Best-Reviewed Directorial Debuts 2018

In this new category for this year, we look at the most accomplished leaps into the director’s chair. Some came from those with already-established careers in front of the camera, like Bradley Cooper and his Star is Born remake. Hereditary‘s Ari Aster cut his teeth on shorts, while musician Boots Riley saw an opening and took his shot.

The order of the rank below reflects the Adjusted Score as of December 31, 2018. Scores might change over time.

#1

A Star Is Born (2018)
90%

#1
Adjusted Score: 122371%
Critics Consensus: With appealing leads, deft direction, and an affecting love story, A Star Is Born is a remake done right -- and a reminder that some stories can be just as effective in the retelling.
Synopsis: Seasoned musician Jackson Maine discovers -- and falls in love with -- struggling artist Ally. She has just about given... [More]
Directed By: Bradley Cooper

#2

Eighth Grade (2018)
99%

#2
Adjusted Score: 118800%
Critics Consensus: Eighth Grade takes a look at its titular time period that offers a rare and resounding ring of truth while heralding breakthroughs for writer-director Bo Burnham and captivating star Elsie Fisher.
Synopsis: Thirteen-year-old Kayla endures the tidal wave of contemporary suburban adolescence as she makes her way through the last week of... [More]
Directed By: Bo Burnham

#3
#3
Adjusted Score: 112210%
Critics Consensus: Fearlessly ambitious, scathingly funny, and thoroughly original, Sorry to Bother You loudly heralds the arrival of a fresh filmmaking talent in writer-director Boots Riley.
Synopsis: In an alternate reality of present-day Oakland, Calif., telemarketer Cassius Green finds himself in a macabre universe after he discovers... [More]
Directed By: Boots Riley

#4

Hereditary (2018)
89%

#4
Adjusted Score: 112885%
Critics Consensus: Hereditary uses its classic setup as the framework for a harrowing, uncommonly unsettling horror film whose cold touch lingers long beyond the closing credits.
Synopsis: When the matriarch of the Graham family passes away, her daughter and grandchildren begin to unravel cryptic and increasingly terrifying... [More]
Directed By: Ari Aster

#5

Wildlife (2018)
94%

#5
Adjusted Score: 106354%
Critics Consensus: Wildlife's portrait of a family in crisis is beautifully composed by director Paul Dano -- and brought brilliantly to life by a career-best performance from Carey Mulligan.
Synopsis: Fourteen-year-old Joe is the only child of Jeanette and Jerry -- a housewife and a golf pro -- in a... [More]
Directed By: Paul Dano

