Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "SOAP," "Material Girls" Not Screened; "Accepted" Denied; "Sunshine" Shines

by | August 17, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got snakes…. on a plane ("Snakes on a Plane," starring Samuel L. Jackson), slackers on a campus ("Accepted," starring Justin Long), and Duffs on the screen ("Material Girls," starring Hilary and Haylie Duff). What do the critics have to say?

"Snakes on a Plane," the movie with the greatest title since "Dude, Where’s My Car?", has captured the imagination of the blogosphere. However, it will have to wait to capture the imagination of the critics, since it wasn’t screened in advance. The plot involves an FBI agent (Samuel L. Jackson) who, golly, would really like to expel those ophidians from the aircraft upon which he’s traveling. Since "SOAP" (as the fanboys and girls call it) has no reviews, we’re going to play our favorite game: Guess the @#&$*$ Tomatometer.

Contrary to the wishes of Samuel L. Jackson, these guys are putting the snakes on the @#&$*$ plane.

There’s something inherently appealing about a bunch of party-hearty students and their battles with the uptight squares; that’s why movie people keep trying to recapture the magic of "Animal House" and "Rock ‘n’ Roll High School." "Accepted" tells the story of a high school graduate (Justin Long) who’s having no luck getting into college, so he decides to start his own fake institute of higher learning. To his surprise, a bunch of like-minded outcasts join him. Critics say the movie has its share of laughs, but it never totally gels, and turns a little too sweet at the end. At 31 percent on the Tomatometer, "Accepted" has been waitlisted.

"Accepted": In culinary class, these guys are preparing an official South Harmon Institute of Technology sandwich.

Critics can beg, and critics can plead, but they can’t see "Material Girls" (that’s right!), ’cause the audience members with the cold hard cash are always Mr. (and Ms.) Right. Or, perhaps the people behind the latest Duff sisters vehicle feel the film is in the same artistic league as Madge‘s "Body of Evidence." Guess this Tomatometer while you’re at it.

The Duff sisters flee in anguish after their unsuccessful auditions for "Hulk 2"

"Little Miss Sunshine" was a big hit at this year’s Sundance Film Festival, and now that it’s hitting the theaters, the scribes are just as enthusiastic as the folks in Park City. This tale of a dysfunctional family hitting the road for a child pageant is Certified Fresh, and features sharp performances from its ensemble cast, particularly Greg Kinnear and Steve Carell. At 94 percent, this one’s a ray of "Sunshine." (Check out RT’s interview with co-directors Valerie Faris and Jonathan Dayton here.)

Also in theaters in limited release this week: "Factotum," the Sundance-approved Bukowski adaptation starring Matt Dillon and Lili Taylor, is at 75 percent; "The Illusionist," a tale of intrigue in turn of the century Vienna starring Ed Norton, Jessica Biel, and Paul Giamatti, is at 67 percent; Dutch import "Moonlight," a tale of risky teenage love, is at 60 percent; "Trust the Man," a rom-com starring David Duchovny and Julianne Moore, is at 39 percent; and "10th & Wolf," a story of mob family ties starring James Marsden and Giovanni Ribisi, is at zero percent.

Finally, props to XeternityX, who came closest to predicting "Pulse"’s 12 percent Tomatometer. Nobody got particularly close to "Zoom," still flying high at zero percent. Be forwarned when guessing the Tomatometers for this week’s unscreened releases: the average T-meter for movies not screened for critics is 11.75 percent.

Recent Samuel L. Jackson Movies:
25% — Freedomland (2005)
13% — The Man (2005)
82% — Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith (2005)
18% — XXX: State of the Union (2005)
23% — In My Country (2005)

Recent Hilary Duff Movies:
7% — Cheaper by the Dozen 2 (2005)
6% — The Perfect Man (2005)
15% — Raise Your Voice (2004)
11% — A Cinderella Story (2004)
24% — Cheaper by the Dozen (2003)

