Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: It's Quiet For G.I. Joe. Too Quiet.

Plus, Julie & Julia is sometimes tasty, and The Perfect Getaway is too twisty.

by | August 6, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we got real American heroes (GI Joe: The Rise of Cobra, starring Dennis Quaid and Sienna Miller); kitchen chronicles (Julie & Julia, starring Meryl Streep and Amy Adams); and honeymoon horror (A Perfect Getaway, starring Timothy Olyphant and Milla Jovovich). What do the critics have to say?



[tomatometer]MuzeID=1193682[/tomatometer]

G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra

Knowing may be half the battle, but in the case of GI Joe: The Rise of Cobra, the war is far from over, as a majority of critics has not been willing to support these troops. GI Joe is the origin story of the elite combat unit, based upon the popular Hasbro toy franchise, which is tasked with thwarting the venomous Cobra organization’s plans to wreak global havoc via malicious futuristic technology. Though some reviews say the film delivers on its promise of over-the-top thrills, most say Joe is cheesy and juvenile in its presentation of wanton destruction. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of our favorite fighting squads, as well as Sienna Miller’s Five Favorite Films.)



[tomatometer]MuzeID=1207146[/tomatometer]

Julie & Julia

At this point, praising a Meryl Streep performance is like saying LeBron James played a good game. However, she can’t do it all by herself, and critics say Julie & Julia is riveting when Streep is onscreen, but formulaic when she’s not. Streep plays Julia Child, whose landmark work, Mastering the Art of French Cooking, inspires writer Julie Powell (Amy Adams) to make all 500-odd dishes in the book – and blog about her experience. Nora Ephron’s film weaves the two women’s tales together, and that’s part of the problem, the pundits say: while the Julia Child material is fascinating, the Julie Powell stuff doesn’t have the same charge. (Check out our pictorial tour of Le Cordon Bleu culinary training facility, where the film was recently screened.)



[tomatometer]MuzeID=1200466[/tomatometer]

A Perfect Getaway

There’s nothing wrong with a twisty little genre thriller – as long as it’s done right. Unfortunately, critics say A Perfect Getaway, though well-crafted and tense, is a little too heavily plotted for its own good. The film stars Steve Zahn and Milla Jovovich as a recently-wed couple backpacking in Hawaii. But the trip takes an ominous turn when other hikers inform them of murders in the area, and tension runs high. The pundits say A Perfect Getaway is smarter than average and economically paced, but ultimately gets bogged down in red herrings and an ending that strains credulity.


Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Cold Souls, starring Paul Giamatti in a deadpan comedy about the extraction of the spirit, is at 80 percent.
  • Mumblecore founder Andrew Bujalski‘s Beeswax, a dramedy about some legal wrangling over a vintage clothing store, is at 77 percent.
  • Paper Heart, featuring Charlyne Yi and Michael Cera in a quasi-documentary about a young woman’s search for true love, is at 64 percent.
  • Bliss, a Turkish drama about the honor killing of a 17-year-old girl who’s suffered from an assault, is at 63 percent.
  • I Sell the Dead, starring Dominic Monaghan and Ron Perlman in a gothic horror film about a pair of thieves, is at 42 percent.

Finally, props to Iceman Cometh and Canuck666 for coming the closest to guessing the Tomatometers for Aliens in the Attic and The Collector.

Tag Cloud

Horror Writers Guild of America Grammys TLC Action NYCC BBC YA GLAAD period drama Adult Swim Animation Teen Drama Star Wars TCM TIFF OWN APB vampires Nominations Freeform TV cooking TCA 2017 ESPN DirecTV PaleyFest Tomatazos Rom-Com Starz Red Carpet supernatural cops 45 Biopics Year in Review Fantasy Food Network Mindy Kaling 007 Logo Cartoon Network Certified Fresh Lifetime Marathons Winners E3 what to watch Oscars Bravo Countdown Election diversity BBC America CMT Schedule comiccon war adventure E! ITV The Arrangement Netflix political drama Superheroes Country 2017 Extras transformers crime drama MSNBC WGN Cosplay Music docudrama LGBTQ CNN Crackle Kids & Family TNT 24 frames Amazon TBS Martial Arts AMC cats Emmys Fox News VICE ABC Opinion American Society of Cinematographers Photos VH1 TV Land Sci-Fi Sundance Interview Masterpiece DC Comics Summer Awards Toys Ghostbusters Best and Worst BET Sneak Peek biography Character Guide dramedy Trailer Showtime FOX politics science fiction Reality Spring TV TruTV GoT technology Thanksgiving Rock X-Men Marvel Premiere Dates Watching Series Lionsgate CBS IFC harry potter Winter TV Syfy Super Bowl DC Universe Nickelodeon Podcast Holidays Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime thriller TCA Hulu CBS All Access romance Reality Competition Dark Horse Comics cinemax NBC Set visit sports social media Disney boxoffice Esquire ABC Family serial killer discovery Musical Tumblr Trivia Fall TV Universal Comedy Central Musicals SundanceTV 2015 FXX RT History FX GIFs PBS Nat Geo Rocky Box Office USA Video Games talk show aliens thriller composers historical drama History Ellie Kemper police drama travel sitcom Comedy Star Trek Infographic singing competition El Rey Mystery MTV Mary Tyler Moore Comic Book crime Pirates The CW Pop A&E First Look Warner Bros. Calendar Valentine's Day based on movie SDCC Paramount President HBO 2016 psycho Disney Channel zombie Polls and Games