Tag Cloud

OWN Set visit summer preview south america Crackle Prime Video superman Reality live event Classic Film venice PlayStation DC streaming service art house remakes laika stoner HBO 24 frames DirecTV toy story Polls and Games Musical AMC quibi Marvel Television dreamworks Starz reboot true crime Nat Geo E! spanish joker FX on Hulu binge movies A&E Rocky indie Paramount Plus TIFF king kong dogs cults sag awards police drama leaderboard ghosts parents Pacific Islander TCA Awards composers mission: impossible spider-man international renewed TV shows what to watch dceu Superheroes Sony Pictures TCA black comedy Women's History Month Neflix summer TV preview franchise nbcuniversal Schedule batman dc zombies Christmas Tokyo Olympics TV Land X-Men discovery Netflix Christmas movies comic book movie Image Comics spy thriller Esquire kong Chernobyl Disney Discovery Channel thriller aapi AMC Plus Comedy Central worst screen actors guild Countdown ID mcc Box Office canceled TV shows cops zombie History Infographic sequels GLAAD blockbusters Thanksgiving new york CW Seed Britbox CMT name the review ABC Family vampires Holidays Amazon Prime Mudbound Shudder deadpool Walt Disney Pictures Lucasfilm TV renewals Lifetime Christmas movies mob zero dark thirty sequel strong female leads hidden camera japan trophy 73rd Emmy Awards National Geographic Ghostbusters new zealand 2016 psychological thriller Disney Plus dramedy 21st Century Fox SXSW 2022 festivals interviews Pop CNN The CW PaleyFest natural history Premiere Dates DGA slasher FX cancelled TV shows GoT critic resources Wes Anderson The Academy rotten movies we love Bravo El Rey critics action-comedy jamie lee curtis tv talk Comic Book ITV Super Bowl 20th Century Fox telelvision CBS Comics on TV RT History Film Festival VOD vs. Year in Review Brie Larson prank TCA Winter 2020 Video Games sitcom Extras singing competition Valentine's Day hispanic heritage month Election adventure Character Guide Horror Grammys slashers Disney Channel Syfy cinemax movie comedies Marvel Studios Western feel good IMDb TV Toys women romantic comedy mutant Trailer basketball rotten YouTube Premium RT21 political drama FOX game of thrones Cartoon Network unscripted Awards adenture boxoffice video Pirates Tags: Comedy Rom-Com Tumblr Travel Channel godzilla universal monsters Animation Turner Classic Movies Nominations HFPA blockbuster green book lord of the rings sports Teen monster movies wonder woman BBC One rt archives diversity book gangster concert documentary Star Wars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ViacomCBS Fall TV Columbia Pictures war YA Hallmark Christmas movies VICE game show GIFs Exclusive Video Peacock a nightmare on elm street saw Lionsgate scorecard New York Comic Con transformers Endgame BAFTA legend Awards Tour talk show BBC America Summer 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Certified Fresh Arrowverse cooking docuseries crime drama french CBS All Access OneApp ABC Signature 71st Emmy Awards 1990s streamig PBS Mary Tyler Moore streaming movies animated Emmys Star Trek DC Universe films DC Comics Binge Guide king arthur Action MGM black Tarantino Anna Paquin Disney streaming service scary movies Netflix Best Director Trophy Talk period drama suspense First Reviews Pet Sematary cats Crunchyroll Cosplay Mary poppins witnail Instagram Live Stephen King Creative Arts Emmys Television Academy crime thriller golden globe awards Television Critics Association ratings royal family space children's TV cancelled TV series teaser TBS cancelled television olympics 94th Oscars streaming Emmy Nominations debate Amazon james bond kids BET emmy awards Superheroe comic book movies technology romance news Song of Ice and Fire YouTube Warner Bros. Music genre Comedy scene in color Dark Horse Comics nature Ovation documentaries superhero sopranos ESPN anime Watching Series Marvel biopic heist movie spanish language young adult breaking bad Ellie Kemper independent Pop TV popular Universal TNT crossover Funimation Avengers book adaptation Family Winners Calendar Musicals dexter Paramount Network Best Actor Fox Searchlight Paramount Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina serial killer comic books HBO Max Best Picture 90s SundanceTV trailers Comic-Con@Home 2021 Apple spinoff Food Network Baby Yoda kaiju Oscar 2015 South by Southwest Film Festival WarnerMedia Legendary travel Holiday posters 45 The Arrangement USA TV One supernatural theme song Kids & Family video on demand The Walking Dead 2018 Apple TV Plus MSNBC japanese IFC Films Vudu anthology golden globes Epix Fox News hispanic italian revenge Showtime Mystery australia First Look comiccon YouTube Red IFC Hollywood Foreign Press Association hollywood BET Awards 93rd Oscars broadcast comics razzies E3 television 2017 Mary Poppins Returns Reality Competition Broadway 007 72 Emmy Awards robots versus The Purge Acorn TV Academy Awards 2019 Amazon Prime Video The Witch BBC NBA worst movies crime Drama directors science fiction elevated horror social media free movies 2021 TCA 2017 facebook high school Quiz HBO Go Logo 79th Golden Globes Awards nfl football canceled APB Oscars Marathons ABC Best Actress biography Turner Apple TV+ christmas movies all-time Writers Guild of America doctor who fast and furious 2020 Focus Features festival Trivia Rock comic A24 marvel cinematic universe SDCC werewolf Spring TV blaxploitation See It Skip It FXX spain Captain marvel adaptation pirates of the caribbean Alien Black Mirror award winner summer TV Hallmark Pride Month Sundance Now Tomatazos die hard LGBTQ Paramount halloween tv The Walt Disney Company asian-american American Society of Cinematographers Biopics psycho Tubi Photos target TV Heroines child's play MCU Hulu NBC cancelled TruTV new star wars movies Disney+ Disney Plus Martial Arts latino screenings Freeform Fargo live action dark SXSW Opinion Podcast richard e. Grant rom-coms Shondaland Film hist 99% series marvel comics Red Carpet TV movies Pixar historical drama Winter TV satire Elton John Country LGBT disaster stop motion justice league WGN cartoon VH1 toronto reviews foreign Best and Worst harry potter TCM rt labs critics edition aliens indiana jones fresh Nickelodeon Sci-Fi twilight Sundance President docudrama classics USA Network based on movie miniseries mockumentary TLC Masterpiece obi wan 4/20 Amazon Studios Black History Month Mindy Kaling Spectrum Originals politics Cannes finale dragons Hear Us Out Fantasy criterion NYCC Sneak Peek best archives Lifetime scary medical drama casting halloween Spike know your critic San Diego Comic-Con boxing rt labs MTV Interview Universal Pictures jurassic park chucky cars stand-up comedy obituary Sundance TV Rocketman Adult Swim spider-verse