(Photo by ABC/Eric McCandless)

TV Musical Adaptations by Tomatometer

If we’ve learned anything from networks’ recent fixation on televised musicals, high ratings do not always equal standing ovations; in fact, only a handful of musical productions from the past few years received Fresh scores on Rotten Tomato’s Tomatometer: Fox’s Grease: Live! and NBC’s Jesus Christ Superstar Live in ConcertThe Wiz Live!, and Hairspray Live! And no, the exclamation mark doesn’t make a difference — Fox’s A Christmas Story Live! and NBC’s Peter Pan Live! and The Sound of Music Live! are all on the Rotten end of this list.

ABC’s The Little Mermaid Live! continues the downward trend, unfortunately, joining Fox’s Rent below the Fresh threshold.

Check out where The Little Mermaid Live! lands among TV’s recent musicals, both live and taped (like Rocky Horror Picture Show and Dirty Dancing).


Dirty Dancing (2017)

Adjusted Score: 18.334%
Critics Consensus: Clever casting can't save Dirty Dancing, a hollow remake that trips over its own good intentions.
Synopsis: Adaptation of the 1987 box-office smash about an innocent teen vacationing with her parents at an upscale resort in the... [More]
Directed By: Wayne Blair

Adjusted Score: 19.466%
Critics Consensus: A strange hybrid that's more confusing than charming, The Little Mermaid Live! flounders under the weight of its own lofty ambitions.
Synopsis: "The Wonderful World of Disney presents The Little Mermaid Live!" will honor the 30th anniversary of the beloved animated classic... [More]
Directed By: Hamish Hamilton


Rent Live (2019)

Adjusted Score: 27.081%
Critics Consensus: Despite the show's earnest intentions, Rent Live's clumsy production and pre-recorded broadcast render it an underwhelming "live" musical event.
Synopsis: A re-imagining of Puccini's "La Bohème," and set in New York City's gritty East Village, "Rent" tells the unforgettable story... [More]
Directed By: Alex Rudzinski

Adjusted Score: 28.703%
Critics Consensus: Laverne Cox's fabulous portrayal of Frank N. Furter leads a strong ensemble effort, but the stars can't infuse this reimagining with enough energy, creativity, and quirk to make TRHPS: Let's Do the Time Warp Again a worthwhile endeavor.
Synopsis: A reimagining of the cult film that follows a young couple as they end up at a strange convention hosted... [More]
Directed By: Kenny Ortega

Adjusted Score: 27.662%
Critics Consensus: Overlong and perhaps a little too faithful, A Christmas Story Live! can't quite capture the holiday spirit of its source material.
Synopsis: From Warner Horizon Unscripted & Alternative Television, A CHRISTMAS STORY LIVE! is inspired by the holiday classic feature "A Christmas... [More]
Directed By: Alex Rudzinski

Adjusted Score: 29.685%
Critics Consensus: The Sound of Music is definitely there, but without the necessary feeling to make it feel truly alive.
Synopsis: Carrie Underwood and Stephen Moyer star in the live telecast of a beloved family classic, based on the original Broadway... [More]


Peter Pan Live! (2014)

Adjusted Score: 43.305%
Critics Consensus: Allison Williams and company do their best, but no amount of clapping or pixie dust can keep Peter Pan Live! afloat.
Synopsis: Preparing to sprinkle fairy dust across America, NBC presents a bold new LIVE television production of the classic Broadway musical... [More]
Directed By:


The Passion (2016)

Adjusted Score: 12.769%
Critics Consensus: No consensus yet.
Synopsis: Tyler Perry narrates a musical portrait of the last days of Jesus Christ, from the Last Supper to the Resurrection,... [More]
Directed By:


Hairspray Live! (2016)

Adjusted Score: 76.064%
Critics Consensus: Hairspray Live! shimmers with outstanding performances, an engaging story, and songs that let its stars shine.
Synopsis: A teenage girl living in Baltimore in the early 1960s dreams of appearing on a popular TV dance show.... [More]
Directed By: Kenny Leon, Alex Rudzinski


The Wiz Live! (2015)

Adjusted Score: 91.382%
Critics Consensus: The Wiz Live! is several notches above NBC's other musical broadcasts thanks to bold performances and large-scale production pieces.
Synopsis: NBC embarks on its latest musical holiday tradition: a 3-hour LIVE event production of the groundbreaking Broadway show that brought... [More]


Grease: Live! (2016)

Adjusted Score: 92.532%
Critics Consensus: Grease: Live took the pressure and threw away conventionality -- it belongs to yesterday. There was a chance that it could make it so far; we started believin' we can be who we are. Grease: Live is the word.
Synopsis: The first-ever live television production of "Grease" will re-imagine and reintroduce some of the most memorable moments, great music and... [More]

Adjusted Score: 100.226%
Critics Consensus: Shaking up traditional religious and musical iconography, Jesus Christ Superstar Live in Concert is a sight to be heard, superbly infiltrating the classic source material with originality, rock legend star power, and soulful depth.

