free movies Britbox Holidays A24 007 thriller Character Guide LGBTQ Awards Tour MTV renewed TV shows National Geographic archives crossover universal monsters The Academy Comic Book Christmas Sundance TV boxoffice Rocky Mystery reviews binge Film Superheroe deadpool Arrowverse Alien james bond 71st Emmy Awards TV Land sports Superheroes fast and furious Marvel Studios ratings Television Critics Association cancelled versus Sundance 24 frames YA Columbia Pictures cops comic books Turner mission: impossible Mary Tyler Moore Infographic GoT screenings cinemax Crunchyroll Valentine's Day cats Universal Brie Larson ID toronto DC streaming service Black History Month Trailer Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt slashers satire Television Academy superhero TLC Schedule Tubi Drama movie Ghostbusters Pride Month El Rey japanese USA Extras Stephen King spanish language Epix black hist Funimation Video Games NYCC SDCC Black Mirror films name the review Dark Horse Comics asian-american Election sequel Peacock comic disaster boxing FX on Hulu Cannes revenge Certified Fresh E3 Pixar unscripted Ovation animated worst movies A&E comiccon Kids & Family twilight Food Network anthology TCM Acorn TV concert comedies Quiz 2017 what to watch SXSW BET TCA Turner Classic Movies serial killer screen actors guild Song of Ice and Fire directors BBC Holiday period drama Watching Series Paramount Box Office Paramount Network LGBT Ellie Kemper quibi YouTube Red Disney Channel Disney Plus 2020 See It Skip It Podcast CBS spain zero dark thirty E! medical drama cooking Elton John Binge Guide Apple miniseries Cosplay TBS remakes 4/20 based on movie Summer Pet Sematary Comics on TV Biopics Mary poppins History The CW Hear Us Out discovery supernatural green book venice PaleyFest cults YouTube Premium dc Women's History Month Sundance Now stoner Marvel dogs CNN Netflix Christmas movies New York Comic Con Nickelodeon The Witch Captain marvel Marvel Television RT History Hulu rotten criterion WGN HBO laika Rock The Walking Dead Hallmark Tomatazos Emmy Nominations BET Awards Crackle a nightmare on elm street independent Travel Channel game of thrones Esquire Lifetime Christmas movies Lifetime Fox Searchlight reboot Writers Guild of America Red Carpet stop motion composers Fox News scorecard travel HBO Go science fiction GIFs natural history streaming Shudder OneApp Anna Paquin Vudu Oscars facebook social media christmas movies TV DirecTV spy thriller television Freeform police drama ABC Family Martial Arts war IFC Films Spring TV cancelled television spider-man BBC America video on demand teaser 2019 fresh festivals Winners Creative Arts Emmys technology Awards dramedy zombie french psycho cartoon President Set visit Nominations GLAAD Music ITV series CW Seed Musicals stand-up comedy NBC biography Calendar USA Network critics Year in Review Star Trek Classic Film 45 theme song Sony Pictures SundanceTV Fantasy classics VICE Amazon Baby Yoda Lucasfilm diversity richard e. Grant 20th Century Fox AMC dragons TCA Winter 2020 rt archives award winner 2018 Spike franchise spinoff Tumblr finale Action zombies 99% golden globes romantic comedy joker Western nbcuniversal The Arrangement YouTube worst nfl mutant Rom-Com 2016 best Netflix VOD Comedy Pop blockbuster sag awards The Purge italian canceled TV shows Tarantino Film Festival