Tag Cloud

Awards Tour Calendar GoT cars ratings scary movies mockumentary Stephen King james bond Baby Yoda Trophy Talk Classic Film women 2020 trailers CW Seed Peacock sports Holidays Country Brie Larson RT History french cancelled stoner Film witnail VH1 Cartoon Network Pet Sematary First Look Disney Tumblr Opinion TCA 2017 Binge Guide Infographic laika Sundance TV name the review critics National Geographic American Society of Cinematographers AMC Music Ghostbusters Drama HBO USA Network Pixar dogs Tomatazos TIFF Adult Swim Character Guide dc Mary poppins directors NBC Trivia Lionsgate YouTube Red vampires crime Television Academy boxing MCU BBC America facebook composers OneApp Oscars hispanic festival APB The Walt Disney Company Rocky Netflix Christmas movies Hear Us Out Valentine's Day Nat Geo tv talk Pirates renewed TV shows TCA Winter 2020 2019 HBO Max Captain marvel video CNN Comic Book Ovation comics 24 frames green book TV One Disney+ Disney Plus BET Awards game show festivals true crime cancelled TV series serial killer sitcom mutant technology social media The Academy Acorn TV Set visit zombies video on demand Watching Series Rocketman obituary Box Office FOX cults venice cancelled television satire movie dragons worst Vudu biography remakes teaser Avengers sequels Television Critics Association 72 Emmy Awards Biopics Podcast comedies Awards E! A&E Grammys Thanksgiving richard e. Grant USA CBS All Access Super Bowl children's TV Cosplay cats LGBT Marvel Studios The CW Mary Poppins Returns History Certified Fresh golden globe awards universal monsters Pride Month zero dark thirty emmy awards Columbia Pictures cooking YA Countdown stand-up comedy strong female leads SundanceTV Crackle Reality Competition Spectrum Originals Marathons justice league Musical comiccon YouTube Premium disaster Quiz Hallmark jurassic park Britbox Video Games golden globes Pop TV Walt Disney Pictures Dark Horse Comics spanish language Paramount Plus japanese news Amazon Studios Fox Searchlight TLC blaxploitation GLAAD crime thriller stop motion Lifetime Christmas movies screenings Fantasy slashers asian-american comic books NYCC halloween tv 2018 CBS Year in Review Apple TV+ TCM Superheroes Summer Best and Worst Universal Anna Paquin toronto twilight miniseries spinoff die hard batman Shondaland VICE PlayStation Amazon Prime deadpool sag awards nfl psychological thriller war police drama Kids & Family MTV psycho Heroines spanish Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Endgame romance robots Mindy Kaling Writers Guild of America The Purge E3 Marvel Academy Awards Reality First Reviews game of thrones The Walking Dead 2015 theme song child's play Travel Channel Comics on TV Hulu reboot reviews Funimation revenge Chernobyl 2016 DC Comics TCA Awards VOD ABC Family Crunchyroll anime finale 007 Sony Pictures a nightmare on elm street best dramedy Netflix Star Wars boxoffice cinemax Amazon Prime Video science fiction Pop President TCA book Lifetime Trailer Red Carpet cartoon documentary series Discovery Channel IFC A24 PaleyFest dceu San Diego Comic-Con zombie Nickelodeon DC streaming service Sci-Fi Syfy Holiday Masterpiece Black Mirror Action unscripted MSNBC joker Elton John X-Men nature BET RT21 IFC Films FX on Hulu fast and furious space Extras canceled TV shows Star Trek rom-coms BBC nbcuniversal PBS archives blockbuster Marvel Television black mission: impossible Creative Arts Emmys romantic comedy spain franchise australia Comedy sequel aliens ID breaking bad Emmys 71st Emmy Awards talk show binge Christmas Bravo all-time ghosts south america transformers chucky based on movie TV Land 21st Century Fox thriller 99% Sundance Now superhero Tubi docudrama Disney streaming service cancelled TV shows spider-man Winners Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Amazon hollywood historical drama Cannes BBC One Animation natural history elevated horror FXX YouTube Film Festival rt archives crossover Showtime DGA documentaries Disney Plus Polls and Games Disney Channel Nominations TV renewals FX rotten movies we love Ellie Kemper toy story pirates of the caribbean Schedule spy thriller DirecTV New York Comic Con parents supernatural fresh WGN CMT Women's History Month films See It Skip It Alien HBO Go Logo casting comic what to watch television adventure independent streaming Premiere Dates Toys Superheroe 4/20 canceled medical drama anthology Paramount ITV Arrowverse Apple TV Plus Starz OWN ABC Signature Apple Turner El Rey Horror award winner Teen The Arrangement Fox News Paramount Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards discovery indiana jones Mary Tyler Moore TV GIFs ABC Photos christmas movies Emmy Nominations diversity crime drama movies hist animated italian cops versus quibi SDCC period drama Lucasfilm ESPN classics 45 TBS scorecard Turner Classic Movies Rom-Com harry potter Hallmark Christmas movies WarnerMedia Family latino Esquire Comedy Central Shudder kids LGBTQ Spring TV travel werewolf BAFTA Black History Month 2017 rotten Interview halloween Winter TV jamie lee curtis worst movies Western Spike singing competition Sneak Peek Mudbound concert foreign indie doctor who DC Universe free movies Food Network TNT The Witch TruTV ViacomCBS Musicals Song of Ice and Fire screen actors guild football Freeform 20th Century Fox Fall TV Mystery dark Election Warner Bros. adaptation criterion Epix politics Tarantino SXSW Rock Martial Arts political drama Sundance