Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Norbit" Is Flabby; "Hannibal Rising" Isn't That Tasty

by | February 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a nerd with an overbearing fiancée ("Norbit," starring Eddie Murphy) and the early days of Hannibal Lecter ("Hannibal Rising," starring Gaspard Ulliel and Gong Li). What do the critics have to say?

Eddie Murphy’s searing, Oscar-nominated performance as a James Brown-esque soul singer in "Dreamgirls" may be the venerable star’s best work to date. So, what does he do for an encore? "Norbit," a film that critics say is as lowbrow as the day is long. Murphy plays three roles (a nerdy guy, his incredibly brash and obese significant other, and his Asian-American adoptive father), a strategy that paid off in the "Nutty Professor" movies. Does it work this time? Not really, say critics; though Murphy gives it his all, the material is crass and largely unfunny. At 21 percent on the Tomatometer, "Norbit" is not phat.

Eddie Murphy gets in touch with nature.

As Hannibal Lecter, Anthony Hopkins created one of the most iconic villains in the movies, a character so morally repugnant and yet so brilliant that audiences could only imagine what was going on inside his head. "Hannibal Rising" is an attempt at explanation. As it turns out, young Dr. Lecter (Gaspard Ulliel) went through a lot: he was orphaned, his sister suffered a horrible fate, and he became hell-bent on revenge. The problem with "Hannibal Rising," say critics, is not the direction, as Peter Webber creates an eerie, sinister mood throughout. The scribes say that explaining Hannibal’s motivations reduces the character to a collection of dime-store psychological traits. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, "Hannibal Rising" isn’t much of a cinematic feast.

Underage drinking will lead to other problems in life.

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Lives of Others," a thriller set during the paranoid days of the East German regime (and a Best Foreign Film Oscar Nominee), is at 93 percent; "The Decomposition of the Soul," a documentary about the tactics of the East German secret police, is at 67 percent; "Burning Annie," an indie comedy about a college kid obsessed with "Annie Hall," is at 29 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the tale of a young girl’s search for absolution, is at 17 percent.

Praying for a better Tomatometer.

And finally, mad props to bribios for correctly guessing "The Messengers"’ Tomatometer of 14 percent. Excellent work, bribios.

Recent Eddie Murphy Movies:
79% — Dreamgirls (2006)
88% — Shrek 2 (2004)
14% — The Haunted Mansion (2003)
29% — Daddy Day Care (2003)
17% — I Spy (2002)

Hannibal Lecter Movies:
68% — Red Dragon (2002)
37% — Hannibal (2001)
95% — The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
94% — Manhunter (1986)