Tag Cloud

adventure TCM Netflix Family SXSW A&E ratings Winter TV Holidays Paramount Network Starz singing competition Disney Plus The Arrangement anime WGN Disney AMC Creative Arts Emmys natural history Thanksgiving TCA New York Comic Con TBS Fantasy cancelled Shudder Ghostbusters Quiz biography what to watch space spider-man Writers Guild of America A24 PaleyFest dramedy Women's History Month Discovery Channel sports science fiction Interview facebook Tumblr based on movie Classic Film crime thriller cinemax Reality binge Mindy Kaling 2019 anthology Infographic game show Video Games Apple American Society of Cinematographers streaming Arrowverse Marvel Studios Epix GoT LGBTQ Disney Channel Television Academy Summer ABC Disney streaming service Oscars CBS All Access Character Guide vampires IFC Films animated Amazon Prime Video theme song politics Ellie Kemper Pet Sematary Fox News screenings Black Mirror Rocketman Year in Review Endgame hist green book Tubi comic SundanceTV TV renewals ABC Family Sundance TV Apple TV Plus historical drama USA kids San Diego Comic-Con Turner Classic Movies Marvel Television Emmys DC Comics doctor who Universal Awards Tour independent aliens Mary poppins golden globes Anna Paquin Britbox YouTube X-Men History Pop tv talk Box Office disaster TNT cancelled television The Walking Dead Countdown 71st Emmy Awards VICE MCU Dark Horse Comics WarnerMedia Fall TV National Geographic Reality Competition TLC jamie lee curtis justice league Music Hallmark BBC America crime richard e. Grant Freeform NBC TV Land psychological thriller See It Skip It supernatural Syfy Elton John miniseries 21st Century Fox zombies quibi Schedule Hallmark Christmas movies Grammys harry potter Cartoon Network Best and Worst Election blaxploitation Film Festival Rom-Com sag awards Valentine's Day Crackle 20th Century Fox Baby Yoda medical drama cancelled TV shows spy thriller hispanic First Look finale Superheroes travel Stephen King Emmy Nominations Kids & Family christmas movies foreign DirecTV romance unscripted Logo E3 Peacock Comics on TV crossover 24 frames series docudrama boxoffice Action Biopics CBS Walt Disney Pictures free movies discovery Polls and Games Paramount YouTube Red The Witch OWN spinoff Martial Arts The Purge name the review Podcast Star Wars Trophy Talk canceled TV shows spanish language Hulu sitcom book directors The CW cults latino Certified Fresh USA Network robots teaser renewed TV shows elevated horror Spring TV TCA 2017 Mudbound Calendar TIFF Comedy stand-up comedy Showtime spain ESPN 007 Comic Book zombie south america Heroines Cannes werewolf YouTube Premium Lifetime Disney+ Disney Plus Rock First Reviews breaking bad PBS MTV APB Sundance FOX Columbia Pictures Acorn TV Trailer blockbuster cops Musical Amazon Star Trek versus TCA Winter 2020 Crunchyroll Marathons talk show Cosplay slashers Pixar Extras cancelled TV series nature Captain marvel Sundance Now dceu 2018 indie Nickelodeon Avengers Turner Adult Swim E! mutant rotten movies we love BET Warner Bros. Holiday police drama Marvel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Academy Awards 2015 joker YA Set visit diversity El Rey Red Carpet Musicals Super Bowl 2017 sequel 2016 transformers TV Pride Month technology Spectrum Originals thriller serial killer Brie Larson LGBT BBC DC Universe Comedy Central Mary Tyler Moore halloween NYCC OneApp war GLAAD CW Seed dc ITV Film Nominations Tarantino cars canceled dragons Spike true crime Superheroe VH1 Awards 45 Bravo RT21 television political drama revenge Mary Poppins Returns movies Ovation MSNBC zero dark thirty witnail cartoon Nat Geo comiccon period drama Lifetime Christmas movies Lucasfilm FXX mockumentary Song of Ice and Fire Animation GIFs psycho Masterpiece CNN Christmas award winner Country composers Amazon Prime cooking Lionsgate Shondaland Netflix Christmas movies comics batman crime drama game of thrones Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Western FX adaptation video Mystery Tomatazos Winners festivals strong female leads Sci-Fi reboot IFC Binge Guide Apple TV+ casting Chernobyl 2020 ghosts Toys President HBO Max CMT Photos screen actors guild cats Drama SDCC children's TV TruTV DC streaming service Premiere Dates Food Network Sony Pictures Esquire Sneak Peek Watching Series Horror HBO Opinion DGA Teen Trivia social media Rocky romantic comedy Vudu RT History toy story Pirates