Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Norbit" Is Flabby; "Hannibal Rising" Isn't That Tasty

by | February 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a nerd with an overbearing fiancée ("Norbit," starring Eddie Murphy) and the early days of Hannibal Lecter ("Hannibal Rising," starring Gaspard Ulliel and Gong Li). What do the critics have to say?

Eddie Murphy’s searing, Oscar-nominated performance as a James Brown-esque soul singer in "Dreamgirls" may be the venerable star’s best work to date. So, what does he do for an encore? "Norbit," a film that critics say is as lowbrow as the day is long. Murphy plays three roles (a nerdy guy, his incredibly brash and obese significant other, and his Asian-American adoptive father), a strategy that paid off in the "Nutty Professor" movies. Does it work this time? Not really, say critics; though Murphy gives it his all, the material is crass and largely unfunny. At 21 percent on the Tomatometer, "Norbit" is not phat.

Eddie Murphy gets in touch with nature.

As Hannibal Lecter, Anthony Hopkins created one of the most iconic villains in the movies, a character so morally repugnant and yet so brilliant that audiences could only imagine what was going on inside his head. "Hannibal Rising" is an attempt at explanation. As it turns out, young Dr. Lecter (Gaspard Ulliel) went through a lot: he was orphaned, his sister suffered a horrible fate, and he became hell-bent on revenge. The problem with "Hannibal Rising," say critics, is not the direction, as Peter Webber creates an eerie, sinister mood throughout. The scribes say that explaining Hannibal’s motivations reduces the character to a collection of dime-store psychological traits. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, "Hannibal Rising" isn’t much of a cinematic feast.

Underage drinking will lead to other problems in life.

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Lives of Others," a thriller set during the paranoid days of the East German regime (and a Best Foreign Film Oscar Nominee), is at 93 percent; "The Decomposition of the Soul," a documentary about the tactics of the East German secret police, is at 67 percent; "Burning Annie," an indie comedy about a college kid obsessed with "Annie Hall," is at 29 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the tale of a young girl’s search for absolution, is at 17 percent.

Praying for a better Tomatometer.

And finally, mad props to bribios for correctly guessing "The Messengers"’ Tomatometer of 14 percent. Excellent work, bribios.

Recent Eddie Murphy Movies:
79% — Dreamgirls (2006)
88% — Shrek 2 (2004)
14% — The Haunted Mansion (2003)
29% — Daddy Day Care (2003)
17% — I Spy (2002)

Hannibal Lecter Movies:
68% — Red Dragon (2002)
37% — Hannibal (2001)
95% — The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
94% — Manhunter (1986)

Tag Cloud

medical drama diversity Mudbound strong female leads AMC New York Comic Con Year in Review boxoffice APB Extras BBC RT History what to watch Country San Diego Comic-Con Musical tv talk Teen kids revenge supernatural Nat Geo Election Emmys sequel A&E true crime Photos 45 Grammys sports war based on movie Logo Set visit historical drama Sundance Now Interview Kids & Family MSNBC nature YouTube Red NBC Masterpiece Musicals Cartoon Network Sci-Fi HBO Thanksgiving Pop dragons Mary Poppins Returns Mary Tyler Moore dc Ovation Valentine's Day Superheroe composers elevated horror HBO Max WarnerMedia CNN Emmy Nominations Winter TV MCU Esquire Anna Paquin Cosplay police drama 2019 book Watching Series TCA 2017 politics crime thriller adventure Quiz Video Games GoT GLAAD anime casting X-Men SDCC period drama justice league 2018 DC streaming service TruTV Universal Freeform Heroines Spring TV theme song Sony Pictures ESPN golden globes IFC Trophy Talk Pet Sematary game show CBS adaptation aliens Lifetime social media YA Star Trek Writers Guild of America Creative Arts Emmys sitcom Martial Arts Film Pirates Rocketman See It Skip It Countdown Premiere Dates Comedy Central biography The Arrangement Action Oscars cops USA Network facebook 2015 ghosts thriller Horror finale space jamie lee curtis transformers 007 docudrama Starz Paramount Network Red Carpet Superheroes unscripted richard e. Grant cats VICE Nominations SXSW PaleyFest cooking LGBT Disney anthology Chilling Adventures of Sabrina witnail Super Bowl Reality Competition Brie Larson Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Britbox crime Hulu WGN MTV science fiction Marvel CBS All Access political drama Rocky Showtime Animation discovery natural history Shudder Food Network Epix hist robots romance Pride Month cinemax American Society of Cinematographers LGBTQ National Geographic Schedule Crackle Winners DirecTV Character Guide Drama Infographic cults President Holidays DC Universe spy thriller Calendar ABC Trailer First Look doctor who CMT Comic Book Amazon Trivia Biopics Women's History Month Warner Bros. Summer Ellie Kemper quibi SundanceTV Mindy Kaling TBS Opinion Bravo crossover Comedy series streaming FOX FX comiccon Marathons Stephen King BBC America Paramount Dark Horse Comics Fox News comic Mystery Fantasy History The Witch Lucasfilm spinoff Binge Guide Sneak Peek TIFF Columbia Pictures 24 frames disaster Amazon Prime Video Walt Disney Pictures award winner singing competition Rom-Com TNT Awards Syfy TCM Chernobyl Music FXX Pixar travel Family festivals TCA Black Mirror Mary poppins Tumblr TV Star Wars E3 Lionsgate children's TV Elton John serial killer CW Seed teaser mutant RT21 USA Disney streaming service ratings DGA zombies VH1 Box Office NYCC Apple Disney Channel OWN Song of Ice and Fire zero dark thirty spider-man vampires ABC Family Tomatazos TV Land IFC Films 21st Century Fox Vudu Spectrum Originals Nickelodeon 2017 20th Century Fox Podcast psychological thriller The CW technology Certified Fresh crime drama Cannes YouTube Premium E! harry potter Rock Spike TLC Amazon Prime Ghostbusters talk show Best and Worst animated Reality miniseries toy story blaxploitation mockumentary Awards Tour Adult Swim 2016 PBS psycho zombie Polls and Games BET El Rey ITV Captain marvel television green book Tarantino DC Comics GIFs Shondaland dramedy Toys cars Netflix Comics on TV binge dceu Sundance movies Christmas Film Festival Western Acorn TV Fall TV