Tag Cloud

Rocketman crossover parents BBC America aliens olympics quibi canceled Thanksgiving supernatural halloween tv Sundance TV rotten Lifetime Christmas movies screen actors guild biopic based on movie Disney Channel Box Office monster movies Fox Searchlight Marvel Television war mutant anime Nominations Country Nat Geo ID YA Countdown Baby Yoda cults book adaptation renewed TV shows Set visit Winners docuseries political drama scary movies Spectrum Originals PBS Avengers versus TCA Awards 72 Emmy Awards sequel Tokyo Olympics 73rd Emmy Awards nature latino Marvel Studios President a nightmare on elm street discovery game of thrones black comedy halloween sag awards Britbox GIFs Mary poppins feel good spinoff E! harry potter toronto reboot dceu Black History Month FX crime concert Fantasy Spring TV Columbia Pictures transformers medical drama TCM vs. BBC Comic Book blockbusters The Walking Dead legend new star wars movies Ovation Crunchyroll TIFF golden globe awards ESPN best adenture animated slashers El Rey 2021 First Reviews Fargo Crackle A24 Summer Anna Paquin movie ABC Signature TV Land WarnerMedia canceled TV shows Sundance DGA Legendary Mary Poppins Returns streaming movies singing competition 1990s doctor who AMC asian-american A&E italian Ghostbusters CNN satire worst HFPA sports Esquire Pride Month The Purge Grammys Disney streaming service target comic twilight Schedule Comics on TV TV renewals TV movies Animation documentary Alien video Television Critics Association TV One dragons green book USA Network Fox News Family indiana jones zombie universal monsters period drama Arrowverse spanish IFC women Sony Pictures FXX Amazon Prime Video Travel Channel Universal Pictures Ellie Kemper rt labs critics edition boxing NBC dexter 2018 Television Academy popular 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards movies Netflix Horror cartoon Reality Competition batman National Geographic slasher Extras justice league Interview IMDb TV BBC One talk show miniseries australia Nickelodeon dramedy Paramount Plus Star Trek Superheroe Cosplay news hispanic heritage month Christmas Hollywood Foreign Press Association Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy Central Drama christmas movies Heroines spain Hulu stoner BET 2017 Oscars Film hispanic worst movies gangster DC Universe SDCC Tubi 99% Rocky nbcuniversal japan sopranos chucky TBS Emmy Nominations classics werewolf documentaries wonder woman spanish language Best and Worst psycho Martial Arts Freeform cats Hallmark Christmas movies Film Festival Tomatazos kaiju Trailer Emmys GLAAD 2020 24 frames zero dark thirty Prime Video blockbuster comic books Logo unscripted true crime travel international Sci-Fi theme song Podcast Paramount Network The Arrangement sequels archives criterion History Biopics FOX MSNBC Apple TV+ video on demand superman Sneak Peek Infographic elevated horror rom-coms children's TV free movies Musicals mob WGN 90s The CW stand-up comedy vampires series Wes Anderson Character Guide NBA Amazon Prime Syfy social media french Western Superheroes 93rd Oscars genre rt archives posters psychological thriller Year in Review dc Kids & Family Instagram Live ITV Pop TV award winner what to watch scorecard king kong basketball critics razzies festivals The Walt Disney Company Polls and Games 21st Century Fox TCA 2017 boxoffice Amazon marvel comics mission: impossible Mary Tyler Moore OWN comic book movies MTV thriller FX on Hulu Comedy heist movie Brie Larson YouTube Red Marathons Holidays Universal Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt romance nfl HBO Max crime drama dogs robots Super Bowl Spike Shondaland hist comics hollywood Walt Disney Pictures stop motion 71st Emmy Awards trailers Rock cancelled TV shows 20th Century Fox television Food Network crime thriller The Academy CBS All Access screenings anthology Awards revenge Marvel Winter TV NYCC Toys CBS cinemax scary 007 Election young adult Pixar art house Cartoon Network directors trophy Binge Guide king arthur witnail YouTube Premium Funimation toy story Women's History Month Trophy Talk zombies CW Seed rotten movies we love mockumentary Acorn TV Action Shudder reviews joker debate MCU dreamworks Quiz Broadway cancelled television cops VICE mcc cancelled historical drama streaming jurassic park disaster Bravo Endgame Certified Fresh Awards Tour child's play Calendar TruTV TV Musical American Society of Cinematographers Mystery hidden camera police drama franchise kids spy thriller 2015 comiccon suspense comedies Adult Swim jamie lee curtis E3 Tags: Comedy Reality tv talk new york YouTube Rom-Com Pacific Islander black DirecTV prank The Witch Lifetime HBO Go Fall TV Masterpiece Elton John aapi new zealand live event Teen VH1 politics Mindy Kaling Netflix Christmas movies 79th Golden Globes Awards BAFTA cooking See It Skip It Turner Classic Movies leaderboard ViacomCBS scene in color live action docudrama rt labs saw Red Carpet Mudbound ABC Apple 4/20 TCA blaxploitation Premiere Dates facebook diversity Black Mirror adventure all-time Exclusive Video japanese LGBT Tumblr remakes PlayStation die hard book Image Comics foreign RT History game show Creative Arts Emmys Dark Horse Comics superhero lord of the rings San Diego Comic-Con AMC Plus sitcom VOD Valentine's Day Stephen King LGBTQ name the review romantic comedy Lionsgate comic book movie binge Disney venice IFC Films Showtime 45 fast and furious Turner indie space ratings Warner Bros. First Look fresh teaser independent USA cars Chernobyl breaking bad 2019 Vudu richard e. Grant DC Comics kong Cannes OneApp Video Games Writers Guild of America natural history serial killer Comic-Con@Home 2021 DC streaming service Discovery Channel festival composers obituary football Peacock high school casting Hear Us Out action-comedy Academy Awards Star Wars cancelled TV series dark Opinion telelvision Photos PaleyFest 2016 Watching Series Paramount golden globes ghosts RT21 TNT critic resources Lucasfilm science fiction Captain marvel Trivia ABC Family APB laika Disney Plus Classic Film GoT Epix Apple TV Plus Sundance Now deadpool adaptation spider-man finale Starz south america TCA Winter 2020 royal family strong female leads Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark Tarantino emmy awards godzilla Amazon Studios Music Pop CMT technology biography BET Awards marvel cinematic universe HBO Neflix james bond SundanceTV films TLC know your critic spider-verse Holiday Song of Ice and Fire Pirates X-Men New York Comic Con Pet Sematary SXSW pirates of the caribbean